FULLTEXT01 $(function(){PrimeFaces.cw("Tooltip","widget_formSmash_items_resultList_6_j_idt799_0_j_idt801",{id:"formSmash:items:resultList:6:j_idt799:0:j_idt801",widgetVar:"widget_formSmash_items_resultList_6_j_idt799_0_j_idt801",showEffect:"fade",hideEffect:"fade",target:"formSmash:items:resultList:6:j_idt799:0:fullText"});});

by user

on 15 сентября 2016

Category: Documents

>> Downloads: 6

views

Report

Comments

Description

Download FULLTEXT01 $(function(){PrimeFaces.cw("Tooltip","widget_formSmash_items_resultList_6_j_idt799_0_j_idt801",{id:"formSmash:items:resultList:6:j_idt799:0:j_idt801",widgetVar:"widget_formSmash_items_resultList_6_j_idt799_0_j_idt801",showEffect:"fade",hideEffect:"fade",target:"formSmash:items:resultList:6:j_idt799:0:fullText"});});

Transcript

FULLTEXT01 $(function(){PrimeFaces.cw("Tooltip","widget_formSmash_items_resultList_6_j_idt799_0_j_idt801",{id:"formSmash:items:resultList:6:j_idt799:0:j_idt801",widgetVar:"widget_formSmash_items_resultList_6_j_idt799_0_j_idt801",showEffect:"fade",hideEffect:"fade",target:"formSmash:items:resultList:6:j_idt799:0:fullText"});});

ESSAYS ON PUBLIC FINANCE:
RETIREMENT BEHAVIOR AND DISASTER RELIEF
by
Thomas Eisensee
INSTITUTE FOR INTERNATIONAL ECONOMIC STUDIES
Stockholm University
Monograph Series
No. 54
2005
THE INSTITUTE FOR INTERNATIONAL ECONOMIC STUDIES
University of Stockholm
is an institute for independent scholarly research in the field of international economic relations.
DIRECTOR: Torsten Persson, Professor of Economics
DEPUTY DIRECTOR: Mats Persson, Professor of Economics
BOARD OF GOVERNORS:
Kåre Bremer, Professor, President, Stockholm University, Chairman
Ulf Jakobsson, Director of the Research Institute of Industrial Economics
Leif Lindfors, University Director
Sven-Olof Lodin, Professor
Karl O. Moene, Professor
Lars-Göran Nilsson, Professor
Mats Persson, Professor
Torsten Persson, Professor
Michael Sohlman, Executive Director of the Nobel Foundation
Eskil Wadensjö, Professor
RESEARCH STAFF AND VISITING FELLOWS 2004/2005:
Professors
Lars Calmfors
Harry Flam
John Hassler
Henrik Horn
Assar Lindbeck
Mats Persson
Torsten Persson
Peter Svedberg
Fabrizio Zilibotti
Visiting Professors
Per Krusell
Kjetil Storesletten
Research Fellows
Nicola Gennaioli
Ethan Kaplan
Jesper Lindé (visiting)
Dirk Niepelt
David Strömberg
Jakob Svensson
Graduate Students
Martin Bech Holte
Martina Björkman
Alessandra Bonfiglioli
Thomas Eisensee
Giovanni Favara
Daria Finocchiario
Erika Färnstrand
Mathias Herzing
Anna Larsson
Martin Ljunge
MAIL ADDRESS:
STREET ADDRESS:
Natalie Pienaar
José Mauricio Prado, Jr.
Virginia Queijo
Zheng (Michael) Song
Ulrika Stavlöt
Mirco Tonin
Gisela Waisman
Visiting Fellows
Gino Gancia
University Pompeu Fabra
Martín Gonzalez-Eiras
Universidad de San Andrés
Jean Imbs
University of Lausanne and
London Business School
Paul Klein
University of Western Ontario
Jo Thori Lind
University of Oslo
Egil Matsen
Norwegian University of Science and
Technology, Trondheim
Andrea Moro
University of Minnesota
Anders Olofsgård
Georgetown University
Gérard Roland
University of California, Berkeley
Betsey Stevenson
University of Pennsylvania
Lars E.O. Svensson
Princeton University
S-106 91 STOCKHOLM, SWEDEN
Universitetsvägen 10 A, 8th floor
Davide Ticchi
Università degli Studi di Urbino "Carlo Bo"
Harald Uhlig
Humboldt University
Justin Wolfers
University of Pennsylvania
Joseph Zeira
Hebrew University Jerusalem
ESSAYS ON PUBLIC FINANCE:
RETIREMENT BEHAVIOR AND DISASTER RELIEF
by
Thomas Eisensee
INSTITUTE FOR INTERNATIONAL ECONOMIC STUDIES
Stockholm University
January 2006
© Copyright Thomas Eisensee, 2006. All rights reserved.
Institute for International Economic Studies
Stockholm University
ISBN 91-7155-197-2
Printed by Akademitryck AB
Edsbruk, Sweden 2006
Doctoral Dissertation
Department of Economics
Stockholm University
ABSTRACT
This thesis consists of three self-contained essays. The …rst essay is an empirical
analysis of the relationship between news coverage of disasters and the provision of
disaster relief. The two last essays deal with the relationship between …scal policy
and the retirement decision.
News Droughts, News Floods and U.S. Disaster Relief studies the mass media’s
in‡uence on the U.S. government response to approximately 5,000 natural disasters
in developing countries in 1968-2002. These disasters took around 63,000 lives and
a¤ected 125 million people per year. Given the huge losses involved, it is essential
that disaster relief is provided to those most in need. We show that U.S. disaster
relief depends on the occurrence of other newsworthy events at the time of the
disaster, such as the Olympic Games or the O.J. Simpson Trial, which are obviously
unrelated to need. We argue that the only plausible explanation for this is that
relief decisions are driven by news coverage of disasters, and that this news coverage
might be crowded out by other newsworthy material.
Fiscal Policy and Retirement in the Twentieth Century proposes a model that
explains the trend in labor supply among older workers through changes in …scal policy, including social security. The model emphasizes the general equilibrium e¤ects
of …scal policy on retirement behavior. In particular, the radical shift in …scal policy
at the beginning of the century raised the returns to savings, which induced workers
to retire earlier. The model predicts a large change in the retirement age upon the
introduction of social security, while subsequent increases in replacement rates are
shown to have a small impact on retirement. Speci…cally, the retirement elasticity
is found to be a decreasing and convex function of the replacement rate. The essay
re-introduces social security as a major determinant of retirement behavior in the
second half of the twentieth century, while simultaneously o¤ering an explanation
to the two main puzzles in the literature: (i) the small contemporary retirement
elasticities and (ii) the drop in the retirement age prior to the introduction of social
security.
Sustainable Fiscal Policy and the Retirement Decision concerns the sustainability
of …scal policy in aging economies and the retirement decision. The essay develops
an applied general equilibrium overlapping generation model calibrated to the U.S.
iii
economy, where retirement behavior is endogenous and current …scal policy is a
response to future demographic developments. Three distinguishing sustainable
policies are analyzed: (1) raising taxes only (2) reducing the replacement rate only
and (3) raising the Full Retirement Age (FRA) only. All policies are found to
have a substantial impact on retirement behavior. In particular, sustaining …scal
policy will result in falling interest rates, inducing a general delay in retirement.
This general equilibrium e¤ect on retirement behavior can be substantially larger
than the direct e¤ect of changing social security incentives. However, although the
delay in retirement reduces the burden of an aging population, the required …scal
adjustments are large. The reason is that U.S. social security is roughly actuarially
fair, which implies that delayed retirement only has a small e¤ect on public co¤ers.
iv
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I would like to express my gratitude to all those who gave me the possibility to
complete this thesis. I want to thank the Institute for giving me the opportunity
to work here as a research assistant and later as a graduate student. My gratitude
goes especially to my advisors, Fabrizio Zilibotti and Kjetil Storesletten: Thanks
for sharing your knowledge, creative ideas and great enthusiasm. Not least, I am
grateful for your support and patience. I am also indebted to my co-author David
Strömberg whose dedication and e¤ectivity is highly contageous. It has been a great
joy and inspiration to work with you.
I would also like to thank the Wallis Institute at University of Rochester for
their hospitality during my 6 months stay and Per Krusell for several insightful
discussions. Also, thanks to the crowd of graduate students in Rochester who gave
Gabriela and I a very hearty welcome.
Warm thanks to all my teachers, collegues and friends who has made life at
the Institute more enjoyable. A special thanks goes to Annika Andreasson, Conny
Olovsson, Ulrika Stavlöt and Mathias Herzing for their support and inspiration.
Editorial and administrative assistance from Christina Lönnblad and Annika Andreasson has been deeply appreciated. For …nancial support, I thank Tore Browaldh’s
Foundation, Jan Wallander’s and Tom Hedelius’ Foundation and Finanspolitiska
Forskningsinstitutet.
My greatest gratitude belong to my wife, Gabriela, and daughter, Clara; your
constant support, patience and encouragement has been invaluable in the completion
of this thesis.
v
vi
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Chapter 1: Introduction
1
Chapter 2: News Droughts, News Floods and U.S. Disaster Relief
5
Chapter 3: Fiscal Policy and Retirement in the Twentieth Century 49
Chapter 4: Sustainable Fiscal Policy and the Retirement Decision
vii
83
viii
.'59+7 3974*:)9/43
/@AK L@=KAK ;GFKAKLK G> L@J== K=D>;GFL9AF=< =KK9QK GF HM:DA; SF9F;= /@= SJKL =KK9Q AK
9F =EHAJA;9D 9F9DQKAK G> L@= J=D9LAGFK@AH :=LO==F F=OK ;GN=J9?= G> <AK9KL=JK 9F< L@=
HJGNAKAGF G> <AK9KL=J J=DA=> /@= LOG D9KL =KK9QK <=9D OAL@ L@= J=D9LAGFK@AH :=LO==F
SK;9D HGDA;Q 9F< L@= J=LAJ=E=FL <=;AKAGF
9F< 9J= ;DGK=DQ J=D9L=< AF L=JEK G> L@=
L@=GJ=LA;9D 9F< E=L@G<GDG?A;9D >J9E=OGJC MK=<
+<8 '3* /8'89+7 "+1/+, G F=OK KLGJA=K 9Z=;L HGDALA;K /@AK IM=KLAGF @9K
G;;MHA=< J=K=9J;@=JK AF HGDALA;9D K;A=F;= 9F< =;GFGEA;K >GJ <=;9<=K $F ?=F=J9D
AL
AK <AY;MDL LG N=JA>Q O@=L@=J 9 F=OK KLGJQ 9Z=;LK HGDALA;K !AJKL
O= <G FGL CFGO
L@= ;GMFL=J>9;LM9D
A= O@=L@=J L@= HGDALA;9D KQKL=E OGMD< @9N= 9;L=< AF L@= K9E=
O9Q AF L@= 9:K=F;= G> L@= E=<A9 KLGJQ .=;GF<
=N=F A> O= ;9F SF< 9F =PH=JAE=FL
O@=J= KM;@ 9 ;GMFL=J>9;LM9D =PAKLK
AL AK MF;D=9J O@=L@=J ;9MK9DALQ ;9F := =KL9:DAK@=<
!GJ =P9EHD=
E=<A9 ;GN=J9?= ;GMD< := 9F GML;GE= G> L@= HGDA;Q J9L@=J L@9F L@=
<=L=JEAF9FL
$F &73 2/5()43 &73 ,//%3 ".%
*3"34&2 &,*&' O= KLM<Q @GO F=OK
KLGJA=K GF <AK9KL=JK 9Z=;L L@= HJGNAKAGF G> <AK9KL=J J=DA=> /@AK AK 9F AEHGJL9FL KLM<Q
AF ALK GOF JA?@L =9;@ Q=9J <AK9KL=JK L9C= 9JGMF< DAN=K 9F< 9Z=;L EADDAGF
H=GHD= $L AK AEHGJL9FL LG MF<=JKL9F< O@=L@=J E=<A9 AFTM=F;=K L@= 9DDG;9LAGF G>
J=DA=> LG <AK9KL=J NA;LAEK $F 9<<ALAGF
<AK9KL=J J=DA=> HJGNA<=K 9 MFAIM= GHHGJLMFALQ
LG KLM<Q L@= =Z=;L G> E9KK E=<A9 GF HGDALA;K AK9KL=JK 9J= 9J?M9:DQ =PG?=FGMK
=N=FLK L@9L 9J= J=9KGF9:DQ O=DD<G;ME=FL=< 9F< J=?MD9JDQ ;GN=J=< AF L@= E=<A9 $L
AK L@=J=>GJ=
AF HJAF;AHD=
HGKKA:D= LG SF< ;GMFL=J>9;LM9DK #GO=N=J
D9J?=J 9F< EGJ=
K=N=J= <AK9KL=JK 9J= :GL@ EGJ= DAC=DQ LG := AF L@= F=OK 9F< J=;=AN= J=DA=> /@AK <G=K
FGL F=;=KK9JADQ AEHDQ ;9MK9DALQ
N=F ;GFLJGDDAF? >GJ L@= K=N=JALQ G> 9 <AK9KL=J CADD=<
9Z=;L=< =L; AL AK MF;D=9J O@=L@=J L@= J=E9AFAF? ;GJJ=D9LAGF AK <M= LG F=OK GJ GL@=J
#! #!$#
>=9LMJ=K G> L@= <AK9KL=JK >GJ O@A;@ O= 9J= MF9:D= LG ;GFLJGD >GJ =? L@= K9DA=F;= G>
9 <AK9KL=J
$F L@= =KK9Q
O= HJGHGK= LG MK= L@= 9N9AD9:ADALQ G> GL@=J F=OKOGJL@Q =N=FLK
>GJ
AFKL9F;= L@= *DQEHA;K GJ L@= *% .AEHKGF LJA9D
LG =KL9:DAK@ ;9MK9DALQ 2= ;GFKLJM;L
LOG E=9KMJ=K LG ;9HLMJ= L@= 9N9AD9:ADALQ G> GL@=J F=OKOGJL@Q =N=FLK ,9-0*$3 9F<
.&73 02&3352& 2= 9J?M= L@9L L@=K= E=9KMJ=K 9J= =PG?=FGMK :GL@ LG F=OK ;GN=J9?=
G> 9 <AK9KL=J 9F< J=DA=> <=;AKAGFK
:ML 9Z=;L L@= E=<A9VK <=;AKAGF G> O@=L@=J LG ;GN=J
9 <AK9KL=J /@= E=9KMJ=K L@=J=>GJ= 9DDGO MK LG =KL9:DAK@ ;9MK9DALQ $F H9JLA;MD9J
O= K@GO L@9L O@=F GL@=J F=OKOGJL@Q =N=FLK L9C= HD9;=
L@= DAC=DA@GG< L@9L E=<A9
OADD ;GN=J 9 <AK9KL=J <=;J=9K=K /@9L AK
L@= 9N9AD9:ADALQ G> GL@=J F=OKOGJL@Q =N=FLK
;JGO<K GML F=OK ;GN=J9?= G> <AK9KL=JK (GJ=GN=J
L@= HJG:9:ADALQ L@9L 9 <AK9KL=J
J=;=AN=K J=DA=> <JGHK /@MK
O= 9J?M= L@9L J=DA=> <=;AKAGFK 9J= <JAN=F :Q F=OK ;GN=J9?=
G> <AK9KL=JK
9F< L@9L L@AK F=OK ;GN=J9?= AK ;JGO<=< GML :Q L@= 9N9AD9:ADALQ G> GL@=J
F=OKOGJL@Q E9L=JA9D
,M9FLAL9LAN=DQ
<AK9KL=JK 9J=
GF 9N=J9?=
9JGMF< SN= H=J;=FL D=KK DAC=DQ LG J=;=AN=
J=DA=> A> L@=Q G;;MJ <MJAF? L@= *DQEHA;K L@9F <MJAF? GL@=J LAE=K 9F< 9JGMF< =A?@L
H=J;=FL D=KK DAC=DQ LG J=;=AN= J=DA=> O@=F .&73 02&3352& AK 9L ALK @A?@=KL D=N=D J=D9LAN=
LG ALK DGO=KL D=N=D 0KAF? 9FGL@=J E=LJA;
9 <AK9KL=J G;;MJJAF? <MJAF? L@= *DQEHA;K
EMKL @9N= L@J== LAE=K 9K E9FQ ;9KM9DLA=K 9K 9 <AK9KL=J GF 9F GJ<AF9JQ <9Q LG @9N= L@=
K9E= ;@9F;= G> J=;=ANAF? J=DA=> .AEAD9JDQ
9 <AK9KL=J G;;MJJAF? O@=F .&73 02&3352& AK
9L ALK @A?@=KL D=N=D EMKL @9N= KAP LAE=K 9K E9FQ CADD=< 9K 9 <AK9KL=J G;;MJJAF? O@=F
.&73 02&3352& AK 9L ALK DGO=KL D=N=D
9DD =DK= =IM9D /@=K= SF<AF?K @GD< MH AF 9 D9J?=
9JJ9Q G> JG:MKLF=KK ;@=;CK
/@= =KK9Q AK 9F AEHGJL9FL ;GFLJA:MLAGF LG L@= DAL=J9LMJ= GF E=<A9 9F< HGDALA;K
9F< LG L@= DAL=J9LMJ= GF <AK9KL=JK 9F< <AK9KL=J J=DA=>
/8)'1
41/)> '3* 9.+ "+9/7+2+39 +)/8/43 /@= D9KL LOG =KK9QK G> L@= L@=KAK
9J= ;GF;=JF=< OAL@ L@= J=D9LAGFK@AH :=LO==F SK;9D HGDA;Q
AF;DM<AF? KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
9F< L@= J=LAJ=E=FL <=;AKAGF /@=Q 9J= EGLAN9L=< :Q L@= GF?GAF? <AK;MKKAGFK G> J=
>GJEK G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ AF <=N=DGH=< =;GFGEA=K /@=K= J=>GJEK HGL=FLA9DDQ @9N= 9
?J=9L AEH9;L GF J=LAJ=E=FL <=;AKAGFK 9F< MF<=JKL9F<AF? L@= F9LMJ= 9F< KAR= G> L@AK
=Z=;L AK ;JM;A9D /@= =KK9QK 9J= ;DGK=DQ J=D9L=< L@=GJ=LA;9DDQ 9K O=DD 9K E=L@G<GDG?
A;9DDQ /@=Q E9C= MK= G> 9F 9HHDA=< ?=F=J9D =IMADA:JAME EG<=D
O@=J= AF<ANA<M
9DK E9C= GHLAE9D <=;AKAGFK GF ;GFKMEHLAGF
K9NAF?K
9F< @GMJK OGJC=< GN=J L@=AJ
DA>=;Q;D= C=Q >=9LMJ= AK L@9L AF<ANA<M9DK 9DKG E9C= GHLAE9D ;@GA;=K 9:GML L@=AJ
J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= /@= EG<=DK 9J= ;9DA:J9L=< LG ;9HLMJ= KLQDAR=< >=9LMJ=K G> L@= 0.
#! #!$#
=;GFGEQ
AF;DM<AF? L@= 0. KG;A9D K=;MJALQ KQKL=E
*3$", /,*$9 ".% &4*2&-&.4 *. 4)& 7&.4*&4) &.4529 L9C=K 9 @AKLGJA;9D DGGC 9L
L@= J=LAJ=E=FL <=;AKAGF Q KGE= 9;;GMFLK
L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= AF L@= 0. <=;DAF=<
>JGE 9JGMF< AF LG LG<9Q /@= LJ=F< AK KAEAD9J AF GL@=J <=N=DGH=< ;GMF
LJA=K .G;A9D K=;MJALQ @9K G>L=F :==F HJGHGK=< 9K L@= E9AF <=L=JEAF9FL G> L@= <=;DAF
AF? LJ=F< #GO=N=J
LOG HMRRD=K EMKL := 9<<J=KK=< :Q 9FQGF= 9J?MAF? L@9L KG;A9D
K=;MJALQ AK L@= ;9MK9D >9;LGJ !AJKL
EA;JG=;GFGE=LJA; KLM<A=K L=F< LG SF< 9 N=JQ
KE9DD =Z=;L G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ GF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ .=;GF<
L@= <=;DAF= AF D9:GJ
>GJ;= H9JLA;AH9LAGF KL9JL=< 9DJ=9<Q AF L@= =9JDQ LO=FLA=L@ ;=FLMJQ
DGF? :=>GJ= KG;A9D
K=;MJALQ O9K AFLJG<M;=<
/@= =KK9Q HJGHGK=K 9 EG<=D L@9L =PHD9AFK L@= LJ=F< AF D9:GJ KMHHDQ 9EGF? GD<=J
OGJC=JK L@JGM?@ ;@9F?=K AF SK;9D HGDA;Q
AF;DM<AF? KG;A9D K=;MJALQ /@= EG<=D =E
H@9KAR=K L@= ?=F=J9D =IMADA:JAME =Z=;LK G> SK;9D HGDA;Q GF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ $F
H9JLA;MD9J
L@= J9<A;9D K@A>L AF SK;9D HGDA;Q
=KH=;A9DDQ <=:L HGDA;Q
9L L@= :=?AFFAF?
G> L@= ;=FLMJQ J9AK=< L@= J=LMJFK LG K9NAF?K
O@A;@ AF<M;=< OGJC=JK LG J=LAJ= =9JDA=J
/@= EG<=D HJ=<A;LK 9 D9J?= ;@9F?= AF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ MHGF L@= AFLJG<M;LAGF G>
KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
O@AD= KM:K=IM=FL AF;J=9K=K AF J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=K 9J= K@GOF LG @9N= 9
KE9DD AEH9;L GF J=LAJ=E=FL .H=;AS;9DDQ
L@= J=LAJ=E=FL =D9KLA;ALQ AK >GMF< LG := 9
<=;J=9KAF? 9F< ;GFN=P >MF;LAGF G> L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= /@MK
L@= =KK9Q HJGHGK=K
KG;A9D K=;MJALQ 9K 9 E9BGJ <=L=JEAF9FL G> J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ AF L@= K=;GF< @9D> G>
L@= LO=FLA=L@ ;=FLMJQ
O@AD= KAEMDL9F=GMKDQ GZ=JAF? 9F =PHD9F9LAGF G> L@= LOG E9AF
HMRRD=K AF L@= DAL=J9LMJ=
534"*."#,& *3$", /,*$9 ".% 4)& &4*2&-&.4 &$*3*/. L9C=K 9 H==C AFLG L@=
>MLMJ= MJJ=FL <AK;MKKAGFK 9:GML J=>GJEAF? KG;A9D K=;MJALQ 9J= D9J?=DQ EGLAN9L=<
:Q <=EG?J9H@A; <=N=DGHE=FLK
AF H9JLA;MD9J
L@= J9HA<DQ JAKAF? GD<9?= <=H=F<=F;Q
J9LAGK $F L@= 0.
>GJ AFKL9F;=
L@= <=H=F<=F;Q J9LAG AK =PH=;L=< LG JAK= >JGE AF LG 9JGMF< AF /@= EG<=D <=N=DGH=< @=J= =PL=F<K L@= EG<=D G>
L@= HJ=NAGMK =KK9Q AF LOG O9QK !AJKL
L@= 0. <=EG?J9H@A; LJ9FKALAGF AK EG<=DD=<
AF <=L9AD .=;GF<
L@= EG<=D 9DDGOK >GJ @=L=JG?=F=ALQ AF KCADDK /@= =KK9Q 9KCK
O@=L@=J J=>GJEK LG KMKL9AF SK;9D HGDA;Q 9J= DAC=DQ LG @9N= 9 KM:KL9FLA9D =Z=;L GF
J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ 9F<
A> KG
O@=L@=J L@AK AK DAC=DQ LG =9K= L@= :MJ<=F G> L@= 9?AF?
HGHMD9LAGF /@J== J=>GJEK LG KMKL9AF SK;9D HGDA;Q 9J= ;GFKA<=J=< 9F AEE=<A9L=
AF;J=9K= AF L9P=K
9F AEE=<A9L= 9F< MFAN=JK9D J=<M;LAGF AF J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=K
9F< 9F AEE=<A9L= 9F< MFAN=JK9D AF;J=9K= AF L@= !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= !-
/@= =KK9Q SF<K L@9L J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ AK DAC=DQ LG := ;GFKA<=J9:DQ <=D9Q=< :Q 9DD
HGDA;A=K /@= E9AF J=9KGF AK L@9L 9DD J=>GJEK ;GFKA<=J=< AF;J=9K= ?GN=JFE=FL K9NAF?K
#! #!$#
L@MK J=<M;AF? AFL=J=KL J9L=K /@AK ;9MK=K 9 ?=F=J9D <=D9Q AF J=LAJ=E=FL (GJ=GN=J
L@= =KK9Q K@GOK L@9L O@AD= ;@9F?=K AF L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= @9N= 9 KE9DD =Z=;L GF
J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ
;@9F?=K AF !- @9N= 9 D9J?= =Z=;L
#GO=N=J
9DL@GM?@ L@= <=D9Q AF J=LAJ=E=FL J=<M;=K L@= :MJ<=F G> 9F 9?AF? HGH
MD9LAGF
L@= J=IMAJ=< SK;9D 9<BMKLE=FLK 9J= D9J?= /@= J=9KGF AK L@9L 0. KG;A9D
K=;MJALQ AK JGM?@DQ 9;LM9JA9DDQ >9AJ
A= L@= HJ=K=FL <AK;GMFL=< N9DM= G> :=F=SLK AK
JGM?@DQ L@= K9E= AJJ=KH=;LAN= G> L@= ;@GA;= G> J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= /@AK AEHDA=K L@9L
<=D9Q=< J=LAJ=E=FL GFDQ @9K 9 KE9DD =Z=;L GF HM:DA; ;GZ=JK
/@= =KK9Q 9DKG E9C=K 9F AEHGJL9FL ;GFLJA:MLAGF :Q IM9FLA>QAF? L@= ;GKLK G> 9F
9?AF? HGHMD9LAGF $F H9JLA;MD9J
AL AK K@GOF L@9L L@= ;MJJ=FL SK;9D HGDA;Q AF L@= 0.
;9F := KMKL9AF=< :Q 9F AF;J=9K= AF L9P=K G> H=J;=FL9?= HGAFLK
9 J=<M;LAGF AF
J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=K :Q GJ 9F AF;J=9K= AF !- LG L@= 9?= G> GL@ =KK9QK @9N= AEHGJL9FL AEHDA;9LAGFK >GJ L@= DAL=J9LMJ= GF KG;A9D K=;MJALQ 9F<
J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ
.'59+7 +<8 74:-.98 +<8 144*8 '3*
%# /8'89+7 "+1/+,
3974*:)9/43
$F (9Q 9 KLGJE KLJM;C $F<A9
J=HGJL=<DQ CADDAF? H=GHD= 9F< 9Z=;LAF? *F L@= K9E= <9Q
9 Q=9JGD< KGH@GEGJ= K@GL 9F< OGMF<=< KAP ;D9KKE9L=K 9L L@=
#=JAL9?= #A?@ .;@GGD AF KM:MJ:9F LD9FL9 /@= LOG =N=FLK ;GEH=L=< >GJ F=OK LAE=
.AF;= L@AK O9K BMKL 9 EGFL@ 9>L=J L@= GDME:AF= @A?@ K;@GGD LJ9?=<Q
L@= =N=FLK 9L
L@= #=JAL9?= #A?@ .;@GGD O=J= =PL=FKAN=DQ ;GN=J=< :Q L@= 0. L=D=NAKAGF F=LOGJC
F=OK
O@AD= L@= $F<A9F KLGJE O9K FGL ;GN=J=< :GML GF= Q=9J =9JDA=J
9 KLGJE G>
KAEAD9J KAR= KLJM;C $F<A9 CADDAF? 9F< 9Z=;LAF? H=GHD= L L@9L LAE=
L@=J=
O9K D=KK GL@=J :J=9CAF? F=OK
9F< L@= KLGJE O9K ;GN=J=< :Q L@= L=D=NAKAGF F=LOGJC
F=OK /OG <9QK D9L=J
L@= 0. E:9KK9<GJ AF $F<A9
-A;@9J< ! =D=KL=
<=;D9J=<
L@AK KLGJE 9 <AK9KL=J
9F< ALK NA;LAEK ;GFK=IM=FLDQ J=;=AN=< 0. J=DA=> #GO=N=J
@=
<A< FGL AKKM= 9 <AK9KL=J <=;D9J9LAGF >GJ L@= SJKL E=FLAGF=< KLGJE 9F< L@=J= O9K FG
0. ?GN=JFE=FL J=DA=>
/@AK H9H=J AFN=KLA?9L=K O@=L@=J L=D=NAKAGF F=LOGJC F=OK KLGJA=K AFTM=F;= ?GN=JF
E=FL HGDA;Q E9CAF? DL@GM?@ F=LOGJC F=OK AK OA<=DQ :=DA=N=< LG := 9F AEHGJL9FL
<=L=JEAF9FL G> ?GN=JFE=FL HGDA;Q
DALLD= ;GF;DMKAN= =NA<=F;= @9K :==F HJG<M;=< LG
L@AK =Z=;L
EHAJA;9D KLM<A=K @9N= LQHA;9DDQ DGGC=< 9L L@= HM:DA;9LAGF G> 9 KLGJQ
DAC=
L@= GF= 9:GN=
9F< KM:K=IM=FL HGDA;Q 0F>GJLMF9L=DQ
O= <G FGL CFGO O@9L OGMD<
@9N= @9HH=F=< AF L@= ;GMFL=J>9;LM9D ;9K=
A= A> L@=J= @9< :==F FG HM:DA;9LAGF $L
E9Q := L@9L HGDA;Q E9C=JK OGMD< @9N= 9;L=< AF L@= K9E= O9Q @9< L@= E=<A9 FGL
/@AK H9H=J AK BGAFL OAL@ 9NA< .LJ^E:=J? 2= L@9FC /GJKL=F +=JKKGF
L@9F &9HD9F
%9E=K
#9EADLGF
.L=>9FG =DD9NA?F9 9F< !9:JARAG 5ADA:GLLA >GJ @=DH>MD ;GEE=FLK 9F< KM??=KLAGFK
9F<
@JAKLAF9 '^FF:D9< >GJ =<ALGJA9D 9KKAKL9F;=
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! HM:DAK@=< L@= KLGJQ DL@GM?@ GF= AF;A<=FL
DAC= L@= GF= 9:GN=
;9FFGL ;GF;DMKAN=DQ
K@GO L@9L E=<A9 9Z=;LK HGDA;Q
9 KLM<Q G> 9 D9J?= FME:=J G> KAEAD9J =N=FLK ;9F GN=J
;GE= L@AK <AY;MDLQ 2= OADD K@GO L@9L 9:GN= H9LL=JF AK FGL BMKL 9F AKGD9L=< =N=FL
:ML H9JL G> 9 KQKL=E9LA; H9LL=JF AF L@= <9L9 9 H9LL=JF O@A;@ OGMD< := N=JQ MFDAC=DQ
A> E=<A9 <A< FGL 9Z=;L HGDA;Q
$F L@AK H9H=J
O= OADD KLM<Q E9KK E=<A9VK AFTM=F;= GF L@= 0. ?GN=JFE=FL
J=KHGFK= LG F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK AF <=N=DGHAF? ;GMFLJA=K /@= AF;A<=F;= 9F< K=N=JALQ G>
F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK 9J= 9J?M9:DQ 9F =PG?=FGMK HJG;=KK L@9L ?=F=J9L=K F=OKOGJL@Q 9F<
J=9KGF9:DQ O=DD <G;ME=FL=< =N=FLK 2= KLM<Q 9HHJGPAE9L=DQ F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK
AF <=N=DGHAF? ;GMFLJA=K :=LO==F 9F< /@=K= <AK9KL=JK O=J= A<=FLAS=< 9F<
<G;ME=FL=< :Q L@= =FLJ= >GJ -=K=9J;@ GF L@= HA<=EAGDG?Q G> AK9KL=JK - *F 9N=J9?=
F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK G;;MJJ=< =9;@ Q=9J <MJAF? L@= H=JAG< L9CAF? 9JGMF<
DAN=K 9F< 9Z=;LAF? EADDAGF H=GHD= ;;GJ<AF? LG GMJ =KLAE9L=K
9:GML H=J;=FL G> L@=K= F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK O=J= ;GN=J=< AF L@= L=D=NAKAGF F=LOGJC F=OK 9F< H=J;=FL J=;=AN=< J=DA=> >JGE 0.$VK *Y;= G> !GJ=A?F AK9KL=J KKAKL9F;= *!
/@AK O9K >GMF< 9>L=J 9F9DQRAF? L@= ;GFL=FLK G> L@= =N=FAF? F=OK :JG9<;9KLK G> L@=
0. E9BGJ F=LOGJCK .
)
9F< ))
<9L9 HJGNA<=< :Q L@= 19F<=J:ADL
)=OK J;@AN=K
9F< J=DA=> <9L9 >JGE *!
/@= G:NAGMK HJG:D=E AF =KL9:DAK@AF? L@= AEH9;L G> F=OK GF J=DA=> AK L@9L EGJ=
K=N=J= <AK9KL=JK 9J= :GL@ EGJ= DAC=DQ LG := AF L@= F=OK 9F< LG J=;=AN= J=DA=> 2=
9LL9;C L@AK HJG:D=E :Q MKAF? L@= 9N9AD9:ADALQ G> GL@=J F=OKOGJL@Q E9L=JA9D 9K 9F
AFKLJME=FL >GJ O@=L@=J L@= <AK9KL=J O9K AF L@= F=OK $F GL@=J OGJ<K
O= 9J= 9KCAF?
O@=L@=J 9 F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=J AK D=KK DAC=DQ LG J=;=AN= J=DA=> :=;9MK= F=OK 9:GML L@AK
<AK9KL=J O9K ;JGO<=< GML :Q F=OK 9:GML
>GJ =P9EHD=
L@= K@GGLAF?K 9L L@= #=JAL9?=
#A?@ .;@GGD
L@= *DQEHA;K
GJ L@= *% .AEHKGF LJA9D
IM9DDQ AEHGJL9FL
O= 9DKG
KLM<Q O@=L@=J <AK9KL=JK G> EGJ= EG<=J9L= KAR= 9J= EGJ= DAC=DQ LG J=;=AN= J=DA=> KAEHDQ
:=;9MK= L@=Q 9HH=9J=< GF L@= =N=FAF? F=OK KAF;= L@=J= O9K DALLD= GL@=J F=OK 9JGMF<
2= MK= LOG E=9KMJ=K G> L@= 9N9AD9:ADALQ G> F=OKOGJL@Q E9L=JA9D *F= AK KGD=DQ
:9K=< GF L@= <9L=K G> L@= *DQEHA; "9E=K /@= *DQEHA;K HJG<M;= F=OKOGJL@Q
E9L=JA9D <MJAF? KH=;AS; <9L=K /@= :MDC G> L@= F=OK KLGJA=K 9:GML L@= *DQEHA;K
L@9L O= A<=FLA>Q 9J= 9AJ=< <MJAF? L@= ?9E=K 2= OADD MK= L@= 9N=J9?= FME:=J G> <9QK
AEE=<A9L=DQ >GDDGOAF? 9 <AK9KL=J L@9L >9DDK OAL@AF L@= <MJ9LAGF G> L@= *DQEHA;K 9K
2= L@9FC *! 9F< 2=KD=Q (GKK:MJ? >GJ HJGNA<AF? L@= <9L9 9F< GL@=J AF>GJE9LAGF L@JGM?@
GML L@= HJGB=;L
2= OADD MK= L@= L=JE F=OKOGJL@Q LG E=9F L@= 9M<A=F;= 9HH=9D G> L@= F=OK 9K H=J;=AN=< :Q
L@= E=<A9
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! 9F AFKLJME=FL >GJ F=OK ;GN=J9?= G> <AK9KL=JK
/@= GL@=J E=9KMJ= AK L@= 9EGMFL G> LAE= KH=FL GF L@= LGH L@J== F=OK K=?E=FLK
AF 9 F=LOGJC F=OK :JG9<;9KL 2@=F 9 D9J?= E=<A9 =N=FL L9C=K HD9;=
L@= KLGJQ AK
MKM9DDQ HD9;=< 9K GF= G> L@= SJKL F=OK KLGJA=K AF 9 :JG9<;9KL 9F< <=NGL=< 9 ?J=9L
<=9D G> LAE= !GJ AFKL9F;=
GF *;LG:=J 9 BMJQ >GMF< *% .AEHKGF FGL ?MADLQ
G> LOG ;GMFLK G> EMJ<=J /@9L FA?@L
L@= . 9F< ) <=NGL=< 9DD L@=AJ
SJKL L@J== F=OK K=?E=FLK LG L@9L KLGJQ /@= LGH L@J== F=OK K=?E=FLK ;GEHJAK=< 9F
9N=J9?= G> EAFML=K 9F< K=;GF<K X L@= @A?@=KL N9DM= G> L@9L Q=9J $F ;GEH9JAKGF
L@= 9N=J9?= 9EGMFL G> LAE= KH=FL GF L@= LGH L@J== F=OK K=?E=FLK AF O9K EAFML=K /@= .AEHKGF N=J<A;L =Z=;LAN=DQ ;JGO<=< GML GL@=J F=OK ) /.,9 ;GN=J=<
L@AK KLGJQ
O@AD= . 9DKG J=HGJL=< GF= GL@=J KLGJQ KLG;C E9JC=L J=HGJL 9F< AF;DM<=< GL@=J KLGJA=K .AF;= <AK9KL=J F=OK AK G>L=F :JG9<;9KL 9>L=J L@= <9Q L@=
<AK9KL=J KLJM;C
O= 9N=J9?= L@AK E=9KMJ= GN=J L@= <9QK >GDDGOAF? L@= <AK9KL=J KLJAC=
<9L= 2= ;9DD L@AK N9JA9:D= .&73 02&3352&
2= 9J?M= L@9L O@=F L@=J= AK HD=FLQ G> GL@=J F=OKOGJL@Q E9L=JA9D 9N9AD9:D=
L@=F
F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK AF >GJ=A?F ;GMFLJA=K 9J= ;JGO<=< GML >JGE F=LOGJC F=OK :JG9<;9KLK
9F<
;GFK=IM=FLDQ
9J= D=KK DAC=DQ LG J=;=AN= 0. J=DA=> /@=J= AK FG H9JLA;MD9J J=9KGF
LG :=DA=N= L@9L L@= K=N=JALQ G> F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK AF >GJ=A?F ;GMFLJA=K AK J=D9L=< LG L@=
9N9AD9:ADALQ G> GL@=J F=OK .LADD
0. E:9KK9<GJK X O@G 9J= LQHA;9DDQ J=KHGFKA:D=
>GJ <AK9KL=J <=;D9J9LAGFK X 9J= D=KK DAC=DQ LG <=;D9J= <AK9KL=JK <MJAF? L@= *DQEHA;K
9F< <MJAF? LAE=K O@=F 0. .&73 02&3352& AK @A?@ K== !A?MJ= 2= OADD K@GO
L@9L L@=K= ;GJJ=D9LAGFK J=E9AF 9>L=J 9;;GMFLAF? >GJ L@= FME:=J G> CADD=< 9F< 9Z=;L=<
9K O=DD 9K SP=< =Z=;LK >GJ <AK9KL=J LQH=
EGFL@
Q=9J 9F< ;GMFLJQ
HGL=FLA9D HJG:D=E AK L@9L .&73 02&3352& E9Q := <AJ=;LDQ 9Z=;L=< :Q L@= HM:
DA;9LAGF G> <AK9KL=J F=OK $> <AK9KL=J F=OK AK HD9;=< 9EGF? L@= LGH L@J== KLGJA=K
L@AK
OADD ?=F=J9L= 9 HGKALAN= ;GJJ=D9LAGF :=LO==F F=OK HJ=KKMJ= 9F< L@= K=N=JALQ G> L@=
<AK9KL=J $> F=OK 9:GML L@= <AK9KL=J AK HD9;=< GMLKA<= L@= LGH L@J==
AL EA?@L ;9MK=
D=KK LAE= LG := <=NGL=< LG L@= LGH L@J== K=?E=FLK
AF<M;AF? 9 F=?9LAN= ;GJJ=D9LAGF
/@AK ;GF;=JF AK 9<<J=KK=< AF LOG O9QK !AJKL
O= J=EGN= 9DD <9QK O@=F 9FQ <AK9KL=J
KLGJQ O9K 9AJ=< >JGE L@= <9Q 9N=J9?= /@AK @9K 9 EAFAE9D AEH9;L GF L@= =KLA
E9L=< ;G=Y;A=FLK )=PL
O= AFL=FLAGF9DDQ :A9K .&73 02&3352& :Q 9<<AF? 9DD F=OK
LAE= <=NGL=< LG <AK9KL=J KLGJA=K LG L@= LAE= <=NGL=< LG L@= LGH L@J== F=OK K=?E=FLK
$F J=9DALQ
L@= F=OK LAE= >J==< MH :Q FGL 9AJAF? L@= <AK9KL=J F=OK OGMD< H9JLA9DDQ :=
9DDG;9L=< LG F=OK K=?E=FLK GMLKA<= L@= LGH L@J==
N=F L@AK =PLJ=E= AF<M;=< :A9K
/@AK AFKLJME=FL AK J=D9L=< LG L@9L MK=< AF JT= 9F< (;(ADD9F A= L@= O==CDQ 9N=J9?=
H=J;=FL9?= G> LGL9D F=OK LAE= <=NGL=< LG L@= LOG D=9<AF? FGF=F=J?Q F=OK LGHA;K
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! .14
Share disasters receiving relief
.16
.18
.2
.22
p<5
5<p<10
(News Drought)
10<p<25
25<p<50
50<p<75
75<p<90
News pressure, percentiles
90<p<95
95<p
(News flood)
!A?MJ= .@9J= F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK J=;=ANAF? *! J=DA=>
:Q <GE=KLA; 0. F=OK
HJ=KKMJ=
@9K DALLD= AFTM=F;= GF GMJ =KLAE9L=< ;G=Y;A=FLK
/@AK H9H=J AK ;DGK=DQ J=D9L=< LG J=;=FL OGJC KLM<QAF? @GO E9KK E=<A9 H=F=LJ9
LAGF 9Z=;LK ?GN=JFE=FL HGDA;Q .LJ^E:=J? SF<K L@9L 0. ;GMFLA=K OAL@
@A?@=J D=N=DK G> J9<AG GOF=JK@AH O=J= EGJ= KM;;=KK>MD AF 9LLJ9;LAF? )=O =9D KH=F<
AF? .AEAD9JDQ
=KD=Q 9F< MJ?=KK SF< L@9L ?GN=JFE=FL J=DA=> HJG?J9EK O=J=
EGJ= J=KHGFKAN= LG <JGM?@LK 9F< TGG<K AF $F<A9F KL9L=K OAL@ 9 @A?@=J F=OKH9H=J
;AJ;MD9LAGF /@= IM=KLAGF O= 9KC AK AFKL=9< "AN=F E=<A9 H=F=LJ9LAGF @GO D9J?= AK
L@= =Z=;L GF ?GN=JFE=FL HGDA;Q G> HM:DAK@AF? 9 F=OK KLGJQ
/@AK IM=KLAGF @9K DGF? :==F KLM<A=< :Q HGDALA;9D K;A=FLAKLK !GJ 9F GN=JNA=O
K==
L@= ;@9HL=J /@= (=<A9 K +GDA;Q (9C=JK AF "J9:=J K E=FLAGF=< =9JDA=J
L@AK DAL=J9LMJ= @9K FGL :==F KM;;=KK>MD AF A<=FLA>QAF? L@= E=<A9VK HGDA;Q AFTM=F;=
$L @9K
@GO=N=J
A<=FLAS=< 9 FME:=J G> =EHAJA;9D HAL>9DDK !GJ =P9EHD=
GGC =L
9D KLM<Q L@= HGDA;Q =Z=;L G> E=<A9 =PHGKMJ= G> >J9M< 9F< 9:MK= AF 9 #GE=
#=9DL@ 9J= HJG?J9E AF @A;9?G /@= J=K=9J;@=JK O=J= AF>GJE=< AF 9<N9F;= L@9L 9
F=OK KLGJQ OGMD< := :JG9<;9KL 9F< @9< L@= GHHGJLMFALQ G> AFL=JNA=OAF? H=GHD= HJ=
9F< HGKL HM:DA;9LAGF /@=Q >GMF< L@9L L@= HM:DA;9LAGF ;@9F?=< HGDALA;A9FKV 9F< L@=
?=F=J9D HM:DA;VK NA=OK 9F< O9K =N=FLM9DDQ >GDDGO=< :Q 9 ;@9F?= AF L@= D=?AKD9LAGF
#GO=N=J
AL LMJF=< GML L@9L L@= F=OK KLGJQ O9K AFALA9L=< :Q HGDALA;A9FK K==CAF? HGDA;Q
;@9F?=
KG AL AK IM=KLAGF9:D= O@=L@=J L@= F=OK KLGJQ 9;LM9DDQ ;9MK=< L@= HGDA;Q
;@9F?= /@AK ADDMKLJ9L=K 9 ?=F=JA; HJG:D=E AF A<=FLA>QAF? E=<A9 =Z=;LK HGDALA;A9FK
MK= L@= E=<A9 LG HMJKM= HGDA;Q ?G9DK $F L@= ;GFL=PL G> GMJ H9H=J
HGDA;Q E9C=JK
E9Q E9C= L@= HJ=KK 9O9J= G> <AK9KL=JK LG O@A;@ L@=Q O9FL LG K=F< J=DA=> LG
;J=9LAF?
9 KHMJAGMK ;GJJ=D9LAGF :=LO==F ;GN=J9?= 9F< KM:K=IM=FL J=DA=>
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! FGL@=J HJG:D=E AK L@9L
=N=F H=J>=;LDQ ;GFLJGDDAF? >GJ L@= K=N=JALQ G> L@= <AK9KL=J
E=<A9 ;GN=J9?= OADD := ;GJJ=D9L=< OAL@ J=DA=> :=;9MK= :GL@ 9J= <JAN=F :Q L@= MFG:
K=JN9:D= K9DA=F;= G> L@= <AK9KL=J LG L@= E=JA;9F HM:DA; /@AK AK FA;=DQ ADDMKLJ9L=<
:Q JMJQ
*DKGF 9F< 19F =DD= /@=AJ H9H=J AK N=JQ ;DGK=DQ J=D9L=< LG GMJK
AF KLM<QAF? L@= =EHAJA;9D 9DDG;9LAGF G> 0. >GJ=A?F <AK9KL=J 9KKAKL9F;= /@=Q ;GF;DM<= L@9L >GJ=A?F HGDA;Q 9F< <GE=KLA; >9;LGJK 9J= L@= GN=JJA<AF? <=L=JEA
F9FLK G> L@AK 9DDG;9LAGF *> H9JLA;MD9J AFL=J=KL OAL@ J=?9J< LG GMJ H9H=J
L@=Q SF<
<AK9KL=J J=DA=> LG := HGKALAN=DQ ;GJJ=D9L=< OAL@ L@= K9DA=F;= G> L@= <AK9KL=J
E=9KMJ=<
:Q L@= 9EGMFL G> E=<A9 ;GN=J9?= *MJ AFKLJME=FL9D N9JA9:D=K 9HHJG9;@ 9NGA<K :GL@
L@=K= HAL>9DDK KAF;= L@= 9N9AD9:ADALQ G> GL@=J F=OKOGJL@Q E9L=JA9D AK MFJ=D9L=< LG L@=
K9DA=F;= G> <AK9KL=JK 9F< HGDALA;A9FKV HGDA;Q ?G9DK J=?9J<AF? <AK9KL=J J=DA=>
2@AD= E=<A9 ;GN=J9?= AK >GMF< LG 9Z=;L <AK9KL=J J=DA=>
O= <G FGL MF;GN=J L@=
=P9;L E=;@9FAKE L@JGM?@ O@A;@ G;;MJK $F ?=F=J9D L=JEK
<AK9KL=J J=DA=> LQHA;9DDQ
<=DAN=JK >9NGJ9:D= HM:DA;ALQ
O@A;@ ;9F := =FBGQ=< :Q HGDA;Q E9C=JK HJGNA<AF? J=DA=>
LG <AK9KL=JK ;GN=J=< AF L@= F=OK ML L@AK AK ;GFKAKL=FL OAL@ 9 FME:=J G> L@=GJA=K
!AJKL
NGL=JK E9Q =N9DM9L= HGDALA;A9FK :9K=< GF AKKM=K J=;=FLDQ ;GN=J=< :Q L@= E=<A9
(;GE:K 9F< .@9O
/@MK
A> 9 <AK9KL=J O9K J=;=FLDQ ;GN=J=< AF L@= E=<A9
L@AK E9Q =F@9F;= L@= K9DA=F;= G> L@= AKKM= 9L L@= :9DDGL :GP .=;GF<
HGDALA;A9FK @9N=
9 KLJGF?=J AF;=FLAN= LG 9;L O@=F NGL=JK ;9F G:K=JN= L@=AJ 9;LAGFK L@JGM?@ L@= E=<A9
KAF;= G:K=JN9:D= 9;LAGFK @9N= 9 KLJGF?=J AFTM=F;= GF KM:K=IM=FL NGL=K .LJ^E:=J?
/@AJ<
NGL=JK E9Q J=KHGF< LG F=OK KLGJA=K :Q <AJ=;LDQ LJQAF? LG AFTM=F;=
L@=AJ J=HJ=K=FL9LAN=K <AJ=;LDQ +M:DA; ;LAGF $F 9DD ;9K=K
AL AK 9KKME=< L@9L L@=
?GN=JFE=FL GY;A9D L9CAF? L@= J=DA=> <=;AKAGF ;9J=K 9:GML L@= HGDALA;A9FKV =D=;LGJ9D
KMHHGJL /@= J=9KGF ;GMD< =AL@=J := L@9L L@= ?GN=JFE=FL GY;9D ;9J=K 9:GML L@=
>MF<AF? G> L@= J=DA=> HJG?J9E K== )AKC9F=F
9F< L@AK AK AF;J=9KAF? AF ALK
HGDALA;9D HGHMD9JALQ
GJ L@9L L@= GY;A9DVK >MLMJ= ;9J==J <=H=F<K GF @GO KCADD>MDDQ K@=
E9F9?=K L@= J=DA=> HJG?J9E AF L@= HGDALA;A9FKV AFL=J=KL K== D=KAF9 9F< /9:=DDAFA
$F HH=F<AP L@= +M:DA; ;LAGF 9F< 1GL=J $F>GJE9LAGF EG<=DK G> <AK9KL=J
J=DA=> 9J= <=N=DGH=< 9F< <=K;JA:=< EGJ= AF EGJ= <=L9AD
/@= H9H=J AK GJ?9FAR=< 9K >GDDGOK .=;LAGF <AK;MKK=K L@= :9;C?JGMF< 9F< <9L9
O@AD= K=;LAGF <AK;MKK=K L@= J=KMDLK /@=F
K=;LAGF <AK;MKK=K O@9L ;GFLAF=FLK 9F<
<AK9KL=J LQH=K 9J= EGJ= DAC=DQ LG J=;=AN= J=DA=> :=;9MK= G> L@= E=<A9 =Z=;LK
9F< 9DKG
!GJ AFKL9F;=
<9EKGF =L 9D SF< L@9L G> L@= 0. HGHMD9LAGF KMHHGJL 0. >GJ=A?F
=;GFGEA; 9KKAKL9F;= 9F< L@9L :=DA=N= L@9L >GJ=A?F <AK9KL=J J=DA=> K@GMD< := ?AN=F L@= @A?@=KL
HJAGJALQ AF 0. >GJ=A?F 9A< HGDA;Q /@= 9N=J9?= HJAGJALQ ?AN=F LG >GJ=A?F <AK9KL=J J=DA=> O9K GF
9 K;9D=
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! GZ=JK ;GF;DM<AF? J=E9JCK
')0-74:3* '3* '9'
/@AK K=;LAGF HJ=K=FLK L@= <9L9 GF <AK9KL=JK
<AK9KL=J J=DA=> 9F< L=D=NAKAGF F=OK /9:D=
HJGNA<=K KMEE9JQ KL9LAKLA;K G> GMJ <9L9
/8'89+78
2= MK= <9L9 GF F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK >JGE L@=
E=J?=F;Q AK9KL=J 9L9:9K= 9K HJGNA<=< :Q L@= =FLJ= >GJ -=K=9J;@ GF L@= HA<=EAGDG?Q G> AK9KL=JK - $F L@AK <9L9:9K=
9F =N=FL IM9DAS=K 9K 9 <AK9KL=J A> 9L D=9KL GF= G> L@= >GDDGOAF?
;JAL=JA9 9J= >MDSDD=< GJ EGJ= H=GHD= 9J= J=HGJL=< CADD=< GJ EGJ= H=GHD= 9J=
J=HGJL=< 9Z=;L=<
AFBMJ=< 9F<GJ @GE=D=KK L@=J= @9K :==F 9 <=;D9J9LAGF G> 9 KL9L=
G> =E=J?=F;Q GJ L@=J= @9K :==F 9 ;9DD >GJ AFL=JF9LAGF9D 9KKAKL9F;= 2= E=9KMJ= L@=
K=N=JALQ G> 9 <AK9KL=J :Q LOG N9JA9:D=K L@= FME:=J G> CADD=<
<=FGL=< +*,,&%
9F< L@=
LGL9D FME:=J G> 9Z=;L=<
<=FGL=< ":&$4&% /@= N9JA9:D= +*,,&% 9J= H=JKGFK ;GFSJE=<
<=9< 9F< H=JKGFK EAKKAF? 9F< HJ=KME=< <=9< /@= N9JA9:D= ":&$4&% AK L@= KME G>
WAFBMJ=<W
W@GE=D=KKW 9F< W9Z=;L=<W 9K J=HGJL=< AF
/@= <9L9 HJGNA<=<
AF AK :9K=< GF GY;A9D S?MJ=K O@=F 9N9AD9:D=
2= 9F9DQR= 9 KM:K9EHD= G> L@AK <AK9KL=J <9L9 /G 9NGA< KGE= =F<G?=F=ALQ HJG:
D=EK
O= J=KLJA;L 9LL=FLAGF LG F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK /@MK
O= <G FGL ;GFKA<=J ;GEHD=P
=E=J?=F;A=K 9F< L=;@FGDG?A;9D <AK9KL=JK =? 9AJHD9F= ;J9K@=K 2= 9DKG <JGH L@= G:K=JN9LAGFK GF <AK9KL=JK L@9L G;;MJJ=< HJAGJ LG M?MKL L@= <9L= O@=F L@=
19F<=J:ADL /=D=NAKAGF )=OK J;@AN=K KL9JL=< ;GDD=;LAF? <9L9 .AF;=
>GJ L@= HMJHGK=
G> L@AK KLM<Q
AL AK AEHGJL9FL LG CFGO L@= <9L= G> L@= <AK9KL=J
O= <JGH G:K=J
N9LAGFK >GJ O@A;@ O= GFDQ @9N= AF>GJE9LAGF 9:GML L@= Q=9J G> L@= =N=FL !AF9DDQ
KAF;= GMJ KH=;AS;9LAGF 9DDGOK >GJ ;GMFLJQ SP=< =Z=;LK
O= GFDQ AF;DM<= ;GMFLJA=K OAL@
EGJ= L@9F GF= <AK9KL=J 9F< O@A;@ @9K J=;=AN=< *! J=DA=> 9L D=9KL GF;= !GJ L@AK
J=9KGF
O= <JGH G:K=JN9LAGFK
+=GHD= KMZ=JAF? >JGE H@QKA;9D AFBMJA=K
LJ9ME9 GJ 9F ADDF=KK J=IMAJAF? E=<A;9D LJ=9LE=FL 9K 9
<AJ=;L J=KMDL G> 9 <AK9KL=J
+=GHD= F==<AF? AEE=<A9L= 9KKAKL9F;= AF L@= >GJE G> K@=DL=J
+=GHD= J=IMAJAF? AEE=<A9L= 9KKAKL9F;= <MJAF? 9 H=JAG< G> =E=J?=F;Q
A= J=IMAJAF? :9KA; KMJ
NAN9D F==<K KM;@ 9K >GG<
O9L=J
K@=DL=J
K9FAL9LAGF 9F< AEE=<A9L= E=<A;9D 9KKAKL9F;=
- VK KGMJ;= J9FCAF? AK 9K >GDDGOK 0)
0. ?GN=JFE=FL
DG;9D ?GN=JFE=FL
$!-
-=K=9J;@
=FLJ=K
'DGQ<K 9KM9DLQ 2==C
-=AFKMJ9F;=
+J=KK
+JAN9L=
(9FE9<= <AK9KL=JK ;GEHD=P <AK9KL=JK J9AK= GL@=J FGFLJANA9D AKKM=K LQH= G> O9J
K9>=LQ >GJ
9A< OGJC=JK =L; O@A;@ 9J= :=QGF< L@= K;GH= G> L@AK H9H=J
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! /@AK D=9N=K MK OAL@ 9 LGL9D G> F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK
G;;MJJAF? AF ;GMFLJA=K
AF *F 9N=J9?=
F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK G;;MJJ=< =9;@ Q=9J L9CAF? 9JGMF<
DAN=K 9F< 9Z=;LAF? EADDAGF H=GHD=
9;@ <AK9KL=J GF 9N=J9?= @9< ;9KM9DLA=K 9F< 9Z=;L=< L@= DAN=K G> EADDAGF H=GHD= K== /9:D= /@= E9BGJALQ G> F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK O=J= ;9MK=< :Q TGG<K H=J;=FL
KLGJEK
H=J;=FL GJ =HA<=EA;K H=J;=FL JGM?@LK LGGC EGKL ;9KM9DLA=K 9F< 9Z=;L=<
EGKL H=GHD= H=J AF;A<=FL !AJ=K 9F< TGG<K ;9MK=< L@= >=O=KL ;9KM9DLA=K H=J AF;A<=FL
O@AD= AF>=KL9LAGFK @9< L@= KE9DD=KL FME:=J G> 9Z=;L=<
/@=J= AK 9 KDA?@L <GOFO9J< LJ=F< AF L@= K=N=JALQ G> <AK9KL=JK 9K E=9KMJ=< :Q L@=
E=9F FME:=J G> +*,,&% 9F< ":&$4&% /@AK AK H9JLDQ <JAN=F :Q AEHJGN=E=FLK AF <9L9
;GDD=;LAGF HJG;=<MJ=K LGO9J<K L@= =F< G> L@= K9EHD= H=JAG<
O@A;@ @9K AF;J=9K=< L@=
9N9AD9:ADALQ G> <9L9 GF D=KK K=N=J= <AK9KL=JK
%# 2+7-+3)> "+1/+, '3* /@= 0. AK L@= D9J?=KL HJGNA<=J G> =E=J?=F;Q 9F< <AKLJ=KK J=DA=> :Q >9J
9;;GMFLAF? >GJ
9JGMF< 9 L@AJ< G> L@= LGL9D =E=J?=F;Q 9A< HJGNA<=< :Q * ;GMFLJA=K LG <=N=DGHAF?
;GMFLJA=K $F >GJ AFKL9F;=
* ;GMFLJA=K HJGNA<=< 0. EADDAGF AF
=E=J?=F;Q 9F< <AKLJ=KK J=DA=>
G> O@A;@ L@= 0. 9;;GMFL=< >GJ 0. EADDAGF GJ
H=J;=FL * 2= OADD KLM<Q <AK9KL=J J=KHGFK=K :Q L@= *Y;= G> !GJ=A?F AK9KL=J KKAKL9F;=
*! GN=J L@= H=JAG< /@= *! AK 9F GY;= OAL@AF L@= 0. ?=F;Q
>GJ $FL=JF9LAGF9D =N=DGHE=FL 0.$ $L @9K :==F ?AN=F T=PA:D= 9ML@GJALQ O@A;@
H=JEALK AL LG J=KHGF< IMA;CDQ LG L@= F==<K G> <AK9KL=J NA;LAEK #=F;=
AL AK ?=F=J9DDQ
L@= SJKL 0. 9?=F;Q LG := GF L@= K;=F= G> 9 <AK9KL=J 9F< AL 9DKG AFTM=F;= GL@=J
J=DA=> =ZGJLK !GJ =P9EHD=
L@= D9J?=KL 0. <AK9KL=J J=DA=> HJG?J9E
MF<=J L@= *Y;=
G> !GG< >GJ +=9;=
J=IMAJ=K 9F *! <AK9KL=J <=;D9J9LAGF LG LJA??=J KGE= G> ALK
<AK9KL=J 9KKAKL9F;= DL@GM?@ L@= *! GFDQ ;GFLJA:ML=K 9JGMF< G> L@= LGL9D
0. <AK9KL=J J=DA=>
=9;@ <GDD9J KH=FL :Q L@= *! O9K E9L;@=< :Q >GMJ <GDD9JK
>JGE GL@=J 0. 9?=F;A=K AF L@= SK;9D Q=9J G> *MJ <=H=F<=FL N9JA9:D=
2&,*&'
AF<A;9L=K O@=L@=J L@= *! HJGNA<=< J=DA=> LG
L@= <AK9KL=J *N=J L@= H=JAG< L@= *! J=KHGF<=< LG H=J;=FL G> L@=
<AK9KL=JK AF L@= K9EHD= GJ
GF 9N=J9?=
F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK H=J Q=9J
.GE= <AK9KL=JK @9N= EAKKAF? N9DM=K >GJ +*,,&% 9F< ":&$4&% /@=J=>GJ=
E=9F N9DM=K J=>=J LG L@=
KM:K9EHD= O@=J= G:K=JN9LAGFK =PAKL 2= LJ=9L =FLJA=K AF +*,,&% 9F< ":&$4&% 9K EAKKAF? N9DM=K
9>L=J ;GJJ=KHGF<=F;= OAL@ - #! %" !$#" %" " ""#! <AK9KL=J J=;=AN=K *! J=DA=> A> 9F< GFDQ A> AL AK <=;D9J=< <AK9KL=J ;9F :=
<=;D9J=< :Q L@= 0. E:9KK9<GJ L@= @A=> G> L@= 0. (AKKAGF AF L@= 9Z=;L=<
;GMFLJQ GJ
A> 9 0. (AKKAGF AK FGL DG;9L=< AF L@= ;GMFLJQ
:Q L@= 9HHJGHJA9L= 0.
KKAKL9FL .=;J=L9JQ <AK9KL=J <=;D9J9LAGF 9DDGOK L@= @A=> G> (AKKAGF LG 9DDG;9L= MH
LG 0. MFLAD 0. >GJ @GKL ;GMFLJQ J=DA=> =ZGJLK .M:K=IM=FLDQ
0.$ 9F< L@= DG;9D EAKKAGF BGAFLDQ <=L=JEAF= O@=L@=J 9<<ALAGF9D 9KKAKL9F;= >GJ L@=
<AK9KL=J AK O9JJ9FL=<
AK9KL=J J=DA=> AK AFL=F<=< LG 9<<J=KK *--&%*"4& DA>= L@J=9L=FAF? ;GF;=JFK 0.
$
/@= <AK9KL=J K@GMD< E==L L@J== ;JAL=JA9 AL AK G> 9 E9?FALM<= OAL@
O@A;@ L@= 9Z=;L=< ;GEEMFALQ ;9FFGL ;GH=
J=;G?FAR=< J=HJ=K=FL9LAN=K G> L@= 9>
>=;L=< HGHMD9LAGF <=KAJ= L@= 9KKAKL9F;= 9F< AL AK AF L@= 0. "GN=JFE=FLVK AFL=J=KL
LG J=KHGF<
/@= K@9J= G> <AK9KL=JK LG O@A;@ L@= *! @9K J=KHGF<=< <AZ=JK KM:KL9FLA9DDQ
9;JGKK <AK9KL=JK LQH=K
.== /9:D= $F>=KL9LAGFK
<JGM?@LK
9F< NGD;9FGK J=;=AN=
L@= @A?@=KL J=KHGFK= J9L=K
O@AD= ;GD< O9N=K 9F< D9F< KDA<=K J=;=AN= L@= DGO=KL K
=PH=;L=<
L@= *! J=KHGF<K LG <AK9KL=JK L@9L 9J= EGJ= K=N=J= L@9F L@= 9N=J9?=
OAL@ 9F 9N=J9?= G> CADD=< 9F< EADDAGF 9Z=;L=<
+<8 4;+7'-+
*MJ =PHD9F9LGJQ N9JA9:D= G> AFL=J=KL AK 0. F=OK ;GN=J9?= G> <AK9KL=JK $F L@AK
H9H=J
O= J=KLJA;L 9LL=FLAGF LG L=D=NAKAGF F=OK 9L9 GF F=OK ;GN=J9?= AK L9C=F
>JGE L@= 19F<=J:ADL /=D=NAKAGF )=OK J;@AN= 1/) 1/) ;GFL9AFK EGJ= L@9F
AF<ANA<M9D F=LOGJC =N=FAF? F=OK :JG9<;9KLK 9F< F=OK KLGJA=K >JGE
L@= E9BGJ 0. F9LAGF9D :JG9<;9KL F=LOGJCK .
)
9F< )) KAF;=
)=OK ;GN=J9?= AK ;9HLMJ=< :Q 9F AF<A;9LGJ N9JA9:D=
.&73 >GJ O@=L@=J 9
<AK9KL=J O9K ;GN=J=< AF 9 F=OK :JG9<;9KL OAL@AF 9 ;=JL9AF LAE=KH9FOAF<GO $F GMJ
:=F;@E9JC KH=;AS;9LAGF
O= MK= 9 OAF<GO G> LG <9QK
J=D9LAN= LG L@= LAE=
G> L@= =N=FL 2AL@AF L@AK AFL=JN9D
9 F=OK K=?E=FL AK ;G<=< 9K ;GN=JAF? 9 <AK9KL=J A>
AL ;GFL9AFK ;=JL9AF C=QOGJ<K ;GMFLJQ 9F< LQH= G> <AK9KL=J
=? =9JL@IM9C= !GJ
=P9EHD=
9;;GJ<AF? LG - 9F =9JL@IM9C= G;;MJJ=< AF >?@9FAKL9F GF (9J;@ 2= ;G<= 9 <AK9KL=J 9K :=AF? ;GN=J=< AF L@= F=OK A> L@= @=9<DAF= GJ 9:KLJ9;L
AF 1/) ;GFL9AFK L@= OGJ<K >?@9FAKL9F 9F< 9JL@IM9C=
9F< A> L@= KLGJQ
O9K 9AJ=< (9J;@ HJAD <9QK
)) KAF;= *;LG:=J :=>GJ= 9DD O=J= KH=;A9D HJG?J9EK
"=F=J9DDQ EGJ= 9<N9F;=< :GGD=9F K=9J;@=K 9J= ;GF<M;L=<
0
.05
Fraction
.1
.15
.2
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! 0
10
20
date_dist
30
40
!A?MJ= )=OK KLGJA=K GF <AK9KL=JK
:Q <9QK >JGE L@= <AK9KL=J
)=LOGJC F=OK ;GN=J=< 9JGMF< H=J;=FL G> L@= <AK9KL=JK AF GMJ K9EHD= !A?MJ=
HDGLK L@= LAEAF? G> L@= SJKL F=OK KLGJQ GF 9 <AK9KL=J J=D9LAN= LG L@= <9L= G> L@=
<AK9KL=J /@= SJKL F=OK KLGJQ AK LQHA;9DDQ 9AJ=< <MJAF? L@= SJKL <9QK >GDDGOAF? L@=
<AK9KL=J /@= DAC=DA@GG< G> ;GN=JAF? L@= <AK9KL=J L@=F >9DDK J9HA<DQ MFLAD 9JGMF< <9QK 9>L=J L@= <AK9KL=J 9F< L@=F J=E9AFK J=D9LAN=DQ ;GFKL9FL
74<*/3- :9 4, /8'89+7 +<8
$> LOG =IM9DDQ F=OKOGJL@Q <AK9KL=JK G;;MJ
O= OGMD< =PH=;L L@9L L@= <AK9KL=J G;;MJ
JAF? O@=F L@=J= AK 9 ?J=9L <=9D G> GL@=J :J=9CAF? F=OK 9JGMF< OGMD< @9N= 9 DGO=J
;@9F;= G> :=AF? ;GN=J=< :Q L@= F=OK L@9F L@9L G;;MJJAF? O@=F L@=J= AK DALLD= GL@=J
F=OK 9JGMF< /@AK ;JGO<AF? GML AK HJG:9:DQ H9JLA;MD9JDQ KLJGF? >GJ L=D=NAKAGF F=OK
:JG9<;9KLK L@9L 9J= MKM9DDQ G> 9 SP=< D=F?L@ @9D> 9F @GMJ >GJ . 9F< )
9F< GF= @GMJ >GJ ))
/@= ;@9DD=F?= AK LG ;GFKLJM;L E=9FAF?>MD 9F< GH=J9LAGF9D E=9KMJ=K G> L@= 9N9AD
9:ADALQ G> F=OKOGJL@Q E9L=JA9D #=J=
O= AEHD=E=FL LOG KM;@ E=9KMJ=K /@= SJKL
E=9KMJ= GFDQ <=H=F<K GF L@= <9L=K G> L@= *DQEHA; "9E=K $F GMJ K9EHD= H=JAG<
L@=J= 9J= *DQEHA; "9E=K
J9F?AF? >JGE L@= KMEE=J *DQEHA;K AF (=PA;G
ALQ LG L@= OAFL=J ?9E=K AF .9DL '9C= ALQ /@= *DQEHA;K 9J= O=DD ;GN=J=<
:Q L@= )=LOGJC )=OK $F GMJ K9EHD= H=JAG<
F=OK KLGJA=K @9N= *DQEHA;
AF L@=AJ @=9<DAF= /@=K= KLGJA=K 9J= MKM9DDQ 9AJ=< 9JGMF< L@= <9L=K G> L@= *DQEHA;
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! 5
Summer Olympics,
Barcelona, July 25-August 9
0
Number of stories about olympics
1
2
3
4
Winter Olympics,
Albertville February 8-23
Jan
Feb
Mar
Ap r
May
Jun Jul Aug Sep
Day of year, 1992
Oct
Nov Dec
!A?MJ= 9ADQ FME:=J F=OK KLGJA=K 9:GML *DQEHA; "9E=K
"9E=K !A?MJ= K@GOK L@= <9ADQ FME:=J G> F=LOGJC F=OK KLGJA=K ;GN=JAF? L@=
*DQEHA;K AF /@= L@A;C N=JLA;9D DAF=K E9JC L@= :=?AFFAF? 9F< L@= =F< G> L@=
*DQEHA; "9E=K AF D:=JLNADD= !=:JM9JQ 9F< AF 9J;=DGF9
%MDQ M?MKL K =PH=;L=<
F=OK KLGJA=K 9:GML L@= *DQEHA;K 9J= E9AFDQ 9AJ=< :=LO==F L@=K= <9L=K
*F 9F 9N=J9?= <9Q <MJAF? 9F *DQEHA; "9E=
L@= F=LOGJC F=OK :JG9<;9KLK F=OK
KLGJA=K 9:GML L@= *DQEHA;K
=DGO
O= OADD AFN=KLA?9L= O@=L@=J L@=K= KLGJA=K ;JGO< GML F=OK 9:GML F9LMJ9D
<AK9KL=JK 9F< O@=L@=J L@AK 9Z=;LK J=DA=> <=;AKAGFK )9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK 9HH=9J AF L@=
F=OK FGL BMKL GF L@= <9Q G> L@= <AK9KL=J
:ML 9DKG AF L@= <9QK >GDDGOAF? L@= <AK9KL=J
K== !A?MJ= GFK=IM=FLDQ
O= OADD MK= L@= 9N=J9?= FME:=J G> *DQEHA; "9E=
<9QK <AJ=;LDQ >GDDGOAF? L@= <AK9KL=J .H=;AS;9DDQ
O= OADD MK= L@= O=A?@L=< 9N=J9?= G>
<9QK
O@=J= L@= O=A?@LK 9J= L@= =EHAJA;9D <AKLJA:MLAGF G> <AK9KL=J F=OK KLGJA=K H=J
<9Q >GDDGOAF? L@= <AK9KL=J
?AN=F :Q !A?MJ= /@AK O=A?@L=< 9N=J9?= N9JA9:D= OADD
:= ;9DD=< ,9-0*$3 -GM?@DQ H=J;=FL G> L@= <AK9KL=JK AF GMJ K9EHD= LG :=
=P9;L G;;MJ O@=F L@= N9JA9:D= ,9-0*$3 AK ?J=9L=J L@9F R=JG
*MJ K=;GF< E=9KMJ= G> L@= 9N9AD9:ADALQ G> F=OKOGJL@Q E9L=JA9D AK L@= E=<A9F
9;JGKK :JG9<;9KLK AF 9 <9Q FME:=J G> EAFML=K <=NGL=< :Q 9 F=OK :JG9<;9KL <=NGL=K
LG L@= LGH L@J== F=OK K=?E=FLK AF 9 <9Q %"*,9 .&73 02&3352& 2@=F 9 D9J?= E=<A9
=N=FL L9C=K HD9;=
L@9L KLGJQ AK MKM9DDQ HD9;=< 9K GF= G> L@= SJKL F=OK KLGJA=K AF
9 :JG9<;9KL 9F< EGJ= LAE= 9F<GJ F=OK K=?E=FLK 9J= <=NGL=< LG L@= KLGJQ /@AK
KM??=KLK L@9L L@= 9EGMFL G> LAE= <=NGL=< LG L@= SJKL L@J== F=OK K=?E=FLK AK 9 ?GG<
AF<A;9LGJ G> @GO EM;@ F=OKOGJL@Q E9L=JA9D AK 9N9AD9:D= GF 9 ?AN=F <9Q 2= MK= L@=
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! E=<A9F N9DM= 9;JGKK F=OK :JG9<;9KLK AF 9 <9Q J9L@=J L@9F L@= E=9F LG J=<M;= L@=
=Z=;L G> E=9KMJ=E=FL =JJGJ AF L@= J=HGJL=< LAE= >GJ F=OK K=?E=FLK
*F= ;GF;=JF AK L@9L L@= %"*,9 .&73 02&3352& AK =F<G?=FGMK LG KLGJA=K 9:GML <AK9K
L=JK
KAF;= L@= 9AJAF? G> 9 <AK9KL=J KLGJQ OADD 9Z=;L L@= 9EGMFL G> LAE= <=NGL=< LG L@=
LGH L@J== KLGJA=K /G <AEAFAK@ L@AK HJG:D=E
O= OADD MK= L@= 9N=J9?= G> %"*,9 .&73
02&3352& GN=J L@= <9QK >GDDGOAF? L@= <AK9KL=J AF EGKL KH=;AS;9LAGFK /@AK N9JA9:D=
OADD := ;9DD=< .&73 02&3352& $F L@= JG:MKLF=KK K=;LAGF
O= 9DKG J=HGJL J=KMDLK O@=F
MKAF? L@= 9N=J9?= O=A?@L=< :Q L@= =EHAJA;9D <AKLJA:MLAGF G> <AK9KL=J F=OK KLGJA=K H=J
<9Q >GDDGOAF? L@= <AK9KL=J 9F< L@= MFO=A?@L=< <9Q 9N=J9?=
!A?MJ= HDGLK %"*,9 .&73 02&3352& >JGE LG 2= @9N= E9JC=< L@=
<9L= OAL@ L@= @A?@=KL N9DM= G> %"*,9 .&73 02&3352& >GJ =9;@ Q=9J /@= F=OK KLGJA=K
;GJJ=KHGF<AF? LG L@=K= <9L=K 9J= DAKL=< AF /9:D= :=DGO /@= L9:D= 9DKG DAKLK L@=
E9AF KLGJA=K ;GJJ=KHGF<AF? LG L@= K=;GF< 9F< L@AJ< @A?@=KL Q=9JDQ N9DM=K G> %"*,9
.&73 02&3352& /@= GN=J9DD @A?@=KL N9DM= EAFML=K O9K J=;GJ<=< >GJ .=HL=E:=J
#GO=N=J
O= ;G<=< .=HL=E:=J 9K EAKKAF? KAF;= L@= =P;=HLAGF9D =N=FL
=PL=F<=< L@= D=F?L@ G> L@= F=OK :JG9<;9KLK )GL= 9DKG L@9L L@=J= AK 9 KDA?@L MHO9J<
LJ=F< AF %"*,9 .&73 02&3352& /@AK EA?@L J=T=;L 9 ?=F=J9D MHO9J< LJ=F< AF L@=
9N9AD9:ADALQ G> :J=9CAF? F=OK KLGJA=K GJ ;@9F?=K AF L@= F=OK L=;@FGDG?Q 2= OADD
AF;DM<= Q=9J <MEEQ N9JA9:D=K AF 9DD J=?J=KKAGFK LG HA;C MH L@AK LQH= G> N9JA9LAGF
/@=J= AK 9DKG K=9KGF9D N9JA9LAGF AF <9ADQ F=OK HJ=KKMJ= /@=J= AK 9F =9JDQ KMEE=J
F=OK <JGM?@L OAL@ =P;=HLAGF9DDQ DGO %"*,9 .&73 02&3352& AF (9Q 9F< %MF=
9F< F=OK
TGG<K AF L@= >9DD OAL@ @A?@=J %"*,9 .&73 02&3352& AF .=HL=E:=J 9F< )GN=E:=J !GJ
L@AK J=9KGF
O= OADD AF;DM<= EGFL@SP=< =Z=;LK AF 9DD J=?J=KKAGF
$K %"*,9 .&73 02&3352& 9 J=9KGF9:D= E=9KMJ= >GJ L@= G;;MJJ=F;= G> F=OKOGJL@Q
=N=FLK !A?MJ= HDGLK %"*,9 .&73 02&3352& <MJAF? <9QK (9J;@ XHJAD
/@= @GJARGFL9D T9L DAF= <=HA;LK L@= E=9F >GJ L@= H=JAG< /@=
S?MJ= 9DKG <AKHD9QK L@= =N=FLK G;;MJJAF? <MJAF? L@= H=9CK G> %"*,9 .&73 02&3352&
HH9J=FLDQ
GMJ E=9KMJ= ;9HLMJ=K L@= E9BGJ =N=FLK <MJAF? L@=K= <9QK IMAL=
O=DD
KL9JLAF? OAL@ L@= 0.@AF9 .HQ HD9F= AF;A<=FL HJAD HJAD J=9;@AF? ALK E9PAEME 9JGMF< L@= .=HL=E:=J L=JJGJAKL 9LL9;CK 9F< =F<AF?
OAL@ L@= .A=?= 9L L@= @MJ;@ G> )9LANALQ AF =L@D=@=E HJAD X(9Q +DGLK >GJ GL@=J LAE= H=JAG<K <G 9F =IM9DDQ ?GG< BG: AF ;9HLMJAF? E9BGJ =N=FLK DKG
AF;DM<=< AF L@= ?J9H@ AK GMJ <9QK 9N=J9?=
.&73 02&3352& /@AK E=9KMJ= HMLK 9F
=IM9D O=A?@L GF 9DD <9QK <MJAF? L@= <9QK #GO=N=J
9K <AK;MKK=< AF K=;LAGF EGKL KLGJA=K 9J= 9AJ=< OAL@AF L@= SJKL <9QK >GDDGOAF? L@= KLJAC= <9L= G> L@= <AK9KL=J
0
500
News pressure
1000
1500
2000
2500
22aug1968
15oct1969
01jan1970
28sep1970
16jul1971
09jan1972
12feb1973
01mar1974
01jan1975
03nov1975
13jul1976
14jul1977
30jun1985
29jan1986
D ate
Figure 4: Daily news pressure (minutes), by day
19nov1978
31mar1979
01jan1980
10aug1980
30mar1981
04aug1982
25oct1983
12jul1984
01jan1985
26feb1987
22dec1988
09mar1989
23dec1989
04aug1990
27feb1991
01jan1990
16jul1992
17jan1993
17jan1994
01jan1995
03oct1995
18jul1996
23dec1997
16dec1998
01apr 1999
01jan2000
26nov2000
13sep2001
11sep2002
14aug2003
01jan2005
0
10
20
30
0 1oc t20 01
d ate
Daily Ne wspres s ure
W eigh ted News p re ss ure
0 1ju l2 001
01a pr20 02
N ews pre ss ure
M ea n Da ily N ews pres sure
0 1jan 200 2
Figure 5: News Pressure (minutes) during 405 days, March 15 2001 – Apr 23 2002, by day
01 apr2 001
U.S.-China Spy Plane Incident
McVeigh Execution Postponed
Allison hits Texas
McVeigh Execution
New Policy on Stem Cell Research
9/11 Attacks
Invasion of Afghanistan
Anthrax
Bush Address to UN
Plane Crash Flight 587
Afghanistan: Kabul Falls
Afghanistan: Kandahar Falls
Osama Bin Laden Video Tape
Afghanistan: Tora Bora Falls
Enron Bankruptcy
Afghanistan: Operation Anaconda
Bethlehem: Siege at Church of Nativity
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! /@=J=>GJ=
O= ;GFKLJM;L 9F 9DL=JF9LAN= E=9KMJ=
7&*()4&% .&73 02&3352& #=J=
%"*,9 .&73 02&3352& >GJ =9;@ <9Q <MJAF? L@= <9Q H=JAG< AK O=A?@L=< :Q L@= =P
HGKL HJG:9:ADALQ L@9L L@= KLGJQ 9HH=9JK GF L@9L H9JLA;MD9J <9Q
A= L@= <AKLJA:MLAGF
HDGLL=< AF !A?MJ= /@= N9JA9:D= 7&*()4&% .&73 02&3352& AK 9DKG HDGLL=< AF !A?MJ=
)9LMJ9DDQ
AL AK ;@9J9;L=JAR=< :Q EGJ= HJGFGMF;=< H=9CK 9F< LJGM?@K
"+8:198
/@AK K=;LAGFK ;GFL9AFK GMJ =EHAJA;9D J=KMDLK !AJKL
O= <AK;MKK L@= KLJM;LMJ= G> L@=
=EHAJA;9D EG<=D !GJ 9 >GJE9D EG<=D G> L@= =Z=;L G> F=OK GF J=DA=>
K== L@= HH=F<AP
/@=F
O= 9F9DQR= L@= =EHAJA;9D <=L=JEAF9FLK G> F=OK 9F< J=DA=> AF <=L9AD !AF9DDQ
O= <AK;MKK L@= JG:MKLF=KK G> L@= J=KMDLK
#5+)/@)'9/43
*MJ =;GFGE=LJA; KH=;AS;9LAGF OADD := G> L@= >GDDGOAF? >GJE !GJ <AK9KL=J 8 L@= D9L=FL
N9JA9:D= ?49845 J=DA=>OGJL@QF=KK <=K;JA:=K L@= :=F=SLK G> HJGNA<AF? J=DA=> >JGE L@=
<=;AKAGF E9C=JVK H=JKH=;LAN=
?49845 ;4D@ O@=J= ;4D@ ;4D@ AF<A;9L=K L@9L L@= <AK9KL=J O9K ;GN=J=< 6O9K FGL ;GN
=J=<7 AF L@= F=OK /@= N=;LGJ ;GFL9AFK <AK9KL=J KH=;AS; N9JA9:D=K
KM;@ 9K +*,,&%
9F< ":&$4&% 9F< SP=< =Z=;LK >GJ <AK9KL=J LQH=
;GMFLJQ
Q=9J
=L; -=DA=> AK HJGNA<=<
A> ?49845 AK 9:GN= 9 L@J=K@GD< N9DM=
?49845 A> ?49845 A> ?49845 O@=J= ?49845 ?49845 AK L@= =N=FL L@9L *! HJGNA<=< 6<A< FGL HJGNA<=7
<AK9KL=J J=DA=> LG <AK9KL=J 8 2= OADD L=KL L@= @QHGL@=KAK L@9L F=OK ;GN=J9?= @9K 9
HGKALAN= =Z=;L GF L@= J=DA=> <=;AKAGF
.AEAD9JDQ
L@= D9L=FL N9JA9:D= ;4D@ F=OKOGJL@QF=KK <=K;JA:=K L@= :=F=SLK G>
;GN=JAF? <AK9KL=J 8 >JGE L@= /1 F=LOGJCVK H=JKH=;LAN=
;4D@ ;4D@ =?4@@B?4 <9F:=82@ #! %" !$#" %" " ""#! /@AK D9L=FL N9JA9:D= <=L=JEAF=K L@= F=OK <=;AKAGF 9;;GJ<AF? LG
;4D@ A> ;4D@ A> ;4D@ *MJ @QHGL@=KAK @=J= AK L@9L <AK9KL=JK 9J= D=KK DAC=DQ LG := ;GN=J=< O@=F L@=J= AK
9 ?J=9L <=9D G> GL@=J :J=9CAF? F=OK 9N9AD9:D=
9K E=9KMJ=< :Q .&73 02&3352& 9F<
,9-0*$3
L@9L AK 9F< /@= :9KA; =;GFGE=LJA; HJG:D=E AK L@9L F=OKOGJL@AF=KK 9F< J=DA=>OGJL@AF=KK 9J=
:GL@ AF;J=9KAF? AF L@= K=N=JALQ G> L@= <AK9KL=J /@=J= 9J= E9FQ >9;=LK G> L@= K=N=JALQ
G> <AK9KL=JK L@9L O= ;9FFGL G:K=JN=
>GJ =P9EHD=
@GO K=N=J= L@= KALM9LAGF AK >GJ
L@GK= 9Z=;L=< :ML FGL CADD=< /@AK MFG:K=JN=< K=N=JALQ 9Z=;LK :GL@ F=OK ;GN=J9?=
9F< L@= HJGNAKAGF G> J=DA=> K E=FLAGF=< =9JDA=J
;4D@ 9F< ?49845 E9Q 9DKG :=
;GJJ=D9L=< :=;9MK= :GL@ 9J= <JAN=F :Q L@= K9DA=F;= G> L@= <AK9KL=J LG L@= E=JA;9F
HM:DA; GFK=IM=FLDQ
L@=J= AK DALLD= @GH= AF A<=FLA>QAF? L@= ;9MK9D =Z=;L G> ;4D@ GF
?49845 >JGE 9 J=?J=KKAGF G> L@= D9LL=J GF L@= >GJE=J
/G <=L=JEAF= O@=L@=J .&73 @9K 9 ;9MK9D =Z=;L GF 2&,*&'
O= AFKL=9< MK= L@=
AFKLJME=FL9D N9JA9:D=K .&73 02&3352& 9F< ,9-0*$3 KKMEAF? 9 DAF=9J HJG:9:ADALQ
EG<=D
9F< L@9L
# ;4D@ =?4@@B?4 <9F:=82@ # ;4D@ =?4@@B?4 <9F:=82@ L@= J=<M;=< >GJE =IM9LAGFK 9J=
# ?49845 ;4D@ =?4@@B?4 <9F:=82@ ;4D@ =?4@@B?4 <9F:=82@ # ;4D@ ;4D@ =?4@@B?4 <9F:=82@ ;4D@ =?4@@B?4 <9F:=82@ 0F<=J L@= 9:GN= 9KKMEHLAGFK
L@= EG<=D AK A<=FLAS=< 9F< L@= H9J9E=L=JK E9Q :=
=KLAE9L=< MKAF? /OG .L9?= '=9KL .IM9J=K
/@= C=Q A<=FLA>QAF? 9KKMEHLAGF AK L@9L .&73 02&3352& 9F< ,9-0*$3 9J= MF;GJJ=
D9L=< OAL@ L@= MFG:K=JN=< K=N=JALQ G> <AK9KL=JK
;GF<ALAGF9D GF L@= N9JA9:D=K AF /@=J= 9J= K=9KGF9D H9LL=JFK AF L@= K=N=JALQ G> <AK9KL=JK
KM;@ 9K KLGJEK 9F< TGG<K
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! 9F< 9DKG K=9KGF9D H9LL=JFK AF ,9-0*$3 9F< .&73 02&3352& OAL@ L@= LQHA;9D KME
E=J F=OK <JGM?@LK !GJ L@AK J=9KGF
O= AF;DM<= EGFL@ <MEEQ N9JA9:D=K /@=J= AK
9DKG 9 Q=9JDQ LJ=F< AF .&73 02&3352& 9F< 2&,*&'
KG O= AF;DM<= Q=9J <MEEQN9JA9:D=K
GFLJGDDAF? >GJ Q=9J 9F< EGFL@ =Z=;LK
O= K== FG 9 HJAGJA J=9KGF O@Q L@= K=N=JALQ
G> F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK AF >GJ=A?F ;GMFLJA=K K@GMD< := ;GJJ=D9L=< OAL@ GMJ E=9KMJ=K G>
L@= 9N9AD9:ADALQ G> F=OKOGJL@Q E9L=JA9D 2= OADD AF;DM<= >MJL@=J ;GFLJGDK AF L@= J=
?J=KKAGFK
:ML GFDQ LG J=<M;= L@= J=KA<M9D N9JA9F;= <<ALAGF9D ;GF;=JFK J=?9J<AF?
A<=FLAS;9LAGF OADD := 9<<J=KK=< AF L@= JG:MKLF=KK K=;LAGF
4< 9.+ ';'/1'(/1/9> 4, 49.+7 3+<8 'B+)9 */8'89+7 3+<8
'3* 7+1/+,
2= SJKL =P9EAF= @GO L@= HJ=KKMJ= >GJ F=LOGJC F=OK LAE= 9Z=;LK F=OK ;GN=J9?=
G>
9F< J=DA=> LG
<AK9KL=JK /9:D= K@GOK L@= J=KMDLK >JGE =KLAE9LAF? L@= DAF=9J
HJG:9:ADALQ EG<=DK KH=;AS=< AF =IM9LAGFK 9F< DD J=?J=KKAGFK AF;DM<=
;GMFLJQ
Q=9J
<AK9KL=J LQH=
EGFL@ 9F< Q=9J SP=< =Z=;LK 9F< J=HGJL @=L=JGK;=<9KLA;
JG:MKL KL9F<9J< =JJGJK
#A?@=J .&73 02&3352& KA?FAS;9FLDQ J=<M;=K :GL@ L@= HJG:9:ADALQ L@9L L@= F=LOGJCK
;GN=J 9 <AK9KL=J 9F< L@= HJG:9:ADALQ L@9L L@= <AK9KL=J J=;=AN=K J=DA=> /@AK ;9F := K==F
AF L@= :9K=DAF= KH=;AS;9LAGFK G> ;GDMEFK $ 9F< $1 /@= AEHDA=< =Z=;LK 9J= L@9L 9<<ALAGF9D EAFML=K KH=FL GF L@= SJKL L@J== F=OK K=?E=FLK <=;J=9K=K L@= HJG:9:ADALQ G>
9 <AK9KL=J AK :=AF? ;GN=J=< AF L@= F=OK :Q H=J;=FL9?= HGAFLK
9F< L@= HJG:9:ADALQ G>
L@= <AK9KL=J J=;=ANAF? J=DA=> :Q H=J;=FL9?= HGAFLK -=;9DD L@9L 9JGMF< H=J;=FL
G> 9DD <AK9KL=JK 9J= ;GN=J=< AF L@= F=OK 9F< L@9L H=J;=FL J=;=AN= J=DA=>
KG L@=
=Z=;LK 9J= KAR=9:D= (GJ=GN=J
,9-0*$3 AK KA?FAS;9FLDQ F=?9LAN=DQ ;GJJ=D9L=< OAL@
.&73 9F< 2&,*&' /@= =KLAE9L=< ;G=Y;A=FLK AEHDQ L@9L 9 <AK9KL=J G;;MJJAF? <MJAF?
L@= *DQEHA;K AK H=J;=FL D=KK DAC=DQ LG := AF L@= F=OK 9F< H=J;=FL D=KK DAC=DQ LG
J=;=AN= J=DA=>
GF 9N=J9?=
GFLJGDDAF? >GJ L@= K=N=JALQ G> L@= <AK9KL=J <G=K FGL KA?FAS;9FLDQ ;@9F?= L@=
=KLAE9L=< ;G=Y;A=FLK GF .&73 02&3352& 9F< ,9-0*$3 GDMEFK $$ 9F< 1 ;GFLJGD
>GJ L@= DG? FME:=J G> CADD=< 9F< 9Z=;L=< /@AK @9K L@= GFDQ =Z=;L G> J=<M;AF?
L@= HJ=;AKAGF G> L@= =KLAE9L=K
KAF;= L@= K9EHD= KAR= AK J=<M;=< :Q H=J;=FL $F
GDMEFK $$$ 9F< 1$
O= AEHML= L@= EAKKAF? N9DM=K LG L@= 9N=J9?= >GJ =9;@ LQH= G>
<AK9KL=J .AF;= O= 9DKG AF;DM<= SP=< =Z=;LK >GJ L@= AFL=J9;LAGF :=LO==F EAKKAF? <9L9
/G ;GEHML= L@= 9N=J9?= =Z=;L
L@= ;G=Y;A=FLK 9J= EMDLAHDA=< :Q O@A;@ AK L@= 9N=J9?= N9DM=
G> /,9-0*$3 >GJ <9QK <MJAF? L@= *DQEHA; "9E=K
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! 9F< L@= LQH= G> <AK9KL=J
L@= N9DM= 9L O@A;@ CADD=< 9F< 9Z=;L=< 9J= AEHML=< AK G>
FG AEHGJL9F;= >GJ L@= =KLAE9L=< ;G=Y;A=FLK GF .&73 02&3352& 9F< ,9-0*$3
AK9KL=J J=DA=> AK =IM9DDQ J=KHGFKAN= LG L@= FME:=J G> CADD=< 9F< 9Z=;L=<
O@AD=
F=OK ;GN=J9?= J=KHGF<K EM;@ EGJ= LG L@= FME:=J G> CADD=< /@= =KLAE9L=K AEHDQ
L@9L 9K L@= FME:=J G> CADD=< AF;J=9K=K :Q 9 >9;LGJ G> L=F
L@= HJG:9:ADALQ G> J=;=ANAF?
J=DA=> 9F< F=OK ;GN=J9?= :GL@ AF;J=9K=K :Q 9:GML L=F H=J;=FL9?= HGAFLK 2@=F L@=
AF;J=9K=K AF L@= FME:=J G> 9Z=;L=< AK L=F>GD<
L@= ;@9F;= G> J=;=ANAF? J=DA=> AF;J=9K=K
:Q 9JGMF< L=F H=J;=FL
:ML L@= HJG:9:ADALQ G> :=AF? ;GN=J=< AF L@= F=OK GFDQ AF;J=9K=K
:Q L@J== H=J;=FL
)GL= L@9L O= E9Q ;J=9L= 9F =F<G?=F=ALQ HJG:D=E :Q AF;DM<AF? L@= FME:=J G>
CADD=< 9F< 9Z=;L=< AF L@= J=?J=KKAGF $> <AK9KL=J J=DA=> AK =Z=;LAN=
AF L@= K=FK= G>
J=<M;AF? L@= FME:=J G> CADD=< 9F< 9Z=;L=<
L@=K= N9JA9:D=K 9J= =F<G?=FGMK LG J=DA=>
!MJL@=JEGJ=
K9EHD= K=D=;LAGF AK DAC=DQ LG := :9K=< GF L@= <=H=F<=FL N9JA9:D=
2&,*&'
;9MKAF? =F<G?=F=ALQ HJG:D=EK -=DA=> OGJC G>L=F =FL9ADK <9L9 ;GDD=;LAGF 9F< 0.$
AK GF= G> L@= E9AF <9L9 HJGNA<=JK
K O= 9<< EGJ= ;GFLJGDK
L@= J=KA<M9D N9JA9F;= AK J=<M;=< X + AK 9DEGKL <GM:D=<
4=L
L@= =KLAE9L=< ;G=Y;A=FLK GF .&73 02&3352& 9F< ,9-0*$3 9J= @9J<DQ 9Z=;L=<
:=;9MK= L@=K= N9JA9:D=K 9J= MF;GJJ=D9L=< OAL@ L@= ;GFLJGDK
AF H9JLA;MD9J OAL@ +*,,&%
9F< ":&$4&% J=?J=KKAGF G> L@= DG? G> +*,,&% 9F< ":&$4&% J=KH=;LAN=DQ
GF .&73
02&3352& 9F< ,9-0*$3 ;GFSJEK L@9L L@=J= AK FG KA?FAS;9FL J=D9LAGFK@AH :=LO==F
L@=K= LOG K=LK G> N9JA9:D=K
;GFLJGDDAF? >GJ Q=9J
EGFL@
;GMFLJQ 9F< <AK9KL=J LQH=
SP=<=Z=;LK
K== /9:D= 4< 3+<8 'B+)98 */8'89+7 7+1/+,
2= FGO =P9EAF= O@9L 9J= L@= AEHDA;9LAGFK G> L@= 9:GN= =KLAE9L=K J=?9J<AF? L@=
=Z=;L G> F=OK GF J=DA=> /9:D= ;GFL9AFK L@= J=KMDLK >JGE J=?J=KKAGFK 9F9DQRAF? L@=
J=D9LAGF :=LO==F ?49845 9F< ;4D@ /@= SJKL L@J== ;GDMEFK K@GO L@= J=KMDLK G> *'.
J=?J=KKAGFK G> 2&,*&' GF .&73
MKAF? L@= K9E= KH=;AS;9LAGFK 9K L@= SJKL L@J== ;GDMEFK
G> /9:D= /@= SJKL ;GDMEF K@GOK L@9L :=AF? ;GN=J=< AF L@= .&73 AK 9KKG;A9L=< OAL@
9 H=J;=FL AF;J=9K= AF L@= HJG:9:ADALQ G> J=;=ANAF? J=DA=> /@= ;G=Y;A=FL GF .&73
<JGHK KA?FAS;9FLDQ
>JGE LG H=J;=FL
O@=F O= 9<< DG? +*,,&% 9F< DG? ":&$4&%
AF ;GDMEFK $$ 9F< $$$
:=;9MK= 2&,*&' 9F< .&73 9J= :GL@ HGKALAN=DQ ;GJJ=D9L=< OAL@
$F<A;9LGJ N9JA:D=K >GJ 9JL@IM9C= 9F< <9L9 GF CADD=< =PAKLK
9JL@IM9C= 9F< <9L9 GF CADD=<
EAKKAF?
9JL@IM9C= 9F< <9L9 GF 9Z=;L=< =PAKLK
9JL@IM9C= 9F< <9L9 GF 9Z=;L=< EAKKAF?
1GD;9FG
9F< <9L9 GF CADD=< =PAKLK
=L;
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! +*,,&% 9F< ":&$4&%
/@=J= 9J= KLJGF? J=9KGFK LG :=DA=N= L@9L L@= =Z=;L G> F=OK AK @=L=JG?=FGMK 9;JGKK
<AK9KL=JK !GJ KGE= <AK9KL=JK
F=OK ;GN=J9?= @9K DALLD= =Z=;L !GJ =P9EHD=
L@= J=;=FL
/KMF9EA AF /@9AD9F< O9K ;=JL9AF LG J=;=AN= :GL@ J=DA=> 9F< F=OK ;GN=J9?= *L@=J
<AK9KL=JK 9J= ;=JL9AF LG F=AL@=J J=;=AN= J=DA=> FGJ F=OK ;GN=J9?= /@AK AK ADDMKLJ9L=<
AF !A?MJ= /@= 8 9PAK ;GFL9AFK L@= HJ=<A;L=< HJG:9:ADALQ G> 9 <AK9KL=J :=AF? AF L@=
F=OK
:9K=< GF L@= FME:=J G> CADD=< 9F< 9Z=;L=<
<AK9KL=J LQH=
Q=9J
EGFL@ 9F<
;GMFLJQ /@= KGDA< <A9EGF<K K@GO L@= K@9J= G> <AK9KL=JK AF =9;@ <=;AD= ;GN=J=<
AF L@= F=OK
O@AD= L@= ;JGKK=K K@GO L@= K@9J= G> <AK9KL=JK J=;=ANAF? J=DA=> !GJ
=P9EHD=
G> L@= <AK9KL=JK L@9L @9N= HJ=<A;L=< HJG:9:ADALA=K G> :=AF? AF L@= F=OK
9:GN= H=J;=FL
H=J;=FL J=;=AN=< *! J=DA=> $F ;GFLJ9KL
GFDQ H=J;=FL G>
L@= <AK9KL=JK J=;=AN=< J=DA=> O@=F L@=AJ HJ=<A;L=< HJG:9:ADALQ G> :=AF? AF L@= F=OK
O9K :=DGO H=J;=FL
2= OADD 9J?M= L@9L L@= =Z=;L G> .&73 GF 2&,*&' AK ?J=9L=J >GJ <AK9KL=JK L@9L 9J=
E9J?AF9D AF L@= F=OK <=;AKAGF /@= J=9KGF AK L@9L L@=K= <AK9KL=JK 9J= 9DKG EGJ=
DAC=DQ LG := E9J?AF9D AF L@= 2&,*&' <=;AKAGF /G L=KL L@AK
O= AF;DM<= L@= AFL=J9;LAGF
:=LO==F .&73 9F< L@= 9:KGDML= <AKL9F;= G> L@= HJ=<A;L=< HJG:9:ADALQ G> L@= <AK9KL=J
:=AF? AF L@= .&73 >JGE AF L@= J=?J=KKAGF G> 2&,*&' GF .&73 /@= J=KMDLK 9J= K@GOF
AF GDMEF $1 /@= =KLAE9L=< ;G=Y;A=FL GF F=OK AK H=J;=FL O@=F L@= HJ=<A;L=<
HJG:9:ADALQ G> :=AF? AF L@= F=OK AK 2@=F L@= =KLAE9L=< HJG:9:ADALQ G> :=AF? AF
L@= F=OK AK GJ L@= H9JLA9D ;GJJ=D9LAGF AK R=JG GDMEF 1 <AKHD9QK
L@= J=KMDLK >JGE 9 HJG:AL=KLAE9LAGF G> L@AK EG<=D /@=K= =Z=;LK 9J= =KLAE9L=< MKAF?
;G9JK= E=9KMJ=K G> O@=L@=J 9 <AK9KL=J AK E9J?AF9D AF L@= F=OK <=;AKAGF /@= =Z=;L G>
.&73 GF 2&,*&' ;GMD< := KM:KL9FLA9DDQ @A?@=J AF L@= KM:?JGMH G> <AK9KL=JK L@9L O=J=
LJMDQ E9J?AF9D AF L@= F=OK <=;AKAGF
K <AK;MKK=< =9JDA=J
L@= 9:GN= ;GJJ=D9LAGFK <G FGL E=9KMJ= L@= =Z=;L G> .&73 GF
2&,*&' 2@9L O= D=9JF AK L@9L L@= GN=J9DD 9N=J9?= =Z=;L G> .&73 GF 2&,*&' AK MFDAC=DQ
LG := D9J?=J L@9F H=J;=FL
KAF;= L@= :A9K L@JGM?@ MFG:K=JN=< K=N=JALQ G> <AK9KL=JK
AK HGKALAN= #GO=N=J
L@= =Z=;L ;9F := KM:KL9FLA9DDQ @A?@=J >GJ L@= KM:K=L G> <AK9KL=JK
O@A;@ 9J= ;DGK= LG E9J?AF9D AF L@= F=OK <=;AKAGF
/@= D9KL L@J== ;GDMEFK J=HGJL L@= $1 =KLAE9L=K /@= =KLAE9L=K G> 9J= D9J?=
9F< KA?FAS;9FL +M:DAK@AF? 9 KLGJQ GF 9 <AK9KL=J OADD AF;J=9K= L@= HJG:9:ADALQ G>
KM:K=IM=FL J=DA=> :Q 9JGMF< H=J;=FL9?= HGAFLK
:9K=< GF L@= =KLAE9L=K >JGE 9
KH=;AS;9LAGF AF ;GDMEF 1$$ /@=K= =KLAE9L=K 9J= EM;@ D9J?=J L@9F L@= *'. =KLAE9L=K
DAC=DQ J=9KGF AK L@9L L@= $1=KLAE9L=K E=9KMJ= L@= 9N=J9?= =Z=;L G> .&73 GF 2&,*&'
AF L@= KM:?JGMH G> <AK9KL=JK L@9L 9J= E9J?AF9D AF L@= F=OK <=;AKAGF
AF L@= K=FK= G>
0
.2
.4
.6
.8
1
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! 0
.2
.4
.6
.8
Predicted probability disaster in news (deciles)
Share receiving relief
45 degree line
1
Share in news
!A?MJ= +J=<A;L=< HJG:9:ADALQ G> <AK9KL=J F=OK 9F< 9;LM9D K@9J=K G> <AK9KL=JK
J=;=ANAF? J=DA=>
L@=AJ J=;=ANAF? F=OK ;GN=J9?= A> 9F< GFDQ A> L@=J= AK DALLD= GL@=J F=OK 9JGMF< K== >GJ
=P9EHD= B^JCDMF< 9F< (GYL #=;CE9F 9F< -G:: 9F< $E:=FK 9F<
F?JAKL "4(:893+88
2= FGO <AK;MKK 9 FME:=J G> HGL=FLA9D A<=FLAS;9LAGF HJG:D=EK /@= J=KMDLK G> L@AK
JG:MKLF=KK 9F9DQKAK 9J= K@GOF AF /9:D= #GJARGFL9DDQ
L@= L9:D= ;GFL9AFK J=KMDLK >GJ
L@= J=<M;=< >GJE =KLAE9L=K OAL@ .&73 9F< 2&,*&' 9K <=H=F<=FL N9JA9:D=K
9K O=DD 9K
L@= J=KMDLAF? $1=KLAE9L=K G> L@= =Z=;L G> .&73 GF 2&,*&' /@= SJKL ;GDMEF <AKHD9QK
L@= :=F;@E9JC KH=;AS;9LAGFK ;GJJ=KHGF<AF? LG GDMEF $ 9F< $1 G> /9:D= 9F<
GDMEF 1$ G> /9:D= /@= >GDDGOAF? ;GDMEFK ;GFL9AF GL@=J KH=;AS;9LAGFK O@A;@
OADD FGO := <AK;MKK=<
(9FQ G> L@= =F<G?=F=ALQ AKKM=K 9J= J=D9L=< LG L@= AFKLJME=FL .&73 02&3352&
*F 9 HJAGJA ?JGMF<K
AL AK =9KADDQ 9J?M=< L@9L L@= <9L=K G> L@= *DQEHA; "9E=K 9J=
=PG?=FGMK OAL@ J=KH=;L LG <AK9KL=J J=DA=> 9F< F=OK ;GN=J9?=
;GFLJGDDAF? >GJ EGFL@
=Z=;LK *F= ?=F=J9D AF<A;9LAGF L@9L .&73 02&3352& AK 9DKG =PG?=FGMK AK L@9L L@= GN=J
A<=FLA>QAF? J=KLJA;LAGFK 9J= FGL J=B=;L=< AF 9FQ KH=;AS;9LAGF AF /9:D=K 9F< $F
GL@=J OGJ<K
L@= $1=KLAE9L=K MKAF? .&73 02&3352& GFDQ 9K 9F AFKLJME=FL HJG<M;=K
9 KAEAD9J ;G=Y;A=FL =KLAE9L= 9K L@= $1=KLAE9L=K AFKLJME=FLAF? OAL@ ,9-0*$3 GFDQ
2= OADD KL9JL :Q L=KLAF? GMJ 9KKMEHLAGF L@9L .&73 02&3352& AK MF;GJJ=D9L=< OAL@
L@= =JJGJ AF L@= <AK9KL=J F=OK =IM9LAGF
$<=9DDQ
O= OGMD< DAC= LG E=9KMJ= O@9L
.&73 02&3352& OGMD< @9N= :==F
@9< L@=J= :==F FG <AK9KL=J F=OK /@= HJG:D=E AK
L@9L GF KGE= <9QK L@=J= AK <AK9KL=J F=OK 9F< O= @9N= LG ;GFKA<=J @GO L@AK 9Z=;LK
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! GMJ AFKLJME=FL $> F=OK 9:GML 9 <AK9KL=J AK HD9;=< 9EGF? L@= LGH L@J== KLGJA=K
L@AK
OGMD< ?=F=J9L= 9 HGKALAN= :A9K LGO9J<K R=JG AF L@= ;G=Y;A=FL $> F=OK 9:GML L@=
<AK9KL=J AK HD9;=< GMLKA<= L@= LGH L@J==
L@=F AL EA?@L := L@= ;9K= L@9L D=KK LAE= AK
<=NGL=< LG L@= LGH L@J== K=?E=FLK
AF<M;AF? 9 F=?9LAN= :A9K AF 2= ;GFKLJM;L LOG 9DL=JF9LAN= E=9KMJ=K G> L@= HJ=KKMJ= GF F=OK LAE= LG AFN=KLA?9L=
L@= HGL=FLA9D KAR= G> L@AK :A9K -=;9DD L@9L .&73 02&3352& AK L@= MFO=A?@L=< 9N=J9?=
G> %"*,9 .&73 02&3352& >GJ L@= <9QK >GDDGOAF? L@= <AK9KL=J !AJKL
O= ;GEHML=
.&73 02&3352& 9K L@= 9N=J9?= <MJAF? L@= <9QK 9>L=J L@= <AK9KL=J
:ML J=EGN=
9DD <9QK O@=F 9FQ <AK9KL=J KLGJQ O9K 9AJ=< /@AK @9K 9 EAFAE9D AEH9;L GF L@=
=KLAE9L=< ;G=Y;A=FLK
K== GDMEF $$ )=PL
LG ?9M?= L@= E9PAEME KAR= G> L@= :A9K
O= ;GEHML=< 9 F=O E=9KMJ= G> .&73 02&3352& L@9L O9K AFL=FLAGF9DDQ :A9K=< AF L@=
EGKL =PLJ=E= O9Q !GJ =N=JQ F=OK :JG9<;9KL
O= AF;J=9K=< L@= LAE= <=NGL=< LG
L@= LGH L@J== F=OK K=?E=FLK %"*,9 .&73 02&3352& :Q L@= LAE= <=NGL=< LG <AK9KL=J
KLGJA=K /@AK ;GJJ=KHGF<K LG L@= =PLJ=E= 9KKMEHLAGF L@9L 9DD <AK9KL=J F=OK O9K
HD9;=< GMLKA<= L@= LGH L@J== K=?E=FLK 9F< GFDQ LGGC LAE= >JGE L@=K= K=?E=FLK $F
J=9DALQ
L@= F=OK LAE= >J==< MH :Q FGL 9AJAF? L@= <AK9KL=J F=OK OGMD< := H9JLA9DDQ
9DDG;9L=< LG F=OK K=?E=FLK GMLKA<= L@= LGH L@J== K K@GOF AF GDMEF $$$
L@=
J=KMDLAF? :A9K AF L@= =KLAE9L=< ;G=Y;A=FL GF .&73 02&3352& AK EG<=KL
AL ;@9F?=K
>JGE LG /@= DAC=DQ J=9KGF AK L@9L O= 9N=J9?= GN=J <9QK
9F< GFDQ
AFLJG<M;AF? :A9K AF L@= >=O <9QK O@=F <AK9KL=JK O=J= ;GN=J=< @9K DALLD= AEH9;L (GKL
G> L@= <AK9KL=JK L@9L 9J= AF L@= F=OK
9J= GFDQ ;GN=J=< AF GF= <9Q
GDMEFK $1 9F< 1 ;@=;C O@=L@=J AL AK AEHGJL9FL L@9L O= MK= L@= <9Q 9N=J9?=
>GJ .&73 02&3352& #=J=
O= AFKL=9< E=9KMJ= .&73 02&3352& 9K 9F 9N=J9?= HMLLAF?
@A?@=J O=A?@L GF <9QK ;DGK=J LG L@= <AK9KL=J (GJ= HJ=;AK=DQ
GDMEF $1 MK=K L@=
MFO=A?@L=< <9Q 9N=J9?=
9F< GDMEF 1 MK=K L@= =EHAJA;9D <AKLJA:MLAGF G> F=OK
KLGJA=K 9K 9 >MF;LAGF G> L@= <AKL9F;= AF <9QK LG L@= <AK9KL=J >GJ O=A?@LAF?
K== !A?MJ=
/@AK HJG<M;=K EAFGJ ;@9F?=K /@= J=9KGF O@Q O= MK= L@= <9Q 9N=J9?= AF
EGKL KH=;AS;9LAGFK AK L@9L AL AK FGL K=FKALAN= LG L@= LQH= G> :A9K <=K;JA:=< AF L@=
HJ=NAGMK H9J9?J9H@
)=PL
O= 9<< 9 FME:=J G> ;GFLJGDK AF GDMEF 1$ 2= AF;DM<= L@= AEHML=<
DG? *,,&% 9F< L@= AEHML=< DG? :&$4&%
<MEEQ N9JA9:D=K >GJ L@= AFL=J9;LAGF G>
<AK9KL=J LQH= 9F< EAKKAF? <9L9 9K <AK;MKK=< AF .=;LAGF /G 9;;GMFL >GJ FGF
DAF=9J =Z=;LK
O= 9DKG AF;DM<= LOG K=LK G> <MEEQ N9JA9:D=K AF<A;9LAF? O@=L@=J *,,&%
9F< :&$4&% DA= AF L@= H=J;=FLAD= J=?AGFK L@L@
L@L@
L@ L@ 9F< L@=
L@L@ H=J;=FLAD=K
J=KH=;LAN=DQ L@= GEALL=< ;9L=?GJQ AK CADD=< 9:GN= L@= L@
H=J;=FLAD= $F ;9K= L@=J= AK K=9KGF9D N9JA9LAGFK OAL@AF EGFL@K
O= FGO AF;DM<=
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! O==CSP=< =Z=;LK )=PL
L@= 0. E9Q := EGJ= OADDAF? LG HJGNA<= KMHHGJL LG 9DDA=K
9F< L@=J= E9Q := ;@9F?=K AF 0. J=D9LAGFK LG ;GMFLJA=K GN=J LAE=
O@A;@ 9J= FGL
;9HLMJ=< :Q L@= ;GMFLJQSP=< =Z=;LK /G ;GFLJGD >GJ L@AK
O= AF;DM<= 9 N9JA9:D=
AF<A;9LAF? O@=L@=J L@= 0. @9K 9FQ >GJE9D 9DDA9F;= OAL@ L@= ;GMFLJQ AF IM=KLAGF
!GJ =P9EHD=
$J9F O9K 9 >GJE9D 9DDQ G> L@= 0. MFLAD :ML FGL L@=J=9>L=J $F
L@AK KH=;AS;9LAGF
L@= ;G=Y;A=FL GF .&73 02&3352& >9DDK AFKA?FAS;9FLDQ AF L@= J=DA=>
J=?J=KKAGF 9F< @=F;=
AF L@= $1J=?J=KKAGF /@= ;G=Y;A=FL GF :=AF? 9 0. 9DDQ FGL
J=HGJL=< AK FGL KA?FAS;9FL AF L@= F=OK ;GN=J9?= GJ L@= J=DA=> <=;AKAGF
;GFLJGDDAF?
>GJ ;GMFLJQ SP=< =Z=;LK
/@= F=PL LOG ;GDMEFK J=HGJL L@= J=KMDLK >JGE J=?J=KKAGFK GF KM:K9EHD=K /@=
SJKL KM:K9EHD= GFDQ AF;DM<=K <AK9KL=JK O@=J= L@= GML:J=9C AK LQHA;9DDQ O=DD <=SF=<
=9JL@IM9C=K
NGD;9FGK
SJ=K
D9F<KDA<=K
TGG<K 9F< KLGJEK K AK =NA<=FL >JGE GD
MEF 1$$
L@= J=KMDLK GFDQ <AZ=J E9J?AF9DDQ AF L@AK KM:K9EHD=
/@= GL@=J KM:K9EHD= 9<<J=KK=K 9FGL@=J ;GF;=JF J=?9J<AF? L@= AFKLJME=FL .&73
02&3352&
F9E=DQ L@9L L@= J=DA=> <=;AKAGFK 9J= <AJ=;LDQ 9Z=;L=< :Q L@= =N=FLK ;9MKAF?
@A?@ .&73 02&3352& !GJ =P9EHD=
9F E:9KK9<GJ AF )A;9J9?M9 E9Q := <AJ=;LDQ
9Z=;L=< :Q L@= 9LL9;C FGL LG <=;D9J= 9 ;GF;MJJ=FL KLGJE AF )A;9J9?M9 9 <AK9KL=J
#GO=N=J
AL K==EK MFDAC=DQ L@9L 0. E:9KK9<GJK 9J= AF;DAF=< LG <=;D9J= 9 F9LMJ9D
<AK9KL=J :=;9MK= FGL@AF? AFL=J=KLAF? AK @9HH=FAF? GF L@= )=LOGJC )=OK
A= O@=F
L@= .&73 02&3352& AK =P;=HLAGF9DDQ DGO !GJ L@AK J=9KGF
O= J=EGN= 9DD G:K=JN9LAGFK
O@=F L@= .&73 02&3352& O9K AF L@= @A?@=KL L@9L Q=9J /@= J=E9AFAF? G:K=JN9LAGFK
;GFL9AF KALM9LAGFK O@=J= L@= .&73 02&3352& O9K E=<AME LG DGO /@= ;G=Y;A=FL GF
F=OK HJ=KKMJ= FGO A<=FLAS=K =Z=;LK :=;9MK= E9J?AF9DDQ F=OKOGJL@Q <AK9KL=JK
O@A;@
OGMD< LQHA;9DDQ FGL := GF /1
9J= K@A>L=< AFLG L@= )=LOGJC )=OK O@=F L@= .&73
02&3352& AK DGO GDMEF 1$$$ K@GOK L@= J=KMDLK AF L@AK KM:K9EHD= /@= =KLAE9L=<
=Z=;LK G> GMJ AFKLJME=FLK GF .&73 9F< 2&,*&' 9J= KAEAD9J GJ @A?@=J #GO=N=J
KAF;=
L@AK KH=;AS;9LAGF =PHDA;ALDQ J=<M;=K :GL@ L@= K9EHD= KAR= 9F< L@= K9EHD= N9JA9LAGF
AF .&73 02&3352&
L@= KL9F<9J< =JJGJK 9J= EM;@ D9J?=J 9F< L@= =KLAE9L=< =Z=;LK G>
,9-0*$3 GF .&73 9F< .&73 02&3352& GF 2&,*&' 9J= FGL KA?FAS;9FL /@= $1=KLAE9L=
G> L@= =Z=;L G> F=OK GF J=DA=> AK FGL 9Z=;L=< LG 9FQ ;GFKA<=J9:D= =PL=FL
/@= SF9D ;GDMEF AF L@= L9:D= K@GOK L@= J=KMDLK >JGE HJG:AL =KLAE9LAGFK !GJ
;GEH9JAKGF OAL@ L@= *'.=KLAE9L=K
L@= ;G=Y;A=FLK 9J= J=HGJL=< 9K L@= =KLAE9L=<
;@9F?= AF HJG:9:ADALQ >GJ 9F AFSFAL=KAE9D ;@9F?= AF =9;@ AF<=H=F<=FL N9JA9:D=
=N9D
M9L=< 9L L@= K9EHD= E=9F /@= ;@9F?= AF =KLAE9LAGF HJG;=<MJ= @9K DALLD= =Z=;L GF
/@= GJJ=D9L=K G> 29J !GJE9D $FL=JKL9L= DDA9F;= 9L9 .=L
N
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! L@= =KLAE9L=< ;G=Y;A=FLK 9F< KL9F<9J< =JJGJK
SF9D J=E9JC ;GF;=JFK L@= AFL=JHJ=L9LAGF G> L@= =KLAE9L=< ;G=Y;A=FL GF .&73
?AN=F L@9L O= GFDQ ;GFKA<=J /=D=NAKAGF )=LOGJC )=OK 9F< A?FGJ= GL@=J E9KK E=<A9
2= >G;MK GF /1 F=OK KAF;= EGKL H=GHD= ;AL= /1 9K L@=AJ E9AF KGMJ;= G> F9LAGF9D 9F<
AFL=JF9LAGF9D F=OK $EHDA;ALDQ
O= 9KKME= L@9L L@= 0. E:9KK9<GJK <=;D9JAF? L@=
<AK9KL=JK
GJ L@=AJ HJAF;AH9DK AF 29K@AF?LGF ;9J= 9:GML L@= AE9?= G> <AK9KL=J
J=DA=> 9EGF? L@= ?=F=J9D HM:DA;
$F ?=F=J9D
A> GL@=J F=OK KGMJ;=K 9J= AEHGJL9FL AF 9Z=;LAF? L@= J=DA=> <=;AKAGFK
L@=F O= EMKL J=AFL=JHJ=L GMJ J=KMDLK .MHHGK=
>GJ =P9EHD=
L@9L ;GN=J9?= AF L@=
)=O 4GJC /AE=K @9K 9F AF<=H=F<=FL =Z=;L GF L@= J=DA=> <=;AKAGF $> <AK9KL=J ;GN=J9?=
AF L@= /=D=NAKAGF )=LOGJC )=OK 9F< L@= )=O 4GJC /AE=K AK ;GJJ=D9L=<
L@=F L@= *'.
=KLAE9L=K G> <G FGL GFDQ AF;DM<= L@= HGDA;Q =Z=;L G> L@= HM:DA;9LAGF G> 9 F=LOGJC
F=OK KLGJQ $L 9DKG AF;DM<=K L@= =Z=;L G> 9 )=O 4GJC /AE=K HM:DA;9LAGF EMDLAHDA=< :Q
L@= AF;J=9K=< HJG:9:ADALQ G> L@= <AK9KL=J :=AF? ;GN=J=< AF L@= )=O 4GJC /AE=K O@A;@
AK AEHDA=< :Q /1 ;GN=J9?= .AEAD9JDQ
LG L@= =PL=FL L@9L ;GN=J9?= AF L@= )=O 4GJC
/AE=K AK ;GJJ=D9L=< OAL@ .&73 02&3352& 9F< ,9-0*$3
GMJ AFKLJME=FL9D N9JA9:D=K
=KLAE9L=K OADD 9DKG AF;DM<= L@= =Z=;L L@JGM?@ L@= )=O 4GJC /AE=K
/G ;GF;DM<=
L@=J= 9J= KLJGF? 9 HJAGJA J=9KGFK LG :=DA=N= L@9L L@= <9L=K G> L@=
,9-0*$3 9J= =PG?=FGMK OAL@ J=KH=;L LG L@= ;@9J9;L=JAKLA;K G> <AK9KL=JK
9F< O= 9J?M=
L@9L .&73 02&3352& AK 9DKG =PG?=FGMK /9:D= K@GOK L@9L L@= AFKLJME=FLK 9J= FGL
;GJJ=D9L=< OAL@ L@= E=9KMJ=< K=N=JALQ G> <AK9KL=JK AF GMJ K9EHD= !GJ L@AK J=9KGF
L@=
=KLAE9L=< ;G=Y;A=FLK G> AFL=J=KL 9J= MF9Z=;L=< :Q 9;;GMFLAF? >GJ FGFDAF=9JALA=K AF L@=
=Z=;L G> CADD=< 9F< 9Z=;L=<
GJ GL@=J HD9MKA:D= ;GN9JA9L=K
K== GDMEF 1$ G> /9:D= GDMEF 1$$ AF L@= K9E= L9:D= K@GOK L@9L L@= =KLAE9L=< =Z=;LK 9J= 9DKG N=JQ KAEAD9J
AF L@= KM:K9EHD= G> <AK9KL=JK O@=J= L@= KLJAC= <9L=K 9J= :=LL=J <=SF=< -=?9J<AF?
L@= =PG?=F=ALQ G> .&73 02&3352&
L@= GN=JA<=FLAS;9LAGF L=KLK K@GO L@9L AFKLJME=FLAF?
OAL@ .&73 02&3352& 9F< ,9-0*$3 QA=D<K KAEAD9J J=KMDLK $F GDMEFK $$ 9F< $$$
O=
K@GO L@9L L@= =F<G?=F=ALQ G> .&73 02&3352& OAL@ J=KH=;L LG <AK9KL=J F=OK AK FGL
AEHGJL9FL $F 9<<ALAGF
O= @9N= K@GOF L@9L L@= <9Q 9N=J9?= 9KKMEHLAGF AK FGL
AEHGJL9FL /@= =N=FLK ;9MKAF? N=JQ @A?@ .&73 02&3352& <G FGL K==E LG <AJ=;LDQ
9Z=;L L@= <AK9KL=J <=;D9J9LAGFK
KAF;= L@= ;G=Y;A=FL =KLAE9L=K J=E9AF MF;@9F?=<
O@=F GFDQ MKAF? G:K=JN9LAGFK O@=J= F=OK HJ=KKMJ= AK E=<AME LG DGO
H=J;=FL AF 9 .MJN=Q ;GF<M;L=< :Q L@= + 2 -=K=9J;@ =FL=J AF %9FM9JQ #! %" !$#" %" " ""#! /8):88/43 '3* )43)1:8/438
"AN=F L@= =FGJEGMK @ME9FAL9JA9F KL9C=K
AL AK =KK=FLA9D L@9L <AK9KL=J J=DA=> AK HJG
NA<=< LG L@GK= AF EGKL F==< .LADD
O= K@GO L@9L 0. <AK9KL=J J=DA=> <=H=F<K GF
L@= 9N9AD9:ADALQ G> GL@=J F=OKOGJL@Q E9L=JA9D 9L L@= LAE= G> L@= <AK9KL=J
O@A;@ AK
G:NAGMKDQ MFJ=D9L=< LG F==< 2= 9J?M= L@9L L@= GFDQ HD9MKA:D= =PHD9F9LAGF AK L@9L
J=DA=> <=;AKAGFK 9J= <JAN=F :Q F=OK ;GN=J9?= G> <AK9KL=JK 9F< L@9L L@AK F=OK ;GN=J9?=
AK ;JGO<=< GML :Q GL@=J F=OKOGJL@Q E9L=JA9D
2= SF< F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK AF <=N=DGHAF? ;GMFLJA=K LG := EGJ= DAC=DQ LG J=;=AN= J=DA=>
A> L@=Q G;;MJ O@=F L@= HJ=KKMJ= >GJ F=OK LAE= AF L@= 0. F=LOGJC F=OK :JG9<;9KLK
AK DGO ,M9FLAL9LAN=DQ
<AK9KL=JK 9J= GF 9N=J9?= 9JGMF< =A?@L H=J;=FL EGJ= DAC=DQ LG
J=;=AN= J=DA=> A> L@=Q G;;MJ O@=F .&73 02&3352& L9C=K GF ALK @A?@=KL N9DM=K L@9F O@=F
L9CAF? GF ALK DGO=KL
9F< SN= H=J;=FL D=KK DAC=DQ LG J=;=AN= J=DA=> <MJAF? L@= *DQEHA;K
L@9F 9L GL@=J LAE=K 0KAF? 9FGL@=J E=LJA;
LG @9N= L@= K9E= ;@9F;= G> J=;=ANAF?
J=DA=>
L@= <AK9KL=J G;;MJJAF? <MJAF? L@= @A?@=KL .&73 02&3352& EMKL @9N= KAP LAE=K
9K E9FQ ;9KM9DLA=K 9K 9 <AK9KL=J G;;MJJAF? O@=F .&73 02&3352& AK 9L ALK DGO=KL
9DD
=DK= =IM9D .AEAD9JDQ
9 <AK9KL=J G;;MJJAF? <MJAF? L@= *DQEHA;K EMKL @9N= L@J==
LAE=K 9K E9FQ ;9KM9DLA=K 9K 9 <AK9KL=J GF 9F GJ<AF9JQ <9Q LG @9N= L@= K9E= ;@9F;=
G> J=;=ANAF? J=DA=>
/@= AEH9;L G> F=OK GF <AK9KL=JK 9HH=9JK LG N9JQ 9;JGKK <AK9KL=JK 2= SF< L@9L
GF 9N=J9?=
F=OK ;GN=J9?= AK FGL DAC=DQ LG AF;J=9K= L@= HJG:9:ADALQ G> HJGNA<AF? J=
DA=> :Q EGJ= L@9F 9JGMF< H=J;=FL #GO=N=J
>GJ <AK9KL=JK L@9L 9J= E9J?AF9DDQ
F=OKOGJL@Q
AF L@= K=FK= G> :=AF? ;GN=J=< A> 9F< GFDQ A> L@=J= AK DALLD= GL@=J F=OK
9N9AD9:D=
L@= =Z=;L AK EM;@ D9J?=J
9JGMF< H=J;=FL 2= 9J?M= L@9L L@AK AK <M= LG
L@= >9;L L@9L <AK9KL=JK E9J?AF9D AF L@= F=OK <=;AKAGF 9J= 9DKG E9J?AF9D AF L@= J=DA=>
<=;AKAGF /@AK AK J=9KGF9:D= 9F< ;GFKAKL=FL OAL@ NA=OK =PHJ=KK=< :Q HGDA;Q E9C=JK
.GE= <AK9KL=JK
DAC= L@= J=;=FL /KMF9EA AF /@9AD9F<
9J= ;=JL9AF LG J=;=AN= :GL@
J=DA=> 9F< F=OK ;GN=J9?=
O@AD= GL@=JK OADD J=;=AN= F=AL@=J J=DA=> FGJ F=OK ;GN=J9?=
/@= KH=;AS;9LAGF AF GDMEF 1$ G> /9:D= AF;DM<=K =KLAE9L=K GF @GO L@= HJG:9:ADALQ G> J=;=ANAF?
J=DA=> <=H=F<K :GL@ GF L@= F=OK HJ=KKMJ= 9F< L@= FME:=J G> CADD=< /@= =IM9LAGF O= KGDN= AK
.&73 02&3352& .&73 02&3352& O@=J= .&73 02&3352& AK L@= K9EHD= EAFAEME 9F< .&73 02&3352& AK L@= K9EHD= E9PAEME
/@AK AEHDA=K L@9L
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! AJJ=KH=;LAN= G> L@= 9N9AD9:ADALQ G> GL@=J :J=9CAF? F=OK
.GE= LQH=K G> <AK9KL=JK 9J= D=KK DAC=DQ LG J=;=AN= J=DA=> :=;9MK= G> L@= F=LOGJC F=OK
=Z=;L .=F 9J?M=K L@9L E=<A9 OGMD< AF;J=9K= ?GN=JFE=FL J=DA=> LG >9EAF=K
9L L@= =PH=FK= G> J=DA=> LG =F<=EA; @MF?=J /@= J=9KGF AK L@9L >9EAF=K 9J= EGJ=
<J9E9LA; 9F< L@=J=>GJ= F=OKOGJL@Q =N=FLK L@9L J=;=AN= ;GN=J9?= AF L@= E=<A9 #GO
=N=J
9EGF? L@= K=L G> F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK
>9EAF=K 9J= 9EGF? L@= D=9KL F=OKOGJL@Q
$F L@= OGJ<K G> F<J=O )9LKAGK
9<EAFAKLJ9LGJ G> 0.$
$F 9 O9J GJ >9EAF=
L@=
EGKL ;GEEGF LQH=K G> KDGOGFK=L <AK9KL=JK
L@=J= 9J= >=O=J KH=;L9;MD9J =N=FLK LG
J=HGJL GF L@9F L@=J= 9J= AF =9JL@IM9C= GJ NGD;9FA; <AK9KL=JK )9LKAGK /9:D= <AKHD9QK L@= =KLAE9L=< F=OKOGJL@AF=KK G> <AZ=J=FL LQH=K G> <AK9KL=J
2@AD= 9JGMF< H=J;=FL G> L@= =9JL@IM9C=K 9F< NGD;9FA; <AK9KL=JK 9J= ;GN=J=< :Q
L@= F=LOGJCK
D=KK L@9F H=J;=FL G> L@= =HA<=EA;K
<JGM?@LK 9F< >GG< K@GJL9?=K 9J=
;GN=J=<
K== L@= SJKL ;GDMEF /@AK AK FGL :=;9MK= =9JL@IM9C=K 9F< NGD;9FGK 9J=
EGJ= K=N=J= AF L=JEK G> L@= FME:=J G> CADD=< GJ 9Z=;L=< /@= F=PL ;GDMEF ;GFL9AFK
L@= =KLAE9L=< <AK9KL=J LQH= SP=< =Z=;LK >JGE 9 J=?J=KKAGF AF;DM<AF? DG? *,,&%
DG?
:&$4&%
9F< SP=< =Z=;LK >GJ ;GMFLJQ
Q=9J 9F< EGFL@ /@AK GFDQ 9;;=FLM9L=K L@=
<AZ=J=F;=K $F L@= D9KL ;GDMEF
O= @9N= ;GEHML=< L@= ;9KM9DLA=K J9LAG L@9L OGMD<
E9C= E=<A9 ;GN=J9?= =IM9DDQ DAC=DQ
9DD =DK= =IM9D ;GFLJGDDAF? >GJ L@= K9E= >9;LGJK 9K
AF L@= SP=< =Z=;LK J=?J=KKAGF !GJ =P9EHD=
>GJ =N=JQ H=JKGF L@9L <A=K AF 9 NGD;9FG
<AK9KL=J
H=GHD= EMKL <A= G> >GG< K@GJL9?= LG J=;=AN= L@= K9E= =KLAE9L=<
E=<A9 ;GN=J9?= /@= ;GF;DMKAGF AK L@9L E=<A9 AF<M;=K 9<<ALAGF9D J=DA=> LG NGD;9FG
9F< =9JL@IM9C= NA;LAEK
9L L@= =PH=FK= G> NA;LAEK G> =HA<=EA;K
<JGM?@LK
;GD< O9N=K
9F< >GG< K@GJL9?=K
)=LOGJC F=OK 9DKG AF<M;=K 9 J=DA=> :A9K 9?9AFKL >JA;9
KA9 9F< L@= +9;AS;
K== /9:D= 2@AD= L@= /1 F=LOGJCK ;GN=J EGJ= L@9F H=J;=FL G> L@= <AK9KL=JK
AF
MJGH= 9F< .GML@ 9F< =FLJ9D E=JA;9
L@=Q ;GN=J D=KK L@9F H=J;=FL G> L@=
<AK9KL=JK AF >JA;9 9F< L@= +9;AS; KA9F <AK9KL=JK 9J= EGJ= AF L@= F=OK L@9F >JA;9F
GF=K :=;9MK= L@=Q 9J= G> EGJ= F=OKOGJL@Q LQH=K $F H9JLA;MD9J
>JA;9 @9K E9FQ
<JGM?@LK 9F< >GG< K@GJL9?=K J=D9LAN= LG KA9 /@=J= AK FG KA?FAS;9FL <AZ=J=F;= AF
F=OK ;GN=J9?= 9>L=J ;GFLJGDDAF? >GJ <AK9KL=J LQH=
DG? +*,,&% 9F< DG? ":&$4&%
EGFL@
9F< Q=9J /@= J=E9AFAF? <AZ=J=F;=K :=LO==F >JA;9
KA9 9F< L@= +9;AS; GF L@=
GF= @9F<
9F< MJGH= 9F< .GML@ 9F< =FLJ9D E=JA;9 GF L@= GL@=J
9J= @M?= /@=
=KLAE9L=K KM??=KL L@9L AL J=IMAJ=K LAE=K 9K E9FQ CADD=< AF 9F >JA;9F <AK9KL=J
LG 9;@A=N= L@= K9E= HJG:9:ADALQ G> E=<A9 ;GN=J9?= 9K >GJ 9 <AK9KL=J AF
MJGH= 2=
;GF;DM<= L@9L E=<A9 ;GN=J9?= AF<M;=K 9<<ALAGF9D 0. J=DA=> LG NA;LAEK AF
9F< L@= E=JA;9F ;GFLAF=FL
9L L@= =PH=FK= G> NA;LAEK =DK=O@=J=
MJGH=
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! /@= JGD= G> F=LOGJC F=OK @9K ;@9F?=< GN=J LAE= !A?MJ= HDGLK L@= Q=9JSP=<
=Z=;LK >JGE L@= .&73 =IM9LAGF 2= K== L@9L L@=J= AK 9F AF;J=9KAF? LJ=F< AF L@=
HJG:9:ADALQ G> ;GN=J9?= *F= HGL=FLA9D =PHD9F9LAGF AK O@9L HGDALA;9D K;A=FLAKLK @9N=
L=JE=< L@= )) =Z=;L >GJ 9F GN=JNA=O K== -G:AFKKGF 9F< "AD:G9 ;;GJ<AF? LG L@AK L@=GJQ E=<A9 @9K ;GE= LG HD9Q 9F AF;J=9KAF? JGD= AF 0. >GJ=A?F
HGDA;Q /@AK @9K H9JLDQ :==F <JAN=F :Q AFFGN9LAGFK AF ;GEEMFA;9LAGF L=;@FGDG?A=K
O@A;@ @9K KM:KL9FLA9DDQ J=<M;=< L@= ;GKLK G> :JG9<;9KLAF? >JGE J=EGL= 9J=9K
*MJ SF<AF?K @9N= AEHGJL9FL AEHDA;9LAGFK >GJ L@= DAL=J9LMJ= GF E=<A9 9F< HGDALA;K
!AJKL
9K HJ=NAGMKDQ E=FLAGF=<
O= IM9FLAL9LAN=DQ <G;ME=FL L@= J=D9LAGFK@AH :=LO==F
L@= HM:DA;9LAGF G> F=OK KLGJA=K 9F< ?GN=JFE=FL HGDA;A=K .=;GF<
GMJ E=9KMJ=K G>
9N9AD9:D= F=OKOGJL@Q E9L=JA9D ;9F := MK=< LG A<=FLA>Q L@= =Z=;LK G> E=<A9 KLGJA=K
GF GL@=J GML;GE= N9JA9:D=K $L AK =9KQ LG L@AFC G> =P9EHD=K L@= =Z=;L G> F=OK
HM:DA;9LAGF G> =9JFAF?K 9FFGMF;=E=FLK GF KM:K=IM=FL KLG;C J=LMJF
GJ L@= =Z=;L G>
L@= HM:DA;9LAGF G> MF=EHDGQE=FL GJ AFT9LAGF J=HGJLK GF AFT9LAGF =PH=;L9LAGFK
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! /(1/4-7'5.>
67 <9EKGF
9NA< (
)9F;Q =D<=F
%MDA= 919FRG
.9DDQ +9LL=JKGF #GO E=JA;9FK 1A=O 2GJD< +GHMD9LAGF $KKM=K .MJN=Q G> +M:DA; *HAFAGF
-9F< GJHGJ9LAGF
67 A?F=J
=FFAK % -=?J=KKAGF OAL@ 9 AF9JQ $F<=H=F<=FL 19JA9:D= .M:
B=;L LG JJGJK G> *:K=JN9LAGF
%GMJF9D G> ;GFGE=LJA;K 67 =KD=Q
/ 9F< - MJ?=KK /@= HGDALA;9D =;GFGEQ G> ?GN=JFE=FL J=KHGF
KAN=F=KK /@=GJQ 9F< =NA<=F;= >JGE $F<A9
,M9JL=JDQ %GMJF9D G>
;GFGEA;K
HH 67 B^JCDMF<
9F< (GYL
- U/@= KLAE9LAGF G> 29?= "9AFK 9F< 2=D
>9J= "9AFK AF .=D>.=D=;LAGF (G<=DKV
-=NA=O G> ;GFGEA;K 9F< .L9LAKLA;K
!=:
JM9JQ 67 GGC
! '
/QD=J
/ -
"G=LR
"GJ<GF
( /
+JGL=KK
'=Z
-
(GDGL;@
# ' (=<A9 9F< 9?=F<9 K=LLAF?
Z=;LK GF L@= HM:DA;
AFL=J=KL ?JGMH D=9<=JK
HGDA;Q E9C=JK
9F< HGDA;Q
+M:DA; *HAFAGF ,M9JL=JDQ
67 - (/ /@= *!- $FL=JF9LAGF9D AK9KL=J 9L9:9K=
OOO=E<9LF=L
0FAN=JKAL\ 9L@GDAIM= <= 'GMN9AF
JMKK=DK
=D?AME
GOF
DG9<=< (9J;@ 67 J=R=
% 9F< .=F #MF?=J 9F< +M:DA; ;LAGF
*P>GJ< 0FAN=JKALQ
+J=KK
67 JMJQ
GGH=J
-A;@9J< .LM9JL *DKGF 9F< GM?D9K 19F =DD= /@=
+GDALA;K G> #ME9FAL9JA9F A< 0. !GJ=A?F AK9KL=J KKAKL9F;=
/@=
%GMJF9D G> +GDALA;K HH 67
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! JT=
.L=H@=F (;(ADD9F
#=FJQ (=<A9
+GDALA;9D +J=KKMJ=
9F< L@=
!AJE /@= 9K= G> +=LJGD=ME +JA;AF? AF L@= '9L= K
,M9JL=JDQ %GMJF9D G>
;GFGEA;K
67 "A:D=J
GM?D9K (
9F< (=J=<AL@ .9JC==K !GJL@;GEAF? (=9KMJAF? DDA9F;=K
L@= GJJ=D9L=K G> 29J !GJE9D $FL=JKL9L= DDA9F;= 9L9 K=L
%GMJF9D
G> +=9;= -=K=9J;@
67 "J9:=J
GJAK W(9KK (=<A9 9F< E=JA;9F +GDALA;KW 29K@AF?LGF
GF?J=KKAGF9D ,M9JL=JDQ
67 #=;CE9F
%9E=K % 9F< -G::
-A;@9J<
%J DL=JF9LAN= (=L@G<K >GJ N9DM9L
AF? L@= $EH9;L G> $FL=JN=FLAGFK F *N=JNA=O %GMJF9D G> ;GFGE=LJA;K
HH 67 $E:=FK
"MA<G
9F< %GK@M9 F?JAKL
$<=FLAS;9LAGF 9F<
KLAE9LAGF G>
'G;9D N=J9?= /J=9LE=FL Z=;LK
;GFGE=LJA;9 67 (;GE:K
( .@9O
' /@= 9?=F<9K=LLAF? >MF;LAGF G> E9KK E=<A9
+M:DA; *HAFAGF ,M9JL=JDQ 67 )9LKAGK
F<J=O /@= +GDALA;K G> 0FAL=< .L9L=K AK9KL=J -=KHGFK=
(=<AL=JJ9F=9F ,M9JL=JDQ 67 )AKC9F=F
2 MJ=9M;J9;Q 9F< -=HJ=K=FL9LAN= "GN=JFE=FL @A;9?G
D<AF= L@=JLGF
67 * /@= %GMJF9D =N=DGHE=FL GGH=J9LAGF -=HGJL 1GD
+9JAK
67 -G:AFKGF
+A=JK /@= )) =Z=;L ;9F L@= F=OK E=<A9 <JAN= >GJ=A?F
HGDA;Q
-=NA=O G> $FL=JF9LAGF9D .LM<A=K
X
67 .=F
!GG< :9LLD=K GFTA;LK AF L@= 9;;=KK LG >GG<
!GG< 9F<
)MLJALAGF
HH 67 .LJ^E:=J?
9NA< W-9<AGVK $EH9;L GF )=O =9D .H=F<AF?W
;@9HL=J AF
+@ AKK=JL9LAGF
+JAF;=LGF 0FAN=JKALQ
67 .LJ^E:=J?
9NA< W-9<AGVK $EH9;L GF +M:DA; .H=F<AF?W
,M9JL=JDQ
%GMJF9D G> ;GFGEA;K #! %" !$#" %" " ""#! 67 0.$
L9F;=
(9BGJ
.
!MF;LAGF9D
$FL=JF9LAGF9D
.=JA=K
AK9KL=J
+JG?J9E
KKAKL9F;=
KKAK
N9AD9:D=
9L
@LLHOOOMK9A<?GNHGDA;Q9<KH<>
67 0.
GF?J=KK
0.
"GN=JFE=FL
'=?AKD9LAGF
GF
+JAFLAF?
*Y;=
!GJ=A?F
-=D9LAGFK
29K@AF?LGF
/@JGM?@
N9AD9:D=
9L
@LLHOOOMK9A<?GNHGDA;Q9<K>99H<>
55+3*/= /@= K=;LAGF <=JAN=K LOG KAEHD= EG<=DK ADDMKLJ9LAF? @GO E=<A9 ;GN=J9?= ;GMD< 9Z=;L
J=DA=> HGDA;Q /@= HM:DA; 9;LAGF EG<=D 9KKME=K L@=J= LG := 9 ?JGMH G> NGL=JK O@G
;9J= 9:GML <AK9KL=J J=DA=>
:ML O@G 9J= AFALA9DDQ MFAF>GJE=< 9:GML L@= G;;MJ=F;= G>
KH=;AS; F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=JK 2@=F E=<A9 AF>GJEK L@=E 9:GML 9 F9LMJ9D <AK9KL=J
L@=Q
DG::Q L@=AJ HGDALA;9D J=HJ=K=FL9LAN= LG OGJC >GJ J=DA=> :=AF? HJGNA<=< $F L@= K=;GF<
EG<=D
NGL=J KMHHGJL <=H=F<K GF <AK9KL=J J=DA=> =ZGJLK J=HGJL=< AF L@= F=OK 2@=F
9 HGDA;Q E9C=J G:K=JN=K L@9L 9 <AK9KL=J AK ;GN=J=< AF L@= F=OK
@= GJ K@= J=9DAR=K L@9L
AL AK EGJ= DAC=DQ L@9L J=DA=> =ZGJLK OADD 9DKG := ;GN=J=< #=F;=
L@=J= AK 9F AF;J=9K=
AF L@= AF;=FLAN=K LG HJGNA<= J=DA=>
GL@ L@=K= EG<=DK @9N= L@= AEHDA;9LAGF L@9L <AK9KL=JK L@9L 9J= AF L@= F=OK 9J=
EGJ= DAC=DQ LG J=;=AN= J=DA=> /@AK AK L@= @QHGL@=KAK L@9L O= L=KL =EHAJA;9DDQ 2= <G
FGL 9LL=EHL LG =EHAJA;9DDQ <AKLAF?MAK@ :=LO==F L@= EG<=DK
:(1/) ')9/43
/@= LAEAF? G> L@= EG<=D AK L@= >GDDGOAF? !AJKL
9 <AK9KL=J G> K=N=JALQ G;;MJK /@=
E=<A9 ;@GGK=K O@=L@=J LG ;GN=J L@= <AK9KL=J '=L L@= AF<A;9LGJ N9JA9:D= ;4D@ =IM9D A> L@AK AK <GF= :Q L@= E=<A9 9K=< KGD=DQ GF L@= AF>GJE9LAGF HJGNA<=< :Q
L@= E=<A9
NGL=JK E9Q DG::Q >GJ J=DA=> LG := HJGNA<=< )=PL
L@= HGDA;Q E9C=JK L9C=
L@= <=;AKAGF LG HJGNA<= J=DA=> /@= N9JA9:D= ?49845 AF<A;9L=K O@=L@=J J=DA=>
AK ?AN=F !AF9DDQ
NGL=JK ;9KL L@=AJ NGL=K :9K=< GF L@= HGDA;Q 9;LAGF
2= 9KKME= L@9L L@= MLADALQ ?9AF >JGE <AK9KL=J J=DA=> LG := AF;J=9KAF? AF L@= K=N=JALQ
G> L@= <AK9KL=JK '=L B ?49845 := L@= MLADALQ G> <AK9KL=J NA;LAEK D=KK L@= ;GKL G>
J=DA=> /@= ?9AF >JGE J=DA=> AK
B ?49845 B ?49845 ?49845 B #! %" !$#" %" " ""#! O@=J= B /@MK
L@= D9J?=J L@= <AK9KL=J
L@= D9J?=J L@= E9J?AF9D MLADALQ G> 9A<
0. NGL=JK 9J= 9DLJMAKLA; 9F< ;9J= 9:GML L@= O=D>9J= G> L@= <AK9KL=J NA;LAEK /@=
=PH=;L9LAGF G> L@= F=L :=F=SL >JGE J=DA=> AK
# ?49845 B ;4D@ ?49845 B A> ;4D@ B
A> ;4D@ O@=J= B AK L@= =PH=;L=< F=L :=F=SL >JGE J=DA=>
FGL CFGOAF? L@= K=N=JALQ G> L@=
<AK9KL=J GJ O@=L@=J J=DA=> O9K HJGNA<=<
B # ?49845 B >L=J @9NAF? G:K=JN=< 9 <AK9KL=J O@=J= B 9F 9;LAGF ?JGMH 9HHJG9;@=K
L@= AF;ME:=FL HGDALA;A9F /@=J= 9J= 9 FME:=J G> 9;LAGFK L@= ?JGMH ;GMD< L9C= LG
HJ=KKMJ= L@= HGDALA;A9FK LG OGJC >GJ J=DA=> :=AF? HJGNA<=< L@=Q ;GMD< <=EGFKLJ9L=
GJ =PHD9AF L@9L L@=AJ NGL=K <=H=F< GF L@= J=DA=> <=;AKAGF 2= KAEHDQ EG<=D L@AK 9K
GZ=JAF? LG H9Q ;9EH9A?F ;GFLJA:MLAGFK 2 A> J=DA=> AK HJGNA<=<
$F L@= =D=;LAGF
9 NGL=J 8 OADD NGL= LG J==D=;L L@= AF;ME:=FL A>
2 /@= L=JE ;9HLMJ=K NGL=J HJ=>=J=F;=K GF 9DD GL@=J AKKM=K
O@A;@ O= LJ=9L 9K =P
G?=FGMK
9F< ;9HLMJ=K 9 ;GEEGF HGHMD9JALQ K@G;C GL@ 9F< 9J= MFA>GJEDQ
<AKLJA:ML=< GF L@= AFL=JN9D >JGE LG /@= L=JE 2 AK L@= =Z=;L G> L@= ;9E
H9A?F ;GFLJA:MLAGFK GF =D=;LAGF GML;GE= /@= HJG:9:ADALQ G> L@= AF;ME:=FL :=AF?
J==D=;L=< AK L@=J=>GJ=
* ;4D@ ?49845 2
HJGNA<=< L@9L L@= H9J9E=L=JK 9J= KM;@ L@9L L@= 9:GN= =PHJ=KKAGF DA=K :=LO==F R=JG
9F< GF=
2= 9KKME= L@9L L@= E:9KK9<GJ ;9J=K 9:GML L@= <AK9KL=J NA;LAEK
:ML 9DKG HMLK
9 O=A?@L GF NGL=J KMHHGJL >GJ L@= AF;ME:=FL
* /@AK ;GMD< := :=;9MK= L@=Q
;9J= 9:GML L@= >MF<AF? G> L@= J=DA=> HJG?J9E
9F< L@AK AK AF;J=9KAF? AF ALK H9QGZ LG
L@= AF;ME:=FL $L ;GMD< 9DKG := :=;9MK= L@=AJ >MLMJ= ;9J==J <=H=F<K GF @GO O=DD
L@=Q E9F9?= L@= J=DA=> HJG?J9E AF L@= AF;ME:=FLVK AFL=J=KL /@= E:9KK9<GJ >9;=K
9F GHHGJLMFALQ ;GKL G> <=;D9JAF? L@= <AK9KL=J #= GJ K@= <=;D9J=K 9 <AK9KL=J
?49845 A>
B ;4D@ 2 #! %" !$#" %" " ""#! /@= D=N=D G> ;9EH9A?F ;GFLJA:MLAGFK ;9F := =F<G?=FAR=< /@=F
L@= E:9K
K9<GJ <=;D9J=K 9 <AK9KL=J A>
;4D@ B #=F;=
L@= HJG:9:ADALQ L@9L J=DA=> AK HJGNA<=< AK @A?@=J >GJ <AK9KL=JK L@9L 9J= AF L@=
F=OK
&49/3- '3* /3,472'9/43
/@= LAEAF? G> L@AK EG<=D AK L@= >GDDGOAF? !AJKL 9 <AK9KL=J G> K=N=JALQ G;;MJK /@=
E=<A9 ;@GGK=K O@=L@=J LG ;GN=J L@= <AK9KL=J '=L L@= AF<A;9LGJ N9JA9:D= ;4D@ =IM9D A> L@AK AK <GF= :Q L@= E=<A9 )=PL
L@= E:9KK9<GJ ;@GGK=K O@=L@=J LG
HJGNA<= J=DA=> /@= N9JA9:D= ?49845 AF<A;9L=K O@=L@=J J=DA=> AK ?AN=F /@=F
L@= E=<A9 ;@GGK=K O@=L@=J LG ;GN=J L@= <AK9KL=J 9?9AF
;9HLMJ=< :Q L@= AF<A;9LGJ
N9JA9:D= 5 <99<DB=8;4D@ $> AL <G=K KG
AL 9DKG J=HGJLK GF O@=L@=J J=DA=> O9K
?AN=F !AF9DDQ
NGL=JK ;9KL L@=AJ :9DDGLK :9K=< GF L@= AF>GJE9LAGF HJGNA<=< :Q L@=
E=<A9
/@= ?9AF >JGE J=DA=> AK EG<=DD=< 9K :=>GJ= 0. NGL=JK 9J= GF;= EGJ= 9DLJMAKLA;
9F< ;9J= 9:GML L@= O=D>9J= G> L@= <AK9KL=J NA;LAEK #GO=N=J
L@=AJ =PH=;L9LAGF G>
L@= :=F=SL >JGE J=DA=> AK FGO
# ?49845 B ?49845 B A> 5 <99<DB=8;4D@ = ;4D@ B A> ;4D@ 9F< 5 <99<DB=8;4D@ # = ;4D@ B A> ;4D@ 9F< 5 <99<DB=8;4D@ KKMEAF? L@9L AK MFA>GJEDQ <AKLJA:ML=< :=LO==F R=JG 9F< GF=
L@= HJG:9:ADALQ G> ?ANAF? J=DA=>
=IM9DK
KKME= L@9L L@= ;GKL >GJ L@= 9;LAGF ?JGMH LG ;GDD=;L >MF<K AK "AN=F L@AK
L@= 9;LAGF ?JGMH OADD
GZ=J L@= HGDA;Q E9C=J L@= ;GFLJA:MLAGF O@A;@ KGDN=K
O@A;@ AK
.G L@= HJG:9:ADALQ G> HJGNA<AF? <AK9KL=J J=DA=> AK
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! /@= >MF;LAGF = ;4D@ AK L@= NGL=JKV 9KK=KK=< HJG:9:ADALQ L@9L <AK9KL=J J=DA=>
AK HJGNA<=<
?AN=F L@9L E=<A9 @9K J=HGJL=< F9DG?GMKDQ
= ;4D@ AK L@=
9KK=KK=< HJG:9:ADALQ A> L@= E=<A9 <A< FGL J=HGJL GF L@= <AK9KL=J
NGL=J 8 OADD NGL= LG J==D=;L L@= AF;ME:=FL HGDALA;A9F A> @AK GJ @=J =PH=;L=<
MLADALQ AK D9J?=J L@9F KGE= J=K=JN9LAGF MLADALQ
# ?49845 B 9F< L@= HJG:9:ADALQ L@9L L@= AF;ME:=FL AK J==D=;L=< AK
* ?49845 # ?49845 B /@= E:9KK9<GJ GF;= EGJ= ;9J=K 9:GML L@= =Z=;L G> L@= <AK9KL=J >MF<K
:ML 9DKG
HMLK 9 O=A?@L GF NGL=J KMHHGJL #= GJ K@= <=;D9J=K 9 <AK9KL=J A>
* ?49845 B #
?49845
GJ =IMAN9D=FLDQ
B O@=J= AK L@= E:9KK9<GJVK H=J;=AN=< HJG:9:ADALQ L@9L L@= <AK9K9KL=J AK ;GN=J=< AF
L@= E=<A9 9>L=J L@= J=DA=> <=;AKAGF 1GL=K 9J= GFDQ 9Z=;L=< :Q L@= J=DA=> <=;AKAGF A>
L@= J=DA=> =ZGJLK 9J= ;GN=J=< :Q L@= E=<A9
O@A;@ @9HH=FK OAL@ HJG:9:ADALQ 2= FGO <AK;MKK L@AK HJG:9:ADALQ G> J=DA=> F=OK ;GN=J9?= /@= E=<A9 OADD AFALA9DDQ
;GN=J L@= <AK9KL=J A> AL AK KMY;A=FLDQ F=OKOGJL@Q 9F< A> DALLD= GL@=J F=OK AK 9JGMF<
!GJE9DDQ
;4D@ A> O@=J= AK L@= K=N=JALQ G> L@= <AK9KL=J
AK L@= 9N9AD9:ADALQ G> GL@=J F=OKOGJL@Q
E9L=JA9D
9F< 9J= GL@=J >=9LMJ=K G> F=OKOGJL@AF=KK KM;@ 9K @GO <J9E9LA; =N=FL
L@= =N=FL AK 9F< A> AL HJGNA<=K ?GG< H@GL9?= .AEAD9JDQ
L@= E=<A9 OADD ;GN=J L@=
<AK9KL=J J=DA=>
5 <99<DB=8;4D@ A> C=Q >=9LMJ= AK L@9L L@= F=OKOGJL@AF=KK H9J9E=L=JK
9F< 9J= HGKALAN=DQ
;GJJ=D9L=< /@AK HGKALAN= ;GJJ=D9LAGF ;GMD< 9JAK= :=;9MK= G> L@= SP=< ;GKL AF L@=
F=OK L=;@FGDG?Q =? K=F<AF? J=HGJL=JK
:=;9MK= G> <AK9KL=J SP=< ;@9J9;L=JAKLA;K
=? ?GG< H@GL9?=
GJ :=;9MK= 9F AFALA9D KLGJQ :MAD<K MH NA=O=J AFL=J=KL
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! /@AK AEHDA=K L@9L L@= HJG:9:ADALQ G> E=<A9 ;GN=JAF? L@= J=DA=> AK @A?@=J A> E=<A9
;GN=J=< L@= <AK9KL=J AFALA9DDQ '=L L@AK HJG:9:ADALQ :=
;4D@ ! 5 <99<DB=8;4D@ ;4D@ /@=F
;4D@ ;4D@ :=;9MK= G> L@= ;GJJ=D9LAGF :=LO==F 9F< $F GL@=J OGJ<K
9F E:9KK9<GJ G:K=JNAF? L@9L 9 <AK9KL=J AK ;GN=J=< :Q L@= E=<A9
J=9DAR=K L@9L L@AK E9C=K AL EGJ= DAC=DQ L@9L <AK9KL=J J=DA=> =ZGJLK 9J= 9DKG ;GN=J=<
#=F;=
L@= AF;=FLAN=K LG HJGNA<= J=DA=> 9J= KLJGF?=J
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! Table 1: Summary Statistics for Disasters
Disaster type
Flood
Storm
Epidemic
Earthquake
Drought
Landslide
Fire
Cold wave
Volcano
Infestation
Food shortage
Total
67
Number of
disasters
1 675
1 175
737
559
326
310
129
114
102
47
38
5 212
Share of
disasters
0.32
0.23
0.14
0.11
0.06
0.06
0.02
0.02
0.02
0.01
0.01
1.00
Killed per
disaster
170
646
249
1 522
18 657
84
19
103
853
na
4 293
590
Affected per
disaster
1 724 851
601 490
27 528
173 015
5 740 623
38 789
69 552
46 656
39 008
1 100
734 630
1 166 505
Share receiving
OFDA relief
0.22
0.17
0.12
0.21
0.30
0.06
0.13
0.01
0.27
0.68
0.13
0.19
Chapter 2. News Droughts, News Floods and U.S. Disaster Relief
Table 2: Two largest daily news pressure dates and main story, by year
Year
Date
Main News Story
2003
14 Aug
22 Mar
New York City Blackout
Invasion of Iraq: Day 3
2002
11 Sep
24 Oct
9/11 Commemoration
Sniper Shooting in Washington: Arrest of Suspects
2001
13 Sep
12 Sep
9/11 Attack on America: Day 3
9/11 Attack on America: Day 2
2000
26 Nov
8 Dec
Gore vs. Bush: Florida Recount - Certification by Katherine Harris
Gore vs. Bush: Florida Recount - Supreme Court Ruling
1999
1 Apr
18 Jul
Kosovo Crisis: U.S. Soldiers Captured
Crash of Plane Carrying John F. Kennedy, Junior
1998
16 Dec
18 Dec
U.S. Missile Attack on Iraq
Clinton Impeachment
1997
23 Dec
31 Aug
Oklahoma City Bombing: Trial
Princess Diana’
s Death
1996
18 Jul
27 Jul
TWA Flight 800 Explosion
Olympic Games Bombing in Atlanta
1995
3 Oct
22 Apr
O.J. Simpson Trial: The Verdict
Oklahoma City Bombing
1994
17 Jan
18 Jun
California Earthquake
O.J. Simpson Arrested
1993
17 Jan
20 Apr
U.S. Missile Attack on Iraq
Waco, Texas: Cult Standoff Ends in Fire
1992
16 Jul
1 May
Perot Quits 1992 Presidential Campaign
Los Angeles Riots
1991
27 Feb
17 Jan
Gulf War: President Bush Declares Kuwait Liberated
Gulf War: Operation Desert Storm Launched
1990
4 Aug
8 Aug
Iraq Invasion of Kuwait: Day 4
Iraq Invasion of Kuwait: Mobilisation of U.S. Troops
1989
9 Mar
23 Dec
Senate Rejection of Tower Appointment to Secretary of Defense
Romania Revolution
1988
22 Dec
14 Dec
Pan Am Plane Crash
Arafat Condemns Terrorism and Accept Israel’
s Right to Exist
1987
26 Feb
18 May
Iran Arms Scandal: Tower Commission Report
USS Stark Attack in Persian Gulf
1986
29 Jan
15 Apr
Challenger Explosion
U.S. Attack on Libya
1985
30 Jun
29 Jun
TWA Flight 847 Hijacking: Release of Hostages
TWA Flight 847 Hijacking: Release of Hostages
1984
12 Jul
16 Aug
Ferraro as Vice President Candidate
Delorean Verdict
1983
25 Oct
3 Sep
U.S. Invasion of Grenada: Day 1
USSR Downing of Korean Commercial Flight
1982
4 Aug
2 Jan
Israel Invasion of Lebanon
Poland: Martial Law
1981
30 Mar
13 Dec
Ronald Reagan Assassination Attempt
Poland: Martial Law Declared by Wojchiech Jaruzelski
1980
10 Aug
26 Dec
Hurricane Allen in Texas
Iran Hostage Crisis: Iran Release Film of Hostages
39
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! 1979
31 Mar
15 Dec
Three Mile Island Nuclear Accident
Iran Hostage Crisis: Departure of Shah from U.S. Announced
1978
19 Nov
6 Aug
Guyana Incident: Sect Mass Suicide
Death of Pope Paul VI
1977
14 Jul
11 Aug
New York City Blackout
Serial Killer David Berkowitz Arrested
1976
13 Jul
9 Jun
Democratic Convention
Jimmy Carter Wins in Primaries
1975
3 Nov
14 May
Nelson Rockefeller Decides Not to Run for Vice President
Mayaguez Incident: U.S. Attacks
1974
1 Mar
21 Jul
Watergate Indictments Announced
Turkey Invades Cyprus
1973
12 Feb
24 Jan
Vietnam War: U.S. Prisoners of War Released
Vietnam War: Cease-Fire Agreement Reached
1972
9 Jan
28 May
Howard Hughes Telephone Conference
Nixon Visit in USSR: SALT I signed
1971
16 Jul
16 Aug
Nixon Announces Trip to China
Nixon Suspends Convertibility from Dollars to Gold
1970
28 Sep
7 Sep
Gamal Abdel Nasser Dead
Dawson’s Field Hijackings: Blow Up of Planes
1969
15 Oct
28 Mar
Vietnam Anti-War Demonstration (Moratorium)
Eisenhower Dead
1968
22 Aug
1 Nov
USSR Invades Czechoslovakia: Day 2
October Surprise: Vietnam Bombing Halt
Note: Ordered by daily newspressure
Table 3. Summary statistics
Variable
relief
news
killed
affected
news pressure
Olympics
US ally
Observations
5 212
5 212
3 714
4 004
5 212
5 212
5 212
Mean
0.19
0.12
590
1 092 508
7.73
0.02
0.32
Std. Dev.
0.39
0.32
9 143
9 858 292
1.22
0.09
0.47
Min
0
0
1
1
4.56
0
0
Max
1
1
300 000
300 000 000
14.32
0.77
1
Dependent variable: Relief
IV
V
VI
-0.0119
-0.0094
-0.0078
(0.0045)***
(0.0058)
(0.0040)**
-0.1232
-0.1071
-0.1098
(0.0521)**
(0.0763)
(0.0479)**
0.0582
(0.0044)***
0.0376
(0.0024)***
0.0442
(0.0037)***
0.0394
(0.0020)***
Observations
5212
2926
5212
5212
2926
5212
R-squared
0.1791
0.3625
0.2861
0.1989
0.4115
0.3726
Linear probability OLS regressions. All regressions include year, month, country and disaster type fixed effects. Regressions
with imputed values (III and VI) also include fixed effects for the interaction of missing values and disaster type. Robust
standard errors in parentheses:* significant at 10%; ** significant at 5%; *** significant at 1%.
imputed Log Affected
imputed Log Killed
log Affected
log Killed
Olympics
News Pressure
Dependent variable: News
I
II
III
-0.0163
-0.0172
-0.0143
(0.0041)***
(0.0056)***
(0.0037)***
-0.1080
-0.0849
-0.1111
(0.0470)**
(0.0628)
(0.0413)***
0.0604
(0.0040)***
0.0121
(0.0024)***
0.0495
(0.0034)***
0.0148
(0.0020)***
Table 4: Effect of the pressure for news time on disaster News and Relief
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! News Pressure
log Killed
log Affected
-0.0182
-0.0065
(0.0258)
(0.0438)
Olympics
-0.0209
-0.4569
(0.3263)
(0.5897)
p-value: F-test of joint insignificance
0.78
0.73
Observations
3714
4004
R-squared
0.2615
0.3571
OLS regressions including year, month, country and disaster type fixed effects. Robust
standard errors in parentheses:* significant at 10%; ** significant at 5%; *** significant at 1%.
Table 5. Correlations between instruments and the severity of disasters
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! I
0.2859
(0.0200)***
0.0489
(0.0046)***
0.0359
(0.0024)***
II
0.1529
(0.0232)***
0.0378
(0.0038)***
0.0376
(0.0020)***
OLS
III
0.1293
(0.0178)***
0.0549
(0.0050)***
0.0444
(0.0023)***
0.2288
(0.0329)***
-0.4819
(0.1062)***
0.5378
(0.0942)***
IV
Observations
5212
2926
5212
5212
R-squared
0.2435
0.4217
0.3798
0.3857
All regressions include year, month, country, and disaster type fixed effects. Regressions with imputed
values (III and VI) also include fixed effects for the interaction of missing values and disaster type.
Robust standard errors in parentheses:
* significant at 10%; ** significant at 5%; *** significant at 1%.
F-stat, instruments, 1st stage
Over-id restrictions, χ2df (p-value)
imputed log Affected
imputed log Killed
log Affected
log Killed
abs(Pr(news)-0.5)
News*abs(Pr(news)-0.5)
News
Table 6. Dependent variable: Relief
5027
0.0308
(0.0046)***
0.0344
(0.0026)***
0.2549
(0.0567)***
-0.2921
(0.0851)***
0.2945
(0.0834)***
V
5.8
2926
11.1
0.0187
(0.0216)
0.0297
(0.0050)***
IV
VII
0.6543
(0.3478)*
0.511(0.47)
5212
VI
0.8228
(0.2526)***
0.641 (0.42)
5212
11.2
0.0107
(0.0132)
0.0295
(0.0044)***
VIII
0.6746
(0.2544)***
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! -0.0085
(0.0041)**
-0.1290
(0.0521)**
5212
0.1985
-0.0082
(0.0040)**
-0.1182
(0.0515)**
5212
0.3851
-0.0126
(0.0054)**
-0.1338
(0.0583)**
3950
0.1835
-0.0193
(0.0052)***
-0.1008
(0.0572)*
3950
0.1862
8.6
-0.0125
(0.0142)
-0.1767
(0.0893)**
3473
0.2271
-0.0242
(0.0118)**
-0.1320
(0.0864)
3473
0.2072
3.4
Subsamples
VII
VIII
IV-regressions. Dependent variable: Relief
News
0.8228
0.8351
0.9391
0.8012
0.6726
0.7124
0.7561
0.8505
(0.2524)*** (0.2595)*** (0.3225)*** (0.2561)*** (0.2341)*** (0.2637)***
(0.2581)*** (0.4597)*
Observations
5212
5212
5212
5212
5212
5212
3910
3446
Over-id test
0.511(0.47) 0.471 (0.49) 0.201 (0.66) 0.611 (0.43) 1.271 (0.26) 0.751 (0.39) 1.101 (0.30) 0.851 (0.36)
Robust standard errors in parentheses. * significant at 10%; ** significant at 5%; *** significant at 1%. All regressions
include year, month, country and
disaster-type fixed-effects. Column I reports the results from an OLS regression. In Column II all days with news about
disasters have been removed before
computing the average news pressure. In Column III an extreme bias has been intentionally induced in news pressure. In
Column IV news pressure is the 20day average of daily news pressure, and in Column V it is the average using the weights reported in Figure 2. The regression
in Column VI contains controls
for whether the country was a US Ally, imputed log Killed and imputed log Affected, dummy variables for the interaction of
disaster type and missing data,
as well as two sets of dummy variables indicating whether Killed and Affected lie in the percentile regions 0th-25th, 25th-50th,
50th -75th, 75th-95th percentiles
respectively (omitted category is killed above 95th percentile). Column VII contains a sub sample with only earthquakes,
floods, fires landslides, storms and volcano
eruptions. Column VIII excludes observations where News Pressure was in the highest third each year.
-0.0092
(0.0038)**
-0.1266
(0.0521)**
5212
0.1987
Reduced form regressions. Dependent variable: Relief
News Pressure
-0.0119
-0.0116
-0.0104
(0.0045)*** (0.0045)*** (0.0046)**
Olympics
-0.1232
-0.1235
-0.1250
(0.0521)**
(0.0521)** (0.0520)**
Observations
5212
5212
5212
R-squared
0.1989
0.1989
0.1986
VI
-0.0155
-0.0143
(0.0036)*** (0.0038)***
-0.1156
-0.1090
(0.0470)** (0.0460)**
5212
5212
0.1795
0.2969
12.3
10.0
Changes in independent variables
III
IV
V
-0.0133
(0.0033)***
-0.1125
(0.0470)**
5212
0.1789
11.19
II
Reduced form regressions. Dependent variable: News
News Pressure
-0.0163
-0.0157
-0.0124
(0.0041)*** (0.0040)*** (0.0042)***
Olympics
-0.1080
-0.1085
-0.1114
(0.0470)**
(0.0469)** (0.0470)**
Observations
5212
5212
5212
R-squared
0.1791
0.1789
0.1779
F-test (instr.)
11.1
10.5
7.4
Table 7. Robustness
Reference
I
0.9454
(0.0406)***
5209
-0.0135
(0.0051)***
-0.1426
(0.0705)**
5209
-0.0174
(0.0048)***
-0.1048
(0.0547)*
4266
Probit
IX
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! Share in
Fixed
Equal coverage
news
(se)
effects
(se)
casualties ratio*
Volcano
0.29
(0.05)
0.64
(0.09)
1
Earthquake
0.32
(0.02)
0.57
(**)
3
Fire
0.14
(0.03)
0.49
(0.09)
12
Storm
0.14
(0.01)
0.29
(0.03)
336
Flood
0.09
(0.01)
0.23
(0.02)
806
Landslide
0.06
(0.01)
0.20
(0.03)
1 379
Epidemic
0.02
(0.01)
0.18
(0.03)
2 006
Drought
0.03
(0.01)
0.16
(0.07)
2 563
Cold wave
0.06
(0.02)
0.15
(0.07)
3 056
Food shortage
0.03
(0.03)
0.00
(0.10)
39 817
The fixed effects regression includes log Killed, log Affected, and country, year and month fixed
effects.
*To have the same estimated probability of being covered by the Television Network News, a food
shortage
must have 39 817 times as many casualties as a volcano, all else equal (country, year, month, and
number affected).
** Earthquake is the omitted category.
Table 8. Newsworthiness of Disasters, by Disaster Type
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! Share in
Fixed
Equal coverage
news
(se)
effects
(se)
casualties ratio*
Europe
0.18
(0.02)
0.25
(**)
1
S. and C. America
0.18
(0.01)
0.18
(0.04)
3
Asia
0.12
(0.01)
0.04
(0.03)
43
Africa
0.03
(0.01)
0.03
(0.04)
46
Pacific
0.03
(0.01)
0.00
(0.04)
84
The fixed effects regression includes log Killed, log Affected, and disaster type, year and month fixed
effects.
*To have the same estimated probability of being covered by the Television Network News, a disaster
in the
Pacific must have 84 times as many casualties as one in Europe, all else equal (disaster type, year,
month, and number affected).
** Europe is the omitted continent.
Table 9. Newsworthiness of Disasters, by Continents
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! Share in
Fixed
Equal coverage
news
(se)
effects
(se)
casualties ratio*
1968-1972
0.14
(0.02)
-0.17
(0.03)
16
1973-1977
0.13
(0.02)
-0.10
(0.03)
5
1978-1982
0.12
(0.02)
-0.14
(0.02)
10
1983-1987
0.06
(0.02)
-0.16
(0.02)
13
1988-1992
0.10
(0.01)
-0.10
(0.02)
5
1993-1997
0.11
(0.01)
-0.10
(0.02)
4
1998-2002
0.13
(0.01)
0.00
(**)
1
The fixed effects regression includes log Killed, log Affected, and disaster type, country and month
fixed effects.
*To have the same estimated probability of being covered by the Television Network News, a disaster
in the
1968 must have 16 times as many casualties as one in 2002, all else equal (disaster type, country,
month, and number affected).
** 1998-2002 is the omitted period.
Table 10. Newsworthiness of Disasters, by Five-Year period
#! %" !$#" %" " ""#! #! %" !$#" %" " ""#! .'59+7 /8)'1
41/)> '3* "+9/7+2+39 /3
9.+ $<+39/+9. +39:7> 3974*:)9/43
*F= G> L@= EGKL HJGFGMF;=< LJ=F<K AF <=N=DGH=< =;GFGEA=K 9JGMF< L@= OGJD< AK L@=
<=;DAF= AF D9:GJ >GJ;= H9JLA;AH9LAGF 9EGF? GD<=J OGJC=JK $F L@= 0.
>GJ AFKL9F;=
L@= E=<A9F J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= O9K AF $F L@= Q=9J G> L@= Q=9J GD<K
O=J= AF L@= D9:GJ >GJ;=
9F< L@= E=<A9F 9?= G> J=LAJ=E=FL O9K E9BGJ =PHD9F9LAGF HJGHGK=< >GJ L@= <=;J=9K= AF D9:GJ >GJ;= H9JLA;AH9LAGF 9EGF?
GD<=J OGJC=JK @9K :==F L@= JAK= AF L@= KAR= 9F< K;GH= G> L@= KG;A9D K=;MJALQ KQKL=E
$FALA9L=< AF L@= 0. H=FKAGF KQKL=E AK FGO 9F =FLALD=E=FL HJG?J9E L@9L ;GN=JK
F=9JDQ 9DD OGJC=JK 9F< J=LAJ==K $F GFDQ H=J;=FL G> L@GK= 9?=< GJ EGJ=
J=;=AN=< H=FKAGF :=F=SLK *$
9K ;GEH9J=< LG H=J;=FL AF ..
(GJ=GN=J
L@= KQKL=E @9K :=;GE= AF;J=9KAF?DQ ?=F=JGMK /@= J=9D 9N=J9?= EGFL@DQ
:=F=SL LG J=LAJ=< OGJC=JK JGK= >JGE AF LG AF ;GFKL9FL <GDD9JK
9F AF;J=9K= G> EGJ= L@9F H=J;=FL *F 9N=J9?=
L@= K@9J= G> KG;A9D
K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK AF LGL9D @GMK=@GD< AF;GE= G> H=GHD= 9?=< 9:GN= JGK= >JGE H=J;=FL AF LG H=J;=FL AF ..
: 9F< .9EOA;C
/@=F
9L
L@= =F< G> L@= LO=FLA=L@ ;=FLMJQ
KG;A9D K=;MJALQ HJGNA<=< EGJ= L@9F @9D> L@= AF;GE=
>GJ H=J;=FL G> L@= 9?=< @GMK=@GD<K 9F< O9K L@= GFDQ KGMJ;= G> AF;GE= >GJ H=J;=FL
$ L@9FC !9:JARAG 5ADA:GLLA
&B=LAD .LGJ=KD=LL=F
(9L@A9K #=JRAF? 9F< (9MJA;AG +J9<G
%J
>GJ @=DH>MD ;GEE=FLK 9F< KM??=KLAGFK $ 9DKG L@9FC @JAKLAF9 '^FF:D9< >GJ =<ALGJA9D 9KKAKL9F;=
DD J=E9AFAF? =JJGJK 9J= EAF= !AF9F;A9D KMHHGJL >JGE %9F 29DD9F<=JVK 9F< /GE #=<=DAMKV -=
K=9J;@ !GMF<9LAGF
/GJ= JGO9D<VK !GMF<9LAGF 9F< !AF9FKHGDALAKC9 !GJKCFAF?KAFKLALML=L AK ?J9L=
>MDDQ 9CFGOD=<?=<
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
A< L@= JAK= G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ ;J=9L= L@AK LJ=E=F<GMK ;@9F?= AF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9N
AGJ *:K=JN9LAGFK
KM;@ 9K L@GK= E9<= 9:GN=
OGMD< KM??=KL L@9L AL <A< #GO=N=J
=;GFGEAKLK @9N= FGL :==F 9:D= LG =KL9:DAK@ L@AK 9K 9F MF<AKHML9:D= >9;L !AJKL
L@=
EA;JG=KLAE9L=K G> L@= J=LAJ=E=FL =D9KLA;ALQ OAL@ J=KH=;L LG KG;A9D K=;MJALQ 9J= FGLG
JAGMKDQ DGO $F<==<
AF J=NA=OAF? L@= DAL=J9LMJ=
&JM=?=J 9F< (=Q=J ;GF;DM<=
L@9L EA;JG=;GFGE=LJA; KLM<A=K L=F< LG SF< 9 N=JQ EG<=KL AEH9;L G> .G;A9D .=;MJALQ
67 GF D9:GJ KMHHDQ 67 MJLD=KKV ;GFL=FLAGF
:9K=< GF @AK GOF =KLAE9L=
G> L@= J=LAJ=E=FL =D9KLA;ALQ
AK L@9L L@= E9AF =PHD9F9LAGF >GJ L@= J9HA< <=;DAF= AF
=EHDGQE=FL G> GD<=J E9D=K EMKL DA= =DK=O@=J= .=;GF<
L@= LJ=F< LGO9J<K =9JDA=J
J=LAJ=E=FL KL9JL=< 9DJ=9<Q 9L L@= :=?AFFAF? G> L@= ;=FLMJQ
:=>GJ= KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
O9K AFLJG<M;=<
L@MK J9AKAF? L@= IM=KLAGF G> O@=L@=J L@= <JGH OGMD< @9N= G;;MJJ=<
9FQO9Q
GFK=IM=FLDQ
=;GFGEAKLK @9N= DGGC=< =DK=O@=J= >GJ =PHD9F9LAGFK GKL9 9F< &GH=;CQ 9J?M= L@9L >9DDAF? HJA;=K G> D=AKMJ= ?GG<K @9N= E9<= D=AKMJ= EGJ=
9LLJ9;LAN= /@= EG<=D G> (9LKMQ9E9 AEHDA=K L@9L =;GFGEA; <=N=DGHE=FL
AF<M;=K =D<=JDQ LG KM:KLALML= AFLG D=AKMJ=
KAF;= D=AKMJ= AK 9 DMPMJQ ?GG< @ALMN 9F<
5=AJ9 KM??=KL L@9L >9KL=J L=;@FGDG?A;9D HJG?J=KK AF;J=9K=K L@= <=HJ=;A9LAGF G>
KCADDK
J=KMDLAF? AF =9JDA=J =PAL >JGE L@= D9:GJ E9JC=L (GJ=GN=J
&9D=EDA*R;9F 9F<
2=AD 9J?M= L@9L L@= AF;J=9K= AF DA>= =PH=;L9F;Q J=<M;=K L@= JAKC G> K9NAF? >GJ
J=LAJ=E=FL
9DDGOAF? =9JDA=J D9:GJ E9JC=L =PAL
$F ;GFLJ9KL
L@AK H9H=J 9J?M=K L@9L AL AK HJ=E9LMJ= LG <AKEAKK KG;A9D K=;MJALQ 9K
9F =PHD9F9LAGF >GJ L@= K=;MD9J LJ=F< AF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ $F H9JLA;MD9J
:Q 9<
=IM9L=DQ 9;;GMFLAF? >GJ ;@9F?=K AF DA>= =PH=;L9F;Q 9F< SK;9D HGDA;Q GN=J L@= H9KL
;=FLMJQ
AL AK K@GOF L@9L KG;A9D K=;MJALQ ;GMD< AF<==< @9N= :==F 9 E9AF ;GFLJA:MLAF?
>9;LGJ (GJ=GN=J
L@= EG<=D AK K@GOF LG := ;GFKAKL=FL :GL@ OAL@ L@= KE9DD ;GFL=E
HGJ9JQ J=LAJ=E=FL =D9KLA;ALA=K >GMF< AF L@= EA;JG=;GFGEA; DAL=J9LMJ=
9F< OAL@ L@=
<JGH AF J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=K HJAGJ LG L@= AFLJG<M;LAGF G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ $F H9JLA;MD9J
L@= J=LAJ=E=FL =D9KLA;ALQ AK K@GOF LG := 9 <=;J=9KAF? 9F< ;GFN=P >MF;LAGF G> L@=
J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=
OAL@ GFDQ 9 KE9DD KDGH= 9L L@= HJ=K=FL D=N=D G> J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=K
!MJL@=JEGJ=
L@= =9JDQ <JGH AF J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=K ;9F := 9LLJA:ML=< LG L@= AF;J=9K= AF
?GN=JFE=FL D=F<AF? /@AK J=KMDL=< AF 9F AF;J=9K= AF AFL=J=KL J9L=K X L@= J=LMJF LG
J=LAJ=E=FL AF;GE= X 9F< L@=J=>GJ= LG =9JDA=J J=LAJ=E=FL
KLQDAR=< EG<=D G> L@= 0. =;GFGEQ AK <=N=DGH=< AF GJ<=J LG 9J?M= L@9L SK
;9D HGDA;Q 9F< KG;A9D K=;MJALQ @9N= :==F 9 E9AF <JANAF? >GJ;= AF L@= =NGDMLAGF G>
J=LAJ=E=FL GN=J L@= H9KL ;=FLMJQ /@= EG<=D >=9LMJ=K @GMK=@GD<K L@9L ;@GGK= ;GF
KMEHLAGF
K9NAF?K
@GMJK OGJC=< 9K O=DD 9K L@=AJ 9?= G> J=LAJ=E=FL +JGSL E9PAEARAF?
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
SJEK ;@GGK= AFHMLK G> D9:GJ 9F< ;9HAL9D /G =EH@9KAR= L@= JGD= G> SK;9D HGDA;Q
L@=
?GN=JFE=FL AK EG<=DD=< AF KGE= <=L9AD $F H9JLA;MD9J
L@= ?GN=JFE=FL HJGNA<=K 9
HM:DA; ;GFKMEHLAGF ?GG< 9F< LJ9FK>=JK
AF;DM<AF? KG;A9D K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK "GN=JF
E=FL =PH=F<ALMJ=K 9J= SF9F;=< =AL@=J L@JGM?@ L9P=K GF D9:GJ 9F< ;9HAL9D AF;GE=
GJ
:Q AKKMAF? <=:L .G;A9D K=;MJALQ AK EG<=DD=< 9K 9 T9L J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= GF L@= 9N=J9?=
=9JFAF?K AF L@= =;GFGEQ #GO=N=J
;GFKAKL=FL OAL@ L@= 0. KG;A9D K=;MJALQ KQKL=E
L@= J9L= <=H=F<K GF L@= 9?= G> J=LAJ=E=FL /@AK >=9LMJ= AK AEHGJL9FL KAF;= AL 9DDGOK
>GJ AFL=JF9D KGDMLAGFK LG L@= J=LAJ=E=FL HJG:D=E
/@= EG<=D AK ;9DA:J9L=< LG ;9HLMJ= >=9LMJ=K G> L@= 0. =;GFGEQ AF L@= Q=9J
"GN=JFE=FL =PH=F<ALMJ=K
?GN=JFE=FL <=:L 9F< H9QJGDD L9P=K 9J= ;9DA:J9L=<
LG E9L;@ L@= <9L9 ?=F=J9D AF;GE= L9P AK J=KA<M9DDQ <=L=JEAF=< LG :9D9F;= L@=
?GN=JFE=FLVK :M<?=L #GMK=@GD<K @9N= HJG<M;LANALQ HJGSD=K 9F< DA>==PH=;L9F;A=K
;GFKAKL=FL OAL@ L@= <9L9 /@= MLADALQ >MF;LAGF AK ;9DA:J9L=< LG ;9HLMJ= @GMJK OGJC=<
<MJAF? HJAE=9?= 9F< 9 J=9DAKLA; !JAK;@ =D9KLA;ALQ $EHGJL9FLDQ
L@= J=KMDLAF? J=LAJ=
E=FL 9?=
O@A;@ AK FGL ;9DA:J9L=<
AK :JG9<DQ ;GFKAKL=FL OAL@ L@= =EHAJA;9D =NA<=F;=
/@= KM:K=IM=FL =PH=JAE=FLK C==H L@= H9J9E=L=JK SP=<
:ML ;@9F?= ?GN=JFE=FL
HGDA;Q 9F< DA>= =PH=;L9F;Q 9K G:K=JN=< AF L@= <9L9 /@= EG<=D <G=K 9 ?GG< BG: AF
E9L;@AF? L@= LJ=F< AF L@= 9N=J9?= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= GN=J L@= H9KL ;=FLMJQ FME:=J
G> =PH=JAE=FLK J=N=9D L@9L L@= JAK= AF L@= J=LMJFK LG K9NAF?K 9F< L@= AFLJG<M;LAGF G>
KG;A9D K=;MJALQ 9J= L@= EGKL AEHGJL9FL >9;LGJK <JANAF? L@= <=;DAF= AF J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=K
/@= J=E9AF<=J G> L@= H9H=J HJG;==<K 9K >GDDGOK .=;LAGF <=K;JA:=K L@= =EHAJA;9D
=NA<=F;= GF L@= =NGDMLAGF G> J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ <MJAF? L@= LO=FLA=L@ ;=FLMJQ AF L@=
0FAL=< .L9L=K .=;LAGF <=K;JA:=K L@= =;GFGEA; EG<=D 9F< K=;LAGF <AK;MKK=K L@=
HJG;=<MJ= >GJ ;9DA:J9LAF? L@= =;GFGEQ LG L@= 0. AF L@= Q=9J .=;LAGF SJKL
;9JJA=K GML 9 KL=9<Q KL9L= 9F9DQKAK MKAF? @AKLGJA;9D <9L9 GF DA>= =PH=;L9F;Q 9F< SK;9D
HGDA;Q
AF;DM<AF? KG;A9D K=;MJALQ .=;LAGF GZ=JK 9 <AK;MKKAGF G> L@= J=KMDLK AF NA=O
G> L@= LOG J=LAJ=E=FL HMRRD=K .=;LAGF GZ=JK ;GF;DM<AF? J=E9JCK
$7+3*8 /3 7+9/7+2+39
-=LAJ=E=FL AK <=SF=< 9K L@= OAL@<J9O9D >JGE L@= D9:GJ >GJ;= :Q GD<=J OGJC=JK $L
AK MKM9DDQ
:ML FGL 9DO9QK
H=JE9F=FL 9F< G>L=F J=D9L=< LG L@= ;D9AEAF? G> KG;A9D
K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK /@AK K=;LAGF HJ=K=FLK =NA<=F;= G> L@= ?=F=J9D LJ=F< AF J=LAJ=E=FL
AF L@= 0FAL=< .L9L=K <MJAF? L@= LO=FLA=L@ ;=FLMJQ
NA<=F;= >JGE GL@=J ;GMFLJA=K AK
9DKG HJ=K=FL=< KM??=KLAF? L@AK LG := 9 ;GEEGF LJ=F< AF EGKL <=N=DGH=< =;GFGEA=K
/@= =NGDMLAGF G> J=LAJ=E=FL GN=J L@= H9KL ;=FLMJQ ;9F := <G;ME=FL=< AF 9 N9JA=LQ
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
100
Labor Force Participation Rate (%)
90
US 55-64
80
70
60
50
UK
Germany
France
40
US 65+
30
20
10
0
1850
1900
1950
2000
Year
!A?MJ= '9:GJ !GJ;= +9JLA;H9LAGF -9L=K
(=F
0FAL=< .L9L=K
!J9F;=
"=J
E9FQ
JAL9AF
9F< 0FAL=< .L9L=K
G> O9QK !A?MJ= K@GOK L@= D9:GJ >GJ;= H9JLA;AH9LAGF J9L=K G> E=F 9?=< 9F<
9:GN= >GJ L@= H=JAG< LG >GJ L@= 0FAL=< .L9L=K
"J=9L JAL9AF
!J9F;=
9F<
"=JE9FQ
9F< L@= D9:GJ >GJ;= H9JLA;AH9LAGF J9L=K G> E=F 9?=< >GJ L@= 0FAL=<
.L9L=K GKL9 )GLA;= L@9L L@= <=;DAF= G;;MJJ=< KAEMDL9F=GMKDQ AF 9DD >GMJ
;GMFLJA=K /@= D9:GJ >GJ;= H9JLA;AH9LAGF J9L= >GJ E9D=K 9?=< J=E9AF=< JGM?@DQ
;GFKL9FL MFLAD O@=F AL KL9JL=< LG <=;DAF=
&GH=;CQ =KLAE9L=K E9D= J=LAJ=E=FL J9L=K >GJ L@= H=JAG< AF L@=
0FAL=< .L9L=K -=LAJ=E=FL J9L=K 9J= ;GEHML=< 9K L@= J9LAG :=LO==F L@= FME:=J G>
E=F O@G 9J= J=LAJ=< LG L@= LGL9D G> 9DD E=F AF L@= D9:GJ >GJ;= 9F< J=LAJ=< !A?MJ= <AKHD9QK L@= J=LAJ=E=FL J9L=K :Q 9?= ?JGMH 9F< Q=9J /@= J=LAJ=E=FL J9L=K AF;J=9K=
>GJ 9DD 9?= ?JGMHK
:ML EGKL E9JC=<DQ >GJ L@= ?JGMHK H9KL L@= 9?= G> )GLA;= L@9L
L@= LJ=F< LGO9J<K =9JDA=J J=LAJ=E=FL 9;;=D=J9L=K 9JGMF< L@= Q=9J >GJ 9?= ?JGMHK
H9KL L@= 9?= G> /@= 9;;=D=J9LAGF G;;MJK 9>L=J >GJ L@GK= 9?=< !GJ
L@GK= 9?=< L@= J=LAJ=E=FL J9L= AF;J=9K=K >JGE AF LG AF /@= LJ=F< AK GFDQ AFL=JJMHL=< <MJAF? L@= LOG OGJD< O9JK
/@= EG<=D <=N=DGH=< AF D9L=J K=;LAGFK ;9F := MK=< LG E9C= HJ=<A;LAGFK 9:GML L@=
9?= G> J=LAJ=E=FL 0KAF? <9L9 >JGE &GH=;CQ L@= E=<A9F J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= @9K
/@GK= O@G F=N=J H9JLA;AH9L=< AF L@= D9:GJ >GJ;= 9J= FGL ;GMFL=<
A= J=LAJ=< FGL AF
D9:GJ>GJ;= X F=N=J H9JLA;AH9LAF? X F=N=J H9JLA;AH9LAF?
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
0.9
Ages 75-79
0.8
Retirement Rate (%)
0.7
Ages 70-74
0.6
0.5
Ages 65-69
Ages 60-64
0.4
0.3
Ages 55-59
0.2
Ages 50-54
0.1
0
1850
1900
1950
2000
Year
!A?MJ= -=LAJ=E=FL -9L=K >GJ (=F ?=< 9F< 9:GN= :Q ?= "JGMH
0FAL=< .L9L=K
:==F ;GEHML=< 9K L@= 9?= 9L O@A;@ @9D> L@= E9D= HGHMD9LAGF AK GML G> L@= D9:GJ >GJ;=
K== !A?MJ= Q L@AK E=9KMJ=
L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= <=;DAF=< >JGE AF LG
AF 9F< AF MJAF? 22$$
L@=J= O9K F=9JDQ FG ;@9F?= AF L@=
J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=
O@AD= L@= H=JAG< :=LO==F 9F< GF;= EGJ= =PH=JA=F;=< 9
D9J?= <=;DAF= >JGE LG =LO==F 9F< L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= <=;DAF=<
:Q 9JGMF< GF= Q=9J H=J <=;9<=
9F< KLGG< 9L AF Q=9J /@AK E=9KMJ= G> L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= ;GF>GMF<K ;G@GJL=Z=;LK OAL@ LAE==Z=;LK
#GO=N=J
EGJ= 9<N9F;=< E=9KMJ=K O@A;@ 9LL=EHL LG 9;;GMFL >GJ ;G@GJL=Z=;LK
JGM?@DQ SF< KAEAD9J LJ=F<K >GJ L@= HGKL22$$ H=JAG<
9DL@GM?@ L@= D=N=DK <AZ=J
KGE=O@9L !GJ AFKL9F;=
"=F<=DD =KLAE9L=K L@9L L@= E=<A9F 9?= G> D9:GJ
>GJ;= OAL@<J9O9D <=;DAF=< >JGE AF LG 9L L@= =F< G> L@= VK 0KAF? 9
J=D9L=< E=L@G<
D^F<9D 9F< .;9JH=LL9 SF< L@9L L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= <=;DAF=<
>JGE LG <MJAF? L@= K9E= H=JAG< "=F<=DD ;GFKLJM;LK 9F 9DL=JF9LAN=
E=9KMJ= :9K=< GF KG;A9D K=;MJALQ :=F=SL ;D9AEK /@AK E=9KMJ= K@GOK 9 K@9JH <=;DAF=
AF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= :=LO==F 9F< >JGE LG >L=J L@=
<=;DAFAF? LJ=F< AF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= D=N=DK GZ "=F<=DD 9F< D^F<9D 9F<
.;9JH=LL9 9DKG K@GO L@9L L@= LJ=F<K @9N= :==F JGM?@DQ KAEAD9J >GJ :GL@ E=F
;M:A; KHDAF= AK MK=< LG ;GEHML= L@= =P9;L J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
80
78
76
Median Retirement Age
Age
74
72
70
Gendell - Social security
68
Blöndal and Scarpetta
66
Gendell - Median
64
62
1900
1910
1920
1930
1940
1950
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
Year
!A?MJ= /@= -=LAJ=E=FL ?= AF L@= 0FAL=< .L9L=K
(9D=K
9F< OGE=F
/@= <=;DAF= AF 9N=J9?= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=K @9K G;;MJJ=< ;GFL=EHGJ9F=GMKDQ OAL@
L@= AF;J=9K= AF DA>= =PH=;L9F;Q Q=9J GD< E9D= OGJC=J ;GMD< =PH=;L LG DAN=
9FGL@=J Q=9JK AF 9FGL@=J Q=9JK AF 9F< 9FGL@=J Q=9JK AF MJLD=KK !GJ OGE=F
L@= AF;J=9K= @9K :==F =N=F EGJ= HJGFGMF;=< X L@=
;GJJ=KHGF<AF? FME:=JK 9J= 9F< J=KH=;LAN=DQ /@MK
L@=J= AK 9 KM:KL9FLA9D
AF;J=9K= AF L@= =PH=;L=< <MJ9LAGF G> J=LAJ=E=FL !A?MJ= K@GOK L@= =PH=;L=<
H=J;=FL9?= G> 9<MDL DA>= KH=FL AF J=LAJ=E=FL
/@MK
9 LO=FLQQ=9J GD< E9D= AF
OGMD< @9N= =PH=;L=< LG DAN= KAP H=J;=FL G> @AK 9<MDL DA>= AF J=LAJ=E=FL /@=
;GJJ=KHGF<AF? S?MJ= AF O9K F=9JDQ L@AJLQ
$.+ +)4342/) 24*+1
/@AK K=;LAGF <=N=DGHK 9 EG<=D LG 9;;GMFL >GJ L@= LJ=F<K AF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ /@=
EG<=D AK J=D9L=< LG M=J:9;@ 9F< &GLDACGZ #GO=N=J
L@= EG<=D 9DDGOK >GJ
=F<G?=FGMK J=LAJ=E=FL (GJ=GN=J
LG ?9M?= L@= AEHGJL9F;= G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
L@=
0. KG;A9D K=;MJALQ JMD=K OADD := EG<=DD=< AF KGE= <=L9AD
9L9 AK >JGE &GH=;CQ /@= =PH=;L=< D=F?L@ G> J=LAJ=E=FL AK ;GEHML=< 9KKMEAF? LO=FLQ
Q=9JGD<K LG @9N= H=J>=;L AF>GJE9LAGF 9:GML >MLMJ= EGJL9DALQ J9L=K
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
Expected Percentage of Life Spent in Retirement
30
25
20
15
10
5
1850
1900
1950
2000
Year
!A?MJ= PH=;L=< K@9J= G> <MDL 'A>= .H=FL AF -=LAJ=E=FL 0FAL=< .L9L=K
+24-7'5./)8
/@= =;GFGEQ AK HGHMD9L=< :Q AF<ANA<M9DK DANAF? 9 E9PAEME G> % H=JAG<K $F<ANA<M9DK
<AZ=J AF 9?=
8 %
O@=J= AK L@= 9?= 9L O@A;@ 9F AF<ANA<M9D =FL=JK 9<MDL@GG<
GF<ALAGF9D GF :=AF? 9DAN= 9L 9?= 8 L@= HJG:9:ADALQ G> KMJNANAF? LG 9?= 8 AK @ 9F<
HGHMD9LAGF ?JGOK 9L L@= J9L= ; /@= E=9KMJ= G> AF<ANA<M9DK AF 9?= ?JGMH 8 9L LAE= A
AK ?AN=F :Q $ 7+,+7+3)+8 9+).3414-> '3* 2'70+98
$F<ANA<M9DK <=JAN= MLADALQ >JGE 9 KL9F<9J< ;GFKMEHLAGF ?GG< 9F< D=AKMJ= +J=>=J=F;=K
9J= LAE= K=H9J9:D= /@= AFKL9FL9F=GMK MLADALQ >MF;LAGF L9C=K L@= >GJE B
2 7
O@=J= 2 AK ;MJJ=FL ;GFKMEHLAGF 9F< 7 AK L@= LAE= KH=FL OGJCAF? AF L@= E9JC=L /@=
>MF;LAGF B
AK AF;J=9KAF? 9F< KLJA;LDQ ;GF;9N= AF :GL@ 9J?ME=FLK
F 9?=FL E9PAEAR=K DA>=LAE= MLADALQ 9K ?AN=F :Q
"
B
2 7 KM:B=;L LG L@= AFL=JL=EHGJ9D :M<?=L ;GFKLJ9AFLK LG := KH=;AS=< :=DGO + AK L@=
J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= <=SF=< 9K L@= 9?= 9L O@A;@ L@= AF<ANA<M9D ;@GGK=K LG KLGH OGJCAF?
7 AK L@= MF;GF<ALAGF9D HJG:9:ADALQ >GJ 9F 9?=FL G> :=AF? 9DAN= 9L 9?= 8
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
<=SF=< 9K @ 0HGF <=9L@
AF<ANA<M9DK ?=L R=JG MLADALQ
$F<ANA<M9DK AFN=KL L@=AJ 9KK=LK AF 9 H=J>=;L 9FFMALQ E9JC=L O@A;@ H9QK 9 HJ=EAME
G>
#
GF L@= ?JGKK AFL=J=KL J9L=
*MLHML AF H=JAG< A AK ?AN=F :Q 9 KL9F<9J< ;GFKL9FL J=LMJFK LG K;9D= HJG<M;LAGF
>MF;LAGF 5 '$ ($ OAL@ 9??J=?9L= D9:GJ
($ 9F< ;9HAL9D
'$ 9K AFHMLK *MLHML AK
MK=< >GJ ;GFKMEHLAGF 9F< AFN=KLE=FL AF ;9HAL9D >GJE9LAGF ??J=?9L= D9:GJ AFHML
AF H=JAG< A
($ AK L@= KME G> =Y;A=F;Q MFALK KMHHDA=< :Q AF<ANA<M9DK
A= ($ 4$ 7$ $ O@=J= 4$ AK L@= FME:=J G> D9:GJ =Y;A=F;Q MFALK 9F< 7$ AK L@= LAE=
KH=FL OGJCAF? :Q AF<ANA<M9DK G> 9?= 8 AF H=JAG< A -=HJ=K=FL9LAN= SJEK J=FL D9:GJ
9F< ;9HAL9D GF L@= KHGL E9JC=LK 9L 9 ?AN=F O9?= J9L=
D$ 9F< 9 ?JGKK J=FL9D J9L=
?$ 9F< L@= SJE KGDN=K
" 5 '$ ($ ?$ '$ D$ ($ O@=J= AK L@= <=HJ=;A9LAGF J9L= G> ;9HAL9D
4;+732+39 '3* 84)/'1 8+):7/9>
"GN=JFE=FL HGDA;Q ;GFKAKLK G> 9 L9P JMD=
9 HM:DA; KH=F<AF? JMD=
9F< 9 LJ9FK>=J
JMD= AF;DM<AF? KG;A9D K=;MJALQ 9F< GL@=J ?GN=JFE=FL LJ9FK>=J HJG?J9EK /@= L9P JMD=
KH=;AS=K 9F =PG?=FGMK H9QJGDD L9P J9L= 9F< 9F =F<G?=FGMK L9P J9L= GF ;9HAL9D
AF;GE= 9F< D9:GJ AF;GE=
.G;A9D K=;MJALQ AK EG<=DD=< LG ;9HLMJ= L@= K9DA=FL >=9LMJ=K G> L@= 0. KG;A9D
K=;MJALQ KQKL=E L KGE= 9?=
& AF<ANA<M9DK :=;GE= =DA?A:D= >GJ KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
:=F=SLK *FDQ =DA?A:D= AF<ANA<M9DK O@G 9J= J=LAJ=< 7 ;9F J=;=AN= KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
:=F=SLK /@= AF<ANA<M9DVK KG;A9D K=;MJALQ LJ9FK>=J AK 9 >MF;LAGF F + G> @=J 9N=J9?=
=9JFAF?K <MJAF? OGJCDA>= 9F< @=J 9?= 9L J=LAJ=E=FL
+ AK O=9CDQ AF;J=9KAF? AF
+
KM;@ L@9L 9 HJ=EAME E9Q := ?AN=F >GJ <=D9Q=< J=LAJ=E=FL /@= HJ=EAME ?AN=F
>GJ <=D9Q=< J=LAJ=E=FL E9Q N9JQ :Q 9?=
DD GL@=J ?GN=JFE=FL LJ9FK>=J HJG?J9EK
KM;@ 9K E=<A;9J=
MF=EHDGQE=FL AF
KMJ9F;=
O=D>9J= H9QE=FLK =L;
9J= <AKLJA:ML=< 9K H9JL G> L@= DMEHKME LJ9FK>=JK
/@= 9??J=?9L= KG;A9D K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK 9F< GL@=J ?GN=JFE=FL LJ9FK>=JK AF H=JAG<
A ;9F := ;GEHML=< 9K
-$ $ F +$ #! " & #!# # %## #$!&
O@=J= F AK 9N=J9?= DA>=LAE= =9JFAF?K 9F< +$ AK L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= G> 9F AF<ANA<M9D
:GJF 9L LAE= A 8 !GJ KAEHDA;ALQ 9N=J9?= DA>=LAE= =9JFAF?K
F AK ;GEHML=< GN=J
L@= SJKL & Q=9JK G> OGJC DA>=
F D$ 4 7 !AF9DDQ
L@= ?GN=JFE=FL ;9F 9DDG;9L=
J=KGMJ;=K LG ?GN=JFE=FL ;GFKMEHLAGF
$$ /GL9D L9P J=N=FM=K 9J= ?AN=F :Q
+#.$ D$ ($ ?$ '$ D$ ($
O@=J= ($ 9F< '$ 9J= J=KH=;LAN=DQ 9??J=?9L= D9:GJ AFHML 9F< 9??J=?9L= ;9HAL9D
J=
KH=;LAN=DQ
M<?=L <=S;ALK 9J= SF9F;=< L@JGM?@ AF;J=9K=K AF L9P=P=EHL ?GN=JFE=FL :GF<K
!$ GF<K 9J= @=D< :Q HJAN9L= 9?=FLK 9F< =NGDN= 9;;GJ<AF? LG
!$ !$ ?$ +#.$ -$ $$
O@=J= E9JC=L ;D=9JAF? AF L@= :GF<K E9JC=L @9K :==F AEHGK=<
A= ?$
?$ 3*/;/*:'18A (:*-+9 )43897'/39 '3* *+)/8/43 574(1+2
/@= :M<?=L ;GFKLJ9AFL G> 9F AF<ANA<M9D G> 9?= 8 9L LAE= A AK
2$ 0$ 0$
:$
@$
O@=J= :$ <=FGL=K AF<ANA<M9D 8VK 9>L=JL9P AF;GE= 9L <9L= A
0$ <=FGL=K 8VK 9KK=L
@GD<AF?K AF H=JAG< A
9F<
#
;9HLMJ=K L@= KMJNANGJVK HJ=EAME AEHDA=< :Q L@= H=J>=;L
9FFMALQ E9JC=LK $FALA9D O=9DL@ AK R=JG .M:K=IM=FLDQ
9F AF<ANA<M9D @9K >GMJ HG
L=FLA9D KGMJ;=K G> AF;GE= D9:GJ =9JFAF?K
AFL=J=KL AF;GE=
DMEHKME LJ9FK>=JK 9F<
KG;A9D K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK /@MK
:$ ?$ 0$ #
D$ 7$ A> $ ?$ 0$ #
F +$ A> $ O@=J= $ L9C=K GF L@= N9DM= G> A> AF<ANA<M9D 8 @9K ;@GK=F LG J=;=AN= *$ :=F=SLK
9L LAE= A
9F< GL@=JOAK= $F GL@=J OGJ<K
O@=F=N=J $ L@= AF<ANA<M9D AK
F AEHDA;AL 9KKMEHLAGF =E:G<A=< AF L@= :M<?=L ;GFKLJ9AFL AK L@9L 9 :=F=S;A9JQ ;9FFGL OGJC
A= EHAJA;9DDQ
9JGMF< G> L@= :=F=S;A9JA=K 9?=< <A< FGL OGJC AF !JA=<:=J?
F =IMAN9D=FL 9KKMEHLAGF AK L@9L 9 D9:GJ L9P AK D=NA=< GF :=F=S;A9JA=K L
D=9KL LOG >=9LMJ=K G> J=9DALQ ;9F EGLAN9L= KM;@ 9F 9KKMEHLAGF AF 9<<ALAGF LG >=<=J9D 9F< KL9L=
L9P=K
L@= J=LAJ=E=FL =9JFAF?K L=KL D=NA=K 9 E9J?AF9D L9P GF D9:GJ KMHHDQ GF Q=9J GD<
:=F=S;A9JA=K O@G OGJC
9F< L@= =PAKL=F;= G> L=;@FGDG?A;9D ;GFKLJ9AFLK HJ=N=FLAF? 9 DGO FME:=J
G> @GMJK G> OGJC
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
;GFKA<=J=< J=LAJ=< /@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= G> 9F AF<ANA<M9D :GJF 9L A 8 AK <=SF=<
9K +$ 8 % $ $L OADD := 9KKME=< L@9L L@= J=LAJ=E=FL
<=;AKAGF AK AJJ=N=JKA:D=
A= L@9L $ >GJ 8 +$ $JJ=N=JKA:ADALQ ;GFKA<=J9:DQ
KAEHDAS=K L@= HJG:D=E
/@= KL9L= G> 9F AF<ANA<M9D ;9F := KMEE9JAR=< :Q L@= LMHD= 0 F 8 "AN=F
HJA;=K
HGDA;A=K
LJ9FK>=JK 9F< L@= AFALA9D ;GF<ALAGFK
9 OGJC=JVK N9DM= >MF;LAGF
C$ AK L@= KGDMLAGF LG L@= >GDDGOAF? J=;MJKAN= HJG:D=E
C$ 0 F 8 " B 2 7 0 F 8 C$
0 F 8 @ C$
KM:B=;L LG
2 0 ?$ 0
0 D$ 7 @
8
0 8 %
D$
F F D$ 7
D$
&
7
8 &
9F<
C$' 0 F % E /@= OGJC=JVK HJG:D=E AK KL9F<9J<
=P;=HL >GJ L@= J=LAJ=E=FL <=;AKAGF
9F<
=IM9LAGF IM9LAGF MH<9L=K L@= AF<ANA<M9DVK 9N=J9?= =9JFAF?K AF<=P=<
LG L@= ?JGOL@ J9L= G> O9?=K AF L@= =;GFGEQ
&
&
)GL= L@9L KG;A9D K=;MJALQ AF<AJ=;LDQ
9Z=;L D9:GJ KMHHDQ AF;=FLAN=K
KAF;= 9N=J9?= =9JFAF?K <=L=JEAF=K L@= KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
:=F=SLK J=;=AN=< <MJAF? J=LAJ=E=FL
J=LAJ== KGDN=K L@= >GDDGOAF? J=;MJKAGF
C$ 0 F 8 "
B
2
@
C
0
F
8
$
KM:B=;L LG
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
F + @
2 0 ?$ 0
9F< 9F< +@3/9/43 4, 6:/1/(7/:2
/@AK K=;LAGF <=K;JA:=K L@= ;GF<ALAGFK BGAFLDQ ;@9J9;L=JARAF? L@= KL=9<Q KL9L= G> L@=
=;GFGEQ 9L <9L= A "AN=F AFALA9D ;GF<ALAGFK >GJ <=:L ! L@= <AKLJA:MLAGF G> 9KK=LK 0 HGHMD9LAGF
HGDA;A=K $$ 9F =IMADA:JAME AK
<AKLJA:MLAGF 9F< ?GN=JFE=FL
9F< 9 L9P J9L=
<=SF=< 9K 9 K=IM=F;= D$ ?$ ($ '$ $ !$ 7$ 2$ 0$ $ $
KM;@ L@9L L@= >GDDGOAF? @GD<K
7$ 2$ 0$ $ KGDN=K L@= AF<ANA<M9DKV E9PAEAR9LAGF HJG:D=E
A= 9F< ?AN=F D$ ?$ 9F< ?GN=JFE=FL HGDA;A=K !9;LGJ E9JC=LK ;D=9J
D$ ?$ 5 '$ ($ ($
A 5 '$ ($ '$
A /@= ?GG<K E9JC=L ;D=9JK =N=JQ H=JAG<
5 '$ ($ '$ '$ $$ !
!$ 2!$
A /@= L9P J9L= KGDN=K L@= ?GN=JFE=FLVK >=9KA:ADALQ ;GFKLJ9AFL
! +#.$ $$ -$
$
$
? O@=J= +#.$ AK ?AN=F :Q 9F< -$ :Q /@= E9JC=L >GJ K9NAF?K ;D=9JK
'$ O@=J=
$
!$ 0!$ $
!$
A #! " & #!# # %## #$!&
/9:D= 9DA:J9LAGF
+9J9E=L=J 19DM=
+GHMD9LAGF
%
(GJL9DALQ )#.
4=9J +J=>=J=F;=K /=;@FGDG?Q '/
"GN=JFE=FL $$ /$
-$ /$
!$ /$
'1/(7'9/43
/@= EG<=D AK ;9DA:J9L=< LG ;9HLMJ= >=9LMJ=K G> L@= 0. =;GFGEQ AF L@= Q=9J /@AK K=;LAGF <AK;MKK=K L@= HJG;=<MJ= MK=< LG ;9DA:J9L= L@= EG<=D /9:D= HJGNA<=K
9F GN=JNA=O G> L@= ;9DA:J9LAGF ;@GA;=K /@= =;GFGEQ AK 9KKME=< LG := AF 9 KL=9<Q
KL9L= AF L@= Q=9J +24-7'5./)8
$F<ANA<M9DK 9J= :GJF AFLG L@= =;GFGEQ 9L L@= 9?= G> 9F< <A= >GJ KMJ= 9L
L@= 9?= G> % /@= KMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K 9J= L9C=F >JGE L@= .G;A9D .=;MJALQ
<EAFAKLJ9LAGF 9F< ;GJJ=KHGF< LG L@= ;JGKKK=;LAGF KMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K AF
L@= Q=9J /@= HGHMD9LAGF ?JGOL@ J9L= AK K=L LG ; ;@GK=F LG E9L;@ L@=
J9LAG :=LO==F L@= HGHMD9LAGF 9?=< 9:GN= LG Q=9J GD<K 9L 9JGMF< ..
74*:)9/;/9>
#9FK=FVK E=L@G< >GJ =KLAE9LAF? HJG<M;LANALQ HJGSD=K G> HJAE= 9?= OGJC=JK
AK :Q FGO KL9F<9J< AF L@= DAL=J9LMJ= #GO=N=J
=KLAE9LAF? HJG<M;LANALQ HJGSD=K >GJ
GD<=J OGJC=JK AK ;GFKA<=J9:DQ EGJ= HJG:D=E9LA; !AJKL G> 9DD
<9L9 GF O9?=K 9F< @GMJK
OGJC=< >GJ GD<=J OGJC=JK AK K;9J;= ML EGJ= AEHGJL9FLDQ
K=D>K=D=;LAGF HJG:D=EK 9J=
DAC=DQ LG QA=D< :A9K=< =KLAE9L=K !GJLMF9L=DQ
!J=F;@ @9K ;9J=>MDDQ =KLAE9L=<
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
Productivity profile
1,4
1,2
1
0,8
0,6
0,4
0,2
French (2005)
80
78
76
74
72
70
68
66
64
62
60
58
56
54
52
50
48
46
44
42
40
38
36
34
32
30
28
26
24
22
20
0
CPS (1999)
!A?MJ= +JG<M;LANALQ +JGSD=
HJG<M;LANALQ HJGSD=K 9;;GMFLAF? >GJ K=D=;LAGF :A9K #AK =KLAE9L=K OADD := MK=< @=J=
#GO=N=J
@= GFDQ =KLAE9L=K HJG<M;LANALQ >GJ L@GK= 9?=< 9:GN= !GJ L@AK J=9KGF
9
HJG<M;LANALQ HJGSD= >GJ Q=9J GD<K AK =KLAE9L=< MKAF? <9L9 >JGE =FKMK 9F< 9 E=L@G< J=D9L=< LG #9FK=F GL@ HJGSD=K 9J= <AKHD9Q=< AF !A?MJ= !J=F;@VK HJGSD= AK L@=F MK=< LG?=L@=J OAL@ L@= =KLAE9L= >JGE MJ=9M G> L@=
=FKMK >GJ Q=9J GD<K /@AK HJG<M;LANALQ HJGSD= AK 9KKME=< LG := LAE=
AFN9JA9FL
$+).3414-> '3* %9/1/9> ,:3)9/43
+J=>=J=F;=K 9J= KL9F<9J< >JGE L@= EA;JG=;GFGEA; DAL=J9LMJ= GF D9:GJ KMHHDQ /@=
AFKL9FL9F=GMK MLADALQ G> 9F 9?=FL AK 9<<ALAN=DQ K=H9J9:D= AF ;GFKMEHLAGF 9F< D=AKMJ=
B 2$ 7$ 2
7$ $
/@AK >MF;LAGF9D >GJE @9K L@= 9LLJ9;LAN= HJGH=JLQ L@9L :GL@ @GMJK OGJC=< 9F< L@=
=D9KLA;ALQ G> D9:GJ KMHHDQ ;9F := ;9DA:J9L=< AF 9;;GJ<9F;= OAL@ =EHAJA;9D =KLAE9L=K
/@= H9J9E=L=JK LG?=L@=J AEHDQ L@9L 9 L@= 9N=J9?= D9:GJ KMHHDQ
>GJ Q=9J GD<K AK @GMJKO==C
A= L@= K9E= 9K L@= 9N=J9?= @GMJK OGJC=< AF
Q=9J >GJ L@= 0. HGHMD9LAGF 0. MJ=9M G> L@= =FKMK 9F< : L@9L
L@= AEHDA=< !JAK;@ =D9KLA;ALQ AK /@AK AK ;DGK= LG L@= !JAK;@ =D9KLA;ALQ G> =KLAE9L=< :Q #=9L@;GL= =L 9D /@= ;G=Y;A=FL G> J=D9LAN= JAKC 9N=JKAGF AK K=L
9L #! " & #!# # %## #$!&
/@= HJG<M;LAGF L=;@FGDG?Q AK 9 KL9F<9J< G::GM?D9K
'$ (
O@=J= ;9HAL9DVK
$
K@9J= AK 9KKME=< LG := 0KAF? =KLAE9L=K >JGE +J=K;GLL L@= L9J?=L
>GJ L@= ;9HAL9DGMLHML J9LAG AK K=L 9L (;"J9LL9F 9F< +J=K;GLL ;GEHML=
9F AFL=J=KL J9L= F=L G> L9P=K G> /@=K= L9J?=LK 9J= 9;@A=N=< AF L@AK EG<=D :Q
K=LLAF? 9F< L@= <=HJ=;A9LAGF J9L= 4;+732+39
"GN=JFE=FL ;GFKMEHLAGF
$$ AK 9KKME=< LG := G> ")+ AF L@= AFALA9D KL=9<Q
KL9L=
L@= K9E= 9K AF DD OGJC=JK 9J= 9KKME=< LG := =FJGDD=< AF KG;A9D K=;MJALQ .G;A9D K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK
9J= 9 >MF;LAGF G> HJ=NAGMK =9JFAF?K 9F< L@= 9?= G> J=LAJ=E=FL
F + O@=J= F D$ 7 4 9J= L@= 9N=J9?= =9JFAF?K GN=J L@= SJKL Q=9JK G> OGJCAF? DA>=
0HGF J=LAJ=E=FL 9L L@= !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= !-
:=F=SLK 9J= HJGNA<=< 9K 9 T9L
J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= GF 9N=J9?= =9JFAF?K
F /@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= AK :9K=<
GF <9L9 >JGE L@= .G;A9D .=;MJALQ <EAFAKLJ9LAGF /@= .. @9N= ;GEHML=<
J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=K >GJ @QHGL@=LA;9D 9N=J9?= OGJC=JK >GJ N9JAGMK Q=9JK
/@= !MDD
-=LAJ=E=FL ?= !- AK K=L 9L #GO=N=J
OGJC=JK 9J= =DA?A:D= >GJ KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
:=F=SLK 9L J=<M;=< J9L=K >JGE L@= 9?= G> =F=SLK 9J= J=<M;=< :Q >GJ
=9;@ Q=9J :=>GJ= !- L@9L L@= AF<ANA<M9D ;@GGK=K LG J=LAJ= J=<M;LAGF >GJ =9JDQ
J=LAJ=E=FL
- - (GJ=GN=J
A> 9 OGJC=J ;@GGK=K LG <=D9Q J=LAJ=E=FL :=QGF< L@= 9?=
G> K@= OADD ?=L 9 <=D9Q=< J=LAJ=E=FL ;J=<AL - G> H=J Q=9J MFLAD L@= 9?=
G> /@AK AEHDA=K L@9L L@= EGFL@DQ KG;A9D K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK J=;=AN=< :Q 9 J=LAJ==
9J= $L AK AEHGJL9FL LG EG<=D L@= -- - LG ?=L AFL=JF9D KGDMLAGFK >GJ L@=
J=LAJ=E=FL HJG:D=E 2AL@GML -- -
AF<ANA<M9DK J=LAJ= 9L L@= 9?= G> L@=
=9JDA=KL =DA?A:ADALQ 9?= /@= ;9DA:J9LAGF AEHDA=K L@9L KG;A9D K=;MJALQ LJ9FK>=JK KL9F<
9L G> ")+ AF L@= Q=9J =;GFGEQ
;;GJ<AF? LG L@= <9L9
LGL9D FGFKG;A9D K=;MJALQ LJ9FK>=JK KLGG< 9L G> ")+
AF L@= Q=9J $L OADD := 9KKME=< L@9L L@=K= 9J= =N=FDQ <AKLJA:ML=< 9;JGKK 9DD
AF<ANA<M9DK 9K DMEHKME LJ9FK>=JK
GEHML=< 9K ;GFKMEHLAGF =PH=F<ALMJ=K D=KK ;MJJ=FL LJ9FK>=J J=;=AHLK HJAE9JADQ SF=K
>==K 9F<
<GF9LAGFK /@AK KH=;AS;9LAGF AK ;@GK=F :=;9MK= AL E9C=K L@= KM:K=IM=FL ;9DA:J9LAGFK G> J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=K
KLJ9A?@L>GJO9J<
/@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=K 9J= :9K=< GF L@= +JAE9JQ $FKMJ9F;= EGMFLK G> @QHGL@=LA;9D OGJC=JK
O@G J=LAJ=< 9L L@= !- 9>L=J >MDDLAE= ;9J==JK OAL@ KL=9<Q =9JFAF?K =IM9D LG 9N=J9?= =9JFAF?K AF
L@= =;GFGEQ
/@= 9N=J9?= *$ :=F=SL >GJ 9 F=ODQ J=LAJ=< AF<ANA<M9D O9K AF .. #! " & #!# # %## #$!&
/@= AFALA9D <=:L AK K=L 9L G> ")+
=IM9D LG L@= F=L SF9F;A9D DA9:ADALA=K G>
L@= 0. ?GN=JFE=FL 9L L@= =F< G> * /@= H9QJGDD L9P
AK K=L LG =IM9D LG L@= 9;LM9D ;GE:AF=< E=<A;9J= 9F<
*.$ H9QJGDD L9P =EHDGQ=J 9F< =EHDGQ==
/@= ?GN=JFE=FL K=LK L9P=K LG :9D9F;= ALK :M<?=L ;GFKLJ9AFL "AN=F =PH=F<ALMJ=K
GL@=J L9P HGDA;A=K 9F< AFALA9D <=:L
L@= AEHDA=< L9P J9L= AK L@=F 9F< L@=
9KKG;A9L=< L9P J=N=FM= AK H=J;=FL G> GMLHML
$.+ =5+7/2+39
$F L@= HJ=NAGMK K=;LAGF
L@= =;GFGEQ O9K ;9DA:J9L=< LG ;9HLMJ= >=9LMJ=K G> L@= 0.
=;GFGEQ >GJ L@= Q=9J $F L@AK K=;LAGF
O= OADD KLM<Q L@= @AKLGJA;9D LJ=F<K AF SK;9D
HGDA;Q 9F< L@=AJ =Z=;LK GF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ /@= EG<=D OADD := JMF >GJ L@= H=JAG<
GFDQ ;@9F?AF? HGDA;A=K 9F< KMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K /@MK
9DD HJ=>=J=F;=
9F< L=;@FGDG?Q H9J9E=L=JK 9J= @=D< ;GFKL9FL >GJ L@AK =PH=JAE=FL !GJ ;D9JALQ O=
;GFKA<=J KL=9<Q KL9L=K F =PL=FKAGF OAL@ LJ9FKALAGF9D <QF9EA;K AK ;GFKA<=J=< AF
KM:K=;LAGF !GJ K=N=F <=;9<=K <MJAF? L@= LO=FLA=L@ ;=FLMJQ
KL=9<Q KL9L=K 9J=
;GEHML=< EAFAEME G> G:K=JN9:D= ?GN=JFE=FL HGDA;Q N9JA9:D=K OADD := ;@9F?=<
$F H9JLA;MD9J
O= OADD N9JQ L@= ?GN=JFE=FLVK <=:LLGGMLHML J9LAG
L@= ?GN=JFE=FLVK
;GFKMEHLAGF KH=F<AF?
9F< LJ9FK>=JK
AF;DM<AF? KGE= >=9LMJ=K G> L@= KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
KQKL=E !AF9DDQ
L@= EGJL9DALQ J9L=K OADD := ;@9F?=< AF 9;;GJ<9F;= OAL@ L@= <9L9
.=;LAGF =PHD9AFK L@= @AKLGJA;9D <=N=DGHE=FLK G> J=D=N9F;= >GJ L@= =PH=JAE=FLK
9F< L@= AEHD=E=FL9LAGF
O@AD= K=;LAGF <AK;MKK=K L@= J=KMDLK
$7+3*8 /3 /8)'1
41/)>
/@= LO=FLA=L@ ;=FLMJQ O9K ;@9J9;L=JAR=< :Q L@= JAK= G> ?GN=JFE=FL AF L@= 0FAL=<
.L9L=K 9F< E9FQ GL@=J 2=KL=JF ;GMFLJA=K 29DDAK >GJ AFKL9F;=
=KLAE9L= L@9L
0. ?GN=JFE=FL J=N=FM= DG;9D
KL9L= 9F< F9LAGF9D AF;J=9K=< >JGE G> ")+ AF
LG 9L L@= LMJF G> L@= FAF=L==FL@ ;=FLMJQ
9F< JGK= LG AF /@=
?JGOL@ J9L= G> ?GN=JFE=FL J=N=FM= 9F< KH=F<AF? O9K H9JLA;MD9JDQ @A?@ <MJAF? L@=
SJKL @9D> G> L@= LO=FLA=L@ ;=FLMJQ
9JGMF< H=J;=FL H=J Q=9J =LO==F 9F<
L@= ?JGOL@ J9L= O9K H=J Q=9J
/@= 9N=J9?= L9P J=N=FM= O9K H=J;=FL G> ")+ /@AK AK ;GEHML=<
9K ;MJJ=FL L9P J=;=AHLK HDMK ;GFLJA:MLAGFK >GJ ?GN=JFE=FL KG;A9D AFKMJ9F;= D=KK L9P=K >JGE L@= J=KL
G> OGJD< $F L@= L9P J=N=FM=K KLGG< 9L H=J;=FL G> ")+ 9F< L@= KMJHDMK O9K H=J;=FL
G> ")+
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
/9:D= "GN=JFE=FL PH=F<ALMJ=K 9F< =:L
+=J;=FL
"/
$/
- /
.GMJ;=K =:L * -+
"4/4 )GL= /@= S?MJ= >GJ /4 9F< "4 AK K=L 9K @9D> L@= N9DM=
29DDAK <G;ME=FLK L@9L LGL9D ?GN=JFE=FL =PH=F<ALMJ=K <GM:D=<
:=LO==F 9F< +(9 '3* 4;+732+39 =5+3*/9:7+8
$L OADD := 9KKME=< L@9L L@= SK;9D <=N=DGHE=FLK
GL@=J L@9F KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
;9F :=
9<=IM9L=DQ KMEE9JAR=< :Q ;@9F?=K AF ?GN=JFE=FL ;GFKMEHLAGF
DMEHKME LJ9FK>=JK
9F< <=:L HGDA;Q /9:D= <AKHD9QK L@= @AKLGJA;9D E=9KMJ=K L@9L OADD := MK=< AF L@=
KM:K=IM=FL ;9DA:J9LAGF =P=J;AK=
$F ?=F=J9D
L@=J= O9K 9F AF;J=9KAF? LJ=F< AF ?GN=JFE=FL LJ9FK>=JK 9F< ?GN=JF
E=FL ;GFKMEHLAGF :=LO==F 9F< >L=J =PH=F<ALMJ=K KL9:ADAR=< 9F<
=N=F <JGHH=< KGE=O@9L LGO9J<K L@= =F< G> L@= ;=FLMJQ /@= <=:LLGGMLHML J9LAG
AF;J=9K=< :=LO==F 9F< HJAE9JADQ <M= LG L@= OGJD< O9JK =LO==F 22$$
9F< L@= K
L@= <=:LLGGMLHML J9LAG <=;DAF=<
:ML GF;= EGJ= JGK= LG 9JGMF< G> ")+ 9L L@= =F< G> L@= ;=FLMJQ
$F L@= ;9DA:J9LAGF
L@=K= S?MJ=K OADD := E9L;@=< =P9;LDQ
9F< L@= ?=F=J9D L9P J9L=
OADD := =F<G?=FGMKDQ <=L=JEAF=< LG K9LAK>Q L@= ?GN=JFE=FLVK :M<?=L ;GFKLJ9AFL
#4)/'1 #+):7/9>
DL@GM?@ L@= K==<K O=J= KGOF >GJ L@= 0FAL=< .L9L=K KG;A9D K=;MJALQ KQKL=E :Q L@=
.G;A9D .=;MJALQ ;L G> AL LGGC <=;9<=K >GJ L@= KQKL=E LG E9LMJ= =DGO
L@=
=NGDMLAGF G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ OADD := <=K;JA:=< AF KGE= <=L9AD
$F L@= EG<=D
AL OADD := 9KKME=< L@9L L@= @AKLGJA;9D =NGDMLAGF G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ ;9F
:= <=K;JA:=< :Q KAP H9J9E=L=JK /@=K= 9J= N9JA9:D=K L@9L L@= EA;JG=;GEA; DAL=J9LMJ=
@9K A<=FLAS=< 9K :=AF? HGL=FLA9DDQ AEHGJL9FL >GJ L@= J=LAJ=E=FL <=;AKAGF H9QJGDD L9P
=DA?A:ADALQ 9?=K !-
-
HJ=EAME LGHMFAK@E=FL >GJ <=D9QAF?:JAF?AF?
>GJO9J< J=LAJ=E=FL -- - 9F< J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= /9:D= :=DGO <AKHD9QK
L@= H9J9E=L=J N9DM=K >GJ KG;A9D K=;MJALQ /@= H9J9E=L=J ;@GA;=K OADD := >MJL@=J
EGLAN9L=< :=DGO
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
/9:D= .G;A9D .=;MJALQ KKMEHLAGFK
- - - -
!-
FGF=
FGF=
FGF=
FGF=
FGF=
FGF=
FGF=
FGF=
.GMJ;=K ..
..
'3* /@= 0. .G;A9D .=;MJALQ KQKL=E O9K D9MF;@=< AF #GO=N=J
<MJAF? L@= SJKL L=F Q=9JK
:=F=SLK O=J= N=JQ MF;=JL9AF 9F< L@= =DA?A:ADALQ JMD=K O=J=
J=KLJA;LAN= !AJKL
:=F=SLK @9< :==F SP=< 9L L@=AJ D=N=D
AF 9F =FNAJGFE=FL
O@=J= L@= 9N=J9?= AFT9LAGF J9L= O9K 9:GML 9 Q=9J L@= KL9F<9J< <=NA9LAGF O9K
'. K 9 J=KMDL
L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=
;GEHML=< 9K L@= J9LAG :=LO==F
:=F=SLK 9F< L@= 9N=J9?= =9JFAF?K AF L@= =;GFGEQ
<=;J=9K=< >JGE 9JGMF< AF
LG GFDQ AF .=;GF<
GFDQ OGJC=JK AF AF<MKLJQ 9F< ;GEE=J;= O=J= ;GN=J=< MF<=J L@= KQKL=E
/@MK
9L EGKL G> L@= ;G@GJL L@9L OGMD< J=9;@ L@= =DA?A:ADALQ 9?= AF @9< OGJC=< AF ;GN=J=< =EHDGQE=FL <MJAF? L@= K (GJ=GN=J
9 EAFAEME G>
OGJC =ZGJL 9F< AF;GE= O9K J=IMAJ=< LG :=;GE= =DA?A:D= /@=J=>GJ=
;9F :=
;GFKA<=J=< 9F MHH=J :GMF< >GJ L@= >J9;LAGF G> =DA?A:D= AF L@= ;G@GJL
!GJ L@=K= J=9KGFK
AL OADD := 9KKME=< L@9L L@=J= O=J= FG KG;A9D K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK
9N9AD9:D= AF 9F< /@AK ;9F := ;GFKA<=J=< 9 ;GFK=JN9LAN= ;@GA;=
KAF;= 9DD
;@9F?=K AF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ <MJAF? L@AK H=JAG< EMKL := <JAN=F :Q GL@=J HGDA;A=K
/@= H9QJGDD L9P
GF L@= GL@=J @9F<
OADD := 9KKME=< LG := AF 9F< AF
9K AF L@= <9L9
$L O9K GFDQ <MJAF? L@= K L@9L KG;A9D K=;MJALQ =PH9F<=< /@= E=F<
E=FLK KA?FAS;9FLDQ AF;J=9K=< L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= 9F< E9<= KG;A9D K=;MJALQ 9N9AD9:D=
LG 9 D9J?=J K@9J= G> L@= HGHMD9LAGF K 9 J=KMDL
L@= >J9;LAGF G> AFKMJ=< AF L@= HGHMD9
LAGF AF;J=9K=< LG AF $F L@= K9E= Q=9J L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= O9K /@=
/@AK AK ;GEHML=< 9K >GDDGOK $F 67
L@= FME:=J G> 67 Q=9J GD<K OGJCAF? AF
;GN=J=< =EHDGQE=FL O9K 6
7
O@AD= L@= HGHMD9LAGF AF L@= K9E= 9?= ?JGMH O9K
6
7 ..
#GHHK 9F< .LGGHK /@MK
G> L@= HGHMD9LAGF
O=J= OGJCAF? AF ;GN=J=< =EHDGQE=FL <MJAF? L@= K
/G := =DA?A:D= >GJ *$ :=F=SLK
9 OGJC=J O9K J=IMAJ=< LG @9N= OGJC=< AF ;GN=J=< =EHDGQE=FL
9L D=9KL GF=@9D> G> L@= IM9JL=JK =D9HK=< :=LO==F 9F< @=J L@ :AJL@<9Q
=9JFAF? EGJ= L@9F
H=J IM9JL=J L@= E=<A9F 9FFM9D O9?= AF ;GN=J=< =EHDGQE=FL O9K AF =IMAN9D=FL LG
H=J IM9JL=J
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=K J=HGJL=< AF L9:D= 9J= >GJ 9 @QHGL@=LA;9D OGJC=J OAL@ 9N=J9?=
=9JFAF?K
$F L@= =9JDQ J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= - 9F< L@= >MDD J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= !-
;GAF;A<=< 9L L@= 9?= G> 9F< L@=J= O9K FG <=D9Q=< J=LAJ=E=FL ;J=<AL - GJ
J=<M;LAGF >GJ =9JDQ J=LAJ=E=FL - -
Q L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= KLGG< 9L (GJ=GN=J
- @9< :==F
J=<M;=< LG L@= 9?= G> AF 9F< L@= - - 9F< - KLGG< 9L 9F< J=KH=;LAN=DQ
/@= Q=9JK :=LO==F 9F< O=J= 9 H=JAG< G> ;GFKGDA<9LAGF >GJ L@=
KG;A9D K=;MJALQ KQKL=E M= LG GN=JAF<=P9LAGF G> :=F=SLK
L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= O9K
@A?@ AF 9L - JGK= LG AF '3* DL@GM?@ 9 FME:=J G> AEHGJL9FL J=>GJEK O=J= AFLJG<M;=< <MJAF?
L@= K 9F< K
EGKL G> L@=K= O=J= AFL=F<=< LG 9Z=;L ;G@GJLK J=LAJAF? 9>L=J L@=
Q=9J G> /@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=K KL9:ADAR=< 9L 9JGMF< (GJ=GN=J
-
;@9F?=< X LG AF 9F< AF 479'1/9> 7'9+8
/@= EGJL9DALQ J9L=K 9DKG ;@9F?=< <J9E9LA;9DDQ <MJAF? L@AK H=JAG<
O@A;@ OADD :=
AEHGJL9FL >GJ LOG J=9KGFK !AJKL
L@AK ;@9F?=K L@= <=EG?J9H@A; ;GEHGKALAGF G>
L@= HGHMD9LAGF K LAE= H9KK=K 9 D9J?=J >J9;LAGF G> L@= HGHMD9LAGF OADD := GD<=J
9F< @9N= @A?@=J K9NAF?K /@AK 9Z=;LK L@= AFL=J=KL J9L= 9F< L@=J=>GJ= J=LAJ=E=FL
.=;GF<
EGJL9DALQ <AJ=;LDQ 9Z=;LK L@= AF<ANA<M9DVK J=LAJ=E=FL ;@GA;= #A?@=J KMJNAN9D
HJG:9:ADALQ J=<M;=K L@= J=LMJF LG 9FFMALA=K 9 F=?9LAN= O=9DL@ =Z=;L O@A;@ L=F<K LG
<=D9Q J=LAJ=E=FL
$L OADD := 9KKME=< L@9L L@= <=EG?J9H@A; <=N=DGHE=FLK ;9F := <=K;JA:=< :Q L@=
;JGKKK=;LAGF9D EGJL9DALQ J9L=K >GJ L@= J=KH=;LAN= Q=9JK /@MK
DA>= =PH=;L9F;Q 9L
:AJL@ AF;J=9K=K >JGE AF LG AF 9F< AF L@= Q=9J (GJL9DALQ
J9L=K 9J= <AJ=;LDQ J=D9L=< LG L@= GD<9?= <=H=F<=F;Q J9LAG
;GEHML=< 9K L@= FME:=J
G> LG L@= Q=9J GD<K AF L@= HGHMD9LAGF $F L@= EG<=D
L@AK J9LAG AF;J=9K=K
>JGE AF LG AF Q=9J #! " & #!# # %## #$!&
/9:D= .=D=;L=< .L9LAKLA;K >JGE L@= (G<=D ;GFGEA=K
+
? $ D
'/
"+8:198
/9:D= <AKHD9QK K=D=;L=< J=KMDLK >JGE L@= EG<=D =;GFGEA=K /@= JAK= AF ?GN=JF
E=FL J=KMDLK AF AF;J=9KAF? L9P J9L=K
=KH=;A9DDQ <MJAF? L@= SJKL @9D> G> L@= ;=FLMJQ
(GJ=GN=J
L@= J9<A;9D ;@9F?= AF <=:L HGDA;Q 9F< L@= JAK= AF ;9HAL9D L9P9LAGF ;JGO<
GML ;9HAL9D
O@A;@ AEHDA=K L@9L L@= ;9HAL9DLGGMLHML J9LAG <=;DAF=K >JGE AF LG AF 9F< L@= AFL=J=KL J9L=K JAK= >JGE LG AF "+9/7+2+39 +.';/47
/9:D= J=HGJLK L@= GHLAE9D J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= >GJ AF<ANA<M9DK AF L@= KL=9<Q KL9L=K
.AF;= L@= EG<=D AK K=L AF GF=Q=9J H=JAG<K
;M:A; KHDAF=K @9N= :==F MK=< LG ?=F=J9L=
9 ;GFLAFMGMK E=9KMJ= G> J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= )GLA;= L@9L L@= EG<=D <G=K 9 J=9KGF9:DQ
?GG< BG: AF LJ9;CAF? L@= 9N=J9?= J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ KAF;= L@= :=?AFFAF? G> L@=
LO=FLA=L@ ;=FLMJQ /@AK ;9F 9DKG := N=JAS=< AF !A?MJ= $F L@= EG<=D HJ=<A;LK
9 J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= G> O@AD= AF L@= =;GFGEQ L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= <=;DAF=K LG
0HGF AFLJG<M;AF? KG;A9D K=;MJALQ AF L@= =;GFGEQ
L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= <JGHK
K@9JHDQ LG >L=J L@= =9JDQ =DA?A:ADALQ 9?= AK J=<M;=< LG >JGE 9F< GFO9J<
L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= KL9:ADAR=K 9L 9JGMF< -=D9LAN= LG L@= E=9KMJ= ;GEHML=< AF
K=;LAGF L@= EG<=D GN=J=KLAE9L=K L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= :=>GJ= 22$$ 9F< 9>L=J /@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= AK ?JGKKDQ MF<=J=KLAE9L=< AF L@= Q=9J =;GFGEQ
2@9L ;9F 9;;GMFL >GJ L@= LJ=F<K AF J=LAJ=E=FL 9;;GJ<AF? LG L@= EG<=D !JGE
L@= NA=OHGAFL G> L@= AF<ANA<M9D
KAP G:B=;LK ;@9F?= :=LO==F L@= KL=9<Q KL9L=K L@=
AFL=J=KL J9L=
L@= O9?= J9L=
L@= LOG L9P J9L=K
L@= KMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K 9F< L@=
KG;A9D K=;MJALQ KQKL=E /9:D= <=;GEHGK=K L@= ;@9F?= AF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= AFLG
L@=K= KAP KGMJ;=K G> ;@9F?= /@= L9:D= AK ;GFKLJM;L=< :Q ;@9F?AF? HJA;=K
HGDA;A=K GJ
EGJL9DALQ J9L=K GF= 9L 9 LAE=
9F< ;GEHMLAF? L@= GHLAE9D J=LAJ=E=FL J=KHGFK= !GJ
AFKL9F;=
9L L@= HJA;=K
HGDA;A=K 9F< KMJNAN9D J9L=K HJ=N9ADAF? AF L@= GHLAE9D
J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= AK GDMEF $$ G> L9:D= K@GOK L@9L AF;J=9KAF? L@= AFL=J=KL J9L=
/@= E=L@G< AFL=JHGD9L=K :=LO==F L@= N9DM= >MF;LAGFK 9L <AZ=J=FL AFL=?=J J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=K
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
80
78
U.S. Median Retirement Age
76
Model with Medicare
74
Baseline Model
72
70
Transitional Analysis
68
66
64
62
1900
1910
1920
1930
1940
1950
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
!A?MJ= /@= NGDMLAGF G> -=LAJ=E=FL
(G<=D 9F< 9L9
>JGE AF LG AF $&4&2*3 0"2*#53 AEHDA=K 9 SN=Q=9J J=<M;LAGF AF
L@= GHLAE9D J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= >JGE LG *F L@= GL@=J @9F<
L@= AF;J=9K= AF
L@= ?=F=J9D L9P J9L= >JGE LG $&4&2*3 0"2*#53 <=D9QK J=LAJ=E=FL :Q SN=
Q=9JK >JGE LG $L EMKL := =EH@9KAR=< L@9L L@= H9JLA9D =Z=;LK AF ?=F=J9D <G
FGL 9<< MH LG L@= LGL9D =Z=;L
KAF;= J=LAJ=E=FL J=KHGFK=K 9J= FGFK=H9J9:D= >MF;LAGFK
G> L@= G:B=;LK
/9:D= AK N=JQ MK=>MD >GJ AFL=JHJ=LAF? L@= <=N=DGHE=FLK AF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ
GN=J L@= LO=FLA=L@ ;=FLMJQ ;;GJ<AF? LG L@= EG<=D
L@= J=<M;LAGF AF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL
9?= :=LO==F 9F< O9K <JAN=F :Q L@= <J9E9LA; ;@9F?= AF ?GN=JFE=FL <=:L
HGDA;Q 9F< L@= AF;J=9K= AF ;9HAL9D L9P9LAGF GL@ HGDA;A=K ;JGO<=< GML ;9HAL9D J=
KMDLAF? AF @A?@=J AFL=J=KL J9L=K
9 HGKALAN= O=9DL@ =Z=;L
L@=J=:Q E9CAF? J=LAJ=E=FL
EGJ= 9LLJ9;LAN= #GO=N=J
L@=J= O=J= 9DKG >GJ;=K AF L@= GHHGKAL= <AJ=;LAGF !AJKL
L@= AF;J=9K= AF HJGNA<=< AF;=FLAN=K LG <=D9Q J=LAJ=E=FL
KAF;= 9 L@= L9P AK H9JLDQ
D=NA=< GF ;9HAL9D
KG L@9L 9F AF;J=9K= =Z=;LAN=DQ J=<M;=K L@= F=L J=LMJF LG K9NAF?K
9F< : L@= AF;GE= =Z=;L <GEAF9L=K KG L@9L L@= AF;J=9K= AF D9:GJ L9P9
LAGF J=<M;=K L@= <=E9F< >GJ D=AKMJ=
AF;DM<AF? J=LAJ=E=FL .=;GF<
L@= AF;J=9K= AF
KMJNAN9D J9L=K AEHDA=< L@9L L@= J=LMJF LG 9FFMALA=K <=;J=9K=<
O@A;@ 9DKG E9<= J=LAJ=
E=FL D=KK 9LLJ9;LAN= #GO=N=J
L@= AFL=J=KL J9L= =Z=;L <GEAF9L=<
9F< AF<ANA<M9DK
:JGM?@L >GJO9J< J=LAJ=E=FL :Q GF= Q=9J 9F< L@J== EGFL@K
LG J=LAJ= 9L L@= 9?= G> /@= KME G> L@= =Z=;LK <G FGL F=;=KK9JA9DDQ 9<< LG L@= LGL9D
/9:D= /@= .GMJ;=K G> @9F?= AF -=LAJ=E=FL )G G> 4=9JK -=D9LAN= LG 9K= 4=9J
$
?
D
@
,,
/GL9D
)GL= /@= ;@9F?= AK ;GEHML=< 9K +$ +$ KG L@9L HGKALAN= FME:=JK AEHDQ 9 <=D9Q AF J=LAJ=E=FL
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
2@=F KG;A9D K=;MJALQ AK AFLJG<M;=< AFLG L@= EG<=D AF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=
<JGHK K@9JHDQ LG GDMEF $$$ AF L9:D= K@GOK L@9L
AF<==<
L@= ;@9F?= O9K
<JAN=F :Q L@= AFLJG<M;LAGF G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ SJKL
:=;9MK= L@= AFLJG<M;LAGF G> KG;A9D
K=;MJALQ AF ALK=D> HJGNA<=< KLJGF? SF9F;A9D AF;=FLAN=K LG J=LAJ= 9F< K=;GF<
:=;9MK=
KG;A9D K=;MJALQ J=<M;=< L@= AF;=FLAN=K LG K9N=
L@=J=:Q ;JGO<AF? GML ;9HAL9D /@AK
J=KMDL=< AF @A?@=J AFL=J=KL J9L=K 9F< L@=J=>GJ=
=9JDA=J J=LAJ=E=FL #GO=N=J
L@=K=
=Z=;LK O=J= EALA?9L=< :Q L@= AF;J=9K= AF L9P=K
$F L@= =;GFGEQ
L@= =9JDQ =DA?A:ADALQ 9?= O9K J=<M;=< LG 9F< -- O=J= AFLJG<M;=< /@= ;GE:AF=< =Z=;L J=<M;=< L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= :Q F=9JDQ LOG
9<<ALAGF9D Q=9JK
$F L@= =;GFGEQ
L@= @A?@ J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= 9DKG HJGNA<=< AF;=FLAN=K LG J=LAJ=
=9JDA=J $F 9<<ALAGF
9F AF;J=9K= AF L@= AFL=J=KL J9L= ;J=9L=< :Q 9F AF;J=9K= AF ;9HAL9D
L9P9LAGF 9F< :Q ;JGO<AF? GML G> K9NAF?K <M= LG L@= @A?@ J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=
J=KMDL=<
AF 9 J=<M;LAGF AF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= LG /@= SF<AF?K >GJ L@= ;@9F?=K AF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ :=LO==F 9F< 9J=
KGE=O@9L HMRRDAF? 9L SJKL ;;GJ<AF? LG GDMEF 1$ G> L9:D= L@= ;@9F?=K
AF HJA;=K GFDQ @9N= 9 E9J?AF9D AEH9;L GF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ
AF<A;9LAF? L@9L L@=
J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= OGMD< ;@9F?= :Q 9L EGKL EGFL@K 4=L
L@= ;GE:AF=< =Z=;L O9K 9
<=D9Q AF J=LAJ=E=FL G> GF= 9F< 9 @9D> Q=9JK /@= =PHD9F9LAGF ;9F := 9HHJ=;A9L=< :Q
HDGLLAF? L@= N9DM= >MF;LAGFK >GJ J=LAJ=E=FL 9L <AZ=J=FL 9?=K K== !A?MJ= )GLA;=
L@9L L@= N9DM= >MF;LAGF AK F=9JDQ T9L :=LO==F L@= 9?=K 9F< EG<=D 9?= 9F< /@MK
L@= AF<ANA<M9D AK 9DEGKL AF<AZ=J=FL :=LO==F J=LAJAF? 9L L@= 9?= G> GJ 9L L@= 9?= G> /@AK 9DKG AEHDA=K
L@9L J=D9LAN=DQ KE9DD ;@9F?=K AF HJA;=KHGDA;A=K
;9F ;9MK= D9J?= J=LAJ=E=FL J=KHGFK=K $F L@= =;GFGEQ
L@= H9JLA9D ;@9F?=K AF
HJA;=KHGDA;A=K O=J= FGL KMY;A=FL LG ?=F=J9L= D9J?= J=KHGFK=K AF J=LAJ=E=FL
O@AD=
L@=AJ ;GE:AF=< =Z=;L O9K
/@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= @9J<DQ ;@9F?=K :=LO==F L@= =;GFGEQ 9F< L@= Q=9J =;GFGEQ 2@AD= L@= DGO=J ?=F=J9D L9P J9L= 9F< L@= J=<M;LAGF AF L@= J=HD9;=E=FL
J9L= HJGNA<=< AF;=FLAN=K LG J=LAJ= =9JDA=J
L@AK O9K ;GMFL=J9;L=< :Q L@= AF;J=9K= AF
AFL=J=KL J9L=K 9F< KMJNAN9D J9L=K
/9:D= ;GFKA<=JK L@= ;@9F?= :=LO==F L@= =9JDQ LO=FLA=L@ ;=FLMJQ 9F< Q=9J
/@= L9:D= ;D=9JDQ KM??=KLK L@9L KG;A9D K=;MJALQ O9K 9 E9AF <JANAF? >GJ;= AF L@=
=NGDMLAGF G> J=LAJ=E=FL KAF;= +JAE9JADQ <M= LG KG;A9D K=;MJALQ AF;=FLAN=K
:ML
9DKG :=;9MK= KG;A9D K=;MJALQ ;JGO<=< GML K9NAF?K 9F< AF;J=9K=< AFL=J=KL J9L=K /@=
L9:D= 9DKG KM??=KLK L@9L L@= <JGH AF J=LAJ=E=FL :=LO==F 9F< O9K <M= LG
L@= AF;J=9K= AF AFL=J=KL J9L=K /@= AF;J=9K= AF AFL=J=KL J9L=K O9K HJAE9JADQ ;9MK=< :Q
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
-348.5
Approximation
-349
Utility
Value function
at integer ages
-349.5
-350
-350.5
-351
41
42
43
44
45
Model Age
46
47
48
49
!A?MJ= 19DM= >MF;LAGF 9L <AZ=J=FL J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=K
-=9D ?= (G<=D ?=
;GFGEQ
L@= <J9E9LA; AF;J=9K= AF ?GN=JFE=FL <=:L >JGE G> ")+ AF LG AF /9:D= .GMJ;=K G> @9F?= AF -=LAJ=E=FL )G G> 4=9JK
? $
D
@
,,
/GL9D
.== FGL= >GJ /9:D= '(47 #:551>
$L AK 9DKG AFL=J=KLAF? LG DGGC 9L L@= =NGDMLAGF G> D9:GJ KMHHDQ GN=J L@= DA>= ;Q;D= AF
L@= LO=FLA=L@ ;=FLMJQ !A?MJ= <=HA;LK HJGSD=K G> DA>= ;Q;D= @GMJK OGJC=< >GJ L@=
<AZ=J=FL KL=9<Q KL9L=K K L@= ;=FLMJQ H9KK=K
L@= HJGSD= G> DA>= ;Q;D= D9:GJ KMHHDQ
K@A>LK ;DG;COAK= K H=GHD= =FL=J =9JDA=J AFLG J=LAJ=E=FL
L@=Q 9DKG L=F< LG OGJC
EGJ= <MJAF? L@=AJ OGJC DA>=
:GL@ <M= LG AFL=JL=EHGJ9D KM:KLALMLAGF G> D=AKMJ= >JGE
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
0.4
1900
1930
1950
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
0.35
Hours Worked (Weekly)
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
20
30
40
50
Age
60
70
80
!A?MJ= 2==CDQ #GMJK 2GJC=<
HJAE=9?= LG GD< 9?=
9F< LG AF;J=9K=K AF L9P=K GF D9:GJ O@A;@ <JAN= MH L@= @GMJK
OGJC=<
$L AK AFL=J=KLAF? LG ;GEH9J= L@AK S?MJ= OAL@ L@= HJGSD=K G> @GMJK OGJC=< ;GF
KLJM;L=< :Q (;"J9LL9F 9F< -G?=JKKGF K== !A?MJ= (;"J9LL9F 9F<
-G?=JKKGF ;GFKLJM;L HJGSD=K G> @GMJK OGJC=< >GJ ;G@GJLK :GJF LG AF L@=
0FAL=< .L9L=K /@= H9LL=JF G> D9:GJ KMHHDQ K@A>LK ;DG;COAK= 9K AF L@= EG<=D ,M9F
LAL9LAN=DQ
L@= EG<=D 9HH=9JK LG := ;GFKAKL=FL OAL@ L@= J=<M;LAGF AF @GMJK OGJC=<
9EGF? L@= =D<=JDQ /@= EG<=D ;9F GFDQ 9;;GMFL >GJ L@= JAK= AF @GMJK OGJC=< 9EGF?
OGJC=JK LG 9 DAEAL=< =PL=FL
#42+ **/9/43'1 "+8:198
/@= EG<=D AK JGM?@DQ ;GFKAKL=FL OAL@ L@= D9:GJ KMHHDQ H9LL=JF 9EGF? GD<=J OGJC
=JK AF L@= H9KL ;=FLMJQ /@AK K=;LAGF HJ=K=FLK KGE= 9<<ALAGF9D J=KMDLK !AJKL
L@=
=;GFGEA=K ;GFKA<=J=< AF L@= HJ=NAGMK K=;LAGF O=J= KL=9<Q KL9L= =;GFGEA=K *:NA
GMKDQ
AL AK 9 KLJ=L;@ LG 9J?M= L@9L L@= 0. =;GFGEQ O9K AF 9 KL=9<Q KL9L= 9L 9FQ G>
L@=K= HGAFLK AF LAE= /@=J=>GJ=
9 LJ9FKALAGF9D 9F9DQKAK AK ;9JJA=< GML /@= =;GFGEQ
AK 9KKME=< LG KL9JL GML AF 9 KL=9<Q KL9L= AF OAL@GML 9 ?GN=JFE=FL /@=F
AF
F=O HGDA;A=K 9F< KMJNAN9D J9L=K 9J= MF9FLA;AH9L=<DQ 9FFGMF;=< $L AK 9KKME=<
F =PLJ9HGD9LAGF HJG;=<MJ= AK MK=< >GJ ;G@GJLK >GJ O@A;@ <9L9 AK EAKKAF?
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
Hours worked, US Total Population
McGrattan and Rogerson (2004)
40
35
30
1866-75
1876-85
1886-95
1896-1905
1906-15
1916-25
1926-35
1936-45
1946-55
1956-65
1966-75
1976-85
25
20
15
10
5
0
15-24
25-34
35-44
45-54
55-64
65-74
75-99
!A?MJ= #GMJK 2GJC=< :Q G@GJL 9F< ?=
0. +GHMD9LAGF
L@9L L@= KMJNAN9D J9L=K ;GFN=J?= LG L@= ;JGKKK=;LAGF9D KMJNAN9D J9L=K AF L@= Q=9J =;GFGEQ (GJ=GN=J
L@= <=:LJ9LAG
?GN=JFE=FL ;GFKMEHLAGF J9LAG
9F< LJ9FK>=J
J9LAGK =NGDN= DAF=9JDQ GN=J L@= L=FQ=9J AFL=JN9DK $F<ANA<M9DK 9J= 9KKME=< LG >MDDQ
9FLA;AH9L= 9DD ;@9F?=K AF HJA;=K 9F< HGDA;A=K
/@= J=KMDLK >GJ L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=K 9J= HJ=K=FL=< AF S?MJ= LG?=L@=J OAL@
L@= :9K=DAF= 2= K== L@9L L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= >GDDGOK 9 KGE=O@9L DGO=J LJ9B=;LGJQ
;GEH9J=< LG L@= 9K=DAF= EG<=D /@= J=9KGF AK
L@9L AF<ANA<M9DK J=9DAR= L@9L AFL=J=KL
J9L=K OADD JAK= 9F< L@9L KG;A9D K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK OADD := 9N9AD9:D= 9F< 9<BMKLK L@=AJ
;GFKMEHLAGF HD9FK 9;;GJ<AF?DQ 0HGF L@= AFLJG<M;LAGF G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
L@=J= AK
GF;= EGJ= 9 <AK;J=L= BMEH AF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=
:ML D=KK KG :=;9MK= AF<ANA<M9DK
@9N= 9FLA;AH9L=< L@= J=>GJE
/@= EG<=D <A< FGL <G O=DD AF E9L;@AF? L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= >GJ L@= Q=9J /@= EG<=D
9K ;GFKLJM;L=<
9:KLJ9;LK >JGE 9F AEHGJL9FL LJ9FK>=J HJG?J9E
F9E=DQ
E=<A;9J= (=<A;9J= ;GFKLALML=K GF= G> L@= KAF?D= EGKL AEHGJL9FL LJ9FK>=J HJG?J9EK
AF GD< 9?= .LGJ=KD=LL=F =KLAE9L=K E=<A;9J= LJ9FK>=JK 9K 9 K@9J= G> ")+ H=J
;9HAL9
:Q 9?= K== !A?MJ= /@AK HJGSD= ;9F @9N= AEHGJL9FL AEHDA;9LAGFK >GJ
K9NAF?K :=@9NAGJ
LG L@= =PL=FL L@9L AF<ANA<M9DK ;GFKA<=J AL 9 KM:KLALML= >GJ K9NAF?K
$F H9JLA;MD9J
AFLJG<M;AF? E=<A;9J= AFLG L@= =;GFGEQ @=DHK MK LG ;J=9L= 9 D9J?=J ?9H
AF AFL=J=KL J9L=K :=LO==F L@= AFALA9D Q=9J 9F< L@= SF9D Q=9J G> L@= =;GFGEQ .AF;=
/@= FME:=JK 9J= FGL <AJ=;LDQ ;GEH9J9:D=
KAF;= L@=J= 9J= ;G@GJL 9F< LAE= =Z=;LK AF L@= LJ9F
KALAGF9D 9F9DQKAK /@= ?J9H@ >GJ L@= LJ9FKALAGF <AKHD9QK L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= G> L@= ;G@GJL LMJFAF? AF L@= ?AN=F Q=9J
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
Lump Sum Transfer Function
0.35
0.3
Share of GNP/capita
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
0
20
40
60
Age
80
100
120
!A?MJ= (=<A;9J= /J9FK>=J :Q ?=
.@9J= G> ")+ H=J 9HAL9
AFL=J=KL J9L=K AK 9F AEHGJL9FL <=L=JEAF9FL G> L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=
L@AK E9Q ?AN= MK
KGE= D==O9Q AF L=JEK G> L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= /@=J=>GJ=
L@= >GDDGOAF? =PH=JAE=FL
O9K ;GF<M;L=< /@= =;GFGEQ O9K J=;9DA:J9L=< LG L@= Q=9J 9<<AF? E=<A;9J=
AFLG L@= ?GN=JFE=FLVK LJ9FK>=J HJG?J9E (=<A;9J= AK 9KKME=< LG := HJGNA<=< DMEH
KME 9;;GJ<AF? LG L@= >MF;LAGF =KLAE9L=< :Q .LGJ=KD=LL=F !A?MJ= HJ=K=FLK
L@= J=KMDLK >GJ L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= OAL@ E=<A;9J= $F<ANA<M9DK FGO J=LAJ= EM;@ D9L=J
AFALA9DDQ
$<4
:??1+8
/@= EG<=D <=N=DGH=< @=J= AK ;9H9:D= G> E9L;@AF? L@= ?=F=J9D LJ=F< AF J=LAJ=E=FL GN=J
L@= LO=FLA=L@ ;=FLMJQ +J=NAGMK DAL=J9LMJ= @9K IM=KLAGF=< O@=L@=J KG;A9D K=;MJALQ AK
J=KHGFKA:D= >GJ L@= =NGDMLAGF AF J=LAJ=E=FL !AJKL
EA;JG=;GFGE=LJA; KLM<A=K L=F<
LG SF< 9 N=JQ KE9DD =Z=;L G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ GF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ .=;GF<
L@=
<=;DAF= AF D9:GJ >GJ;= H9JLA;AH9LAGF KL9JL=< 9DJ=9<Q AF L@= =9JDQ LO=FLA=L@ ;=FLMJQ
DGF? :=>GJ= KG;A9D K=;MJALQ O9K AFLJG<M;=< /@AK K=;LAGF <AK;MKK L@=K= HMRRD=K AF NA=O
G> L@= EG<=D
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
/9:D= -=LAJ=E=FL
.LM<Q
?= "JGMH
&JM=?=J 9F< +AK;@C= #9MKE9F 9F< 2AK= #MJ< 9F< GKCAF !JA=<:=J? GKL9 GKL9 D9KLA;ALA=K
4=9J
=9JDQ K
9F< D9KLA;ALQ
.GMJ;= GKL9 $.+ "+9/7+2+39 1'89/)/9> "+;/8/9+*
.AF;= L@= =9JDQ VK
=;GFGEAKLK @9N= <=NGL=< EM;@ 9LL=FLAGF LG KLM<QAF? L@=
=Z=;L G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ GF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ -=NA=OK G> L@= DAL=J9LMJ= ;9F :=
>GMF< AF !=D<KL=AF =L 9D &JM=?=J 9F< (=Q=J 9F< !JA=<:=J? =L 9D
/@AK K=;LAGF 9J?M=K L@9L L@= AEHDA;9LAGFK G> L@= EA;JG=;GFGE=LJA; KLM<A=K
9J= :JG9<DQ ;GFKAKL=FL OAL@ L@= HJ=<A;LAGFK G> L@= EG<=D
/9:D= HJGNA<=K K=D=;L=< =KLAE9L=K G> L@= J=LAJ=E=FL =D9KLA;ALQ >GMF< AF L@=
DAL=J9LMJ= /@= J=LAJ=E=FL =D9KLA;ALQ 9K J=HGJL=< ?AN=K L@= H=J;=FL9?= ;@9F?= AF L@=
HJG:9:ADALQ G> J=LAJ=E=FL
;9MK=< :Q 9 GF= H=J;=FL AF;J=9K= AF :=F=SLK
(9FQ G> L@= =9JDQ KLM<A=K KMZ=J=< >JGE >MF<9E=FL9D HJG:D=EK AF L@=AJ A<=FLAS;9
LAGF KLJ9L=?Q !AJKL
9K HGAFL=< GML :Q (GSLL 9F< &JM=?=J 9F< (=Q=J KLM<A=K L@9L =P9EAF= ;JGKKK=;LAGF9D <9L9 F=;=KK9JADQ =KLAE9L= @GO L@= KG;A9D K=;M
JALQ KQKL=E 9L 9 ?AN=F HGAFL AF LAE= AFTM=F;=K J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ =? #MJ< 9F<
GKCAF GKCAF /@MK
KAF;= 9DD AF<ANA<M9DK 9J= ;GN=J=< :Q L@= K9E=
JMD=K
9DD N9JA9LAGF AF KG;A9D K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK AK <M= LG <AZ=J=F;=K AF AF<ANA<M9DKH=;AS;
;@9J9;L=JAKLA;K =? @9J< OGJC
O=DD H9A< BG:K =L;
9F< FGL L@= KG;A9D K=;MJALQ KQK
L=E 9K KM;@ GFK=IM=FLDQ
L@= =D9KLA;ALQ =KLAE9L=< AK DAC=DQ LG ;9HLMJ= <AZ=J=F;=K AF
KM;@ ;@9J9;L=JAKLA;K
J9L@=J L@9F <AZ=J=F;=K AF :=F=SL D=N=DK .=;GF<
KLM<A=K MKAF?
DGF?LALM<9D <9L9 L=F< LG SF< D9J?= =Z=;LK G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ GF J=LAJ=E=FL =? #MJ<
9F< GKCAF MJLD=KK 9F< F<=JKGF
MJC@9MK=J 9F< ,MAFF #GO=N=J
9K 9J?M=< :Q &JM=?=J 9F< (=Q=J L@= F=?9LAN= ;GJJ=D9LAGF :=LO==F
D9:GJ >GJ;= H9JLA;AH9LAGF 9F< :=F=SLK EA?@L N=JQ O=DD := KHMJAGMK
$F 9 N=JQ AFTM=FLA9D KLM<Q
&JM=?=J 9F< +AK;@C= LJQ LG 9NGA< L@=K= HJG:
D=EK :Q KLM<QAF? 9 H9JLA;MD9J ;G@GJL
L@= )GL;@ 9:A=K
L@9L O9K ;GN=J=< :Q <AZ=J=FL
JMD=K /@=K= JMD=K
O@A;@ O=J= MF9FLA;AH9L=<DQ AEHD=E=FL=<
KH=;AS=< MH LG DGO=J :=F=SLK >GJ L@= )GL;@ 9:A=K 4=L
L@= <GOFO9J< LJ=F< AF D9:GJ >GJ;= H9JLA;
AH9LAGF ;GFLAFM=< MF9:9L=< $F =Z=;L
L@= J=LAJ=E=FL =D9KLA;ALQ >GMF< AF L@AK KLM<Q
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
78
76
74
Age
72
70
General Equilibrium
68
66
Partial Equilibrium
64
62
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
Replacement Rate
0.5
0.6
0.7
!A?MJ= *HLAE9D -=LAJ=E=FL ?= 9F< L@= -=HD9;=E=FL -9L=
O9K F=9JDQ R=JG *L@=J KLM<A=K SF< =IM9DDQ KE9DD =D9KLA;ALA=K
KM??=KLAF? L@9L :=
LO==F R=JG 9F< GF= L@AJ< G> L@= <=;DAFAF? LJ=F< AF D9:GJ >GJ;= H9JLA;AH9LAGF ;9F :=
=PHD9AF=< :Q KG;A9D K=;MJALQ #9MKE9F 9F< 2AK= MJLD=KK 9F< (GSLL
!A?MJ= <=HA;LK L@= J=LAJ=E=FL HGDA;Q JMD=
+ >GJ L@= =;GFGEQ
/@= HGDA;Q JMD= LJ9;=K GML L@= GHLAE9D J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= >GJ <AZ=J=FL D=N=DK G> J=HD9;=
E=FL J9L=K
/@= +9JLA9D
IMADA:JAME DAF= AK ;GFKLJM;L=< >GJ ?AN=F HJA;=K 9F<
L9P=K /@= DAF= ;9F := AFL=JHJ=L=< 9K J=HJ=K=FLAF? L@= EA;JG=;GFGE=LJA; =KLAE9L=K
/@= "=F=J9D
IMADA:JAME DAF= AK ;GFKLJM;L=< :Q D=LLAF? HJA;=K 9F< L9P=K J=KHGF<
LG L@= ;@9F?=K AF AF<ANA<M9D :=@9NAGJ
2= K== L@9L L@= GHLAE9D J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= AK 9 <=;J=9KAF? >MF;LAGF G> L@= J=HD9;=E=FL
J9L= (GJ=GN=J
L@= KDGH= AK <=;J=9KAF? 9L @A?@=J J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=K /@= KDGH= AK
KL==H=J >GJ L@= ?=F=J9D =IMADA:JAME ;9K=
:=;9MK= 9F AF;J=9K= AF :=F=SLK ;JGO<K GML
K9NAF?K
AF;J=9K=K AFL=J=KL J9L=K 9F< L@=J=>GJ= <=D9QK J=LAJ=E=FL L L@= HJ=K=FL
D=N=D G> L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=
9JGMF< L@= J=LAJ=E=FL =D9KLA;ALQ AK AF<==< N=JQ
DGO J=<M;LAGF AF L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= :Q <=D9QK J=LAJ=E=FL :Q D=KK L@9F EGFL@K AF L@= +9JLA9D
IMADA:JAME ;9K= 9F< EGFL@K AF L@= "=F=J9D
IMADA:JAME
;9K= $FL=J=KLAF?DQ
!J=F;@ =KLAE9L=K L@9L 9 J=<M;LAGF AF :=F=SLK <=D9QK
/@= J=KMDLK 9J= N=JQ KAEAD9J AF L@= GL@=J =;GFGEA=K
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
J=LAJ=E=FL :Q 9JGMF< EGFL@K
#GO=N=J
L@= KE9DD J=LAJ=E=FL =D9KLA;ALQ <G=K :Q FG E=9FK AEHDQ L@9L KG;A9D K=
;MJALQ AK MFAEHGJL9FL >GJ J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ /G L@= ;GFLJ9JQ
9:GDAK@AF? KG;A9D
K=;MJALQ OGMD< 9;;GJ<AF? LG L@= EG<=D AEHDQ 9 <=D9Q AF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= G> Q=9JK /@MK
L@= EG<=KL J=LAJ=E=FL =D9KLA;ALA=K >GMF< AF L@= EA;JG=;GFGEA; DAL=J9
LMJ=
;9FFGL := L9C=F 9K =NA<=F;= L@9L KG;A9D K=;MJALQ @9K 9 KE9DD =Z=;L GF J=LAJ=E=FL
:=@9NAGJ
39+7+89 "'9+8 /3 9.+
7+#4)/'1 #+):7/9> 7'
F AEHGJL9FL 9J?ME=FL >GJ O@Q KG;A9D K=;MJALQ E9Q FGL @9N= :==F 9 E9AF <JANAF?
>GJ;= >GJ L@= D9:GJ KMHHDQ :=@9NAGJ G> GD<=J OGJC=JK
AK L@9L L@= LJ=F< LGO9J<K =9JDA=J
J=LAJ=E=FL KL9JL=< 9DJ=9<Q :=>GJ= KG;A9D K=;MJALQ O9K AFLJG<M;=< K== !A?MJ= /@= EG<=D <=N=DGH=< @=J= KM??=KLK L@9L L@= >9DD AF D9:GJ >GJ;= H9JLA;AH9LAGF
:=LO==F ;9 LG O9K <M= LG 9F AF;J=9K= AF AFL=J=KL J9L=K ;9MK=< :Q L@= JAK=
G> ?GN=JFE=FL /@AK K=;LAGF DGGCK 9L KGE= G> L@= =EHAJA;9D =NA<=F;= AF >9NGJ G> L@AK
HJGHGKALAGF
/@= AF;J=9K= AF ?GN=JFE=FL =PH=F<ALMJ=K 9F< ?GN=JFE=FL D=F<AF? @9K 9DJ=9<Q
:==F <G;ME=FL=< AF L9:D= /@= EG<=D HJ=<A;LK JAKAF? AFL=J=KL J9L= >JGE L@= =9JDQ
K 0F>GJLMF9L=DQ
L@= =NA<=F;= GF QA=D<K G> <AZ=J=FL 9KK=LK :=>GJ= 22$$ AK N=JQ
K;9J;=
!A?MJ= <AKHD9Q L@= QA=D<K GF DGF?L=JE
@A?@?J9<= EMFA;AH9D :GF<K >JGE
LG L9C=F >JGE (;"J9LL9F 9F< +J=K;GLL DL@GM?@ GFDQ 9 N=JQ KE9DD
>J9;LAGF G> @GMK=@GD< 9KK=LK X AF !- X O=J= @=D< AF EMFA;AH9D
K=;MJALA=K
AL E9Q HJGNA<= 9F A<=9 G> L@= <=N=DGHE=FLK 2= K== L@9L L@= QA=D<K AF;J=9K=
GN=J L@= H=JAG< LG /@=F
9>L=J L@=Q >=DD 9:JMHLDQ :=;9MK= G> L@=
"J=9L =HJ=KKAGF 9F< J=E9AF=< DGO MFLAD L@= EA<K (;"J9LL9F 9F< +J=K;GLL
>GJ;=>MDDQ 9J?M=K L@9L L@= DGO QA=D<K <MJAF? 22$$ 9F< L@= &GJ=9F 29J O9K
9 <=DA:=J9L= HGDA;Q >JGE L@= ?GN=JFE=FLVK KA<=
9;@A=N=< L@JGM?@ @=9NADQ J=?MD9L=<
:=@9NAGJ G> @GMK=@GD<K 9F< :MKAF=KK=K /@MK
AL E9Q FGL := 9 ?GG< 9HHJGPAE9LAGF
>GJ L@= J=LMJFK LG K9NAF?K AF L@AK H=JAG<
+=J@9HK 9 :=LL=J AF<A;9LGJ AK (;"J9LL9F 9F< +J=K;GLLVK =KLAE9L= >GJ L@=
J=LMJF GF D9J?= ;GEH9FQ KLG;CK $F G> @GMK=@GD< 9KK=LK O=J= @=D< AF
;GJHGJ9L= =IMALA=K !- !A?MJ= K@GOK L@9L L@= J=LMJF LG =IMALQ >GDDGOK
9F AF;J=9KAF? LJ=F< :=LO==F 9F< /@MK
L@=J= K==E LG := KGE= =NA<=F;= L@9L J=LMJFK LG K9NAF?K AF<==< AF;J=9K=<
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
10
Large-company Stocks
Long-term Municipal Bonds
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
1880
1890
1900
1910
1920
1930
1940
1950
!A?MJ= =:L -=LMJFK 9F< -=9D -=LMJFK LG KK=LK
:=LO==F 9F< 2@=L@=J GJ FGL L@= AF;J=9K= AF AFL=J=KL J9L=K O9K <JAN=F :Q L@= =PH9FKAGF G>
?GN=JFE=FL AK 9F MFK=LLD=< IM=KLAGF #GO=N=J
>GJ L@= HGKLO9J H=JAG< 9 FME:=J G>
KLM<A=K @9N= <G;ME=FL=< L@9L @A?@=J ?GN=JFE=FL <=:L AF<==< AF;J=9K=< DGF? L=JE
AFL=J=KL J9L=K 9JL@ =L 9D 59@A< =:MD9 9F< G;C 9@E9FA*KCGG== &9DMDMEA9 43)1:8/43
.G;A9D K=;MJALQ @9K G>L=F :==F HJGHGK=< 9K L@= E9AF <=L=JEAF9FL G> L@= <=;DAFAF?
LJ=F< AF D9:GJ >GJ;= H9JLA;AH9LAGF 9EGF? GD<=J OGJC=JK #GO=N=J
LOG HMRRD=K EMKL
:= 9<<J=KK=< :Q 9FQGF= 9J?MAF? L@9L KG;A9D K=;MJALQ AK L@= ;9MK9D >9;LGJ !AJKL
EA;JG
=;GFGE=LJA; KLM<A=K L=F< LG SF< 9 N=JQ KE9DD =Z=;L G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ GF J=LAJ=E=FL
:=@9NAGJ .=;GF<
L@= <=;DAF= AF D9:GJ >GJ;= H9JLA;AH9LAGF KL9JL=< 9DJ=9<Q AF L@=
=9JDQ LO=FLA=L@ ;=FLMJQ
DGF? :=>GJ= KG;A9D K=;MJALQ O9K AFLJG<M;=<
FME:=J G> KLM<A=K 9J?M= L@9L L@=J= AK FG J=D9LAGF :=LO==F ?GN=JFE=FL <=:L 9F< AFL=J=KL
J9L=K N9FK 9JJG =J9NA =L 9D .=9L=J 9F< "MDD=Q #GO=N=J
L@=Q HJAE9JADQ MK= K@GJLL=JE AFL=J=KL J9L=K 'GF?L=JE AFL=J=KL J9L=K 9J= EGJ= J=D=N9FL
@=J= AF<ANA<M9DK MKM9DDQ K9N= >GJ L@=AJ J=LAJ=E=FL AF DGF?L=JE 9KK=LK
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
/@AK H9H=J HJGHGK=K 9 EG<=D L@9L =PHD9AFK L@= LJ=F< AF D9:GJ KMHHDQ 9EGF?
GD<=J OGJC=JK L@JGM?@ ;@9F?=K AF SK;9D HGDA;Q
AF;DM<AF? KG;A9D K=;MJALQ /@= EG<=D
=EH@9KAR=K L@= ?=F=J9D =IMADA:JAME =Z=;LK G> SK;9D HGDA;Q GF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ
$F H9JLA;MD9J
L@= J9<A;9D K@A>L AF SK;9D HGDA;Q 9L L@= :=?AFFAF? G> L@= ;=FLMJQ J9AK=<
L@= J=LMJFK LG K9NAF?K
O@A;@ AF<M;=< OGJC=JK LG J=LAJ= =9JDA=J /@= EG<=D HJ=<A;LK
9 D9J?= ;@9F?= AF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ MHGF L@= AFLJG<M;LAGF G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
O@AD=
KM:K=IM=FL AF;J=9K=K AF J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=K 9J= K@GOF LG @9N= 9 KE9DD AEH9;L GF
J=LAJ=E=FL .H=;AS;9DDQ
L@= J=LAJ=E=FL =D9KLA;ALQ AK >GMF< LG := 9 <=;J=9KAF? 9F<
;GFN=P >MF;LAGF G> L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= /@MK
L@= =KK9Q HJGHGK=K KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
9K 9 E9BGJ <=L=JEAF9FL G> J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ AF L@= K=;GF< @9D> G> L@= /O=FLA=L@
;=FLMJQ
O@AD= KAEMDL9F=GMKDQ GZ=JAF? 9F =PHD9F9LAGF G> L@= LOG E9AF HMRRD=K AF L@=
DAL=J9LMJ=
/@= H9H=J 9:KLJ9;LK >JGE >=9LMJ=K L@9L 9J= HGL=FLA9DDQ AEHGJL9FL =? HJG<M;
LANALQ ?JGOL@
AEH=J>=;L 9FFMALQ E9JC=LK 9F< :=IM=KL !MLMJ= OGJC K@GMD< ;GFKA<=J
=PL=FKAGFK AF L@AK <AJ=;LAGF DKG
L@= EAP :=LO==F AF;GE= L9P9LAGF 9F< ;9HAL9D L9P
9LAGF @9K ;@9F?=< ;GFKA<=J9:DQ GN=J LAE= (;"J9LL9F 9F< +J=K;GLL .AF;=
;9HAL9D L9P9LAGF AK 9 E9AF <=L=JEAF9FL G> J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ AF L@= EG<=D
>MLMJ=
OGJC K@GMD< =PHDGJ= L@= LAE= N9JA9LAGF AF L@AK <AE=FKAGF
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
/(1/4-7'5.>
67 @ALMN
NF=J 9F< %GK=H@ 5=AJ9 /=;@FA;9D +JG?J=KK 9F<
9JDQ -=LAJ=
E=FL
+- AK;MKKAGF +9H=J )G 67 "4*/.", .$/-& ".% 2/%5$4 $$/5.43 N9AD9:D= 9L
@LLHOOO:=9?GN
67 '. /9:D= GFL9AFAF? #AKLGJQ G> GFKME=J +JA;= $F<=P
0. =H9JL
E=FL G> '9:GJ
MJ=9M G> '9:GJ .L9LAKLA;K
29K@AF?LGF 67 MJLD=KK
"9JQ 9F< %GK=H@ ! ,MAFF &4*2&-&.4 2&.%3 ".% /,*$*&3 4/
.$/52"(& !/2+ -/.( ,%&2 -&2*$".3
/@= JGGCAF?K $FKLALMLAGF
(AE=G
67 MJLD=KK
"9JQ F
;GFGEA; 1A=O G> -=LAJ=E=FL
AF #=FJQ % 9JGF
=<
&)"6*/2", *-&.3*/.3 /' &4*2&-&.4 $/./-*$3
JGGCAF?K $FKLALMLAGF
+J=KK
67 GKL9
GJ9 ' )& 6/,54*/. /' &4*2&-&.4 . -&2*$". $/./-*$
*34/29 /@= 0FAN=JKALQ G> @A;9?G +J=KK
67 !=<=J9D -=K=JN= 9FC !DGO G> !MF<K ;;GMFL G> L@= 0FAL=< .L9L=K F
FM9D !DGOK 9F< *MLKL9F<AF?K
G9J< G> "GN=JFGJK G> L@= !=<=J9D -=
K=JN= .QKL=E
29K@AF?LGF 67 !J=F;@
JA; /@=
Z=;L G> #=9DL@
2=9DL@ 9F< 29?=K GF '9:GJ .MHHDQ
9F< -=LAJ=E=FL =@9NAGJ
>GJL@;GEAF? AF &6*&7 /' $/./-*$ 45%*&3
67 "=F<=DD
(MJJ9Q -=LAJ=E=FL ?=K =;DAF=K 9?9AF AF K
/.4),9 "#/2
&6*&7
*;LG:=J 67 #9FK=F
"9JQ /@= Q;DA;9D 9F< .=;MD9J =@9NAGMJ G> L@= '9:GJ $F
HML GEH9JAF?
Y;A=F;Q 0FALK 9F< #GMJK 2GJC=<
%GMJF9D G> HHDA=<
E=LJA;K
1GD HH ;GFG
#! " & #!# # %## #$!&
67 #=9L@;GL=
%GF9L@9F
&B=LAD .LGJ=KD=LL=F 9F< "AGN9FFA ' 1AGD9FL= /@=
JGKK.=;LAGF9D $EHDA;9LAGFK G> -AKAF? 29?= $F=IM9DALQ AF L@= 0FAL=< .L9L=K
(AE=G
67 #G::K
!J9FC 9F< )A;GD= .LGGHK =EG?J9H@A; /J=F<K AF L@= L@ =F
LMJQ
0. =FKMK MJ=9M
=FKMK .H=;A9D -=HGJLK
.=JA=K ).-
0.
"GN=JFE=FL +JAFLAF? *Y;=
29K@AF?LGF 67 &GH=;CQ
&9J=F /@= /J=F< AF -=LAJ=E=FL
;GFGEA= <V9N9FL ?9J<=
-=K=9J;@ -=HGJL )G 67 &JM=?=J
D9F 9F< JM;= (=Q=J '9:GJ .MHHDQ
Z=;LK G> .G;A9D
$FKMJ9F;=
) - 2GJCAF? +9H=J
)G 67 (9LKMQ9E9
&AEAFGJA *F=.=;LGJ )=G;D9KKA;9D "JGOL@ (G<=D OAL@
F<G?=FGMK -=LAJ=E=FL
)GJL@O=KL=JF 0FAN=JKALQ
(AE=G
67 (;"J9LL9F
DD=F 9F< <O9J< +J=K;GLL N=J9?= =:L 9F< IMALQ -=
LMJFK +MRRDAF?
-&2*$". $/./-*$ &6*&7
E=JA;9F
;GFGEA; KKG;A9LAGF
NGD HH 67 * * ;GFGEA; *MLDGGC
67 -MKL
%G@F 9F< @JAKLGH@=J +@=D9F #GO .G;A9D .=;MJALQ 9F< (=<A;9J=
Z=;L -=LAJ=E=FL AF 9 2GJD< G> $F;GEHD=L= (9JC=LK
$/./-&42*$"
1GD )G
HH 67 .G;A9D .=;MJALQ <EAFAKLJ9LAGF FFM9D .L9LAKLA;9D .MHHD=E=FL .G;A9D .=;MJALQ <EAFAKLJ9LAGF
29K@AF?LGF 67 .G;A9D .=;MJALQ <EAFAKLJ9LAGF FFM9D .L9LAKLA;9D .MHHD=E=FL .G;A9D .=;MJALQ <EAFAKLJ9LAGF
29K@AF?LGF 67 0. MJ=9M G> L@= =FKMK 522&.4 /05,"4*/. 526&9 "2$) 500,&
-&.4 9N9AD9:D= NA9 9L9!=JJ=LL
.'59+7 #:89'/3'(1+ /8)'1
41/)> '3* 9.+
"+9/7+2+39 +)/8/43
3974*:)9/43
/@= 0. AK AF L@= EA<<D= G> 9 KA?FAS;9FL <=EG?J9H@A; LJ9FKALAGF /@= K@9J= G> L@=
HGHMD9LAGF GD<=J L@9F 9K ;GEH9J=< LG L@= OGJCAF? 9?= HGHMD9LAGF 9?=< AK =PH=;L=< LG <GM:D= >JGE AF LG 9JGMF< AF .. /@AK OADD @9N= =FGJEGMK ;GFK=IM=F;=K >GJ SK;9D HGDA;Q AF L@= ;GEAF? <=;9<=K "AN=F
;MJJ=FL HGDA;A=K
L@= ;GE:AF=< KH=F<AF? GF E=<A;9J=
E=<A;9A< 9F< KG;A9D K=;MJALQ AK
HJGB=;L=< LG JAK= >JGE G> "+ AF LG G> "+ AF *
/@MK
SK;9D HGDA;Q AK MFKMKL9AF9:D= 9L ;MJJ=FL L9P J9L=K
/@J== :9KA; GHLAGFK >GJ J=KLGJAF? SK;9D KMKL9AF9:ADALQ 9J= 9N9AD9:D= LG L@= 0.
?GN=JFE=FL AF;J=9KAF? L9P=K
;MLLAF? J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=K
9F<GJ AF;J=9K
AF? L@= =DA?A:ADALQ 9?= >GJ KG;A9D K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK #GO D9J?= 9J= L@= J=IMAJ=< HGDA;Q
;@9F?=K /G 9<=IM9L=DQ 9FKO=J L@AK IM=KLAGF
AL AK AEHGJL9FL LG 9;;GMFL >GJ AF<ANA<
M9D J=KHGFK=K LG HGDA;Q ;@9F?=K -=LAJ=E=FL J=KHGFK=K 9J= G> H9JLA;MD9J AEHGJL9F;=
AF L@AK J=?9J< -=>GJEK LG KMKL9AF SK;9D HGDA;Q ;9F @9N= 9L D=9KL LOG =Z=;LK GF J=
LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ !AJKL
L@=J= EA?@L := 9 <AJ=;L AF;=FLAN= =Z=;L !GJ AFKL9F;=
9
J=<M;LAGF AF :=F=SLK E9Q <=D9Q J=LAJ=E=FL
<M= LG 9 F=?9LAN= O=9DL@ =Z=;L .=;GF<
$ L@9FC EQ 9<NAKGJK !9:JARAG 5ADA:GLLA 9F< &B=LAD .LGJ=KD=LL=F >GJ @=DH>MD ;GEE=FLK 9F< KM?
?=KLAGFK $ OGMD< 9DKG DAC= LG L@9FC %G@F #9KKD=J
%GF9L@9F #=9L@;GL=
(9L@A9K #=JRAF?
AJC
&JM=?=J
+=J &JMK=DD
(9LK +=JKKGF
H9JLA;AH9FLK 9L L@= .G;A=LQ >GJ ;GFGEA; QF9EA;K FFM9D
(==LAF? AF M<9H=KL
L@= $$ . (9;JG 2GJCK@GH
L@= (9;JG 2GJCK@GH 9L *KDG 0FAN=JKALQ
9F< 9L L@= ( GF>=J=F;= GF *'" 9F< 0F;=JL9AFLQ >GJ ;GEE=FLK 9F< KM??=KLAGFK /@9FCK
9DKG LG @JAKLAF9 '^FF:D9< >GJ =<ALGJA9D 9KKAKL9F;= DD J=E9AFAF? =JJGJK 9J= EAF= !AF9F;A9D KMH
HGJL >JGE %9F 29DD9F<=JVK 9F< /GE #=<=DAMKV -=K=9J;@ !GMF<9LAGF
/GJ= JGO9D<VK !GMF<9LAGF
9F< !AF9FKHGDALAKC9 !GJKCFAF?KAFKLALML=L AK ?J9L=>MDDQ 9CFGOD=<?=<
*VK .4&2-&%*"4& KH=F<AF? K;=F9JAG
#! $"# " & # #!# "
/9:D= Z=;L GF L@= N=J9?= -=LAJ=E=FL ?= G> 9 .=D=;L=< .LM<A=K
.LM<Q
@9F?= AF -=LAJ=E=FL ?=
(A;JGKLM<A=K
&JM=?=J 9F< +AK;@C= MJLD=KK EGFL@K
!J=F;@ EGFL@K
(9;JGKLM<A=K
/@AK H9H=J
Q=9JK
L@=J= E9Q := AEHGJL9FL ?=F=J9D =IMADA:JAME =Z=;LK !GJ =P9EHD=
9 J=<M;LAGF AF KG
;A9D K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK AF;J=9K=K K9NAF?K
L@=J=:Q 9DKG J=<M;AF? AFL=J=KL J9L=K /@AK
AF
LMJF
E9Q <=D9Q J=LAJ=E=FL NA9 9 F=?9LAN= O=9DL@ =Z=;L /@AK H9H=J 9KCK O@=L@=J =F
<G?=FGMK J=LAJ=E=FL J=KHGFK=K 9J= IM9FLAL9LAN=DQ AEHGJL9FL >GJ SK;9D HGDA;Q J=>GJEK
9;;GMFLAF? >GJ :GL@ L@= <AJ=;L AF;=FLAN= =Z=;L 9F< L@= AF<AJ=;L ?=F=J9D =IMADA:JAME
=Z=;L
.AF;= L@= =9JDQ VK
EA;JG=;GFGEAKLK @9N= KLM<A=< O@=L@=J AF<ANA<M9DK J=KHGF<
LG KG;A9D K=;MJALQ AF;=FLAN=K /@= ?=F=J9D SF<AF? AK L@9L L@=Q <G
:ML FGL LG 9FQ
;GFKA<=J9:D= =PL=FL !GJ =P9EHD=
!J=F;@ K@GOK L@9L 9 J=<M;LAGF AF KG;A9D
K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK <=D9QK J=LAJ=E=FL :Q L@J== EGFL@K *L@=J KLM<A=K SF< =Z=;LK L@9L
9J= =IM9DDQ KE9DD
K== /9:D= /@MK
J=LAJ=E=FL J=KHGFK=K 9J= EG<=KL 9F< :JAF?
DALLD= @GH= L@9L <=D9Q=< J=LAJ=E=FL ;9F ;GFLJA:ML= LG J=KLGJ= SK;9D KMKL9AF9:ADALQ
/@= EA;JG=;GFGEA; DAL=J9LMJ= F9LMJ9DDQ <AKJ=?9J<K 9FQ ?=F=J9D =IMADA:JAME =>
>=;LK /@= E9BGJ SF<AF? G> L@AK H9H=J AK L@9L ?=F=J9D =IMADA:JAME =Z=;LK 9J= ;JM;A9D
<=L=JEAF9FLK G> J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ 9F< K@GMD< := L9C=F AFLG 9;;GMFL O@=F ;GFKA<
=JAF? KG;A9D K=;MJALQ J=>GJE !GJ AFKL9F;=
AL AK >GMF< L@9L 9 J=<M;LAGF AF :=F=SLK
J=KMDLK AF 9 J=LAJ=E=FL <=D9Q G> L@J== Q=9JK AF L@= DGF? JMF /@= J=9KGF AK L@9L
AF
L@= =PH=JAE=FL ;GF<M;L=< @=J=
J=<M;LAGFK AF :=F=SLK AF;J=9K= K9NAF?K :Q :GL@ L@=
?GN=JFE=FL 9F< L@= AF<ANA<M9D /@AK J=<M;=K L@= J=LMJF LG K9NAF?K
A= 9 F=?9LAN=
O=9DL@ =Z=;L
J=KMDLAF? AF 9 ?=F=J9D <=D9Q AF J=LAJ=E=FL (GJ=GN=J
L@= H9H=J SF<K
L@9L L@= ?=F=J9D =IMADA:JAME =Z=;L GF J=LAJ=E=FL G> J=<M;AF? L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=
<O9J>K L@= <AJ=;L AF;=FLAN= =Z=;L
$F 9<<ALAGF
L@= H9H=J E9C=K 9 ;GFLJA:MLAGF :Q ;GFKLJM;LAF? L@J== HGDA;A=K KMK
L9AFAF? SK;9D HGDA;Q AF L@= >9;= G> L@= 9?AF? HGHMD9LAGF !AJKL
9F AEE=<A9L= 9F<
MFAN=JK9D J=<M;LAGF AF :=F=SLK G> <=D9QK J=LAJ=E=FL :Q Q=9JK /@= ;GE:AF9
LAGF G> J=<M;=< :=F=SLK 9F< <=D9Q=< J=LAJ=E=FL OADD := KMY;A=FL LG K=L SK;9D HGDA;Q
GF 9 KMKL9AF9:D= H9L@ O@AD= C==HAF? L9P=K MF;@9F?=< .=;GF<
9F AEE=<A9L= 9F<
>GMJL@ HGKKA:ADALQ AK LG AF;J=9K= AEEA?J9LAGF K== .LGJ=KD=LL=F #! $"# " & # #!# "
MFAN=JK9D AF;J=9K= AF L@= !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= !- LG L@= 9?= G> 9DKG KMKL9AFK
SK;9D HGDA;Q O@AD= C==HAF? L9P=K MF;@9F?=< /@= AF;J=9K= AF !- AEHDA=K 9 <=D9Q
AF J=LAJ=E=FL G> Q=9JK
9F< J=<M;=K L@= :=F=SLK H9A< LG =9JDQ J=LAJ==K !AF9DDQ
9F AEE=<A9L= H=J;=FL9?= HGAFL AF;J=9K= AF L@= ?=F=J9D L9P J9L= 9DKG KMKL9AFK
SK;9D HGDA;Q $FL=J=KLAF?DQ
KM;@ 9 J=>GJE 9DKG AEHDA=K 9 <=D9Q AF J=LAJ=E=FL
<M= LG
9 ?=F=J9D >=9LMJ= G> L@= KMKL9AF9:D= HGDA;A=K ;GFKA<=J=< @=J= L@= ?GN=JFE=FL :MAD<K
MH 9 F=L9KK=L HGKALAGF O@A;@ J=<M;=K L@= AFL=J=KL J9L=
L@=J=:Q ;9MKAF? 9 <=D9Q AF
J=LAJ=E=FL
/@=K= J=KMDLK 9J= >GMF< MKAF? 9 <QF9EA; ?=F=J9D =IMADA:JAME EG<=D OAL@ GN=J
D9HHAF? ?=F=J9LAGFK AF L@= LJ9<ALAGF G> M=J:9;@ 9F< &GLDACGZ /@AK AK 9
F9LMJ9D KL9JLAF? HGAFL >GJ KLM<QAF? SK;9D KMKL9AF9:ADALQ /@= EG<=D 9KKME=K L@9L
AF<ANA<M9DK E9C= GHLAE9D <=;AKAGFK GF @GMJK OGJC=<
;GFKMEHLAGF 9F< K9NAF?K GN=J
L@=AJ DA>=;Q;D= C=Q >=9LMJ= AK L@9L AF<ANA<M9DK 9DKG E9C= GHLAE9D ;@GA;=K 9:GML
L@=AJ J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=
<=SF=< 9K L@= 9?= 9L O@A;@ L@=Q KLGH OGJCAF? 9F< KL9JL J=
;=ANAF? :=F=SLK +J=NAGMK DAL=J9LMJ= @9K =AL@=J 9KKME=< =PG?=FGMK J=LAJ=E=FL GJ
J=DA=< GF KAEHDA>QAF? 9KKMEHLAGFK
=? <J9E9LA; 9F< ;GMFL=J>9;LM9D J=<M;LAGFK AF
HJG<M;LANALQ 9JGMF< L@= 9?= G> (GJ=GN=J
L@= 0. KG;A9D K=;MJALQ KQKL=E AK
EG<=DD=< AF <=L9AD LG KLM<Q ALK AF;=FLAN= =Z=;LK
$F<ANA<M9DK 9J= 9KKME=< LG := @=L=JG?=FGMK AF KCADDK
O@A;@ AK AEHGJL9FL >GJ 9
FME:=J G> J=9KGFK !AJKL
J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ <AZ=JK 9;JGKK KCADD ?JGMHK $F H9JLA;M
D9J
DGOKCADD=< AF<ANA<M9DK J=LAJ= EM;@ =9JDA=J L@9F @A?@ KCADD=< GF=K
H9JLDQ :=;9MK=
HJG<M;LANALQ <=;DAF=K 9L GD< 9?= 9J= EGJ= HJGFGMF;=< >GJ DGOKCADD=< AF<ANA<M9DK
@9F?=K AF SK;9D HGDA;Q E9Q L@=J=>GJ= @9N= <AZ=J=FL =Z=;LK GF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ
9;JGKK KCADD ?JGMHK .=;GF<
>MLMJ= ;G@GJLK G> J=LAJ==K 9J=
GF 9N=J9?=
:=LL=J KCADD=<
#A?@KCADD=< AF<ANA<M9DK DAN= DGF?=J 9F< J=;=AN= @A?@=J :=F=SLK /@MK
L@= AF;J=9K=K
AF DA>= =PH=;L9F;Q J9AK= SK;9D =PH=F<ALMJ=K
FGL GFDQ :=;9MK= G> 9 @A?@=J >J9;LAGF G>
GD<
:ML 9DKG :=;9MK= 9 @A?@=J >J9;LAGF G> GD< 9J= @A?@ KCADD=<
/@= ?GN=JFE=FL AK 9KKME=< LG HJGNA<= HM:DA; ;GFKMEHLAGF 9F< J=<AKLJA:ML=
LJ9FK>=JK
AF;DM<AF? KG;A9D K=;MJALQ "GN=JFE=FL =PH=F<ALMJ=K 9J= SF9F;=< L@JGM?@
L9P9LAGF GJ :Q AKKMAF? HM:DA; <=:L !GDDGOAF? .LGJ=KD=LL=F AL AK 9KKME=< L@9L
L@= ?GN=JFE=FL 9<@=J=K LG ;GFKL9FL L9P JMD=K L@9L AK
L9P HGDA;A=K 9J= ;@9F?=< GF;=
9L EGKL 9F< 9J= C=HL ;GFKL9FL >GJ=N=J 9>L=J MF<=J L@= J=IMAJ=E=FL L@9L SK;9D HGDA;Q
AK KMKL9AF9:D=
? &GLDACGZ
.E=LL=JK 9F< 29DDAK=J 9F< )AK@AQ9E9 F =P;=HLAGF AK .9F;@=R
(9JL]F O@G KLM<A=K 9 H=FKAGF J=>GJE AF .H9AF AF 9F< ALK AEH9;L GF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ
#GO=N=J
AF @AK EG<=D
D9:GJ KMHHDQ AK 9KKME=< LG := =PG?=FGMK GF L@= =PL=FKAN= E9J?AF
#! $"# " & # #!# "
/9:D= Z=;L GF L@= +9QJGDD /9P G> 9 =D9Q AF L@= -=LAJ=E=FL ?=
4=9J .LM<Q
-=LAJ=E=FL 9?=
/9P $F;J=9K=
9K=DAF= DL=JF9LAN= 9K=DAF= DL=JF9LAN=
LL9F9KAG =L 9D = )9J<A =L 9D &GLDACGZ =L 9D )GL= +=J;=FL9?= HGAFLK J=D9LAN= LG L@= Q=9J /@= <=EG?J9H@A;K G> L@= =;GFGEQ =NGDN= 9;JGKK LAE=
O@A;@ AEHDA=K L@9L K9NAF?K
D9:GJ KMHHDQ
?GN=JFE=FL =PH=F<ALMJ=K =L; OADD := ;@9F?AF? 9K LAE= ?G=K :Q AF
9;;GJ<9F;= OAL@ L@= <=EG?J9H@A; <=N=DGHE=FLK
/@= J=E9AF<=J G> L@= H9H=J HJG;==<K 9K >GDDGOK .=;LAGF HD9;=K L@AK H9H=J AF
L@= ;GFL=PL G> L@= HJ=NAGMK DAL=J9LMJ= .=;LAGF GMLDAF=K L@= EG<=D 9F< K=;LAGF <AK;MKK=K L@= ;9DA:J9LAGF HJG;=<MJ= /@= J=KMDLK 9J= <AK;MKK=< AF K=;LAGF O@AD=
K=;LAGF GZ=JK ;GF;DM<AF? J=E9JCK
"+1'9+* 1/9+7'9:7+
/@= ?=F=J9D AKKM=K AF KG;A9D K=;MJALQ J=>GJE @9N= :==F 9<<J=KK=< AF A9EGF< !=D<KL=AF 9F< 'A=:E9F 9F< 'AF<:=;C 9F< +=JKKGF /@AK H9H=J
:=DGF?K LG L@= ;D9KK G> <QF9EA; ?=F=J9D =IMADA:JAME EG<=DK GJA?AF9LAF? OAL@ M=J
:9;@ 9F< &GLDACGZ /@=K= EG<=DK @9N= :==F OA<=DQ MK=< LG 9<<J=KK AKKM=K GF
KG;A9D K=;MJALQ J=>GJE +9H=JK AF L@AK LJ9<ALAGF AF;DM<= GF=K9 9F< &JM=?=J 9F< #M??=L 9F< 1=FLMJ9 #GO=N=J
EGKL H9H=JK AF L@AK N=AF 9KKME= L@=
HGHMD9LAGF KLJM;LMJ= LG := KL9LAGF9JQ .GE= =P;=HLAGFK 9J= .LGJ=KD=LL=F =
)9J<A
$EJG@GJG?DM 9F< .9J?=FL )AK@AQ9E9 9F< &GLDACGZ
.E=LL=JK
9F< 29DDAK=J O@G 9DD KLM<Q 0. KG;A9D K=;MJALQ OAL@ 9?AF? HGHMD9LAGFK /@=
;MJJ=FL H9H=J AK 9 ;GFLJA:MLAGF LG L@AK DAL=J9LMJ=
/@= HJ=NAGMK DAL=J9LMJ= @9K IM9FLAS=< @GO EM;@ 9 <=D9Q AF J=LAJ=E=FL ;9F ;GF
LJA:ML= LG SF9F;= L@= K@GJL>9DD AF KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
K== /9:D= /@= ?=F=J9D SF<AF?
AK L@9L L@= DGF?JMF J=IMAJ=< ;@9F?= AF L@= L9P J9L= ;9F := ;ML AF @9D> :Q 9 ?=F
=J9D <=D9Q AF J=LAJ=E=FL LG L@= 9?= G> #GO=N=J
EGKL G> L@= DAL=J9LMJ= 9KKME=K
J=LAJ=E=FL LG := =PG?=FGMK
&GLDACGZ =L 9D 9F< )AK@AQ9E9 KLM<Q EG<=DK OAL@ =F<G?=FGMK J=
LAJ=E=FL #GO=N=J
L@=Q E9C= LOG 9KKMEHLAGFK L@9L =Z=;LAN=DQ HJ=N=FL 9 K=JAGMK
/@= =PH=JAE=FLK ?=F=J9DDQ 9KKME= L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= LG := ;GFKL9FL 9F< L@9L ;D9AEAF?
:=F=SLK AK =PG?=FGMKDQ HGKLHGF=<
#! $"# " & # #!# "
9F9DQKAK G> J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ !AJKL
J=LAJ=E=FL AK 9;@A=N=< :Q 9KKMEAF? 9F =P
G?=FGMK <AK;J=L= <JGH AF HJG<M;LANALQ 9L L@= LAE= G> J=LAJ=E=FL $F &GLDACGZ =L 9D
>GJ AFKL9F;=
HJG<M;LANALQ <JGHK :Q :=LO==F 9?=K 9F< /@AK AK
9L G<<K OAL@ L@= =EHAJA;9D =NA<=F;= !J=F;@ ;9J=>MDDQ =KLAE9L=K HJG<M;LANALQ
HJGSD=K >GJ OGJC=JK 9?=< 9F< SF<K L@9L HJG<M;LANALQ >9DDK :Q 9JGMF< 9
Q=9J :=LO==F 9?=K 9F< $F L@= ;MJJ=FL H9H=J HJG<M;LANALQ OADD := 9KKME=< LG
<=;DAF= 9L J9L=K ;DGK=J LG L@GK= >GMF< :Q !J=F;@ .=;GF<
L@= KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
JMD=K 9J= FGL >MDDQ EG<=DD=< K K@GOF :Q "JM:=J 9F< 2AK= A9EGF< 9F<
"JM:=J GAD= 9F< "JM:=J 9F< AK=FK== 9EGF? GL@=JK
KG;A9D
K=;MJALQ AF;=FLAN=K 9J= AEHGJL9FL >GJ J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ /@=J=>GJ=
L@= 0. KG;A9D
K=;MJALQ JMD=K 9J= EG<=DD=< AF <=L9AD >GJ L@AK H9H=J
/@= HJ=K=FL H9H=J 9KKME=K 9 ;GFKL9FL L9P JMD=
O@=J= L9P=K 9J= ;@9F?=< GF;=
9L EGKL 9F< C=HL ;GFKL9FL L@=J=9>L=J =:L 9<BMKLK 9;;GJ<AF?DQ LG K9LAK>Q L@= ?GN
=JFE=FLVK :M<?=L ;GFKLJ9AFL /@AK 9HHJG9;@ O9K 9<NG;9L=< :Q D9F;@9J< 9F< =PHDGJ=< :Q .LGJ=KD=LL=F AF 9 <QF9EA; ?=F=J9D =IMADA:JAME K=LLAF? $F
;GFLJ9KL
L@= EGKL ;GEEGFDQ MK=< 9KKMEHLAGF AK L@9L G> ;GFKL9FL <=:L JMD= <=:L J=
E9AFK ;GFKL9FL >GJ=N=J
O@AD= L9P=K 9<BMKL H=JAG< :Q H=JAG< LG 9;;GEEG<9L= ;@9F?=K
AF =PH=F<ALMJ=K 2@AD= "02*/2*
L@=J= AK FG J=9KGF LG ;@GGK= GF= E=L@G< GN=J L@=
GL@=J
L@= ;GFKL9FL L9P JMD= AK 9LLJ9;LAN= :=;9MK= AL GZ=JK 9 GF= <AE=FKAGF9D E=9KMJ=
G> L@= ;GKL G> KMKL9AFAF? ;MJJ=FL SK;9D HGDA;Q $F H9JLA;MD9J
AL AK =9KADQ K@GOF L@9L
L@= L9P J9L= AEHD=E=FL=< MF<=J ;GFKL9FL L9P JMD= AK L@= J9LAG
+1 PH=F<ALMJ=K
+1 /9P 9K=
O@=J= +1 AF<A;9L=K HJ=K=FL <AK;GMFL=< N9DM= $F 9<<ALAGF
L@= 9KKMEHLAGF <AJ=;LDQ
9<<J=KK=K L@= KM??=KLAGF :Q KGE= G:K=JN=JK LG :MAD< 9F< E9AFL9AF 9 LJMKL >MF<
;GF
KA<=J9:DQ D9J?=J L@9F L@= ;MJJ=FL GF=
LG K9N= >GJ L@= <=EG?J9H@A; <=N=DGHE=FLK K==
=? A9EGF< #GDRE9FF 9F< .LA?DALR #GDRE9FF 9F< #AFR $F >9;L
L@= EG<=D ?AN=K 9 HJ=;AK= =KLAE9L= G> @GO D9J?= L@= LJMKL >MF< K@GMD< :=
LG J=F<=J SK;9D HGDA;Q KMKL9AF9:D= !AF9DDQ
L@= ;GFKL9FL L9P JMD= AK 9LLJ9;LAN= :=
;9MK= AL HJGNA<=K 9F 9FKO=J LG L@= IM=KLAGF O@9L ;9F $ <G LG<9Q LG KMKL9AF SK;9D
HGDA;Q GFKL9FL <=:L JMD=
GF L@= GL@=J @9F<
AEHDA;ALDQ 9KKME=K L@9L L@= ?GN
=JFE=FL :=@9N=K EQGHA;9DDQ
K=LLAF? L9P=K LG :9D9F;= GFDQ L@= :M<?=L G> L@= ;MJJ=FL
H=JAG<
K E=FLAGF=< AF L@= AFLJG<M;LAGF
L@= H9H=J AK 9DKG J=D9L=< LG L@= EA;JG=;GFGEA;
DAL=J9LMJ= GF J=LAJ=E=FL 9F< KG;A9D K=;MJALQ .GE= J=;=FL H9H=JK AF;DM<= -MKL 9F<
#! $"# " & # #!# "
+@=D9F !J=F;@ GAD= 9F< "JM:=J A9EGF< 9F< "JM:=J 9F< "MKLE9F 9F< .L=AFE=A=J !J=F;@ >GJ AFKL9F;=
SF<K L@9L L@=
9;LM9JA9D MF>9AJF=KK G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ AK 9F AEHGJL9FL <=L=JEAF9FL G> J=LAJ=E=FL
:=@9NAGJ
O@AD= L@= D=N=D G> :=F=SLK 9J= FGL /@= EG<=D <=N=DGH=< @=J= @9K KAEAD9J
HJGH=JLA=K
/@= EA;JG=;GFGEA; DAL=J9LMJ= F9LMJ9DDQ 9:KLJ9;LK >JGE ?=F=J9D =IMADA:JAME =>
>=;LK
:ML L@=K= =Z=;LK LMJF GML LG := AEHGJL9FL AF L@= ;MJJ=FL H9H=J GAD= 9F<
"JM:=J ?G H9JL G> L@= O9Q :Q 9KK=KKAF? L@= :M<?=L9JQ AEH9;L G> KG;A9D K=
;MJALQ J=>GJE AF 9 KL=9<Q KL9L= =FNAJGFE=FL /@=Q =EH@9KAR= LOG =Z=;LK G> KG;A9D
K=;MJALQ J=>GJE GF HM:DA; ;GZ=JK !AJKL
9 E=;@9FA;9D =Z=;L O@=J=:Q ;@9F?AF? :=F
=SLK GJ L9P9LAGF D=9< LG ;@9F?=K AF J=N=FM= 9F< =PH=F<ALMJ=K (*6&. L@= J=LAJ=E=FL
:=@9NAGJ .=;GF<
9 :=@9NAGJ9D =Z=;L O@=J=:Q AF<ANA<M9DK J=KHGF< LG ;@9F?=K AF
:=F=SLK 9F<GJ L9P=K
L@=J=:Q AF<M;AF? 9 ;@9F?= AF J=N=FM=K 9F< =PH=F<ALMJ=K F
AEHGJL9FL SF<AF? AF L@=AJ H9H=J AK L@9L L@= E=;@9FA;9D =Z=;L AK EM;@ D9J?=J L@9F
L@= :=@9NAGJ9D =Z=;L AF L@= 0FAL=< .L9L=K
:=;9MK= L@= 0. KG;A9D K=;MJALQ KQKL=E
AK JGM?@DQ 9;LM9JA9DDQ >9AJ /@9L AK
9 HJ=EAME AK ?AN=F >GJ <=D9Q=< J=LAJ=E=FL
KM;@
L@9L L@= HJ=K=FL <AK;GMFL=< N9DM= G> :=F=SLK AK 9DEGKL L@= K9E=
AJJ=KH=;LAN= G> L@=
9?= G> J=LAJ=E=FL .G
9DL@GM?@ AF<ANA<M9DK J=KHGF< LG KG;A9D K=;MJALQ J=>GJE :Q
;@9F?AF? J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ
L@AK <G=K FGL @9N= 9FQ D9J?= :M<?=L9JQ AEH9;L
'AC= GAD= 9F< "JM:=J L@= HJ=K=FL H9H=J SF<K L@= :=@9NAGJ9D =Z=;L LG
:= KE9DD 9F< HGKALAN= >GJ J=>GJEK GF L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= 9F< L9P=K
:=;9MK= 0.
KG;A9D K=;MJALQ AK JGM?@DQ 9;LM9JA9DDQ >9AJ #GO=N=J
L@= :=@9NAGJ9D =Z=;L AK D9J?= 9F<
F=?9LAN= >GJ J=>GJEK GF L@= !- /@9L AK
AF;J=9K=K AF L@= !- OADD := 9;;GEH9FA=<
:Q <=D9QK AF J=LAJ=E=FL /@=K= ;@9F?=K AF :=@9NAGJ OADD GZK=L L@= E=;@9FA;9D =Z=;L
A= L@= J=<M;LAGF AF :=F=SLK ?AN=F L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= L@9L J=KMDLK >JGE AF;J=9KAF?
!-
$.+ 24*+1
45:1'9/43 '3* .+9+74-+3+/9>
/@= =;GFGEQ AK HGHMD9L=< :Q AF<ANA<M9DK O@G DAN= 9 E9PAEME G> % H=JAG<K $F<A
NA<M9DK <AZ=J AF 9?=
KCADDK 9F<
A> 9F AEEA?J9FL
L@= 9?= 9L L@= LAE= G> AEEA?J9LAGF
/@= LQH= G> 9F AF<ANA<M9D AK <=FGL=< 8 > :
O@=J= 8 % AK 9?=
> AK
$FL=J=KL J9L=K 9F< O9?=K 9J= L9C=F 9K ?AN=F
O@AD= L9P=K E9Q J=KHGF< LG ;@9F?=K AF :=F=SLK
#! $"# " & # #!# "
KCADD 9F< : AK L@= 9?= 9L L@= LAE= G> AEEA?J9LAGF F9LAN=K @9N= : .CADDK ;9F
L9C= GF L@J== N9DM=K > ;GJJ=KHGF<AF? LG DGOKCADD=<
E=<AMEKCADD=< 9F<
@A?@KCADD=<
J=KH=;LAN=DQ .CADD ?JGMHK <AZ=J AF L=JEK G> LAE= KH=FL AF =<M;9LAGF
D9:GJ HJG<M;LANALQ
AFF9L= HJ=>=J=F;= >GJ D=AKMJ=
! 9F< KMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K GF
<ALAGF9D GF :=AF? 9DAN= 9L 9?= 8 L@= HJG:9:ADALQ G> KMJNANAF? LG 9?= 8 >GJ 9 LQH=
8 > AF<ANA<M9D AK @! $F =9;@ H=JAG<
F=O AEEA?J9FLK =FL=J L@= =;GFGEQ 9L L@= ;GFKL9FL J9L= G> L@=
LGL9D HGHMD9LAGF AF H=JAG< A /@= 9?= 9F< KCADD ;GEHGKALAGF G> L@= AEEA?J9FL
HGHMD9LAGF E9Q <AZ=J >JGE L@9L G> F9LAN=K :ML
>GJ KAEHDA;ALQ
AL AK 9KKME=< L@9L 9
LQH= 0 1 AEEA?J9FL AK A<=FLA;9D AF 9DD J=KH=;LK LG 9 LQH= 0 1 F9LAN= /@MK
L@=
JGD= G> AEEA?J9LAGF AK GFDQ LG ;@9F?= L@= 9?= 9F< KCADD ;GEHGKALAGF G> L@= HGHMD9LAGF
$F L@= >GDDGOAF?
: OADD := KMHHJ=KK=< O@=F=N=J FG 9E:A?MALQ OADD 9;;GJ<AF?DQ 9JAK=
!GDDGOAF? '== -]GK-MDD 9F< .LGJ=KD=LL=F L@= :AJL@ HJG;=KK
$ G$ O@=J= $ !$ AK L@= E=9KMJ= G> 9?=
AK EG<=DD=< 9K $ !
8 AF<ANA<M9DK AF H=JAG< A
$ AK L@= FME:=J G> F=O:GJF F9LAN=K 9L LAE= A
!$ AK
L@= E=9KMJ= G> 9?= 8 AF<ANA<M9DK AF KCADD ?JGMH > 9L LAE= A
AK L@= 9?=KH=;AS;
>=JLADALQ J9L=K 9N=J9?=< GN=J LAE=
9F< G$ AK 9 <=L=JEAFAKLA; HJG;=KK LG := KH=;AS=<
D9L=J @AD<J=F G> AEEA?J9FLK 9J= ;GFKA<=J=< LG := F9LAN=K
$F<ANA<M9DK QGMF?=J L@9F 9?= 9J= <=SF=< 9K ;@AD<J=F 0HGF =FL=JAF? 9<MDL@GG<
9L 9?= AF<ANA<M9DK >9;= 9 ;GFKL9FL HJG:9:ADALQ ! G> =FL=JAF? KCADD ?JGMH >
7+,+7+3)+8 9+).3414-> '3* 2'70+98
$F<ANA<M9DK <=JAN= MLADALQ >JGE 9 KL9F<9J< ;GFKMEHLAGF ?GG< 9F< D=AKMJ= +J=>=J=F;=K
9J= LAE= K=H9J9:D= /@= AFKL9FL9F=GMK MLADALQ >MF;LAGF L9C=K L@= >GJE B
2 7
O@=J= 2 AK ;MJJ=FL ;GFKMEHLAGF 9F< 7 AK L@= LAE= KH=FL OGJCAF? AF L@= E9JC=L /@=
>MF;LAGF B
AK AF;J=9KAF? 9F< KLJA;LDQ ;GF;9N= AF :GL@ 9J?ME=FLK @AD<J=F <G
FGL OGJC 9F< GFDQ ;GFKME= L@= LJ9FK>=JK HJGNA<=< :Q L@= ?GN=JFE=FL $F<ANA<M9DK
<G FGL ;9J= 9:GML L@=AJ ;@AD<J=F 9F< @9N= FG :=IM=KL EGLAN=
LQH= > 9?=FL E9PAEAR=K DA>=LAE= MLADALQ 9K ?AN=F :Q
"
! B
2 7 KM:B=;L LG L@= AFL=JL=EHGJ9D :M<?=L ;GFKLJ9AFLK LG := KH=;AS=< :=DGO + AK L@=
J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= <=SF=< 9K L@= 9?= 9L O@A;@ L@= AF<ANA<M9D ;@GGK=K LG KLGH OGJCAF?
.== .LGJ=KD=LL=F >GJ EGJ= J=9DAKLA; 9KKMEHLAGFK 9:GML AEEA?J9FLK
#! $"# " & # #!# "
7 ".% KL9JLK ;GDD=;LAF? J=LAJ=E=FL :=F=SLK /@AK AK 9 K=H9J9L= <=;AKAGF >JGE
L@= D9:GJ KMHHDQ <=;AKAGF
KAF;= 7 AK 9DDGO=< OAL@GML <J9OAF? J=LAJ=E=FL :=F=
SLK ! AK L@= MF;GF<ALAGF9D HJG:9:ADALQ >GJ 9F 9?=FL G> LQH= 8 > G> :=AF? 9DAN= 9L
@! 0HGF <=9L@
AF<ANA<M9DK ?=L R=JG MLADALQ
9?= 8
<=SF=< 9K ! $F<ANA<M9DK AFN=KL L@=AJ 9KK=LK AF 9 H=J>=;L 9FFMALQ E9JC=L O@A;@ H9QK 9 HJ=EAME
G>
#
GF L@= ?JGKK AFL=J=KL J9L=
*MLHML AF H=JAG< A AK ?AN=F :Q 9 KL9F<9J< ;GFKL9FL J=LMJFK LG K;9D= HJG<M;LAGF
>MF;LAGF 5 '$ ($ OAL@ 9??J=?9L= D9:GJ
($ 9F< ;9HAL9D
'$ 9K AFHMLK *MLHML
AK MK=< >GJ ;GFKMEHLAGF 9F< AFN=KLE=FL AF F=O ;9HAL9D ??J=?9L= D9:GJ AFHML
AF H=JAG< A
($ AK L@= KME G> =Y;A=F;Q MFALK KMHHDA=< :Q AF<ANA<M9DK
A= ($ 4!$ 7!$ !$ O@=J= 4!$ AK L@= FME:=J G> D9:GJ =Y;A=F;Q MFALK 9F< 7!$ AK L@=
!
LAE= KH=FL OGJCAF? :Q AF<ANA<M9DK G> LQH= 8 > AF H=JAG< A -=HJ=K=FL9LAN= SJEK
J=FL D9:GJ 9F< ;9HAL9D GF L@= KHGL E9JC=LK 9L 9 ?AN=F O9?= J9L=
D$ 9F< ?JGKK J=FL9D
J9L=
?$ 9F< L@= SJE KGDN=K
" 5 '$ ($ ?$ '$ D$ ($ O@=J= AK L@= <=HJ=;A9LAGF J9L= G> ;9HAL9D
4;+732+39 '3* 84)/'1 8+):7/9>
"GN=JFE=FL HGDA;Q ;GFKAKLK G> 9 L9P JMD=
9 HM:DA; KH=F<AF? JMD=
9F< 9 LJ9FK>=J JMD=
L@9L AF;DM<=K KG;A9D K=;MJALQ 9F< GL@=J ?GN=JFE=FL LJ9FK>=J HJG?J9EK /@= L9P JMD=
KH=;AS=K 9 ;GFKL9FL =PG?=FGMK H9QJGDD L9P J9L= D=NA=< GF D9:GJ AF;GE= :=DGO 9
L@J=K@GD< D=N=D
F
9F< 9 ;GFKL9FL =F<G?=FGMK L9P J9L= GF ;9HAL9D AF;GE=
D9:GJ
AF;GE= 9F< L9P9:D= *$ :=F=SLK
"GN=JFE=FL ;GFKMEHLAGF AK ?AN=F :Q 9 JMD= <=L=JEAFAF? ?GN=JFE=FL HMJ;@9K=K
G> ?GG<K 9F< K=JNA;=K 9K 9 >MF;LAGF G> HGHMD9LAGF
$$ 6 $ O@=J= 6 AK ?GN=JFE=FL ;GFKMEHLAGF H=J 9?=FL G> 9?= 8 AF H=JAG< R=JG $F<ANA<M9DK
<=JAN= FG MLADALQ >JGE ?GN=JFE=FL ;GFKMEHLAGF .AF;= D9J?= ;GEHGF=FLK G> ?GN=JF
E=FL HMJ;@9K=K G> ?GG<K 9F< K=JNA;=K 9J= 9?=<=H=F<=FL
AL AK AEHGJL9FL LG ;GF<ALAGF
HM:DA; ;GFKMEHLAGF GF 9?= $L ;GMD< := 9J?M=< L@9L ?GN=JFE=FL ;GFKMEHLAGF AK 9
>MF;LAGF G> :GL@ 9?= 9F< J=LAJ=E=FL KL9LMK .M;@ 9 DAFC AK KGE=O@9L 9E:A?MGMK
@GO=N=J
KG L@= KAEHD=J JMD= OADD := 9HHDA=<
#! $"# " & # #!# "
/@= ?GN=JFE=FL <AKLJA:ML=K KG;A9D K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK ;GFKAKLAF? G> GD< 9?= AFKMJ9F;=
*$
KMJNANGJVK AFKMJ9F;= .$
<AK9:ADALQ AFKMJ9F;= $
9F< (=<A;9J= ;GFKAKLAF?
G> @GKHAL9D AFKMJ9F;= #$ 9F< KMHHD=E=FL9JQ E=<A;9D AFKMJ9F;= .($
L KGE= 9?= & AF<ANA<M9DK :=;GE= =DA?A:D= >GJ *$ :=F=SLK *FDQ =DA?A:D=
AF<ANA<M9DK O@G 9J= J=LAJ=< 7 ;9F J=;=AN= *$ :=F=SLK /@= AF<ANA<M9DVK
*$ LJ9FK>=J AK 9 >MF;LAGF 3 + G> @=J 9FFM9DAR=< 9N=J9?= AF<=P=< EGFL@DQ
=9JFAF?K $( 3
9F< @=J 9?= 9L J=LAJ=E=FL
+ $( AK 9 >MF;LAGF 3 F G> L@=
AF<ANA<M9DVK =9JFAF? @AKLGJQ F F F O@=J= F 9J= HJ=L9P =9JFAF?K 9L 9?= 8
AK O=9CDQ AF;J=9KAF? AF + 9F< ;GF;9N= AF 3 /@= ;GF;9NALQ AF 3 AEHDA=K L@9L
:=F=SLK 9J= J=?J=KKAN=
O@AD= AEHDA=K L@9L 9 HJ=EAME E9Q := ?AN=F >GJ
<=D9Q=< J=LAJ=E=FL
/@= J=E9AFAF? H9JLK G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ .$
$ 9F< (=<A;9J= 9J= EG<=DD=< 9K
9?=KH=;AS; DMEHKME LJ9FK>=JK /@MK
L@= EG<=D 9:KLJ9;LK >JGE 9FQ AF;=FLAN=K
L@=K= HJG?J9EK E9Q @9N= >GJ L@= J=LAJ=E=FL <=;AKAGF DD GL@=J ?GN=JFE=FL LJ9FK>=J
HJG?J9EK
KM;@ 9K MF=EHDGQE=FL AFKMJ9F;=
O=D>9J= H9QE=FLK =L;
9J= <AKLJA:ML=<
9K H9JL G> L@= 9?=KH=;AS; DMEHKME LJ9FK>=JK /@AK KH=;AS;9LAGF G:NAGMKDQ 9:KLJ9;LK >JGE HGKKA:D= KM:KLALML9:ADALQ :=LO==F <A>
>=J=FL ?GN=JFE=FL HJG?J9EK $L ;GMD<
>GJ AFKL9F;=
:= 9J?M=< L@9L 9 <GOFKARAF?
G> *$ :=F=SLK OGMD< AF;J=9K= =FJGDDE=FL AF GL@=J ?GN=JFE=FL LJ9FK>=J HJG?J9EK
=? .MHHD=E=FL9JQ .=;MJALQ $F;GE= ..$
O=D>9J= H9QE=FLK 9F< MF=EHDGQE=FL
AFKMJ9F;=
/@= 9??J=?9L= KG;A9D K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK 9F< GL@=J ?GN=JFE=FL LJ9FK>=JK AF H=JAG<
A ;9F := ;GEHML=< 9K
-$ !$ 3!$ +!$ !
O@=J= 3!$ 9F< +!$ 9J= L@= $(
9F< L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=
J=KH=;LAN=DQ
G> 9 LQH=
8 > AF<ANA<M9D AF H=JAG< A /GL9D L9P J=N=FM=K 9J= ?AN=F :Q
+#.$ D$ ($ ?$ '$ !$ 3!$ $
D$ (
!
O@=J= ($ 9F< '$ 9J= 9??J=?9L= D9:GJ AFHML 9F< 9??J=?9L= ;9HAL9D
J=KH=;LAN=DQ
9F<
$ !$ 4!$ 7!$ F$ D$ AK L@= H9JL G> D9:GJ AFHML KM:B=;L LG L@= H9QJGDD
(
!
$F H9JLA;MD9J
-MKL 9F< +@=D9F K@GO L@9L (=<A;9J= HJGNA<=K KLJGF? AF;=FLAN=K >GJ <=D9Q=<
J=LAJ=E=FL 9EGF? KGE= KM:?JGMHK
HJAE9JADQ DGO AF;GE= OGJC=JK OAL@ =EHDGQ=J @=9DL@ AFKMJ9F;=
#! $"# " & # #!# "
L9P /@= >MF;LAGF J=LMJFK L@= H9JL G> :=F=SLK L@9L 9J= KM:B=;L LG AF;GE=
L9P9LAGF 9F< AK 9KKME=< LG := 9 >MF;LAGF G> $( 3
M<?=L <=S;ALK 9J= SF9F;=< L@JGM?@ AF;J=9K=K AF L9P=P=EHL ?GN=JFE=FL :GF<K
!$ GF<K 9J= @=D< :Q HJAN9L= 9?=FLK 9F< =NGDN= 9;;GJ<AF? LG
!$ !$ ?$ +#.$ -$ $$ O@=J= E9JC=L ;D=9JAF? AF L@= :GF<K E9JC=L @9K :==F AEHGK=<
A= ?$
?$ 3*/;/*:'18A (:*-+9 )43897'/39 '3* *+)/8/43 574(1+2
/@= :M<?=L ;GFKLJ9AFL G> AF<ANA<M9D 8 > 9L LAE= A AK
2!$ 0!$ 0!$
@!$
:!$ O@=J= :!$ <=FGL=K L@= 9>L=JL9P AF;GE= G> L@= AF<ANA<M9D 8 > 9L <9L= A
0!$
<=FGL=K L@= 9KK=L @GD<AF?K G> 8 > AF H=JAG< A
9F<
#
;9HLMJ=K L@= KMJNANGJVK HJ=
EAME AEHDA=< :Q L@= H=J>=;L 9FFMALQ E9JC=LK $FALA9D O=9DL@ AK R=JG .M:K=IM=FLDQ
9F AF<ANA<M9D @9K >GMJ HGL=FLA9D KGMJ;=K G> AF;GE= D9:GJ =9JFAF?K
AFL=J=KL AF;GE=
DMEHKME LJ9FK>=JK 9F< *$ :=F=SLK F=L G> L9P=K /@MK
:!$ D$ 4! 7!$ ?$ 0!$ #
A> !$ ?$ 0!$ #
3!$ +!$ 3!$ A> !$ O@=J= !$ L9C=K GF L@= N9DM= G> A> AF<ANA<M9D 8 > @9K ;@GK=F LG J=;=AN= *$
:=F=SLK 9L LAE= A
9F< GL@=JOAK=
$F GL@=J OGJ<K
O@=F=N=J !$ L@=
AF<ANA<M9D AK ;GFKA<=J=< LG := J=LAJ=< /@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= G> 9F AF<ANA<M9D 8 > 9L
LAE= A AK <=SF=< 9K +!$ 8 % !$ /@= J=LAJ=E=FL <=;AKAGF
OADD := 9KKME=< LG := AJJ=N=JKA:D=
A= L@9L !$ >GJ 8 +!$ $JJ=N=JKA:ADALQ
;GFKA<=J9:DQ KAEHDAS=K L@= HJG:D=E
F AEHDA;AL 9KKMEHLAGF =E:G<A=< AF L@= :M<?=L ;GFKLJ9AFL AK L@9L 9 :=F=S;A9JQ ;9FFGL OGJC
A=
EHAJA;9DDQ
9JGMF< G> L@= :=F=S;A9JA=K 9?=< <A< FGL OGJC AF !JA=<:=J?
F =IMAN9D=FL 9KKMEHLAGF AK L@9L 9 D9:GJ L9P AK D=NA=< GF :=F=S;A9JA=K L D=9KL LOG
>=9LMJ=K G> J=9DALQ ;9F EGLAN9L= KM;@ 9F 9KKMEHLAGF AF 9<<ALAGF LG >=<=J9D 9F< KL9L= L9P=K
L@=
J=LAJ=E=FL =9JFAF?K L=KL D=NA=K 9 E9J?AF9D L9P GF D9:GJ KMHHDQ GF Q=9J GD< :=F=S;A9JA=K
O@G OGJC 9F< L@= =PAKL=F;= G> L=;@FGDG?A;9D ;GFKLJ9AFLK L@9L HJ=N=FL 9 DGO FME:=J G> @GMJK G>
OGJC
-=D9PAF? L@AK 9KKMEHLAGF OADD FGL KM:KL9FLA9DDQ 9DL=J L@= J=KMDLK $F 9 KL=9<Q KL9L=
AF<ANA<M9DK
OADD ;@GGK= LG J=LAJ= GF;= 9F< GFDQ GF;=
=N=F A> L@=Q @9N= L@= GHHGJLMFALQ LG J=;GFKA<=J L@=AJ
#! $"# " & # #!# "
/@= KL9L= G> 9F AF<ANA<M9D ;9F := KMEE9JAR=< :Q L@= LMHD= 0 F 8 > "AN=F
HJA;=K
HGDA;A=K
LJ9FK>=JK 9F< L@= AFALA9D ;GF<ALAGFK
9 OGJC=JVK N9DM= >MF;LAGF
C$ AK L@= KGDMLAGF LG L@= >GDDGOAF? J=;MJKAN= HJG:D=E
C$ 0 F 8 > " B 2 7 0 F 8 > C$
0 F 8 >
@! C$
KM:B=;L LG
2 0 ?$ 0
D$ 4! 7 @!
0 8
0 8 %
D$
F D$ 4! 7
F D$
7
9F<
C$' 0 F % > E J=LAJ== KGDN=K L@= >GDDGOAF? J=;MJKAGF
B
2
@
C
0
F
8
>
C$ 0 F 8 > "
!
$
KM:B=;L LG
2 0 ?$ 0
3 F +! 3 F @!
9F< 9F< ;@GA;= !GDDGOAF? 9 J=>GJE
L@AK AK D=KK KLJ9A?@L>GJO9J< #GO=N=J
AF 9F =PH=JAE=FL O@=J= L@=
J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= O9K J=<M;=< :Q AL LMJF=< GML L@9L AF<ANA<M9DK O@G O=J= J=LAJ=< 9L L@= LAE=
G> L@= J=>GJE ;@GK= LG J=E9AF J=LAJ=<
#! $"# " & # #!# "
+@3/9/43 4, +6:/1/(7/:2
/@AK K=;LAGF <=K;JA:=K L@= ;GF<ALAGFK BGAFLDQ ;@9J9;L=JARAF? L@= =IMADA:JAME H9L@ G>
L@= =;GFGEQ >GDDGOAF? 9 J=>GJE 9L <9L= A "AN=F AFALA9D ;GF<ALAGFK >GJ <=:L ! L@= =JJGJ L=JE G> L@= >=JLADALQ HJG;=KK G L@=
<AKLJA:MLAGF
G> 9KK=LK
0 HGHMD9LAGF <AKLJA:MLAGF L@= K=IM=F;= G> H9KL =9JFAF?K 9F< ?GN=JFE=FL HGDA;A=K 6 3 D$ 4! 7!$ $
9F =IMADA:JAME AK <=SF=< 9K 9 K=IM=F;= D$ ?$ ($ '$ $ !$ 7!$ 2!$ 0!$ !$ 9F< 9 ;GFKL9FL L9P J9L= KM;@ L@9L L@= >GDDGOAF? @GD<K
KGDN=K L@= AF<ANA<M9DKV E9PAEAR9LAGF HJG:D=E
7!$ 2!$ 0!$ !$ $
A= 9F< ?AN=F D$ ?$ $ 9F< ?GN=JFE=FL HGDA;A=K !9;LGJ E9JC=LK ;D=9J
5 '$ ($ ($
D$ ?$ A 5 '$ ($ '$
A /@= ?GG<K E9JC=L ;D=9JK =N=JQ H=JAG<
5 '$ ($ '$ $
O@=J= $$ K9LAKS=K 9F<
'$ $$ $
!
!
!$ 2!$
A 9J= L@= 9KK=LK
!$ 0!$ "#
:JGM?@L AFLG L@= =;GFGEQ :Q AEEA?J9FLK 9JJANAF? AF H=JAG< A
/@= L9P J9L= KGDN=K L@= ?GN=JFE=FLVK >=9KA:ADALQ ;GFKLJ9AFL
! +#.$ $$ -$
$
$
? O@=J= +#.$ AK ?AN=F :Q $$ :Q 9F< -$ :Q /@= K=IM=F;= G> ?GN=JFE=FL <=:L
!$ $ AK ?=F=J9L=< :Q L@= ?GN=JFE=FLVK
K@GJLL=JE :M<?=L ;GFKLJ9AFL /@= E9JC=L >GJ K9NAF?K ;D=9JK
'$ $
!$
A $
#! $"# " & # #!# "
/9:D= 9DA:J9LAGF
+9J9E=L=J
19DM=
+GHMD9LAGF
%
(GJL9DALQ
.. HJGB=;LAGF)#. KCADD >9;LGJ
$EEA?J9FL TGO <AKLJ
$EEA?J9FL <AKLJA:MLAGF
+J=>=J=F;=K
/=;@FGDG?Q
"GN=JFE=FL
6
6
6 G> /
(=<A;9J=
D=N=D
*L@=J /J9FK>=JK
D=N=D
.G;A9D .=;MJALQ
0. KQKL=E AF (9J?AF9D L9P GF :=F=SLK $FALA9D GF<ALAGFK !/
'/
+GHMD9LAGF <AKLJ
=FKMK
O@=J=
$
!$ 0!$ /@= HGHMD9LAGF K=IM=F;=
!$
$
AK ?=F=J9L=< :Q G 9F< L@= EGJ
L9DALQ
>=JLADALQ 9F< AEEA?J9LAGF HJG;=KK=K 9K KH=;AS=< AF :=DGO
'1/(7'9/43
/@AK K=;LAGF <=K;JA:= L@= ;9DA:J9LAGF HJG;=<MJ= !GJ 9F GN=JNA=O G> ;9DA:J9LAGF
;@GA;=K K== /9:D= #0/11 -74:58
/@= KCADD ?JGMHK 9J= <=SF=< 9K >GDDGOK
'GO KCADD=< #A?@ K;@GGD <=?J== GJ D=KK
(=<AME KCADD=< (GJ= L@9F 9 @A?@ K;@GGD <=?J==
:ML D=KK L@9F 9 :9;@=DGJVK
<=?J==
#! $"# " & # #!# "
#A?@ KCADD=< 9;@=DGJVK <=?J== GJ @A?@=J
/@AK <ANAKAGF O9K ;@GK=F LG =FKMJ= 9 D9J?= E=9KMJ= G> AF<ANA<M9DK AF =9;@ KCADD
?JGMH 9F< Q=L HJ=K=JN= KGE= @=L=JG?=F=ALQ /@MK
AF L@= Q=9J L@=AJ J=KH=;LAN=
K@9J=K G> L@= HGHMD9LAGF O=J= 9F< MJJ=FL +GHMD9LAGF .MJN=Q
(9J;@ .MHHD=E=FL
+24-7'5./)
74)+88
/@= <=EG?J9H@A; HJG;=KK >GJ L@= HGHMD9LAGF ;9F := <=K;JA:=< :Q L@= >GDDGOAF? KQK
L=E
$ $ $ O@=J= $ AK 9 % N=;LGJ ;GFL9AFAF? L@= E=9KMJ= G> AF<ANA<M9DK 9L
<AZ=J=FL 9?=K %
KCADD ?JGMHK @A?@
E=<AME
DGO 9F< ?JGMHK G> GJA?AF F9LAN=K
AEEA?J9FLK 9L LAE= A
9K O=DD 9K L@= D9??=< >=JLADALQ K@G;CK $ AK L@= % % HJGB=;LAGF E9LJAP ;GFL9AFAF? L@= KMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K 9F< >=JLADALQ
J9L=K G> AF<ANA<M9D ;G@GJLK 9L LAE= A
L@= KCADD HJG:9:ADALA=K
L@= F=LAEEA?J9LAGF
J9L=
9F< L@= =JJGJ HJG;=KK G> >=JLADALQ
$F L@= >GDDGOAF?
L@= ;9DA:J9LAGF G> $ $ 9F< OADD := =PHD9AF=< "AN=F
L@= ;9DA:J9LAGF
L@= +=JJGF!JG:=FAMK L@=GJ=E =FKMJ=K ;GFN=J?=F;= LG 9 KL9LAGF9JQ
HGHMD9LAGF <AKLJA:MLAGF OAL@ 9 ;GFKL9FL HGHMD9LAGF ?JGOL@ J9L=
3/9/'1 545:1'9/43 */897/(:9/43
/@= AFALA9D 9?= 9F< KCADD <AKLJA:MLAGF >GJ F9LAN=K 9F< AEEA?J9FLK
AK =KLAE9L=<
>JGE L@= 0. =;=FFA9D =FKMK 9F< L@= MJJ=FL +GHMD9LAGF .MJN=Q (9J;@ .MHHD=E=FL
+79/1/9> 7'9+8
!GDDGOAF? '== -]GK-MDD 9F< .LGJ=KD=LL=F >=JLADALQ J9L=K 9J=
<=JAN=< MKAF? L@= KH=;AS;9LAGF
$ $ G$
.== 9KO=DD >GJ 9F =P;=DD=FL =PHGKALAGF G> E9LJAP HGHMD9LAGF EG<=DK
#! $"# " & # #!# "
Life Expectancy at Birth
Total Fertility Rate
(Births per 1,000 Women 15-44 years old)
90
Data
Projection
120
80
Years
Total Fertility Rate
140
100
2000
2050
Year
2100
50
1900
2150
1940
1960
1980
Year of Birth
2000
2020
Data
Projection
3
2
1
1940 1960 1980 2000 2020 2040 2060 2080 2100 2120
Year
Population Growth Rate
2
5
Net Immigration Rate
1920
Population Growth Rate
Net Immigration Rate
(Per 1,000 in U.S. Population)
4
High-skilled
Medium-skilled
Low-skilled
60
80
60
1950
70
Data
Projection
1.5
1
0.5
1940 1960 1980 2000 2020 2040 2060 2080 2100 2120
Year
!A?MJ= =EG?J9H@A; /J9FKALAGF
X /GL9D !=JLADALQ -9L=
'A>=
H=;L9F;Q
)=L $EEA?J9LAGF -9L= 9F< +GHMD9LAGF "JGOL@ -9L=
P
O@=J= $ AK L@= E=9KMJ= G> 9?= 8 9?=FLK AF H=JAG< A 9F< AK L@= >=JLADALQ J9L=
G> L@= 9N=J9?= OGE9F 9L 9?= 8
9F< G$ AK 9F =JJGJ L=JE /@= >=JLADALQ J9L= AK
=KLAE9L=< :Q 9N=J9?AF? GN=J L@= LAE= H=JAG< )9LAGF9D =FL=J >GJ #=9DL@
.L9LAKLA;K 9F< MJ=9M G> L@= =FKMK
N9JAGMK Q=9JK /@AK AEHDA=K 9 SF9D
LGL9D >=JLADALQ J9L= G> ;GEH9J=< OAL@ AF L@= EA<<D= HJGB=;LAGFK G> L@=
0. MJ=9M G> L@= =FKMK 9F< >GJ L@= AFL=JE=<A9L= HJGB=;LAGFK G> L@=
.G;A9D .=;MJALQ <EAFAKLJ9LAGF .LGJ=KD=LL=F SF<K L@9L >GJ L@= 0.
L@= =JJGJ L=JE G$ AF L@= 9:GN= HJG;=KK ;9F := 9HHJGPAE9L=< :Q 9F - HJG;=KK
G$ G$ G$ $ #AK =KLAE9L=K
9F< 9J= MK=< @=J=
$F L@= EG<=D
G$ OADD := 9KKME=< LG >GDDGO 9 <=L=JEAFAKLA; N=JKAGF G> L@= =KLAE9L=<
- HJG;=KK
OAL@ L@= 9F< N9DM=K 9K 9 KL9JLAF? HGAFL
O@AD= K@MLLAF?
<GOF 9DD >MLMJ= K@G;CK /@= HJG;=KK AEHDA=K L@9L G$ AK ;DGK= LG R=JG 9>L=J 9:GML
LO=FLQ H=JAG<K /@= AEHDA=< >=JLADALQ J9L=K 9J= HDGLL=< AF +9F=D G> !A?MJ= #! $"# " & # #!# "
Dependency Ratio (65+/(20-64))
Dependency Ratio
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
Data
Projection
0.1
1940
1960
1980
2000
2020
2040
2060
2080
2100
2120
Year
Median Age among Workers
55
35
50
Median Age
Median Age
Median Age in Population
40
30
45
High-skilled
Medium-skilled
Low-skilled
Data
Projection
25
1950
2000
2050
Year
2100
2150
40
2000
2020
2040
2060
Year
2080
2100
2120
!A?MJ= =EG?J9H@A; /J9FKALAGF
X =H=F<=F;Q -9LAG 9F< (=<A9F
?=
#! $"# " & # #!# "
/9:D= (GJL9DALQ $F<=P :Q ?= 9F< .CADD "JGMH
?=
.CADD ?JGMH 'GO
(=<AME
#A?@
.GMJ;= ML@GJVK =KLAE9L= :9K=< GF )#.
+. (9J;@ .MHHD=E=FL )GL= /@= N9DM= >GJ L@= 9?=
?JGMH AK 9KKME=< LG := L@= K9E= 9K >GJ L@= 9?= ?JGMH 479'1/9> 7'9+8
N=J9?= EGJL9DALQ J9L=K 9J= >JGE L@= .. 9
.. 9 HJGNA<=K @AK
LGJA;9D 9F< HJGB=;L=< EGJL9DALQ J9L=K >GJ ;G@GJLK :GJF MFLAD 9L L=FQ=9J
AFL=JN9DK (GJL9DALQ J9L=K >GJ ;G@GJLK :GJF AF :=LO==F @9N= :==F G:L9AF=< :Q DAF=9J
AFL=JHGD9LAGF G@GJLK :GJF 9>L=J L@= Q=9J 9J= 9KKME=< LG >9;= L@= K9E= EGJ
L9DALQ J9L=K 9K L@= ;G@GJL .. 9 GFDQ HJGNA<=K EGJL9DALQ J9L=K >GJ E9D=K
9F< >=E9D=K K=H9J9L=DQ /G ;GEHML= EGJL9DALQ J9L=K >GJ E9D=K 9F< >=E9D=K LG?=L@=J
AL AK 9KKME=< L@9L L@= K=P J9LAG E9D=K>=E9D=K >GJ F=O:GJFK AK L@= Q=9J N9DM= >GJ 9DD ;G@GJLK
.=N=J9D KLM<A=K <G;ME=FL L@9L EGJL9DALQ J9L=K <AZ=J OA<=DQ 9;JGKK =<M;9LAGF9D
?JGMHK K== =?
DG 9F< +J=KLGF /@MK
9?= 9F< =<M;9LAGF9D <=H=F<=FL
EGJL9DALQ J9L=K 9J= ;GEHML=< 9K
@! :! @ 8 >
O@=J= @! AK L@= HJG:9:ADALQ G> <QAF? :=LO==F 9?= 8 9F< 8 >GJ 9F AF<ANA<M9D
G> LQH= > /@= H9J9E=L=J :! AK 9 >9;LGJ L@9L EMDLAHDA=K L@= 9N=J9?= EGJL9DALQ J9L=
LG ?=L L@= =<M;9LAGF9D;G@GJL KH=;AS; EGJL9DALQ J9L= /@= N9DM=K 9J= <AKHD9Q=< AF
/9:D= )GL= L@9L :! AK 9KKME=< LG := ;GFKL9FL GN=J LAE=
/@= AEHDA=< DA>= =PH=;L9F;Q 9L :AJL@ >GJ =9;@ KCADD ?JGMH AK <=HA;L=< AF !A?MJ=
+9F=D !GJ L@= ;G@GJL :GJF 9>L=J L@= Q=9J DA>= =PH=;L9F;Q 9L :AJL@ AK
9F< Q=9JK
J=KH=;LAN=DQ DGOE=<AME@A?@ KCADD=< $F ;GEH9JAKGF
L@= DA>= =PH=;L9F;Q AEHDA=< :Q L@= Q=9J EGJL9DALQ L9:D=K AK 9F< J=KH=;LAN=DQ
9L9 O9K CAF<DQ HJGNA<=< :Q !=DA;ALA= =DD
.G;A9D .=;MJALQ <EAFAKLJ9LAGF
#! $"# " & # #!# "
#0/11 574)+88
0HGF LMJFAF? LO=FLQ L@= AF<ANA<M9D >9;=K 9F =PG?=FGMK HJG:9:ADALQ
! G> :=;GEAF?
@A?@
E=<AME GJ DGO KCADD=< /@= HJG:9:ADALA=K 9J= K=L 9L ! J=KH=;LAN=DQ /@=K= S?MJ=K @9N= :==F AEHML=< >JGE L@= KCADD <AKLJA:MLAGF G> Q=9J GD<K AF L@= HGHMD9LAGF AF J=KH=;LAN=DQ 9F< J=KH=;LAN=DQ
LG?=L@=J OAL@ L@= 9;LM9D EGJL9DALQ HJG;=KK =PH=JA=F;=< :Q L@AK ;G@GJL HJGH=JDQ
9<BMKL=< >GJ KCADD <AZ=J=F;=K @AD<J=F G> AEEA?J9FLK >GDDGO L@= K9E= HJG;=KK F
AEHDA;AL 9KKMEHLAGF AK L@9L L@= HGKL22$$ AF;J=9K= AF =<M;9LAGF9D 9LL9AFE=FL ;GE=K
LG 9 @9DL /@AK AK ;GFKAKL=FL OAL@ =NA<=F;= AF 9Q 9F< 9ME9F 22/-7'9/43
/@= 9FFM9D F=L TGO G> AEEA?J9FLK AEEA?J9LAGF D=KK J=LMJF EA?J9LAGF AK K=L 9L H=J;=FL G> L@= LGL9D HGHMD9LAGF /@AK AK <=JAN=< AF L@= >GDDGOAF? O9Q L@= KLG;C G>
# *$ %)$ AEEA?J9FLK AF 9 ?AN=F Q=9J AK 9KKME=< LG >GDDGO L@= HJG;=KK %)$ #=J= %)$ AK L@= KLG;C G> AEEA?J9FLK 9L LAE= A
*$ AK L@= LGL9D HGHMD9LAGF KAR= 9L LAE=
A AK L@= >J9;LAGF G> AEEA?J9FLK J=LMJFAF? LG L@=AJ @GE=;GMFLJQ 9F< # AK L@=
AEEA?J9LAGF J9L= .MHHGK= L@9L F=LAEEA?J9LAGF ;9F := <=K;JA:=< AF L=JEK G> LGL9D
HGHMD9LAGF GFDQ
KG L@9L *$ # *$ %)$ /@=F
L@= F=LAEEA?J9LAGF J9L=
;9F
# *$ %)$ # := <=L=JEAF=< 9K *$ %)$ /@= 9FFM9D
AFTGO G> D=?9D AEEA?J9FLK
# O9K H=J;=FL G> L@= LGL9D HGHMD9LAGF AF $).
29JJ=F 9F< +=;C SF< L@9L H=J;=FL G> L@= AEEA?J9FLK AF @9<
=EA?J9L=< >JGE L@= 0. :Q HJAD /@MK
L@= =IM9LAGF HAFK <GOF L@= 9FFM9DAR=< J=LMJF EA?J9LAGF J9L=
H=J;=FL /@= KLG;C G>
AEEA?J9FLK O9K H=J;=FL G> L@= HGHMD9LAGF AF /G?=L@=J
L@AK AEHDA=K L@9L
L@= F=L TGO G> AEEA?J9FLK AK H=J;=FL G> L@= HGHMD9LAGF +9F=D G> !A?MJ=
HDGLK L@= F=LAEEA?J9LAGF J9L= AF $EEA?J9FL TGOK 9J= 9KKME=< LG >GDDGO L@= 9?= 9F< KCADD <AKLJA:MLAGF G> AEEA
?J9FLK 9JJANAF? :=LO==F +. (9J;@ .MHHD=E=FL
+24-7'5./) $7'38/9/43
/@= 9KKMEHLAGFK <=K;JA:=< 9:GN= J=KMDL AF 9 <=EG?J9H@A; LJ9FKALAGF =F<AF? AF
/@= HGHMD9LAGF ?JGOL@ J9L= <JGHK >JGE AF LG =N=FLM9DDQ
.L9LAGF9JALQ AF L@= HGHMD9LAGF <AKLJA:MLAGF AK AEHGK=< AF Q=9J /@= <=EG?J9H@A; LJ9FKALAGF
AF ?=F=J9D L9C=K DGF?=J #GO=N=J
KM:K=IM=FL J=KMDLK 9J= FGL K=FKALAN= LG L@AK 9KKMEHLAGF
#! $"# " & # #!# "
Productivity Profiles, by Age and Skill Group
2
High-skilled
Medium-skilled
Low-skilled
HS Mean
MS Mean
LS Mean
1.8
1.6
Productivity Units
1.4
1.2
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
20
30
40
50
60
Age
70
80
90
100
!A?MJ= +JG<M;LANALQ +JGSD=
:Q ?= 9F< .CADD "JGMH
K== +9F=D G> !A?MJ= /@= <=H=F<=F;Q J9LAG ;9D;MD9L=< 9K L@= HGHMD9LAGF 9?=<
9:GN= LG L@= HGHMD9LAGF 9?=< JAK=K >JGE AF L@= Q=9J LG AF
+9F=D !A?MJ= (GJ=GN=J
L@= E=<A9F 9?= AF L@= HGHMD9LAGF AF;J=9K=K
>JGE AF L@= Q=9J LG AF +9F=D !A?MJ= /@= AF;J=9K= AF L@=
E=<A9F 9?= AK HJAE9JADQ <JAN=F :Q AF;J=9K=K AF L@= E=<A9F 9?= 9EGF? @A?@ 9F<
E=<AMEKCADD=< +9F=D !A?MJ= /@= E=<A9F 9?= 9EGF? 9<MDLK JAK=K >JGE AF L@= Q=9J LG AF >GJ DGOKCADD=<
9F< >JGE LG >GJ @A?@KCADD=<
74*:)9/;/9>
+JG<M;LANALQ HJGSD=K
4! 9J= HA=;=OAK= HGDQFGEA9DK AF 9?= /@=Q 9J= <ANA<=<
AFLG L@J== K=?E=FLK 9;;GJ<AF? LG KL9?=K AF L@= DA>= ;Q;D= =<M;9LAGF
HJAE=9?=
9F<
D9L=DA>=
*:)'9/43
9K=< GF <9L9 >JGE +. GF =<M;9LAGF9D 9LL9AFE=FL :Q 9?=
AL OADD := 9KKME=<
L@9L DGO
E=<AME 9F< @A?@ KCADD=< 9J= =FJGDD=< AF HGKLK=;GF<9JQ =<M;9LAGF <MJAF?
9F< Q=9JK G> L@=AJ 9<MDL DA>=
J=KH=;LAN=DQ 2@AD= L@=AJ OGJCAF? DA>= L@MK KL9JLK
9L L@= 9?= G> 9F< J=KH=;LAN=DQ
L@=Q OADD := 9DDGO=< LG OGJC H9JLLAE=
<MJAF? L@=AJ =<M;9LAGF9D H=JAG< $F H9JLA;MD9J
L@= )9LAGF9D =FL=J >GJ <M;9LAGF9D
.L9LAKLA;K J=HGJL L@9L >MDDLAE= MF<=J?J9<M9L= KLM<=FLK OGJC GF 9N=J9?= #! $"# " & # #!# "
@GMJK H=J O==C /@=J=>GJ=
E9JC=L HJG<M;LANALQ >GJ @A?@ 9F< E=<AME KCADD=< <MJAF?
HGKLK=;GF<9JQ =<M;9LAGF AK ;9DA:J9L=< KM;@ L@9L 9N=J9?= OGJC =IM9DK @GMJK H=J
O==C AF L@= AFALA9D H=JAG< G> L@= EG<=D
7/2+'-+
+JG<M;LANALQ HJGSD=K <MJAF? HJAE= 9?= 9J= =KLAE9L=< MKAF? 9 KM:K=L G> L@= +. (9J;@ .MHHD=E=FL /@= KM:K=L ;GFKAKLK G> Q=9J GD<K O@G 9J= AF L@= D9:GJ >GJ;=
OGJCAF? >MDD LAE= 9F< @9N= J=HGJL=< HGKALAN= MKM9D D9:GJ =9JFAF?K +JG<M;LANALQ
HJGSD=K 9J= ;GEHML=< >GJ L@J== KCADD ?JGMHK K=H9J9L=DQ
MKAF? 9 E=L@G< KAEAD9J LG
#9FK=F '9+1/,+
KH=;A9DDQ AEHGJL9FL >GJ L@= IM=KLAGF 9<<J=KK=< AF L@AK H9H=J AK L@= HJG<M;LANALQ
HJGSD= K9Q
H9KL L@= 9?= G> !GJ L@AK 9?= ?JGMH
L@= K=D>K=D=;LAGF HJG:D=EK 9J=
HJ=KME9:DQ >GJEA<9:D= (GJ=GN=J
L@=Q 9J= ;GEHGMF<=< :Q L@= KE9DD K9EHD= KAR=K
9L @A?@ 9?=K
!GJ L@AK J=9KGF
9 N=JQ ;JM<= E=L@G< AK <=NAK=< LG 9HHJGPAE9L= L@= HJG<M;LANALQ
HJGSD= G> L@= =D<=JDQ IM9<J9LA; >MF;LAGF AK AFL=JHGD9L=< :=LO==F L@= HJG<M;LANALQ
9L L@= 9?= G> 9F< R=JG 9L L@= E=<A9F 9?= G> LJ9FKALAGF AFLG <AK9:ADALQ /@= E=<A9F
9?= G> LJ9FKALAGF AFLG <AK9:ADALQ
=KLAE9L=< MKAF? <9L9 >JGE L@= .MJN=Q G> $F;GE=
9F< +JG?J9E +9JLA;AH9LAGF 9J= 9?= 9F< >GJ DGO
E=<AME 9F<
@A?@KCADD=<
J=KH=;LAN=DQ /@= ;9DA:J9LAGF AEHDA=K L@9L :=LO==F 9?=K 9F< HJG<M;LANALQ <=;DAF=K 9L 9F 9FFM9D 9N=J9?= G> 9F< H=J;=FL >GJ L@= DGO
E=<AME 9F< @A?@ KCADD=<
J=KH=;LAN=DQ /@AK AK @A?@=J L@9F L@= AEHDA=< :Q L@=
HJG<M;LANALQ HJGSD= =KLAE9L=< :Q !J=F;@ 9F< ;9F L@=J=>GJ= := NA=O=< 9K 9
;GFK=JN9LAN= :=F;@E9JC
7+,+7+3)+8 '3* $+).3414->
+J=>=J=F;=K 9J= KL9F<9J< >JGE L@= EA;JG=;GFGEA; DAL=J9LMJ= GF D9:GJ KMHHDQ /@=
AFKL9FL9F=GMK MLADALQ G> 9F 9?=FL AK 9<<ALAN=DQ K=H9J9:D= AF ;GFKMEHLAGF 9F< D=AKMJ=
B! 2$ 7$ 7$ 2
$
!
/@AK >MF;LAGF9D >GJE @9K L@= 9LLJ9;LAN= HJGH=JLQ L@9L :GL@ D9:GJ KMHHDQ 9F<
L@= =D9KLA;ALQ G> D9:GJ KMHHDQ ;9F := ;9DA:J9L=< AF 9;;GJ<9F;= OAL@ =EHAJA;9D =K
#! $"# " & # #!# "
LAE9L=K /@= K=L G> H9J9E=L=JK LG?=L@=J
AEHDA=K L@9L L@= 9N=J9?= D9:GJ KMHHDQ >GJ Q=9J GD<K AK 9F< @GMJKO==C >GJ DGO
E=<AME 9F< @A?@ KCADD=<
J=KH=;LAN=DQ
A= L@= K9E= 9K AF +. (9J;@ .MHHD=E=FL (GJ=GN=J
L@= AEHDA=< !JAK;@ D9:GJ KMHHDQ =D9KLA;
&
AK 9F< J=KH=;LAN=DQ /@=K= S?MJ=K 9J= 9L
ALQ
&
% L@= EA<<D= G> L@= =EHAJA;9D =KLAE9L=K
O@A;@ LQHA;9DDQ DA= AF L@= J9F?= /@=
JAKC 9N=JKAGF H9J9E=L=J AK K=L 9L /@= HJG<M;LAGF >MF;LAGF AK KL9F<9J< G::
GM?D9K OAL@ 9 ;9HAL9D K@9J= =IM9D LG +J=K;GLL J=HGJLK 9 '/ J9LAG G>
9F< (;"J9LL9F 9F< +J=K;GLL J=HGJLK 9F 9>L=JL9P AFL=J=KL J9L= G> /@=K= L9J?=LK 9J= 9;@A=N=< AF L@AK EG<=D :Q K=LLAF? 9F< L@= <=HJ=;A9LAGF
J9L=
9L $F L@= AFALA9D H=JAG<
L@= LJ9FKALAGF AFLG J=LAJ=E=FL G;;MJK 9L 9?=K 9F<
>GJ DGO
E=<AME 9F< @A?@ KCADD=<
J=KH=;LAN=DQ $F ;GEH9JAKGF
L@= =EHAJA;9D
J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=K 9J= 9JGMF< 9F< K== !A?MJ= /@MK
L@= EG<=D <G=K
9 ?GG< BG: AF J=HDA;9LAF? J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ $L K@GMD< := =EH@9KAR=< L@9L L@=
H9J9E=L=JK @9N= FGL :==F K=L LG 9;@A=N= 9 KH=;AS; J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=
4;+732+39
34"453 15/ =;GFGEQ AK MK=< >GJ ;9DA:J9LAF? L@= H9J9E=L=JK G> L@= ?GN=JFE=FL
O@=J= L@= ;MJJ=FL KG;A9D K=;MJALQ HGDA;A=K 9J= HMJKM=< 9F< L@= ?GN=JFE=FL AK 9KKME=<
LG E9AFL9AF 9 SP=< <=:LLGGMLHML J9LAG >GJ L@= AF<=SFAL= >MLMJ=
A= L@= ?GN=JFE=FL
9<@=J=K LG 9 ;GFKL9FL <=:L JMD= /@= <=L9ADK G> L@= HJG;=<MJ= 9J= =PHD9AF=< AF L@=
G::GM?D9K KH=;AS;9LAGF AF ;GFKMEHLAGF 9F< D=AKMJ= OGMD< AEHDQ 9 LGG @A?@ 9 !JAK;@
=D9KLA;ALQ >GJ J=9DAKLA; @GMJK G> OGJC
MLADALQ >MF;LAGF G>L=F MK=< AF L@= E9;JG=;GFGEA; DAL=J9LMJ= GF D9:GJ KMHHDQ AK /@AK >MF;LAGF @9K L@= 9LLJ9;LAN= >=9LMJ= L@9L L@= !JAK;@ =D9KLA;ALQ
AK ;GFKL9FL 9F< =IM9D LG #GO=N=J
AL <G=K FGL D=F< ALK=D> O=DD LG L@= KLM<Q G> L@= J=LAJ=E=FL
<=;AKAGF !AJKL
L@= E9J?AF9D <AKMLADALQ G> OGJC 9L L@= =PL=FKAN=
E9J?AF AK DGO=J
AF L@9F AF
KAF;=
/G
K==
L@AK
FGL=
L@9L
$F ALK=D>
L@AK AK FGL 9 KMY;A=FL ;GF<ALAGF LG ;@GGK= GN=J #GO=N=J
AL LMJFK GML L@9L
>GJ J=9DAKLA; H9J9E=L=J N9DM=K AEHDA=K L@9L AF<ANA<M9DK OADD ;@GGK= LG J=LAJ= EM;@ D9L=J L@9F
O@9L AK G:K=JN=< AF L@= <9L9 .=;GF<
L@=
EG<=D 9DDGOK >GJ @=L=JG?=F=ALQ AF L@= AFLJAFKA; <=NGLAGF
LG OGJC K ;9F := K==F >JGE GFDQ @9K L@= AEHDA;9LAGF L@9L L@= E9J?AF9D N9DM=
G> J=LAJ=E=FL AF;J=9K=K AF /G ;GEHML= @GMJK G> OGJC
AK L9C=F LG := L@= E=9F @GMJK G> OGJC :=LO==F 9?=K 9F<
GEHML=< 9K L@= 9?= 9L O@A;@ 9L D=9KL H=J;=FL G> L@= KCADD ?JGMH @9K D=>L L@= D9:GJ >GJ;= +.
(9J;@ KMHHD=E=FL /@AK AK 9 N=JQ KAEHD= O9Q G> ;GEHMLAF? J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=K (GJ= 9<N9F;=<
E=L@G<K ;9F := MK=< #GO=N=J
L@=K= E=L@G<K @9N= L@=AJ K@9J= G> E=L@G<GDG?A;9D HJG:D=EK
#! $"# " & # #!# "
Labor Force Participation
90
Low-skilled
Medium-skilled
High-skilled
80
Labor Force Participation (%)
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
55
60
65
Age
70
75
!A?MJ= '9:GJ !GJ;= +9JLA;AH9LAGF -9L=
Q ?= 9F< .CADD "JGMH
HH=F<AP
!GDDGOAF? .LGJ=KD=LL=F ?GN=JFE=FL ;GFKMEHLAGF AK ;GEHML=< 9K $$ 6 $ O@=J= 6 AK ?GN=JFE=FL HMJ;@9K=K G> ?GG<K 9F< K=JNA;=K >GJ 9F AF<ANA<M9D
!
G> 9?= 8 AF L@= :9K= Q=9J 0KAF? L@= M=J:9;@ =L 9D =KLAE9L=K G> 9?=KH=;AS;
K@9J=K AF FGF .G;A9D .=;MJALQ ?GN=JFE=FL =PH=F<ALMJ=K
L@= D=N=DK G> 6 9J= ;GEHML=<
LG 9F< G> ")+ H=J ;9HAL9 >GJ 9?= ?JGMHK 9F< J=KH=;LAN=DQ /@AK AEHDA=K L@9L ?GN=JFE=FL ;GFKMEHLAGF AK G> ")+ AF L@=
SJKL H=JAG< G> L@= KL9LMKIMG =;GFGEQ
L@= K9E= 9K AF DD OGJC=JK 9J= 9KKME=< LG := =FJGDD=< AF KG;A9D K=;MJALQ /@= *D< ?= $FKMJ9F;=
*$ >GJEMD9 AK 9 >MF;LAGF G> $( $(
AK ;GEHML=< 9K L@= 9N=J9?= G>
L@= :=KL =9JFAF? Q=9JK G> OGJCDA>= 9F< AK AF<=P=< LG 9N=J9?= O9?= ?JGOL@ AF
L@= =;GFGEQ /@= >MF;LAGF 3 AK HA=;=OAK= DAF=9J OAL@ L@J== :=F< HGAFLK 0KAF?
<9L9 >JGE .. 9F< L@= 0. ;=FKMK
L@= :=F< HGAFLK 9J= K=L 9L 9F< H=J;=FL G> 9N=J9?= ?JGKK D9:GJ =9JFAF?K AF L@= =;GFGEQ /@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=K
A= L@= KDGH=K G> 3 :=LO==F L@= :=F< HGAFLK 9J= 9F< !GJ
GEHML=< 9K ;GFKMEHLAGF =PH=F<ALMJ=K D=KK ;MJJ=FL LJ9FK>=J J=;=AHLK HJAE9JADQ SF=K
>==K 9F<
<GF9LAGFK "JGKK D9:GJ =9JFAF?K O=J= AF 0. =FKMK MJ=9M
+$) 9F< L@= 9FFM9DAR=<
:J=9CHGAFLK O=J= 9F< AF L@= K9E= Q=9J .. #! $"# " & # #!# "
D9L=J MK=
<=SF= L@= KDGH=K G> 3 9K
3 F
3 F F
3
F
F
3 F
O@=J= F AK E=9F =9JFAF?K /@= !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= !- AK K=L 9L #GO=N=J
OGJC=JK 9J= =DA?A:D= >GJ *$ :=F=SLK 9L J=<M;=< J9L=K >JGE L@= 9?= G> =F=SLK 9J=
J=<M;=< :Q >GJ =9;@ Q=9J :=>GJ= !- L@= AF<ANA<M9D ;@GGK=K LG J=LAJ= J=<M;LAGF
>GJ =9JDQ J=LAJ=E=FL
- - (GJ=GN=J
A> 9 OGJC=J ;@GGK=K LG <=D9Q J=LAJ=E=FL :=QGF<
L@= 9?= G> L@= OGJC=J OADD ?=L 9 <=D9Q=< J=LAJ=E=FL ;J=<AL - G> H=J Q=9J
MFLAD L@= 9?= G> /@AK AEHDA=K L@9L L@= EGFL@DQ *$ :=F=SLK J=;=AN=< :Q 9 J=LAJ==
9J= 9F< >GJ DGO
E=<AME 9F< @A?@ KCADD=<
J=KH=;LAN=DQ /@=
9N=J9?= EGFL@DQ J=LAJ=E=FL :=F=SLK AF L@= =;GFGEQ 9J= H=J J=LAJ==
=F=SLK >JGE KMJNANGJVK AFKMJ9F;= .$
<AK9:ADALQ AFKMJ9F;= $
@GKHAL9D AF
KMJ9F;= #$
9F< L@= KM:KA<Q H9JL G> KMHHD=E=FL9JQ E=<A;9D AFKMJ9F;= .($ 9J=
EG<=DD=< 9K 9?=<=H=F<=FL DMEHKME LJ9FK>=JK .LGJ=KD=LL=F ;GEHML=< L@=K=
LJ9FK>=JK 9K 9 >MF;LAGF G> 9?=
9F< @AK =KLAE9L=K 9J= MK=< @=J= /@AK AEHDA=K L@9L
L@= LGL9D LJ9FK>=JK LG .$
$
#$ 9F< .($ 9J= G> ")+
L@= K9E= 9K AF /@MK
LGL9D GD<9?= J=D9L=< LJ9FK>=JK KL9F< 9L G> ")+
DD GL@=J LJ9FK>=JK 9L L@= >=<=J9D
KL9L= 9F< DG;9D D=N=D O=D>9J=
MF=EHDGQE=FL
:=F=SLK
KM:KA<A=K
=L;
O@A;@ KLGG< 9L G> ")+ AF 9J= =N=FDQ <AKLJA:ML=<
9;JGKK 9DD 9<MDLK 9K H9JL G> L@= LJ9FK>=J /@MK
AF L@= AFALA9D H=JAG< G> L@= <=:L
;GFKLJ9AF=< =;GFGEQ
LGL9D LJ9FK>=JK AF;D KG;A9D K=;MJALQ 9J= G> ")+
/@= AFALA9D <=:L AK K=L 9L G> ")+
=IM9D LG L@= F=L SF9F;A9D DA9:ADALA=K G> L@=
0. ?GN=JFE=FL 9L L@= =F< G> * /@= H9QJGDD L9P
AK K=L LG =IM9D LG L@= 9;LM9D ;GE:AF=< E=<A;9J=
9F< *.$ H9QJGDD L9P =EHDGQ=J 9F< =EHDGQ== /@= H9QJGDD L9P AK GFDQ D=NA=<
GF AF;GE= :=DGO 9 L@J=K@GD< D=N=D 0KAF? <9L9 >JGE .. 9F< L@= 0. ;=FKMK
L@AK
L@J=K@GD< AK K=L 9L H=J;=FL G> L@= 9N=J9?= ?JGKK D9:GJ =9JFAF?K AF L@= =;GFGEQ
/@= 9N=J9?= *$ :=F=SL >GJ 9 F=ODQ J=LAJ=< AF<ANA<M9D O9K AF .. GEHML=< 9K =PH=F<ALMJ= GF .$
#$
.($ 9F< $ F=L G> HJ=EAMEK H9A< >GJ #$ 9F< .($ G9J<
G> /JMKL==K
.AF;= L@= 9LL=FLAGF AK J=KLJA;L=< LG L@J== D9J?= ?JGMHK
FGF= G> L@= AF<ANA<M9DK OADD
AF HJ9;LA;=
@9N= 9F AF;GE= 9:GN= L@= L@J=K@GD< D=N=D
#! $"# " & # #!# "
Lump Sum Transfer Function
0.35
0.3
Share of GNP/Capita
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
0
10
20
30
40
50
Age
60
70
80
90
100
!A?MJ= 'MEH .ME /J9FK>=J !MF;LAGF
/@= :=F=SL L9P9LAGF >MF;LAGF
D=NA=K 9 E9J?AF9D L9P GF :=F=SLK 9L GJ G> L@= AF;GE= L9P J9L= $F L@= 0. L9P ;G<=
L@= L9P J9L= AK 9 >MF;LAGF G> :=F=SLK
9F< GL@=J AF;GE= $ 9:KLJ9;L >JGE L@AK :Q D=LLAF? <=H=F< GF $( GFDQ /@AK
AK OAL@GML KM:KL9FLA9D DGKK G> ?=F=J9DALQ
KAF;= $( AK @A?@DQ ;GJJ=D9L=< OAL@ :GL@
:=F=SLK 9F< FGFLJ9FK>=J AF;GE= J=;=AN=< <MJAF? J=LAJ=E=FL K== !J=F;@ /@= L9P AK D=NA=< GF $(
:=LO==F 9F< G> 9N=J9?= ?JGKK =9JFAF?K AF
L@= =;GFGEQ /@AK AK =IMAN9D=FL LG L@= L@AJ< :J9;C=L AF /@= E9J?AF9D L9P AK
;9DA:J9L=< LG KM;@ L@9L L@= J=N=FM=K >JGE L@= L9P =IM9D G> ")+
L@=
K9E= 9K AF .. 9
0F<=J L@= 34"453 15/ HGDA;Q
L@= ?GN=JFE=FL K=LK L9P=K LG :9D9F;= MF<=J
L@= 9KKMEHLAGF L@9L L@= <=:LGMLHML J9LAG J=E9AFK 9L >GJ=N=J "AN=F =PH=F
<ALMJ=K
GL@=J L9P HGDA;A=K 9F< AFALA9D <=:L
L@= AEHDA=< L9P J9L= AK L@=F 9F< L@= 9KKG;A9L=< L9P J=N=FM= AK H=J;=FL G> GMLHML /@= 9N=J9?= L9P J=N=FM= O9K H=J;=FL G> ")+ $L AK ;GEHML=< 9K
;MJJ=FL L9P J=;=AHLK HDMK ;GFLJA:MLAGFK LG ?GN=JFE=FL KG;A9D AFKMJ9F;=
D=KK L9P=K >JGE L@= J=KL G>
OGJD< $F L@= L9P J=N=FM=K KLGG< 9L H=J;=FL G> ")+ 9F< L@= KMJHDMK O9K H=J;=FL G>
")+ $F L@= EG<=D
L@AK OGMD< := 9;@A=N=< :Q 9F AF;J=9K= AF G> HGAFLK
/@= KL9LMK IMG =;GFGEQ OGMD< AEHDQ 9 ?J9<M9D AF;J=9K= AF L9P=K LG 9;;GEG<9L= L@= AF;J=9KAF?
K@9J= G> J=LAJ==K $F L@= SF9D KL=9<Q KL9L=
L@= L9P J9L= OGMD< KL9F< 9L 9JGMF< #! $"# " & # #!# "
"+8:198
/@AK K=;LAGF ;GFKA<=JK L@J== KMKL9AF9:D= SK;9D J=>GJEK 9 /9P -=>GJE /-
9 -=
HD9;=E=FL -9L= -=>GJE -- 9F< 9 J=>GJE G> L@= !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= !-
$'= 7+,472 $"
$F L@= L9P J=>GJE =;GFGEQ
L@= ;MJJ=FL KG;A9D K=;MJALQ HGDA;A=K 9J= HMJKM=< 9F< L@=
:M<?=L AK :9D9F;=< L@JGM?@ 9F AF;J=9K= AF L@= ?=F=J9D L9P J9L=
/@= =IMADA:JAME AF;GE= L9P J9L= AF L@AK =;GFGEQ AK A= HGAFLK
@A?@=J L@9F L@= AFALA9D L9P J9L= G> /@MK
9 GF;= 9F< >GJ 9DD AF;J=9K= AF L9P=K G>
H=J;=FL9?= HGAFLK OGMD< HJ==EL L@= F==< >GJ 9FQ >MLMJ= SK;9D J=>GJE 9KKG;A9L=<
OAL@ L@= <=EG?J9H@A; LJ9FKALAGF
/@= =;GFGEA; LJ9FKALAGF G> L@= /9P -=>GJE
=;GFGEQ AK <=K;JA:=< AF !A?MJ= /@= AF;J=9K= AF L@= ?=F=J9D L9P J9L= AEHDA=K
L@9L L@= ?GN=JFE=FL JMFK :M<?=L KMJHDMK=K >JGE L@= SJKL H=JAG< 9F< JMFK <GOF
<=:L +9F=D N=FLM9DDQ
L@= ?GN=JFE=FL @GD<K 9 F=L<=:L G> G> ")+ 9F<
L@= HJG;==<K ?G LG SF9F;AF? G> ?GN=JFE=FL =PH=F<ALMJ=K /@MK
L@= ?GN=JFE=FL
:=;GE=K 9 F=LD=F<=J NAK9NAK L@= HM:DA; /@= J=<M;LAGF AF ?GN=JFE=FL F=L<=:L
J=KMDLK AF >9DDAF? AFL=J=KL J9L=K K== +9F=D 9F< 9F =IMAHJGHGJLAGF9D AF;J=9K= AF L@=
O9?= J9L= +9F=D $F 9<<ALAGF
L@= <=EG?J9H@A; ;@9F?=K AEHDQ 9F AF;J=9K= AF L@=
'( J9LAG
O@A;@ 9DKG ;GFLJA:ML= LG L@= <=;DAF= 6AF;J=9K=7 AF AFL=J=KL J9L=K 6O9?=K7
(GJ=GN=J
L@= @AC= AF L@= ?=F=J9D L9P J9L= J=<M;=K L@= 9>L=JL9P J=LMJF
K@A>LAF? L@=
?J9H@ G> L@= AFL=J=KL J9L= N=JLA;9DDQ <GOF #GO=N=J
AL 9DKG J=<M;=K K9NAF? AF;=FLAN=K
O@A;@ L=F< LG AF;J=9K= L@= AFL=J=KL J9L=
$L AK AFL=J=KLAF? LG FGL= L@= J=KHGFK= AF D9:GJ KMHHDQ >GDDGOAF? L@= J=>GJE $F
H9JLA;MD9J
D9:GJ KMHHDQ E=9KMJ=< AF =Y;A=F;Q @GMJK H=J ;9HAL9 <JGHK :Q 9JGMF< MHGF L@= AEHD=E=FL9LAGF G> L@= J=>GJE +9F=D /@AK AK 9 J=KMDL G> L@= H=JE9F=FL
AF;J=9K= AF O9?=K
O@A;@ AF;J=9K=K <=E9F< >GJ D=AKMJ=
A <M= LG 9 O=9DL@ =Z=;L
9F< AA KAF;= L@= AF;GE= =Z=;L <GEAF9L=K L@= KM:KLALMLAGF =Z=;L /@=
@MEHK@9H=< <=N=DGHE=FLK AF =Y;A=F;Q @GMJK H=J ;9HAL9 9JAK= :=;9MK= L@=
;;GJ<AF? LG ..VK 9 HJGB=;LAGFK
L@= 9;LM9JA9D AE:9D9F;= >GJ 9F AFSFAL= @GJARGF ;GJJ=
KHGF<K LG 9 H=J;=FL9?= HGAFL AF;J=9K= AF L@= H9QJGDD L9P #GO=N=J
L@= .. 9 S?MJ=K 9J=
FGL <AJ=;LDQ ;GEH9J9:D=
:=;9MK= L@= EG<=D MK=< @=J= L9C=K 9 :JG9<=J NA=O G> HM:DA; SF9F;=K
:Q =? 9DKG AF;DM<AF? HM:DA; ;GFKMEHLAGF
L@= EG<=D 9;;GMFLK >GJ =F<G?=FGMK J=KHGFK=K LG
;@9F?=K AF HGDA;Q
9F< L@= L9P :9K= AK D9J?=J AF L@= EG<=D :Q 9DKG AF;DM<AF? ;9HAL9D
*F= HGKKA:D= AFL=JHJ=L9LAGF AK L@9L L@= ?GN=JFE=FL =PH9F<K L@= /JMKL !MF<
O@A;@ =N=FLM9DDQ
;GFKLALML=K G> ")+
GJ JGM?@DQ LAE=K ALK KAR= AF
9L L@= =F< G> L@= *.$ /JMKL !MF< KLGG< 9L :ADDAGF GJ G> ")+
#! $"# " & # #!# "
/9:D= /9P -=>GJE =;GEHGKALAGF G> L@= ;@9F?= AF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=
'GO KCADD=< (=<AME KCADD=< #A?@ KCADD=<
$FALA9D +=JAG<
D
D ?
? D @
? D @ :9:Q:GGE ;G@GJL =FL=JK ALK Q=9JK G> H=9C HJG<M;LANALQ 9?= :=>GJ= =N=FLM9DDQ
J=LAJAF?
/@= F=O HGDA;Q AEHDA=K 9 <=D9Q AF J=LAJ=E=FL >JGE L@= SJKL <9Q G> AEHD=E=FL9LAGF
K== !A?MJ= N=FLM9DDQ
DGO
E=<AME 9F< @A?@ KCADD=< J=LAJ= 9L 9?=K 9F<
J=KH=;LAN=DQ /9:D= <=;GEHGK=K L@= ;@9F?= AF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= !JGE L@=
AF<ANA<M9DVK H=JKH=;LAN=
>GMJ G:B=;LK ;@9F?= :=LO==F L@= AFALA9D H=JAG< 9F< L@= SF9D
KL=9<Q KL9L= O9?=K
AFL=J=KL J9L=K
KMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K 9F< L@= L9P J9L= /@= L9:D=
<=;GEHGK=K L@= ;@9F?= AF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= AFLG L@=K= >GMJ H9JLK /@MK
L@= SJKL
JGO J=HGJLK L@= GHLAE9D J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= MF<=J L@= HJA;=K
KMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K 9F<
L9P=K HJ=N9ADAF? AF L@= Q=9J :=>GJ= L@= L9P J=>GJE
A= D ? @ /@=
K=;GF< JGO <AKHD9QK L@= GHLAE9D J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= 9KKMEAF? L@9L O9?=K @9N= ;@9F?=<
LG L@=AJ F=O KL=9<QKL9L= D=N=D
A= D ? @ /@= L@AJ< JGO K@GOK J=LAJ=E=FL
9?=K O@=F O9?=K ".% AFL=J=KL J9L=K @9N= ;@9F?=<
A= D ? @ =L;
/@= AF;J=9K= AF O9?=K L=F<K LG AF;J=9K= L@= <=E9F< >GJ D=AKMJ= 9F< J=LAJ=E=FL
KAF;= L@= AF;GE= =Z=;L AK D9J?=J L@9F L@= KM:KLALMLAGF =Z=;L #GO=N=J
L@AK
=Z=;L AK KE9DD GF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL E9J?AF 9F< AK FGL J=T=;L=< AF /9:D= (GJ=GN=J
AL AK <GEAF9L=< :Q L@J== GL@=J >GJ;=K X 9DD G> L@=E J=<M;AF? L@= J=LMJFK LG K9NAF?K
/@=Q ?AN= JAK= LG 9 F=?9LAN= O=9DL@ =Z=;L J=KMDLAF? AF <=D9Q=< J=LAJ=E=FL !AJKL
L@= J=<M;LAGF AF AFL=J=KL J9L= <=HJ=KK=K L@= J=LMJF LG J=LAJ=E=FL AF;GE=
O@A;@ AK
L@= HJAE9JQ ;9MK= G> L@= J=LAJ=E=FL <=D9Q .=;GF<
L@= JAKAF? KMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K
=Z=;LAN=DQ J=<M;= L@= J=LMJFK LG 9FFMALA=K !AF9DDQ
L@= AF;J=9K= AF L@= ?=F=J9D L9P
J9L=
A J=<M;=K L@= J=LMJFK LG K9NAF?K 9F< AA J=<M;=K 9>L=JL9P =9JFAF?K GL@
>GJ;=K L=F< LG <=D9Q J=LAJ=E=FL #GO=N=J
L@= =Z=;L AK FGL KMY;A=FLDQ D9J?= LG :=
J=T=;L=< AF /9:D= /@MK
AL AK SJKL 9F< >GJ=EGKL L@= ;@9F?= AF AFL=J=KL J9L=K 9F<
KMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K L@9L <JAN=K L@= ;@9F?= AF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ
/@= EG<=D MK=K <AK;J=L= LAE= OAL@ GF=Q=9J H=JAG<K /@=J=>GJ=
E9J?AF9D ;@9F?=K AF L@=
<=E9F< >GJ J=LAJ=E=FL E9Q FGL := J=T=;L=< 9K 9;LM9D ;@9F?=K AF L@= 9?= G> J=LAJ=E=FL AF AFL=?=J
Q=9JK
-=;9DD L@9L L@= AF;GE= =Z=;L <GEAF9L=K /@MK
AA OADD J=KMDL AF AF;J=9K=< D9:GJ KMHHDQ
#! $"# " & # #!# "
Net Interest Rate
0.04
0.5
TR
RR
FR
0
-0.5
-1
2020
2040
2060
Year
2080
2100
Net Interest Rate
Debt to Output Ratio
Debt to Output Ratio
-1.5
2000
0.035
0.03
0.025
0.02
2000
2120
2020
2040
2100
2120
2020
2040
2100
2120
2020
2040
2100
2120
Wage Rate (2000=1)
1.15
1.1
1.05
Efficiency Hours/Capita
2020
2040
2060 2080 2100
Year
Efficiency Hours Per Capita (2000=1)
2120
Capital per Capita (2000=1)
Wage Rate
1.2
1
2000
2060 2080
Year
Capital Per Capita
1.5
1.25
1
2000
2060 2080
Year
Output per Capita
1.15
1
1.1
1.05
0.95
1
0.9
2000
2020
2040
2060
Year
2080
2100
2120
0.95
2000
2060
2080
!A?MJ= ;GFGEA; /J9FKALAGF
:Q -=>GJE X =:L
$FL=J=KL -9L=
29?=
-9L=
9HAL9D9HAL9
Y;A=F;Q #GMJK9HAL9
*MLHML9HAL9
#! $"# " & # #!# "
75
74
73
72
71
70
Age
69
68
67
66
65
64
High skilled
Medium skilled
Low skilled
63
62
61
-100
-80
-60
-40
-20
0
20
Age in 2000
40
60
80
100
!A?MJ= /9P -=>GJE -=LAJ=E=FL ?= :Q ?= AF 4=9J )GLA;= L@9L J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ J=KHGF<K KDGODQ /@=J= ;9F := L@J== J=9KGFK
>GJ L@= ?J9<M9D J=KHGFK= HJA;=K ;@9F?= KDGODQ
KMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K ;@9F?=
KDGODQ
GJ AL L9C=K LAE= >GJ AF<ANA<M9DK LG J=9<BMKL O=9DL@ LG F=O =;GFGEA;
;AJ;MEKL9F;=K /G >MJL@=J AFN=KLA?9L= O@Q L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= J=KHGF<K ?J9<M9DDQ
;GFKA<=J L@= >GDDGOAF? =PH=JAE=FL 9KKME= L@9L HJA;=KKMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K AEE=
<A9L=DQ 9<BMKL LG L@=AJ KL=9<QKL9L= D=N=D )=PL
J=;GEHML= L@= GHLAE9D J=LAJ=E=FL
J=KHGFK= !A?MJ= J=HGJLK L@= J=KMDLK >GJ L@= @A?@KCADD=< L@= J=KMDLK 9J= KAEA
D9J >GJ GL@=J ?JGMHK /@= >MDD :D9;C DAF= AF<A;9L=K L@= J=LAJ=E=FL J=KHGFK= O@=F
:GL@ HJA;=K 9F< KMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K AEE=<A9L=DQ BMEH LG L@=AJ F=O KL=9<QKL9L=
D=N=D /@=F
J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ AEE=<A9L=DQ 9<BMKLK /@= <GLL=< DAF= J=HJ=K=FLK
L@= J=LAJ=E=FL J=KHGFK= O@=F HJA;=K AEE=<A9L=DQ BMEH LG L@= F=O KL=9<QKL9L=
O@AD= KMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K ;@9F?= ?J9<M9DDQ /@= HMF;LM9L=< DAF= J=HJ=K=FLK L@=
J=LAJ=E=FL J=KHGFK= O@=F HJA;=K AEE=<A9L=DQ ;@9F?= LG L@= F=O KL=9<Q KL9L=
O@AD=
KMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K ;@9F?= ?J9<M9DDQ D=9JDQ
L@= ?J9<M9D J=KHGFK= G> J=LAJ=E=FL
AK E9AFDQ <JAN=F :Q L@= ?J9<M9D ;@9F?=K AF KMJNAN9D J9L=K
:ML 9DKG :Q L@= KDM??AK@
;@9F?=K AF HJA;=K
#! $"# " & # #!# "
70
69
Age
68
67
66
Steady State Prices and Survival
Steady State Survival
Steady State Prices
65
64
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Age in 2000
70
80
90
100
!A?MJ= -=LAJ=E=FL ?= G> #A?@ .CADD=< 0F<=J AZ=J=FL KKMEHLAGFK 9:GML
+JA;=K 9F< .MJNAN9D +JG:9:ADALA=K
"+51')+2+39 7'9+ 7+,472 ""
/@AK K=;LAGF ;GFKA<=JK 9 J=>GJE KMKL9AFAF? SK;9D HGDA;Q :Q J=<M;AF? L@= J=HD9;=E=FL
J9L= /.,9 /@=J= 9J= <AZ=J=FL O9QK G> J=<M;AF? L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=
:ML 9 H9J
LA;MD9JDQ KAEHD= >GJE AK ;GFKA<=J=< @=J= $F H9JLA;MD9J
L@= :=F< HGAFLK AF 9J=
9KKME=< LG J=E9AF MF;@9F?=<
O@AD= L@= KDGH=K G> L@= >MF;LAGF 9J= K@A>L=< HJGHGJ
LAGF9L=DQ $F GL@=J OGJ<K
L@= KDGH=K G> AK O@=J= AK <=SF=<
AF 9F< AK L@= >9;LGJ G> HJGHGJLAGF9DALQ /@MK
AK L@= H=J;=FL9?=
;@9F?= AF L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=
$L AK 9KKME=< L@9L L@= J=>GJE AK AEHD=E=FL=< 9L A 9F< L@9L :=F=SLK >GJ :GL@
OGJC=JK 9F< ;MJJ=FL J=LAJ==K 9J= ;@9F?=< $F 9 KMKL9AF9:D= =IMADA:JAME
O@=J= FG
GL@=J ;@9F?=K 9J= J=IMAJ=<
.G
?AN=F L@9L L@= ;MJJ=FL L9P HGDA;Q J=E9AFK
MF;@9F?=<
A= =IM9DK ALK AFALA9D D=N=D G> 9F AEE=<A9L= 9F< MFAN=JK9D
J=<M;LAGF AF L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= G> AK J=IMAJ=< #GO=N=J
=N=F MF<=J L@AK
HGDA;Q
L@= ?GN=JFE=FL :MAD<K MH 9 KM:KL9FLA9D F=L9KK=L HGKALAGF G> G> ")+ LG
K9LAK>Q L@= ?GN=JFE=FLVK DGF?JMF :M<?=L ;GFKLJ9AFL K== +9F=D G> !A?MJ= /@MK
O@AD= =PH=F<ALMJ=K >9DD AEE=<A9L=DQ 9>L=J L@= J=>GJE
<M= LG L@= MFAN=JK9D J=<M;LAGF
AF :=F=SLK
L@= KMJHDMK ?=F=J9L=< :Q C==HAF? L9P=K ;GFKL9FL AK MK=< LG 9;;MEMD9L=
>MF<K
$F;DM<AF? AF<=PAF? :=F=SLK LG AFT9LAGF J9L@=J L@9F O9?=K
#! $"# " & # #!# "
75
74
73
72
71
70
Age
69
68
67
66
65
64
High skilled
Medium skilled
Low skilled
63
62
61
-100
-80
-60
-40
-20
0
20
Age in 2000
40
60
80
100
!A?MJ= -=HD9;=E=FL -9L= -=>GJE -=LAJ=E=FL ?= :Q ?= AF 4=9J $FL=J=KL J9L=K E9AFDQ <JGH K== +9F=D >GJ L@J== J=9KGFK A L@= ?GN=JFE=FL
JMFK <GOF <=:L
AA L@= <=EG?J9H@A; ;@9F?=K AEHDQ EGJ= AF<ANA<M9DK OAL@ @A?@=J
K9NAF?K
9F< AAA K9NAF?K JAK= <M= LG L@= J=<M;LAGF AF KG;A9D K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK )GLA;=
L@9L L@= AFL=J=KL J9L= >9DDK :=DGO L@= AFL=J=KL J9L= AF L@= /9P -=>GJE =;GFGEQ
=N=F
L@GM?@ L@= ?GN=JFE=FL K9N=K D=KK /@AK E9AFDQ G;;MJK :=;9MK= L@= <=;DAF= AF :=F=SLK
AF;J=9K=K L@= AF;=FLAN= LG K9N= O@A;@ AK J=T=;L=< AF 9 @A?@=J ;9HAL9D H=J ;9HAL9 J9LAG
+9F=D DL@GM?@ O9?=K JAK= :=QGF< L@= O9?= J9L= AF L@= /9P -=>GJE =;GFGEQ
=Y;A=F;Q
@GMJK H=J ;9HAL9 9J= @A?@=J MF<=J L@= -=HD9;=E=FL -9L= -=>GJE /@AK AK HJAE9JADQ
<JAN=F :Q L@= <=D9Q AF J=LAJ=E=FL MF<=J L@= J=>GJE K== !A?MJ= O@A;@ AF;J=9K=K
=Y;A=F;Q @GMJK $F L@= SF9D KL=9<Q KL9L=
L@= DGO
E=<AME 9F< @A?@ KCADD=< J=LAJ= 9L
L@= 9?= G> 9F< J=KH=;LAN=DQ /@MK
L@= -=HD9;=E=FL -9L= -=>GJE AEHDA=K
9 Q=9J <=D9Q AF J=LAJ=E=FL
O@A;@ AK 9:GML GF= Q=9J D9L=J L@9F AF L@= /9P -=>GJE
=;GFGEQ $FL=J=KLAF?DQ
L@= 9<<ALAGF9D Q=9JK G> <=D9Q 9J= ./4 <M= LG L@= ;@9F?= AF
L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=
/9:D= <=;GEHGK=K L@= ;@9F?= AF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= AF L@= K9E= E9FF=J 9K
L9:D= K ;9F := K==F >JGE JGO 1 G> L9:D= L@= J=<M;LAGF AF L@= J=HD9;=E=FL
J9L= @9K 9 J=D9LAN=DQ KE9DD AEH9;L GF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL <=;AKAGF $F >9;L
L@= J=<M;LAGF
#! $"# " & # #!# "
/9:D= -=HD9;=E=FL -9L= -=>GJE =;GEHGKALAGF G> L@= ;@9F?= AF L@= J=LAJ=
E=FL 9?=
'GO KCADD=< (=<AME KCADD=< #A?@ KCADD=<
$FALA9D +=JAG<
D
D ?
? D @
? D @ AF :=F=SLK GFDQ AF<M;=K L@= E=<AME KCADD=< LG HGKLHGF= J=LAJ=E=FL /@= E9BGJ
<JANAF? >GJ;= >GJ L@= <=D9Q AF J=LAJ=E=FL JMFK NA9 L@= ?=F=J9D =IMADA:JAME =Z=;L
AF
H9JLA;MD9J L@= J=<M;LAGF AF AFL=J=KL J9L=K /@AK AK ;GFSJE=< :Q -GO $$$ G> /9:D=
/@= J=LAJ=E=FL J=KHGFK= AK D9J?=J L@9F AF L@= /9P -=>GJE =;GFGEQ :=;9MK= L@=
AFL=J=KL J9L= >9DDK :=DGO L@= AFL=J=KL J9L= AF L@= /9P -=>GJE =;GFGEQ
$L AK AFL=J=KLAF? LG ;GEH9J= L@= J=LAJ=E=FL J=KHGFK=K >GMF< @=J= OAL@ L@GK= >GMF<
AF L@= EA;JG=;GFGEA; DAL=J9LMJ= K E=FLAGF=< AF L@= $FLJG<M;LAGF
L@= EA;JG=;G
FGEA; KLM<A=K ?=F=J9DDQ SF< L@9L 9 J=<M;LAGF AF L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= <=D9QK
J=LAJ=E=FL :Q 9:GML EGFL@K $F ;GFLJ9KL
L@= =PH=JAE=FL @=J= K@GOK L@9L 9 J=<M;LAGF AF L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= J=KMDLK AF 9 Q=9J <=D9Q AF J=LAJ=E=FL #GO
=N=J
;GFKAKL=FL OAL@ L@= EA;JG=;GFGEA; DAL=J9LMJ=
L@= <AJ=;L =Z=;L G> L@= :=F=SL
J=<M;LAGF AK EAFGJ
9F< AL AK <O9J>=< :Q L@= AF<AJ=;L =Z=;L NA9 AFL=J=KL J9L=K /@MK
L@= =Z=;L G> 9 J=<M;LAGF AF L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= ;9F := KM:KL9FLA9DDQ D9J?=J L@9F
KM??=KL=< :Q L@= EA;JG=;GFGEA; DAL=J9LMJ=
:11 "+9/7+2+39 -+ "+,472 "
)GO
;GFKA<=J J=>GJEAF? L@= !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?=
& & AK L@= 9?= 9L O@A;@ L@=
J=LAJ== J=;=AN=K G> L@= AFKMJ9F;= 9EGMFL
;MJJ=FLDQ KL9F<AF? 9L L@= 9?= G> !GJ =9;@ Q=9J :=>GJ= & L@= AF<ANA<M9D KL9JLK ;GDD=;LAF? :=F=SLK
K@= J=;=AN=K 9 HMF
AK@E=FL G> - - $F ;GFLJ9KL
>GJ =9;@ Q=9J L@9L J=LAJ=E=FL AK <=D9Q=< :=QGF<
& 9 ;J=<AL G> AK ?AN=F - /@MK
9F AF;J=9K= AF & AEHDA=K 9 J=<M;LAGF AF
:=F=SLK >GJ 9FQ ?AN=F J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=
$L AK 9KKME=< L@9L 9 F=O & AK AEHD=E=FL=< 9L A 9F< L@9L :=F=SLK >GJ
:GL@ OGJC=JK 9F< ;MJJ=FL J=LAJ==K 9J= J=;GEHML=< AF 9;;GJ<9F;= OAL@ L@= F=O & =F=SLK ;9F KLADD := ;D9AE=< 9L L@= 9?= G> *F;= EGJ=
AL K@GMD< := KLJ=KK=< L@9L O@AD= GF L@= E9J?AF
9DD AF<ANA<M9DK <=E9F< EGJ=
J=LAJ=E=FL
L@AK AK FGL E9FA>=KL=< >GJ 9DD :=;9MK= G> L@= <AK;J=L= F9LMJ= G> 9?= AF L@= EG<=D
/@= ;MJJ=FL JMD=K @9N= 9F MHH=J :GMF< G> H=J;=FL GF L@= HMFAK@E=FL /@= MHH=J :GMF<
#! $"# " & # #!# "
75
74
73
72
71
70
Age
69
68
67
66
65
64
High skilled
Medium skilled
Low skilled
63
62
61
-100
-80
-60
-40
-20
0
20
Age in 2000
40
60
80
100
!A?MJ= !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= -=>GJE -=LAJ=E=FL ?= :Q ?= AF 4=9J $F 9 KMKL9AF9:D= =IMADA:JAME O@=J= FG GL@=J ;@9F?=K 9J= J=IMAJ=<
& /@9L AK
9F =A?@L Q=9J AEE=<A9L= 9F< MFAN=JK9D AF;J=9K= AF & KMKL9AFK SK;9D HGDA;Q
H=JH=LM9DDQ /@= ?GN=JFE=FL :MAD<K MH 9 F=L9KK=L HGKALAGF G> G> ")+ LG
SF9F;= L@= <=EG?J9H@A; ;@9F?=K
K== !A?MJ= /@= AFL=J=KL J9L= >9DDK <M= LG A
L@= J=<M;LAGF AF ?GN=JFE=FL <=:L
AA L@= <=EG?J9H@A; ;@9F?=K 9F< AAA L@= JAK=
AF K9NAF?K ;9MK=< :Q L@= !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= -=>GJE
K== +9F=D $FL=J=KLAF?DQ
L@= <QF9EA;K G> HJA;=K >GDDGOAF? L@= J=>GJE ;GAF;A<=K OAL@ L@= <QF9EA;K MF<=J L@=
-=HD9;=E=FL -9L= -=>GJE
/@= J=>GJE @9K 9 KA?FAS;9FL =Z=;L GF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL <=;AKAGF
K== !A?MJ= 0HGF AFLJG<M;AF? L@= F=O HGDA;Q
L@=J= AK SJKL 9F 9:JMHL ;@9F?= AF L@= J=LAJ=E=FL
9?=
>GDDGO=< :Q 9 ?J9<M9D AF;J=9K= $F L@= SF9D KL=9<Q KL9L=
@A?@ 9F< E=<AME
KCADD=< <=D9Q J=LAJ=E=FL :Q =A?@L Q=9JK LG L@= 9?= G> 9F< J=KH=;LAN=DQ
O@AD=
E=<AME KCADD=< <=D9Q J=LAJ=E=FL :Q FAF= Q=9JK LG L@= 9?= G> #GO=N=J
DGO 9F<
E=<AME KCADD=< KLGH OGJCAF? KGGF=J X 9L L@= 9?= G> 9F< J=KH=;LAN=DQ X :ML
AK 9:9F<GF=< AF L@AK =PH=JAE=FL .AEAD9JDQ
9;;GJ<AF? LG L@= ;MJJ=FL JMD=K
- AK FGL ?AN=F H9KL
L@= 9?= G> /@AK JMD= AK 9DKG 9:9F<GF=< AF L@= ;MJJ=FL =PH=JAE=FL
$F >9;L
L@AK J=>GJE AEHDA=K 9 H=J;=FL9?= HGAFL J=<M;LAGF AF /@= HGDA;Q L@9L D=9N=K MF;@9F?=< DA=K :=LO==F 9F< :ML L@= EG<=D GFDQ 9DDGOK >GJ AFL=?=J Q=9JK
#! $"# " & # #!# "
/9:D= !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= -=>GJE =;GEHGKALAGF G> L@= ;@9F?= AF L@= J=LAJ=
E=FL 9?=
'GO KCADD=< (=<AME KCADD=< #A?@ KCADD=<
$FALA9D +=JAG<
D
D ?
? D @
? D @ &
HGKLHGF= ;GDD=;LAF? :=F=SLK DL@GM?@ L@= R=JG ;GFKLJ9AFL GF D9:GJ KMHHDQ AK :AF<AF?
>JGE L@= 9?= G> 67 >GJ L@= DGO 6E=<AME7 KCADD=<
L@=J= 9J= KLJGF? AF;=FLAN=K LG
<=D9Q ;D9AEAF? :=F=SLK $F H9JLA;MD9J
;GDD=;LAF? :=F=SLK >JGE L@= 9?= G> 67
OGMD< AEHDQ 9 J=<M;LAGF AF :=F=SLK G> 67 H=J;=FL J=D9LAN= LG J=LAJ=E=FL 9L
& $FKL=9<
L@= OGJC=J ;@GGK=K LG KLGH OGJCAF? 9F< DAN=K GZ 9;;MEMD9L=< K9NAF?K
MFLAD AL :=;GE=K OGJL@O@AD= LG <J9O :=F=SLK Q <=D9QAF? LG ;D9AE :=F=SLK
L@= DGO
6E=<AME7 KCADD=< GFDQ >9;= 9 J=<M;LAGF AF :=F=SLK G> 67 J=D9LAN= LG ;D9AEAF?
:=F=SLK 9L & -=;9DD L@9L HJA;=K 9F< KMJNAN9D HJG:9:ADALA=K 9J= L@= K9E= AF L@= -=HD9;=E=FL
-9L= -=>GJE =;GFGEQ 9F< L@= !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= -=>GJE =;GFGEQ /@=J=>GJ=
L@= <AZ=J=F;=K AF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ :=LO==F L@=K= LOG =;GFGEA=K EMKL := <JAN=F
:Q <AZ=J=F;=K AF KG;A9D K=;MJALQ JMD=K ;GEH9JAKGF :=LO==F /9:D= 9F< /9:D= ;GFSJEK L@AK ;GFB=;LMJ= *FDQ JGO 1 <AZ=JK :=LO==F L@= LOG =;GFGEA=K /@MK
L@=
;@9F?= AF L@= !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= @9K 9F =FGJEGMK AEH9;L GF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ
/@= HGDA;Q ;@9F?= 9<<K Q=9JK LG L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=
O@A;@ 9DKG =PHD9AFK O@Q L@=
;@9F?= AF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ G;;MJK KG 9:JMHLDQ
!A?MJ= ;GEH9J=K L@= =Z=;LAN= <=H=F<=F;Q J9LAG
L@= J9LAG :=LO==F L@= FME
:=J G> :=F=S;A9JA=K 9F< L@= HGHMD9LAGF AF L@= D9:GJ >GJ;=
>GJ L@= L@J== =PH=JAE=FLK
/@=J= AK 9 D9J?= <AZ=J=F;= AF L@= =Z=;LAN= <=H=F<=F;Q J9LAG G> L@= !- J=>GJE 9F<
L@= LOG GL@=J J=>GJEK
/@MK
L@= SF<AF? @=J= AK L@9L & AK 9F AEHGJL9FL <=L=JEAF9FL G> L@= J=LAJ=E=FL
9?= /@AK =;@G=K SF<AF?K AF L@= EA;JG=;GFGEA; DAL=J9LMJ= $F H9JLA;MD9J
L@= @9R9J<
J9L= >GJ ;D9AEAF? :=F=SLK AK H9JLA;MD9JDQ D9J?= 9JGMF< L@= !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= 9F<
L@= 9JDQ -=LAJ=E=FL ?= K== =? -MKL 9F< +@=D9F 0F<=J ;MJJ=FL D=?AKD9LAGF
& AK K=L LG AF;J=9K= ?J9<M9DDQ LG =N=FLM9DDQ J=9;@ L@=
9?= G> =N=FLM9DDQ >GJ ;G@GJLK :GJF 9>L=J /@= =PH=JAE=FL ;GF<M;L=< AF L@AK
K=;LAGF KM??=KLK L@9L L@AK AK MFDAC=DQ LG ;GFLJA:ML= EM;@ LG KMKL9AF SK;9D HGDA;Q AF
L@= DGF? JMF !AJKL
:=;9MK= L@= D=?AKD9L=< ;@9F?= AF & AK O9Q LGG KE9DD LG @9N= 9FQ
#! $"# " & # #!# "
Effective Dependency Ratio
Retirees to Workers
0.4
Dependency Ratio
0.35
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
TR
RR
FR
0.1
2000
2020
!A?MJ= 2040
2060
Years
2080
2100
2120
Z=;LAN= =H=F<=F;Q -9LAG
KM:KL9FLA9D AEH9;L GF KMKL9AF9:ADALQ .=;GF<
L@= ;@9F?=
9K D=?AKD9L=<
OADD G;;MJ
?J9<M9DDQ O@A;@ E9Q := GHLAE9D >JGE 9 O=D>9J= H=JKH=;LAN= /@= =PH=JAE=FLK
;GF<M;L=< @=J= 9KKME= L@9L L@= KMKL9AF9:D= HGDA;Q AK AEHD=E=FL=< AEE=<A9L=DQ 9F<
MFAN=JK9DDQ $> L@= ;@9F?=K O=J= AFKL=9< AEHD=E=FL=< ?J9<M9DDQ
L@= J=IMAJ=< ;@9F?=K
OGMD< := =N=F D9J?=J
7+ "+9/7+2+39 "+85438+8 25479'39 ,47 #:89'/3'(/1
/9>
$K AL <=D9Q=< J=LAJ=E=FL 0&2 3& L@9L 9;@A=N=K KMKL9AF9:ADALQ GJ AK AL L@= SK;9D ;@9F?=K
/@AK K=;LAGF 9<<J=KK=K L@AK IM=KLAGF :Q D=LLAF? L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= J=E9AF ;GFKL9FL 9L
ALK AFALA9D D=N=D
9F< ;GF<M;LAF? L@= K9E= =PH=JAE=FLK 9K AF L@= HJ=NAGMK KM:K=;LAGFK
/9:D= J=HGJLK L@= J=KMDLAF? HGDA;A=K
9K ;GEH9J=< LG L@= ;9K= O@=J= J=LAJ=E=FL AK
=F<G?=FGMK
DL@GM?@ J=LAJ=E=FL J=KHGFK=K 9J= D9J?= =N=F AF L@= /9P -=>GJE =;GFGEQ
L@AK
GFDQ E9J?AF9DDQ ;GFLJA:ML=K LG KMKL9AF SK;9D HGDA;Q $F >9;L
@GD<AF? ;GFKL9FL L@=
J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= GFDQ AEHDA=K 9 H=J;=FL9?= HGAFL @A?@=J KMKL9AF9:D= L9P J9L= .AE
#! $"# " & # #!# "
/9:D= J= -=LAJ=E=FL -=KHGFK=K $EHGJL9FL
!AP=< -=LAJ=E=FL
F<G?=FGMK -=LAJ=E=FL
/9P -=>GJE
-=HD9;=E=FL -9L= -=>GJE
& !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= -=>GJE
& AD9JDQ
L@= -=HD9;=E=FL -9L= -=>GJE =;GFGEQ J=IMAJ=K 9 ;ML AF :=F=SLK LG
KMKL9AF SK;9D HGDA;Q O@=F L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= AK @=D< SP=< /@MK
J=LAJ=E=FL J=
KHGFK=K ;GFLJA:ML= HGKALAN=DQ LG KMKL9AF9:ADALQ MF<=J L@=K= LOG J=>GJEK
:ML GFDQ
E9J?AF9DDQ KG /@= J=9KGF AK L@9L 0. KG;A9D K=;MJALQ AK JGM?@DQ 9;LM9JA9DDQ >9AJ
/@MK
L@= HJ=K=FL <AK;GMFL=< N9DM= G> :=F=SLK AK JGM?@DQ L@= K9E=
AJJ=KH=;LAN= G>
L@= ;@GA;= G> J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= /@9L AK
EGKL G> L@= =Z=;L GF HM:DA; ;GZ=JK AK <M= LG
L@= E=;@9FA;9D =Z=;L G> ;@9F?AF? :=F=SLK GJ L9P=K ;> GAD= 9F< "JM:=J 0F<=J L@= !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= -=>GJE
:=@9NAGJ9D J=KHGFK=K 9J= ;JM;A9D $F
>9;L
@GD<AF? L@= J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= ;GFKL9FL
AL OGMD< := KMY;A=FL LG ;@9F?= & LG
9?= LG KMKL9AF SK;9D HGDA;Q .AF;= AF<ANA<M9DK AF L@AK =PH=JAE=FL 9J= MF9:D= LG
J=KHGF< LG L@= ;@9F?= AF & L@=Q 9J= >GJ;=< LG 9;;=HL D9J?= ;MLK AF :=F=SLK
<M= LG
L@= HMFAK@E=FL >GJ =9JDQ J=LAJ=E=FL /@AK 9DKG =PHD9AFK O@Q KM;@ 9 D9J?= ;@9F?= AF
& AK J=IMAJ=< LG KMKL9AF SK;9D HGDA;Q $F<ANA<M9DK J=KHGF< :Q <=D9QAF? J=LAJ=E=FL
L@=J=:Q GZK=LLAF? L@= J=<M;LAGF AF :=F=SLK AEHDA=< :Q L@= AF;J=9K= AF & #+38/9/;/9>
/@AK K=;LAGF KLM<A=K L@= K=FKALANALQ G> L@= EG<=D $F 9 SJKL =PH=JAE=FL
L@= EG<=D
AK J=;9DA:J9L=< LG 9 F=LAFL=J=KL J9L= G> O@A;@ KA?FAS;9FLDQ J=<M;=K L@= J=IMAJ=<
SK;9D J=KHGFK=K G> L@= ?GN=JFE=FL K== /9:D= !GJ AFKL9F;=
L@= L9P @AC= J=IMAJ=<
LG KMKL9AF SK;9D HGDA;Q AK GFDQ H=J;=FL9?= HGAFLK /@= J=9KGF AK L@9L L@= J=LMJF
GF L@= ?GN=JFE=FLVK 9KK=LK AK D9J?=J
O@A;@ AEHDA=K L@9L 9 KE9DD=J F=L9KK=L HGKALAGF
AK J=IMAJ=< LG KMKL9AF SK;9D HGDA;Q /@= J=LAJ=E=FL J=KHGFK=K 9J= KLADD KM:KL9FLA9D
KAF;= L@= AFL=J=KL J9L= 9DKG <JGHK AF L@AK =;GFGEQ $L AK AFL=J=KLAF? LG FGL= L@9L L@=
& J=IMAJ=< LG KMKL9AF SK;9D HGDA;Q AK GFDQ AF L@AK =;GFGEQ
$F 9 K=;GF< =PH=JAE=FL
L@= EG<=D AK J=;9DA:J9L=< LG GFDQ @9NAF? GF= KCADD?JGMH
/9:D= .=FKALANALQ
=F;@E9JC )=L$FL=J=KL -9L= *F= .CADD"JGMH
/9P -=>GJE
HGAFLK
-=HD9;=E=FL -9L= -=>GJE
!MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= -=>GJE
& #! $"# " & # #!# "
/@AK KCADD?JGMH @9K L@= 9N=J9?= HJG<M;LANALQ HJGSD= G> L@= :=F;@E9JC =;GFGEQ
$F L@AK =;GFGEQ
SK;9D 9<BMKLE=FLK 9J= KE9DD=J L@9F AF L@= :=F;@E9JC ;9K= /@=
HJAE9JQ J=9KGF AK L@9L L@= @A?@ 9F< E=<AMEKCADD=< ;GFKLALML= 9 D9J?=J >J9;LAGF
G> J=LAJ==K AF L@= >MLMJ= /@=K= ?JGMHK J=;=AN= @A?@=J KG;A9D K=;MJALQ :=F=SLK )GL
9;;GMFLAF? >GJ L@AK ;GEHGKALAGF9D =Z=;L J=KMDLK AF 9F MF<=J=KLAE9L= G> L@= KG;A9D
K=;MJALQ DA9:ADALA=K
!MLMJ= OGJC K@GMD< 9DKG =PHDGJ= L@= K=FKALANALQ OAL@ J=KH=;L LG L@= HJG<M;LANALQ
HJGSD=K 9L GD< 9?= 9F< L@= !JAK;@ =D9KLA;ALQ
43)1:*/3- "+2'708
/@AK H9H=J E9C=K >GMJ ;GFLJA:MLAGFK LG L@= ;MJJ=FL <=:9L= GF L@= KMKL9AF9:ADALQ
G> SK;9D HGDA;Q !AJKL
AL <=N=DGHK 9 >J9E=OGJC O@=J= SK;9D KMKL9AF9:ADALQ 9F< L@=
J=LAJ=E=FL <=;AKAGF 9J= BGAFLDQ <=L=JEAF=< .=;GF<
L@= H9H=J K@GOK L@9L L@= =Z=;L
G> KG;A9D K=;MJALQ J=>GJE GF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ ;9F := EM;@ D9J?=J L@9F O@9L AK
KM??=KL=< :Q L@= EA;JG=;GFGEA; DAL=J9LMJ= J=<M;LAGF AF L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L=
>GJ
=P9EHD=
AF;J=9K=K K9NAF? 9F< J=<M;=K AFL=J=KL J9L=K DGO=J AFL=J=KL J9L=
AF LMJF
AF<M;=K 9 <=D9Q AF J=LAJ=E=FL /@AK AF<AJ=;L =Z=;L G> J=>GJE AK KM:KL9FLA9DDQ D9J?=J
L@9F L@= <AJ=;L =Z=;L G> J=<M;AF? L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= /@= H9H=J 9DKG K@GOK L@9L
;@9F?=K AF L@= !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= ;9F @9N= 9 D9J?= AEH9;L GF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ
$F L@AK ;9K=
L@= AF<M;=< ;@9F?= AF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ AK :GL@ <M= LG L@= <AJ=;L
=Z=;L 9F< L@= AF<AJ=;L ?=F=J9D =IMADA:JAME =Z=;L /@AJ<
L@= H9H=J ;GFKLJM;LK L@J==
HGDA;A=K L@9L KMKL9AF SK;9D HGDA;Q AF L@= >9;= G> L@= 9?AF? HGHMD9LAGF A AEE=<A9L=DQ
J9AKAF? L@= ?=F=J9D L9P J9L= :Q H=J;=FL9?= HGAFLK
AA AEE=<A9L=DQ 9F< MFAN=JK9DDQ
J=<M;AF? L@= J=HD9;=E=FL J9L= :Q 9L MF;@9F?=< L9P=K GJ AAA AEE=<A9L=DQ 9F<
MFAN=JK9DDQ J9AKAF? L@= !MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= LG 9L MF;@9F?=< L9P=K /@= H9H=J
SF<K L@9L L@= K=L G> KMKL9AF9:D= SK;9D HGDA;A=K ;GFKA<=J=< @=J= J=<M;=K L@= AFL=J=KL
J9L=K :Q :9KAK HGAFLK GN=J L@= DGF? L=JE 9F< <=D9QK J=LAJ=E=FL :Q Q=9JK
<=H=F<AF? GF L@= J=>GJE #GO=N=J
9 <=D9Q AF J=LAJ=E=FL AK FGL AF ALK=D> KMY;A=FL LG
KMKL9AF SK;9D HGDA;Q /@= J=9KGF AK L@9L L@= 0. KG;A9D K=;MJALQ KQKL=E AK JGM?@DQ
9;LM9JA9DDQ >9AJ
O@A;@ AEHDA=K L@9L =N=F OAL@ D9J?= ;@9F?=K AF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ
L@= 0. ?GN=JFE=FL OADD @9N= LG E9C= E9BGJ SK;9D 9<BMKLE=FLK LG KMKL9AF SK;9D
HGDA;Q
FME:=J G> ;9N=9LK 9J= AF HD9;= @=J= !AJKL
L@= EG<=D 9KKME=K AF<ANA<M9DK LG
@9N= FG :=IM=KL EGLAN= .=N=J9D H9H=JK 9J?M= L@9L L@AK AK AEHGJL9FL >GJ 9;@A=NAF?
J=9DAKLA; O=9DL@ <AKLJA:MLAGFK K== =? = )9J<A 9F< 9?=LLA 9F< = )9J<A
#! $"# " & # #!# "
!MLMJ= OGJC K@GMD< 9DDGO >GJ 9 :=IM=KL EGLAN= $F H9JLA;MD9J
9DD K9NAF?K
AF L@= EG<=D 9J= <M= LG DA>=;Q;D= K9NAF?K /@=J=>GJ=
;@9F?=K AF L@= KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
KQKL=E OADD @9N= 9 D9J?= =Z=;L GF AFL=J=KL J9L=K $FLJG<M;AF? 9 :=IM=KL EGLAN= AK DAC=DQ
LG J=<M;= L@= =Z=;L GF L@= AFL=J=KL J9L= G> J=>GJEAF? KG;A9D K=;MJALQ
9F< OADD L@=J=>GJ=
9DKG EALA?9L= L@= =Z=;L GF J=LAJ=E=FL :=@9NAGJ #GO=N=J
KAF;= L@= =Z=;L AF L@AK
EG<=D H9JLDQ KL=EK >JGE ?GN=JFE=FL K9NAF?K
L@= E9AF ;GF;DMKAGF AK DAC=DQ LG J=E9AF
MF;@9F?=< .=;GF<
9FFMALQ E9JC=LK 9J= KE9DD AF HJ9;LA;= A;@=F:9ME 9F< +=D=<
!MLMJ= OGJC K@GMD< L@=J=>GJ= ;GFKA<=J 9F =FNAJGFE=FL OAL@GML 9FFMALQ
E9JC=LK /@AJ<
L@= EG<=D 9KKME=K L@9L L@= 0. ?GN=JFE=FL L9C=K AEE=<A9L=
9;LAGF LG KMKL9AF SK;9D HGDA;Q =D9QAF? L@= J=>GJE OADD AEHDQ L@9L D9J?=J ;@9F?=K
AF SK;9D HGDA;Q 9J= J=IMAJ=<
>GJ LOG J=9KGFK A L@= 0. ?GN=JFE=FL GH=J9L=K AF
9 OAF<GO G> GHHGJLMFALQ /@= <=EG?J9H@A; ;@9F?=K OADD E9FA>=KL L@=EK=DN=K 9F< J=>GJEK AEHD=E=FL=< HJAGJ LG L@9L 9J= DAC=DQ LG ;GFKA<=J9:DQ =9K= L@=
LJ9FKALAGF AA $> FG 9;LAGF AK L9C=F FGO
<=:L AK DAC=DQ LG AF;J=9K= AF L@= K@GJL L=JE
E9CAF? L@= J=IMAJ=< SK;9D 9<BMKLE=FLK =N=F D9J?=J !MLMJ= OGJC K@GMD< ;GFKA<=J
J=>GJEK AEHD=E=FL=< 9L D9L=J <9L=K
$F L@= L9P J=>GJE =;GFGEQ
>GJ AFKL9F;=
L@= J=<M;LAGF AF AFL=J=KL J9L=K E9AFDQ KL=EK >JGE L@=
AF;J=9K= AF ?GN=JFE=FL K9NAF?K
#! $"# " & # #!# "
/(1/4-7'5.>
67 LL9F9KAG
*J9RAG
.9?AJA &AL9G
9F< "AGN9FFA ' 1AGD9FL= "DG:9D =
EG?J9@A; /J=F<K 9F< .G;A9D .=;MJALQ -=>GJE
(AE=G
67 M=J:9;@
9F< ' &GLDACGZ 9."-*$ *3$", /,*$9
9E:JA<?= 0FA
N=JKALQ +J=KK
67 )9LAGF9D $F;GE= 9F< +JG<M;L ;;GMFLK /9:D=K
9N9AD9:D= 9L
OOO:=9?GN
67 =F+GJ9L@
4GJ9E
/@= +JG<M;LAGF G> #ME9F 9HAL9D 9F< L@= 'A>=Q;D= G>
9JFAF?K
/52.", /' /,*4*$", $/./-9 67 D9F;@9J<
*DANA=J % .M??=KLAGFK >GJ 9 )=O .=L G> !AK;9D $F<A;9LGJK
* 2GJCAF? +9H=J )G 67 JGOFAF?
(9JLAF 9F< '9JK +=L=J #9FK=F 9F< %9E=K #=;CE9F (A;JG
9L9 9F< "=F=J9D
IMADA:JAME (G<=DK
AF %G@F /9QDGJ 9F< (A;@9=D 2GG<>GJ<
=< ".%#//+ /' "$2/&$/./-*$3
1GDME= )GJL@ #GDD9F<
EKL=J<9E
67 MJLD=KK
" .G;A9D .=;MJALQ
0F9FLA;AH9L=< =F=SL $F;J=9K=K
9F< L@=
/AEAF? G> -=LAJ=E=FL
&6*&7 /' $/./-*$ 45%*&3 67 9?=LLA
(9J;G 9F< (9JA9;JAKLAF9 = )9J<A 2=9DL@ $F=IM9DALQ 9L9 9F<
(G<=DK
!=<=J9D -=K=JN= 9FC G> @A;9?G
2GJCAF? +9H=J
)G 67 9KO=DD
#9D (9LJAP +GHMD9LAGF (G<=DK GFKLJM;LAGF
F9DQKAK
9F<
$FL=JHJ=L9LAGF
F< =<
.AF9M=J KKG;A9L=K
(9KK9;@MK=LLK
67 GF?J=KKAGF9D M<?=L *Y;= )& /.( &2- 5%(&4 54,//+
=;=E:=J
67 GF=K9
%M9F 9F< AJC &JM=?=J .G;A9D .=;MJALQ -=>GJE OAL@ #=L
=JG?=FGMK ?=FLK
&6*&7 /' $/./-*$ 9."-*$3
1GD #! $"# " & # #!# "
67 GAD=
GMJLF=Q 9F< %GF9L@9F "JM:=J .G;A9D .=;MJALQ 9F< -=LAJ=E=FL
) - 2GJCAF? +9H=JK )9LAGF9D MJ=9M G> ;GFGEA; -=K=9J;@
67 GAD=
GMJLF=Q 9F< %GF9L@9F "JM:=J .G;A9D .=;MJALQ $F;=FLAN=K >GJ
-=LAJ=E=FL
) - 2GJCAF? +9H=JK )9LAGF9D MJ=9M G> ;GFGEA; -=K=9J;@
67 MJJ=FL +GHMD9LAGF .MJN=Q
19JAGMK 4=9JK (9J;@ .MHHD=E=FL
MJ=9M G>
'9:GJ .L9LAKLA;K 9;;=KK=< NA9 9L9!=JJ=L
67 9Q
%=FFA>=J 9F< &MJL % 9ME9F #9N= 2= -=9;@=< L@= /GH
<M;9LAGF9D LL9AFE=FL +JGB=;LAGFK >GJ L@= 0. +GHMD9LAGF
0. =FKMK MJ=9M
+GHMD9LAGF ANAKAGF
2GJCAF? +9H=J .=JA=K )G 67 = )9J<A
(9JA9;JAKLAF9 .=DG $EGJG@GJG?DM
9F< /@GE9K % .9J?=FL +JGB=;L=< 0. =EG?J9H@A;K 9F< .G;A9D .=;MJALQ
&6*&7 /' $/./-*$ 9."-*$3
X
67 = )9J<A
(9JA9;JAKLAF9 2=9DL@ $F=IM9DALQ 9F< $FL=J?=F=J9LAGF9D 'AFCK
&6*&7 /' $/./-*$ 45%*&3
%MDQ NGD F HH 67 A9EGF<
+=L=J )9LAGF9D =:L AF 9 )=G;D9KKA;9D "JGOL@ (G<=D
-&2
*$". $/./-*$ &6*&7 67 A9EGF<
+=L=J (9;JG=;GFGEA; KH=;LK G> .G;A9D .=;MJALQ -=>GJE
JGGCAF?K +9H=JK GF ;GFGEA; ;LANALQ
67 A9EGF<
+=L=J /@=
;GFGEA;K G> .G;A9D .=;MJALQ -=>GJE
) -
2GJCAF? +9H=J )9LAGF9D MJ=9M G> ;GFGEA; -=K=9J;@
67 A9EGF<
+=L=J .G;A9D .=;MJALQ
-&2*$". $/./-*$ &6*&7
1GD )G 67 A9EGF<
+=L=J 9F< %GF9L@9F "JM:=J .G;A9D .=;MJALQ 9F< -=LAJ=E=FL
AF L@= 0.
) - 2GJCAF? +9H=J 67 ##. #=9DL@
0FAL=< .L9L=K
.H=;A9D
P;=JHL /J=F< /9:D=K GF
9F< *D<=J +GHMD9LAGF
=H9JLE=FL G> #=9DL@ 9F< #ME9F .=JNA;=K HM:DA;9LAGF
FG 67
A;@=F:9ME
(9JLAF . 9F< 9F +=D=< 9HAL9D ;;MEMD9LAGF 9F< FFM
ALA=K AF 9F <N=JK= .=D=;LAGF
;GFGEQ
/52.", /' /,*4*$", $/./-9
0FAN=JKALQ
G> @A;9?G +J=KK
NGD H9?=K #! $"# " & # #!# "
67
DG
$JE9 / 9F< .9EM=D # +J=KLGF <M;9LAGF9D AZ=J=FLA9DK AF (GJ
L9DALQ 0FAL=< .L9L=K
/$ $* &% 1GD )G 67
AK=FK==
/@GE9K !AK;9D +GDA;Q 9F< -=LAJ=E=FL AF L@= /O=FLA=L@ =F
LMJQ
(AE=G
67 GE=AB
9NA< 9F< (9JLAF !DG<\F /@= '9:GJ.MHHDQ
D9KLA;ALQ 9F<
GJJGOAF? GFKLJ9AFLK 2@Q KLAE9L=K 9J= A9K=<
(AE=G
67 !=D<KL=AF
(9JLAF . 9F< 'A=:E9F
%=ZJ=Q .G;A9D .=;MJALQ
AF D9F
% M=J:9;@ 9F< (9JLAF !=D<KL=AF <K ".%#//+ /' 5#,*$ $/./-*$3 1GD EKL=J<9E
DK=NA=J .;A=F;=
)GJL@#GDD9F<
HH
67 !J=F;@
JA; /@= Z=;L G> #=9DL@
2=9DL@ 9F< 29?=K GF '9:GJ .MHHDQ
9F< -=LAJ=E=FL =@9NAGJ
>GJL@;GEAF? AF &6*&7 /' $/./-*$ 45%*&3
67 !JA=<:=J?
'=GJ9 /@= '9:GJ .MHHDQ Z=;LK G> L@= .G;A9D .=;MJALQ 9JF
AF?K /=KL
) - 2GJCAF? +9H=JK )9LAGF9D MJ=9M G> ;GFGEA; -=K=9J;@
67 "JM:=J
%GF9L@9F 9F< 9NA< 2AK= .G;A9D .=;MJALQ 9F< -=LAJ=E=FL
JGMF< L@= 2GJD<
0FAN=JKALQ G> @A;9?G +J=KK
67 "MKLE9F
D9F ' 9F< /@GE9K .L=AFE=A=J
-=LAJ=E=FL 9F< 2=9DL@
) 2GJCAF? +9H=J 2
)9LAGF9D MJ=9M G> ;GFGEA; -=K=9J;@
67 #9FK=F
"9JQ /@= Q;DA;9D 9F< .=;MD9J =@9NAGMJ G> L@= '9:GJ $F
HML GEH9JAF?
Y;A=F;Q 0FALK 9F< #GMJK 2GJC=<
/52.", /' 00,*&% $/./
-&42*$3
1GD HH 67 #=9L@;GL=
%GF9L@9F
&B=LAD .LGJ=KD=LL=F 9F< "AGN9FFA ' 1AGD9FL= /@=
JGKK.=;LAGF9D $EHDA;9LAGFK G> -AKAF? 29?= $F=IM9DALQ AF L@= 0FAL=< .L9L=K
(AE=G
67 #GDRE9FF
-G:=JL 9F< -A;9J< #AFR *D< ?= $F;GE= .MHHGJL AF L@=
KL =FLMJQ
2GJD< 9FC
29K@AF?LGF 67 #M??=L
(9JC 9F< "MKL9NG 1=FLMJ9 *F L@= AKLJA:MLAGF9D
Z=;LK G>
.G;A9D .=;MJALQ -=>GJE
&6*&7 /' $/./-*$ 9."-*$3
1GD 67 &GLDACGZ
'9MJ=F;= %
&=FL .E=LL=JK 9F< %9F 29DDAK=J !AF<AF? 9 29Q
*ML G> E=JA;9VK AD=EE9
) - 2GJCAF? +9H=J #! $"# " & # #!# "
67 '==
-GF9D< (G<=DDAF? 9F< !GJ=;9KLAF? L@= /AE= .=JA=K G> 0. !=J
LADALQ ?= AKLJA:MLAGF
-9F?=
9F< 0DLAE9L= '=N=D
.4&2."4*/.", /52.", /'
/2&$"34*.( 67 'AF<:=;C
KK9J 9F< (9LK +=JKKGF /@= "9AFK >JGE +=FKAGF -=>GJE
/52.", /' $/./-*$ *4&2"452&
1GDME= 3'$ 67 'MEK<9AF=
-G:AF ' 9F< *DANA9 . (AL;@=DD )=O =N=DGHE=FLK AF L@=
;GFGEA; F9DQKAK G> -=LAJ=E=FL
".%#//+ /' "#/2 $/./-*$3
1GD < *
K@=F>=DL=J 9F< 9J<
DK=NA=J .;A=F;=
67 (9JL]F
D>GFKG - .[F;@=R F<G?=FGMK -=LAJ=E=FL 9F< +M:DA; +=FKAGF .QK
L=E -=>GJE AF .H9AF
(AE=G
67 (;"J9LL9F
DD=F - 9F< <O9J< +J=K;GLL N=J9?= <=:L 9F< =IMALQ
J=LMJFK HMRRDAF?
-&2*$". $/./-*$ &6*&7
)G HH 67 )9LAGF9D =FL=J >GJ #=9DL@ .L9LAKLA;K )9LAGF9D 1AL9D .L9LAKLA;K -=HGJLK
1GD )G )9LAGF9D =FL=J >GJ #=9DL@ .L9LAKLA;K
67 )9LAGF9D =FL=J >GJ #=9DL@ .L9LAKLA;K 9
(GJL9DALQ 9L9 0F<=JDQAF?
9MK=G>=9L@ +M:DA;0K= 9L9SD=K
9N9AD9:D= 9L 9L9!=JJ=L
67 )9LAGF9D =FL=J >GJ
<M;9LAGF .L9LAKLA;K 0F<=J?J9<M9L=K 2@G 2GJC
0. =H9JLE=FL G> <M;9LAGF
) . 67 )AK@AQ9E9
.@AFA;@A F9DQRAF? 9F ?AF? +GHMD9LAGF X QF9EA; "=F
=J9D IMADA:JAME HHJG9;@
(AE=G
67 * 67 *JKR9?
+=L=J - 9F< %GK=H@
.LA?DALR -=L@AFCAF? +=FKAGF -=>GJE
/=F (QL@K 9:GML .G;A9D .=;MJALQ -=>GJE
AF -G:=JL #GDRE9FF 9F< %GK=H@
.LA?DALR <
&7 %&"3 #/54 ,% (& &$52*49
2GJD< 9FC
29K@AF?LGF 67 +J=K;GLL
<O9J< 2@Q G E=JA;9FK 2GJC .G (M;@ (GJ= /@9F
MJGH=9FK
&%&2", &3&26& ".+ /' *..&"0/,*3 5"24&2,9 &6*&7
1GD )G
HH 67 -]GK-MDD
1A;LGJ +GHMD9LAGF @9F?=K 9F< 9HAL9D ;;MEMD9LAGF /@=
?AF? G> L@= 9:Q GGE
<N9F;=K AF (9;JG=;GFGEA;K
/@= %GMJF9D AF
(9;JG=;GFGEA;K
1GD )G #! $"# " & # #!# "
67 -MKL
%G@F 9F< @JAKLGH@=J +@=D9F #GO .G;A9D .=;MJALQ 9F< (=<A;9J=
Z=;L -=LAJ=E=FL AF 9 2GJD< G> $F;GEHD=L= (9JC=LK
$/./-&42*$"
1GD )G
HH 67 .LGJ=KD=LL=F
&B=LAD .MKL9AFAF? !AK;9D +GDA;Q /@JGM?@ $EEA?J9LAGF
/52.", /' /,*4*$", $/./-9
NGD HH 67 .G;A9D .=;MJALQ <EAFAKLJ9LAGF 9
/@= FFM9D -=HGJL G> L@= G9J<
G> /JMKL==K G> L@= !=<=J9D *D<?= 9F< .MJNANGJK $FKMJ9F;= 9F< AK9:ADALQ $FKMJ
9F;= /JMKL !MF<K
29K@AF?LGF
67 .G;A9D .=;MJALQ <EAFAKLJ9LAGF 9
/@= FFM9D -=HGJL G> L@= G9J<
G> /JMKL==K G> L@= !=<=J9D *D<?= 9F< .MJNANGJK $FKMJ9F;= 9F< AK9:ADALQ $FKMJ
9F;= /JMKL !MF<K
29K@AF?LGF
67 .G;A9D .=;MJALQ <EAFAKLJ9LAGF 9
/@= FFM9D -=HGJL G> L@= G9J<
G> /JMKL==K G> L@= !=<=J9D *D<?= 9F< .MJNANGJK $FKMJ9F;= 9F< AK9:ADALQ $FKMJ
9F;= /JMKL !MF<K
29K@AF?LGF
67 .G;A9D .=;MJALQ <EAFAKLJ9LAGF
19JAGMK 4=9JK
FFM9D .L9LAKLA;9D .MHHD=E=FL
LG L@= .G;A9D .=;MJALQ MDD=LAF
29K@AF?LGF
67 .MJN=Q G> $F;GE= 9F< +JG?J9E +9JLA;AH9LAGF !MF;LAGF9D 'AEAL9LAGFK
9F< AK9:ADALQ X <MDLK
29N= 67 $). !AK;9D 4=9J 4=9J:GGC G> $EEA?J9LAGF .L9LAKLA;K
29K@AF?LGF
67 0. MJ=9M G> L@= =FKMK )+/ .MEE9JQ G> !=JLADALQ
(GJL9DALQ
9F< (A?J9LAGF KKMEHLAGFK :Q -9;= 9F< #AKH9FA; *JA?AF 'GO=KL
(A<<D=
9F<
#A?@=KL .=JA=K
LG 29K@AF?LGF
67 0. MJ=9M G> L@= =FKMK
N9JAGMK Q=9JK
.L9LAKLA;9D :KLJ9;L G> L@= 0FAL=<
.L9L=K
67 29JJ=F
-G:=JL 9F< %=FFA>=J (9JCK +=;C !GJ=A?FGJF EA?J9LAGF >JGE
L@= 0FAL=< .L9L=K
&-/(2"0)9
1GD )G !=:JM9JQ
HH #! $"# " & # #!# "
$.+ 1-47/9.2
$.+ #9'9:8 !:4 )4342>
/@= LJ9FKALAGF H9L@ G> 9 EG<=D ;9F := KM:KL9FLA9DDQ 9Z=;L=< :Q L@= ;@GA;= G> AFA
LA9D ;GF<ALAGFK /@=J=>GJ=
AL AK ;JM;A9D LG ;9DA:J9L= AFALA9D ;GF<ALAGFK AF 9 O9Q KM;@
L@9L L@=Q <G FGL 9Z=;L L@= KM:K=IM=FL HGDA;Q =PH=JAE=FLK AF 9 KM:KL9FLAN= O9Q
/@AK HJG:D=E AK =KH=;A9DDQ <AY;MDL LG @9F<D= AF EG<=DK LJQAF? LG J=HDA;9L= L@= <=
EG?J9H@A; <=N=DGHE=FLK GN=J L@= HJ=K=FL ;=FLMJQ /@AK K=;LAGF =PHD9AFK @GO L@=
AFALA9D ;GF<ALAGFK 9J= ?=F=J9L=< >GJ L@AK H9H=J
/G ;9DA:J9L= L@= ?GN=JFE=FL K=;LGJ G> L@= =;GFGEQ 9F< ?=L L@= AFALA9D ;GF<ALAGFK
>GJ 9KK=L @GD<AF?K 9F< H9KL =9JFAF?K 9;JGKK ;G@GJLK 9F< KCADD ?JGMHK
9 4"453 5/
$/./-9 AK MK=< /@= .L9LMK ,MG ;GFGEQ AK ;@9J9;L=JAR=< :Q @9NAF? L@= HGHMD9
LAGF <AKLJA:MLAGF G> L@= 0. AF L@= Q=9J 9F< L@= ;JGKKK=;LAGF9D KMJNAN9D
D=9JDQ
L@=K= LOG 9J= FGL BGAFLDQ ;GFKAKL=FL OAL@
J9L=K G> L@= Q=9J @
9 KL9LAGF9JQ HGHMD9LAGF <AKLJA:MLAGF $F H9JLA;MD9J
<=SF= L@= KL9LAGF9JQ HGHMD9LAGF
9F< L@= HGHMD9LAGF ?JGOL@ J9L= ; :Q ;
<AKLJA:MLAGF 9KKG;A9L=< OAL@ @
/@=F
; >GJ 9FQ ; $F GL@=J OGJ<K
AL AK FGL HGKKA:D= LG KL9JL L@= =;GFGEQ
AF 9 KL=9<QKL9L=
O@A;@ :GL@ @9K L@= HGHMD9LAGF <AKLJA:MLAGF 9F< L@= KMJNAN9D J9L=K
G> L@= Q=9J /G GN=J;GE= L@AK HJG:D=E
L@= >GDDGOAF? HJG;=<MJ= AK MK=< !AJKL
;GEHML= L@= KL=9<QKL9L= G> L@= =;GFGEQ ?AN=F @
9F< 9 HGHMD9LAGF ?JGOL@
J9L= ; /@AK ?AN=K HJA;=K ?
; D
; 9F< L@= L9P J9L= ; $L 9DKG ?AN=K L@= 9KK=L
@GD<AF?K 9F< D9:GJ KMHHDQ <=;AKAGFK 9;JGKK ;G@GJLK 9F< KCADD ?JGMHK 9KKG;A9L=< OAL@
L@= KL9LAGF9JQ HGHMD9LAGF <AKLJA:MLAGF
; )GO
9KKME= L@9L =9;@ ;G@GJL 9F<
KCADD ?JGMH AF E9C= L@= K9E= <=;AKAGFK 9K L@=AJ ;GMFL=JH9JLK AF ; /@AK
OGMD< := L@= ;9K= A> HJA;=K 9F< L9P=K O=J= A<=FLA;9D AF L@= LOG =;GFGEA=K
A= A>
?
; ? D
; D 9F< ; O@=J= ? D <=FGL=K L@=
HJA;=K 9F< L9P J9L= 9KKG;A9L=< OAL@ ??J=?9LAF? 9DDG;9LAGFK GN=J ;G@GJLK 9F<
KCADD ?JGMHK ?AN=F O= ;9F ;GEHML= ? D 9F< /@= 4"453 5/ $/.
/-9 AK ;GEHML=< :Q K=LLAF? ; LG =FKMJ= ?
; ? D
; D 9F< ; (GJ=GN=J
L@= 9DDG;9LAGFK G> =9;@ ;G@GJL 9F< KCADD ?JGMH AF 9J= 9KKME=< LG :=
A<=FLA;9D LG L@=AJ ;GMFL=JH9JLK AF L@= KL9LAGF9JQ =;GFGEQ
%MKL ;GFKA<=J 9 KAEHD= ?JGOL@ EG<=D O@=J= ;9HAL9D KL9JLK 9:GN= ALK KL=9<QKL9L= N=JKMK 9 ;9K=
O@=J= AL KL9JLK 9L ALK KL=9<QKL9L= $L AK MKM9DDQ HJ=>=J=< LG =N9DM9L= HGDA;Q ;@9F?=K 9K <=NA9LAGFK
>JGE 9 KL=9<Q KL9L=
KG 9K LG FGL ;GF>GMF< L@= =Z=;L G> AFALA9D ;GF<ALAGFK OAL@ L@= =Z=;L G> HGDA;Q
$F 9<<ALAGF
L@= @AKLGJQ 9F< >MLMJ= G> HJA;=K 9F< L9P=K K@GMD< := L@= K9E= AF L@= LOG =;GFGEA=K
F AEHDA;AL 9KKMEHLAGF O@=F MKAF? L@AK HJG;=<MJ= AK L@=J=>GJ= L@9L 9FQ H9KL GJ >MLMJ= <=NA9LAGFK
AF HJA;=K 9F< L9P=K @9N= 9 F=?DA?A:D= AEH9;L GF ;MJJ=FL <=;AKAGFK
#! $"# " & # #!# "
/G KLM<Q L@= KL9:ADALQ G> L@AK HJG;=<MJ=
L@= KMJNAN9D J9L=K AF L@= .L9LMK ,MG
;GFGEQ O=J= 9KKME=< LG := @
>GJ L@= LJ9FKALAGF 9F< L@= <=:LLGGMLHML
J9LAG AF<=SFAL=DQ J=E9AFK ;GFKL9FL 9L G> ")+ $F<==<
HJA;=K 9F< L9P=K ;@9F?=
N=JQ DALLD= >JGE A LG A D=KK L@9F /@AK KM??=KLK L@9L L@= AFALA9D
;GF<ALAGFK MK=< @=J= <G AF<==< FGL 9Z=;L L@= HGDA;Q =PH=JAE=FLK AF 9FQ KM:KL9FLAN=
O9Q
$.+ 6:/1/(7/:2
/@AK K=;LAGF <=K;JA:=K L@= ;GEHML9LAGF G> L@= =IMADA:JAME AF L@= /9P -=>GJE =;GF
GEQ
O@=J= AK AF;J=9K=< GF;= 9F< >GJ 9DD 9L A 9F< L@= K=IM=F;= G> <=:L
!$ /$ $ =NGDN=K =F<G?=FGMKDQ DD GL@=J HGDA;Q N9JA9:D=K =AL@=J J=E9AF
SP=< L@JGM?@GML L@= LJ9FKALAGF GJ EGN= <=L=JEAFAKLA;9DDQ /@= =;GFGEQ AK 9KKME=<
LG J=9;@ ALK KL=9<Q KL9L= 9L LAE= -
"M=KK GF 9 N=;LGJ G> J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=K >GJ =9;@ ;G@GJL 9F< KCADD ?JGMHK
"M=KK GF 9 N=;LGJ G> <=:LLGGMLHML J9LAGK
GEHML= L@= SF9D KL=9<QKL9L= ?AN=F ! / /@AK ?AN=K D$ D ?$ ?
9F< $ A - 9F< ?$ $
"M=KK GF 9 K=IM=F;= G> HJA;=K D$ $
!GJ =9;@ ;G@GJL 9F< KCADD ?JGMH
KGDN= >GJ L@= AF<ANA<M9DVK 9DDG;9LAGF 0 7 ?AN=F D$ $ ?$ $ 9F< ??J=?9L= 9KK=LK 9F< D9:GJ KMHHDQ 9;JGKK 9?= 9F< KCADD?JGMHK 9F< ;GEHML=
9F< $> 9F< L@=F ;GFLAFM= *L@=JOAK= J=LMJF LG $> $ A L@=F ;GFLAFM= *L@=JOAK= J=LMJF LG .GDN= >GJ L@= GHLAE9D J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= ?AN=F 9F< =SF= . + B 2 + 7 + O@=J= 2 + 9F< 7 + <=FGL=K L@= GHLAE9D HGD
A;Q JMD=K >GJ ;GFKMEHLAGF 9F< @GMJK OGJC=<
J=KH=;LAN=DQ
?AN=F J=LAJ=E=FL 9?=
+ /@= GHLAE9D J=LAJ=E=FL 9?= >GJ =9;@ ;G@GJL 9F< KCADD ?JGMH AK ;GEHML=<
9K + ! " . + + O@=J= $> L@=F
KLGH *L@=JOAK= J=LMJF LG #! $"# " & # #!# "
2@=F ;GEHMLAF? L@= =IMADA:JA9 >GJ L@= -=HD9;=E=FL -9L= -=>GJE 9F< L@= !MDD
-=LAJ=E=FL ?= J=>GJE
9 KAEAD9J HJG;=<MJ= AK MK=< #GO=N=J
9F 9<<ALAGF9D GML=J
DGGH AK J=IMAJ=< O@=J= L@= =IMADA:JAME -=HD9;=E=FL -9L=!MDD -=LAJ=E=FL ?= AK
<=L=JEAF=< (GJ=GN=J
AF 9F =PLJ9 J=IMAJ=E=FL AK L@9L MONOGRAPH SERIES
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
Michaely, Michael The Theory of Commercial Policy: Trade and
Protection, 1973
Söderström, Hans Tson Studies in the Microdynamics of Production
and Productivity Change, 1974
Hamilton, Carl B. Project Analysis in the Rural Sector with Special
Reference to the Evaluation of Labour Cost, 1974
Nyberg, Lars and Staffan Viotti A Control Systems Approach to
Macroeconomic Theory and Policy in the Open Economy, 1975
Myhrman, Johan Monetary Policy in Open Economies, 1975
Krauss, Melvyn International Trade and Economic Welfare, 1975
Wihlborg, Clas Capital Market Integration and Monetary Policy under
Different Exchange Rate Regimes, 1976
Svensson, Lars E.O. On Competitive Markets and Intertemporal Resources
Allocation, 1976
Yeats, Alexander J. Trade Barriers Facing Developing Countries, 1978
Calmfors, Lars Prices, Wages and Employment in the Open Economy, 1978
Kornai, János Economics of Shortage, Vols I and II, 1979
Flam, Harry Growth, Allocation and Trade in Sweden. An Empirical
Application of the Heckscher-Ohlin Theory, 1981
Persson, Torsten Studies of Alternative Exchange Rate Systems. An
Intertemporal General Equilibrium Approach, 1982
Erzan, Refik Turkey's Comparative Advantage, Production and Trade
Patterns in Manufactures. An Application of the Factor Proportions
Hypothesis with Some Qualifications, 1983
Horn af Rantzien, Henrik Imperfect Competition in Models of Wage
Formation and International Trade, 1983
Nandakumar, Parameswar Macroeconomic Effects of Supply Side Policies
and Disturbances in Open Economies, 1985
Sellin, Peter Asset Pricing and Portfolio Choice with International
Investment Barriers, 1990
Werner, Ingrid International Capital Markets: Controls, Taxes and
Resources Allocation, 1990
Svedberg, Peter Poverty and Undernutrition in Sub-Saharan Africa: Theory,
Evidence, Policy, 1991
Nordström, Håkan Studies in Trade Policy and Economic Growth, 1992
Hassler, John, Lundvik, Petter, Persson, Torsten and Söderlind, Paul The
Swedish Business Cycle: Stylized facts over 130 years, 1992
Lundvik, Petter Business Cycles and Growth, 1992
Söderlind, Paul Essays in Exchange Rates, Business Cycles and Growth, 1993
Hassler, John A.A. Effects of Variations in Risk on Demand and Measures of
Business Cycle Comovements, 1994
Daltung, Sonja Risk, Efficiency, and Regulation of Banks, 1994
Lindberg, Hans Exchange Rates: Target Zones, Interventions and Regime
Collapses, 1994
Stennek, Johan Essays on Information-Processing and Competition, 1994
Jonsson, Gunnar Institutions and Incentives in Monetary and Fiscal Policy, 1995
Dahlquist, Magnus Essays on the Term Structure of Interest Rates and
Monetary Policy, 1995
Svensson, Jakob Political Economy and Macroeconomics: On Foreign Aid
and Development, 1996
Blix, Mårten Rational Expectations and Regime Shifts in Macroeconometrics, 1997
Lagerlöf, Nils-Petter Intergenerational Transfers and Altruism, 1997
Klein, Paul Papers on the Macroeconomics of Fiscal Policy, 1997
Jonsson, Magnus Studies in Business Cycles, 1997
Persson, Lars Asset Ownership in Imperfectly Competitive Markets, 1998
Persson, Joakim Essays on Economic Growth, 1998
Domeij, David Essays on Optimal Taxation and Indeterminacy, 1998
Flodén, Martin Essays on Dynamic Macroeconomics, 1999
Tangerås, Thomas Essays in Economics and Politics: Regulation, Elections
and International Conflict, 2000
Lidbom, Per Pettersson Elections, Party Politics and Economic Policy, 2000
41. Vestin, David Essays on Monetary Policy, 2001
42. Olofsgård, Anders Essays on Interregional and International Political
Economics, 2001
43. Johansson, Åsa Essays on Macroeconomic Fluctuations and Nominal Wage
Rigidity, 2002
Groth, Charlotta Topics on Monetary Policy, 2002
Gancia, Gino A. Essays on Growth, Trade and Inequality, 2003
Harstad, Bård Organizing Cooperation: Bargaining, Voting and Control, 2003
Kohlscheen, Emanuel Essays on Debts and Constitutions, 2004
Olovsson, Conny Essays on Dynamic Macroeconomics, 2004
Stavlöt, Ulrika Essays on Culture and Trade, 2005
Herzing, Mathias Essays on Uncertainty and Escape in Trade Agreements, 2005
Bonfiglioli, Alessandra Essays on Financial Markets and Macroeconomics, 2005
Pienaar, Natalie Economic Applications of Product Quality Regulation in WTO
Trade Agreements, 2005
53. Song, Zheng Essays on Dynamic Political Economy, 2005
54. Eisensee, Thomas Essays on Public Finance: Retirement Behavior and Disaster
Relief, 2005
44.
45.
46.
47.
48.
49.
50.
51.
52.