ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM TO 12-01-2009 12-31-2009
by user
Comments
Transcript
ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM TO 12-01-2009 12-31-2009
Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 08/27/2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137160 JOJO'S AMERICANA SUPPER CLUB 107 BLUE STAR DOUGLAS MI 49406 LICENSEE(S) : L.L. DOUBLE D, LLC CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY STEELE W/DOB 7-23-89 (20): (MSP-WAYLAND POST 69-5056-09(PC)/DECOY/CK SERGIO JUAREZ/NO ID) 12-16-2009 HEARING HELD GRAND RAPIDS POBUR/HALL/DECLERCQ RULE 15(D) COST $72.00 12-21-2009 $500.00 OR 25 DAYS SUSP, PLUS $72.00 WITNESS FEES; TOTAL $572.00 SEC 801(2) RULE 15(D) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: ALLEGAN INTEREST : LLC COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136769 THE SIDETRACK BAR & GRILLE 1590 FIFTY SIXTH FENNVILLE MI 49408 LICENSEE(S) : SIDETRACK BAR AND GRILLE, INC. CHARGE ALLOWED, EMPLOYEE, CAROL BUSHEE, TO BE ON LIC'D PREMISES IN AN INTOX CONDITION: (MSPWAYLAND POST 69-5321-09(PC) 12-15-2009 STIPULATION FOR PROPOSED NEG SETTLEMENT COMM POBUR-AG HALL 12-21-2009 $300.00 OR 15 DAYS SUSP STIPULATED NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/12/2009 COUNTY: ALLEGAN INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137164 CLARK GAS STATION 1602- 1604 N MAIN MARTIN MI 49070 LICENSEE(S) : LANDKO CORPORATION CHARGE 1) SALE TO MINOR - DECOY HARRIS W/DOB 12-26-89 (19): 2) LICENSE NOT PROPERLY DISPLAYED: (MSP-WAYLAND POST 69-5060-09(PC)/DECOY/CK KATHLEEN RYBISKI/NO ID) 12-16-2009 HEARING HELD GRAND RAPIDS POBUR/HALL/DECLERCQ RULE 15(D) COST $61.00 12-21-2009 CHG 1) $1000.00 SEC 801(2); CHG 2) $100.00; $1100.00 OR 55 DAYS SUSP, PLUS $61.00 WITNESS FEES; TOTAL $1161.00. IN ADDITION, BECAUSE OF THE FACT THAT THIS VIOLATION REPRESENTS THE FOURTH VIOLATION OF SECTION 801(2) OF THE CODE IN A PERIOD OF LESS THAN TWO (2) YEARS, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS A SUSPENSION OF THREE (3) CONSECUTIVE DAYS AS ADDED PENALTY. RULE 15(D) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 08/28/2009 COUNTY: ALLEGAN INTEREST : CRP 08/27/2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136854 MEIJER #191 1195 M 89 PLAINWELL MI LICENSEE(S) : MEIJER, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY KORTEMEIER (18): (MSP-WAYLAND POST 69-5019-09(PC)/DECOY/CK ASHLEY RUSTENHOLTZ/NO ID) 11-30-2009 HEARING HELD GRAND RAPIDS MOURNING/GEISSLER/CONTRACT NEG SETTLEMENT 12-14-2009 $500.00 OR 25 DAYS SUSP SEC 801(2) NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 49080 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137607 MULLIGAN'S PUB 107 CENTER BAY CITY MI 48706 LICENSEE(S) : LEOZ, INC. CHARGE 1) SALE TO (18): (BAY 12-09-2009 12-22-2009 : COMM. ORDER : Report: LLVC0180 COUNTY: ALLEGAN INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : CRP 09/17/2009 COUNTY: BAY INTEREST : CRP MINOR - CI #2537 W/DOB 6-19-91 (18): 2) SALE TO MINOR - CI #2529 W/DOB 7-17-91 CITY PD/DECOYS/CK TRACY CARPENTER/ID) LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 400.00 FOR EACH CHARGE TOTAL $700.00 OR 35 DAY SUSP SEC 801(2) January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 1 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137507 OASIS LOUNGE 1913 KOSCIUSZKO BAY CITY MI 48706 LICENSEE(S) : OASIS LOUNGE, INC. CHARGE 1) SALE TO MINOR 91 (18): (BAY CITY 11-17-2009 LIC ACK 12-02-2009 1)$350, : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137604 PIER 7 963 E MIDLAND BAY CITY MI TO 12-31-2009 VIOLATION DATE : 09/25/2009 COUNTY: BAY INTEREST : CRP CI #2540 W/DOB 11-27-90 (18): 2) SALE TO MINOR - CI #2530 W/DOB 8-14PD/DECOYS/CK DEE RIEDEL/ID) - COMM GAFFNEY 2)$350 TOTAL OF $700, $100 WAIVED FOR A TOTAL OF $600 OR 30 DAYS SUSP. VIOLATION DATE : 48706 09/17/2009 COUNTY: BAY LICENSEE(S) : PIER 7, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - CI #2540 W/DOB 11-27-90 (18): (BAY CITY PD/DECOY/CK BUDDY HENIKA/NO ID) : INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 12-10-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-22-2009 600.00/100.00 WAIVED TOTAL 500.00 OR 25 DAY SUSP SEC 801(2) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137508 THE BIG HOUSE & THE HEN HOUSE 510- 512 E MIDLAND BAY CITY MI 48706 LICENSEE(S) : BIG HOUSE INVESTMENTS, INC. CHARGE 1) SALE TO MINOR - CI #2540 W/DOB 11-27-90 (18): 2) SALE TO MINOR - CI #2530 W/DOB 8-1491 (18): (BAY CITY PD/DECOYS/CK REGINA THOMAS/ID) 11-20-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-11-2009 CHGS 1 & 2) $300.00 EACH; TOTAL $600.00 OR 30 DAYS SUSP SEC 801(2) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: BAY INTEREST : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137510 DOUBLETREE HOTEL BAY CITY/RIVERFRONT/RIVERFRONT GRILL 1 WENONAH PARK PLACE BAY CITY MI 48708 COUNTY: BAY LICENSEE(S) : HOTEL INVESTMENT SERVICES, INC. WENONAH PARK PROPERTIES INC. CHARGE 1) SALE TO (18): (BAY 11-17-2009 12-02-2009 : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : VIOLATION DATE : INTEREST : INTEREST : MINOR - CI #2529 W/DOB 7-17-91 (18): 2) SALE TO MINOR CITY PD/DECOYS/CK JESSICA O'DELL/ID) LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 1)$300, 2)$300 TOTAL OF $600 OR 30 DAYS SUSP. 137432 CB DISCOUNT 1600 BROADWAY BAY CITY MI CRP 09/25/2009 CLC CLC CI #2537 W/DOB 6-19-91 VIOLATION DATE : 48706 09/25/2009 09/17/2009 COUNTY: BAY LICENSEE(S) : CHAUHAN BROTHERS ENTERPRISES INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - CI #2530 W/DOB 8-14-91 (18): (BAY CITY PD/DECOY/CK DARLA PIERSON/NO ID) : COMM. ORDER : INTEREST : CRP 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 $600 OR 30 DAY SUSP SEC.801(2) Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 2 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137605 STEPHEN BESON'S PARTY STORE & PIZZERIA 1005 MARQUETTE BAY CITY MI 48706 COUNTY: BAY TO 12-31-2009 VIOLATION DATE : 09/17/2009 LICENSEE(S) : BESON, STEPHEN G CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - CI #2540 W/DOB 11-27-90 (18): (BAY CITY PD/DECOY/CK JUDIE LIPINSKI/ID) : COMM. ORDER : INTEREST : 12-08-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-18-2009 $700.00 OR 35 DAYS SUSP IND SEC 801(2) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137547 COUNTRYSIDE CONVENIENCE 5701 E NAPIER BENTON HARBOR MI 49022 LICENSEE(S) : HAUCH, SHELLY CHARGE REC'D - DENNIS HAUCH, EMPLOYEE, ENGAGED IN AN ILLEGAL OCCUPATION OR ILLEGAL ACT UPON THE LIC'D PREMISES, SPECIFICALLY: FURNISH TOBACCO TO A MINOR, IN VIOLATION OF MCL 722.641, AND WAS FOUND GUILTY: 3-13-09 (LCC INV SCHMIDT) 11-24-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-11-2009 $300.00 OR 15 DAYS SUSP : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 10/22/2009 COUNTY: BERRIEN INTEREST : IND COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137134 J&B PARTY STORE 268 E EMPIRE BENTON HARBOR MI LICENSEE(S) : J. KHALIL, LLC CHARGE REC'D - EMPLOYEE, BALDEV SINGH, ENGAGED IN AN ILLEGAL OCCUPATION OR ILLEGAL ACT UPON THE LIC'D PREMISES, SPECIFICALLY, SALE OF TOBACCO TO MINOR, IN VIOLATION OF MCL 722.641, AND WAS FOUND GUILTY, ON OR ABOUT 5-28-09: (LCC INV SCHMIDT) 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD KALAMAZOO MOURNING/HALL/CONTRACT 12-21-2009 $300.00 OR 15 DAYS SUSP RULE 15(D) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 49022 09/22/2009 COUNTY: BERRIEN INTEREST : LLC COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137135 HARBOR'S PARTY STORE 303 E MAIN BENTON HARBOR MI 49022 LICENSEE(S) : K. KHALIL, LLC CHARGE REC'D - EMPLOYEE, KEHAR SINGH, ENGAGED IN AN ILLEGAL OCCUPATION OR ILLEGAL ACT UPON THE LIC'D PREMISES, SPECIFICALLY: SALE OF TOBACCO TO MINOR, IN VIOLATION OF MCL 722.641, AND WAS FOUND GUILTY: ON OR ABOUT 5-28-09 (LCC INV SCHMIDT) 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD KALAMAZOO MOURNING/HALL/CONTRACT 12-21-2009 $300.00 OR 15 DAYS SUSP. FURTHER, GIVEN THE REPEATED NATURE OF THIS VIOLATION, THE AL JUDGE ORDERS A SUSPENSION OF (3) CONSECUTIVE DAYS. RULE 15(D) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/22/2009 COUNTY: BERRIEN INTEREST : LLC COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137133 SLOSSON'S 812 E NAPIER BENTON HARBOR LICENSEE(S) : DILDEEPAK, INC. CHARGE REC'D - EMPLOYEE, BENNIE WATSON, ENGAGED IN AN ILLEGAL OCCUPATION OR ILLEGAL ACT UPON THE LIC'D PREMISES, SPECIFICALLY, SALE OF TOBACCO TO MINOR, IN VIOLATION OF MCL 722.641, AND WAS FOUND GUILTY; 1-30-09 (LCC INV SCHMIDT) 12-04-2009 LIC ACK - WRITTEN STIPULATION - ALJ MOURNING/AAG HALL 12-21-2009 $300.00 OR 15 DAYS SUSP STIPULATED NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : Report: LLVC0180 VIOLATION DATE : MI 49022 09/22/2009 COUNTY: BERRIEN INTEREST : January 08, 2010 07:36 AM CRP Page 3 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137016 RODEO SALOON 8981 RED ARROW BRIDGMAN MI 49106 LICENSEE(S) : M.K. CORPORATION CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 11-608 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 6-5-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 11-30-2009 HEARING HELD LANSING GAFFNEY/HALL/DECLERCQ RULE 15(D) 12-01-2009 $300 OR 15 DAYS SUSP. FURTHER THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES AND PERMITS BE SUSP AS OF 2-28-10, WITH SUSP BEING WAIVED IF DOCUMENTARY PROOF FO SERVER TRAINING IS PROVIDED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE COMMISSION'S 12-08 ORDER. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDERS THAT SAID LICENSES AND PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE SUSP IS NOT WAIVED BEFORE 4-30-10. RULE 15(D) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/28/2009 COUNTY: BERRIEN INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137033 JAY'S LOUNGE 3025 S ELEVENTH US 31 NILES MI 49120 LICENSEE(S) : NAPOLI, INC. CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 11-608 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 7-22-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 11-16-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 $300 OR 15 DAYS SUSP. AS ADDITIONAL PENALTY, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES AND PERMITS ISSUED BY THE MLCC TO THIS LICENSEE BE SUSP AS OF 3-15-10, WITH SAID SUSP BEING WAIVED IF DOCUMENTARY PROFF OF SERVER TRAINING IS PROVIDED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE COMMISSION'S 11-6-08 ORDER. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDERS THAT SAID LICENSES AND PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE SUSP IS NOT WAIVED BEFORE 5-15-10. : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/30/2009 COUNTY: BERRIEN INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137175 THE NUGGETT 202- 204 E MAIN NILES MI 49120 LICENSEE(S) : D. A. DULEMBA, INC. CHARGE 1) SALE TO MINOR - DECOY W/DOB 11-13-90 (18): 2) SALE TO MINOR - DECOY W/DOB 7-28-89 (20): (NILES PD/DECOYS/CK DEBRA AKEY/ID) 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 1)$350 2)$350 TOTAL $700 OR 35 DAY SUSP. SEC.801(2) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/11/2009 COUNTY: BERRIEN INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137270 PAW PAW LAKE BOARD OF TRADE 8690 LAKE WATERVLIET MI 49098 LICENSEE(S) : BODFISH ENTERPRISES, LLC CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY #3 W/DOB 5-11-89 (20): (BERRIEN CO SHER DEPT/DECOY/CK LISA BRENER/ID?) 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 $600 OR 30 DAY SUSP. SEC.801(2) : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137336 PAR 4 97 W MICHIGAN BATTLE CREEK MI 49017 SONNY & SONS, L.L.C. CHARGE NSF EFT (447.64): (LCC) COMM. ORDER : 09/03/2009 COUNTY: BERRIEN INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : LICENSEE(S) : : VIOLATION DATE : LLC 09/24/2009 COUNTY: CALHOUN INTEREST : LLC 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 $250 OR 12 DAYS SUSP. Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 4 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 133789 PLEASANT LAKE RESORT 68502 CASS EDWARDSBURG MI 49112 LICENSEE(S) : PLEASANT LAKE RESORT, INC. CHARGE : CHARGE : CON'T - UPON THE LIC'D PREMISES, SPECIFICALLY: CONSPIRACY TO COMMIT LEWD AND LASCIVIOUS CONDUCT & DISORDERLY PERSON-A COMMON PROSTITUTE: AS DISCOVERED ON 7-10-09; 16)17) FAILED TO KEEP LICENSE & PERMIT, ISSUED BY THE MLCC, SIGNED, FRAMED UNDER TRANSPARENT MATERIAL, AND/OR FAILING TO PROMINENTLY DISPLAY THE PERMIT ADJACENT TO THE LIQUOR LICENSE IN THE LIC'D PREMISES: ON OR ABOUT 4-22-09; 18) SOLD OR TRF'D LICENSE, OR AN INTEREST IN LICENSE W/OUT PRIOR APPROVAL OF THE MLCC (TERESA KREIGHBAUM AND/OR TSK, INC AND/OR FRANK MASSA): DISCOVERED 4-30-09; 19) ALLOWED PERSON AND/OR CORP WHOSE NAME DOES NOT APPEAR ON THE LICENSE, TO DERIVE USE OR BENEFIT FROM THE LICENSE: DISCOVERED 4-30-09 (MLCC DIST SUPR COX, INV HEALY, INV REEDER, INV SCHMIDT, CASS COUNTY DRUG ENF TEAM (CCDET) REC'D - 1)4) ALLOWED THE SALE, POSSESSION, OR USE OF CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE ON LIC'D PREMISES, SPECIFICALLY: COCAINE: ON OR ABOUT 3-18-09, ON OR ABOUT 3-26-09; 2)3) MELISSA "STAR" GOODMAN, EMPLOYEE OF THE LICENSEE, ENGAGED IN AN ILLEGAL OCCUPATION OR ILLEGAL ACT UPON THE LIC'D PREMISES, SPECIFICALLY: DELIVERY AND/OR POSSESSION OF A CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE CONTAINING COCAINE: ON OR ABOUT 3-18-09, ON OR ABOUT 3-26-09; 5) MELISSA "STAR" GOODMAN, EMPLOYEE OF THE LICENSEE, ENGAGED IN AN ILLEGAL OCCUPATION OR ILLEGAL ACT UPON THE LIC'D PREMISES, SPECIFICALLY: SALE AND/OR DELIVERY OF A CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE, METHYLENEDIOXYMETHAMPHETAMINE COMMONLY KNOWN AS MDMA OR ECTASY: ON OR ABOUT 4-15-09; 6)7) MELISSA "STAR" GOODMAN, EMPLOYEE OF THE LICENSEE, ENGAGED IN AN ILLEGAL OCCUPATION OR ILLEGAL ACT UPON THE LIC'D PREMISES, SPECIFICALLY: LEWD AND LASCIVIOUS CONDUCT: AS DISCOVERED ON 7-10-09 & SEXUAL PENETRATION AS A FELONY: ON OR ABOUT 3-19-09; 8)9) BRENT JOSEPH HANSON, EMPLOYEE OF THE LICENSEE, ENAGED IN AN ILLEGAL OCCUPATION OR ILLEGAL ACT UPON THE LIC'D PREMISES, SPECIFICALLY: CONSPIRACY OF A DISORDERLY PERSON-A COMMON PROSTITUTE & KNOWINGLY LOITERING IN A PLACE WERE AN ILLEGAL OCCUPATION OR BUSINESS IS BEING CONDUCTED: AS DISCOVRERED ON 07-10-09; 10)11) ERIN "HAZEL" DICKERSON, EMPLOYEE OF THE LICENSEE, ENGAGED IN AN ILLEGAL OCCUPATION OR ILLEGAL ACT UPON THE LIC'D PREMISES, SPECIFICALLY: LEWD AND LASCIVIOUS CONDUCT & CONSPIRACY TO COMMIT LEWD AND LASCIVIOUS CONDUCT: AS DISCOVERED ON 7-10-09; 12)13) VICKI "MIA" MCCLAIN, EMPLOYEE OF THE LICENSEE, ENGAGED IN AN ILLEGAL OCCUPATION OR ILLEGAL ACT UPON THE LIC'D PREMISES, SPECIFICALLY: LEWD AND LASCIVIOUS CONDUCT & CONSPIRACY TO COMMIT LEWD AND LASCIVIOUS CONDUCT: AS DISCOVERED ON 7-10-09; 14)15) LAUREN "WHITNEY" COOMBS, EMPLOYEE OF THE LICENSEE, ENGAGED IN AN ILLEGAL OCCUPATION OR ILLEGAL ACT 12-11-2009 HEARING HELD - LANSING POBUR/GEISSLER/DECLERCQ 12-28-2009 CHGS 1 THRU 19) $300.00 EACH; TOTAL $5700.00 OR 285 DAYS SUSP. FURTHER, BECAUSE OF THE SEVERITY OF THE VIOLATIONS CONTAINED IN THIS COMPLAINT, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THE SUBJECT LICENSES & PERMITS TO BE REVOKED UNLESS TRANSFERRED TO AN ENTITY APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THE SUBJECT LICENSES & PERMITS BE RE-INSTATED ON JANUARY 11, 2010, WITH THE EXPRESS UNDERSTANDING THAT THE LICENSED ESTABLISHMENT IS TO BE OPERATED AND CONTROLLED BY THE LICENSEE AND THE LICENSEE ONLY, UNLESS THE LICENSESS IS OPERATING UNDER THE TERMS OF A MANAGEMENT AGREEMENT APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION. THE LICENSEE IS WARNED THAT IF HE DOES ENTER INTO A MANAGEMENT AGREEMENT WHICH IS APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION, HE MUST STRICTLY ADHERE TO THE STATED TERMS OF THAT AGREEMENT. GIVEN THE SERIOUSNESS OF THE CHARGES STATED IN THIS COMPLAINT, THE LICENSEE AND ANY PROPOSED TRANSFEREES SHOULD EXPECT CONSIDERABLE SCRUTINY BY THE COMMISSION AND BY LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT DURING THE PERIOD LEADING UP TO THE PROPOSED TRANSFER OF THE SUBJECT LICENSES. COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 04/30/2009 COUNTY: CASS INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137015 MAULDOON'S SALOON 12946 S STRAITS WOLVERINE MI 49799 LICENSEE(S) : J & S MAULDON, LLC CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 10-108, WITH AN EXTGENSION GRANTED ON 4-29-09, BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 6-23-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 11-20-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-17-2009 100.00 OR 5 DAY SUSP : COMM. ORDER : Report: LLVC0180 VIOLATION DATE : 09/28/2009 COUNTY: CHEBOYGAN INTEREST : January 08, 2010 07:36 AM LLC Page 5 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137236 MALAMUTE 3047 W M 80 KINROSS MI LICENSEE(S) : DERAN, INC. CHARGE 1) SALE TO INTOX PERSON - WALTER PEARCE: 2) ALLOW INTOX PERSON TO CONSUME: 3) ALLOW INTOX PRESON TO LOITER: 4) PERSON CONSUMING AFTER THE LEGAL HOUR: 5) PREMISES OCCUPIED AFTER THE LEGAL HOUR: (MSP-SAULT STE MARIE POST 93-0001630-09/CK JAIME TIBBS) 11-30-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 500.OO CHARGE 1 AND $100.0O EACH FOR CHARGE 2 AND 3 AND $50.00 EACH FOR CHARGE NOS 4 AND 5 TOTAL 800.00 OR 40 DAY SUSP : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 49752 09/20/2009 COUNTY: CHIPPEWA INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137019 THE BOMB SHELTER 501 E PORTAGE SAULT SAINTE MARIE LICENSEE(S) : SNOW PAWS, LLC CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 9-1808, WITH AN EXTENSION GRANTED ON 4-24-09, BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 6-30-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 11-30-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-17-2009 100.00 OR 5 DAY SUSP : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : MI 49783 09/28/2009 COUNTY: CHIPPEWA INTEREST : LLC COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136456 PALACE SALOON 200- 202 W PORTAGE SAULT SAINTE MARIE LICENSEE(S) : GOETZ PORTAGE AVENUE, LTD. CHARGE 1) INSTALLED ADD'L BAR W/OUT PRIOR APPROVAL OF COMMISSION: 2) ALLOWED CONSUMPTION OF ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR OR POSSESSED ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR ON THE LIC'D PREMISES, NOT PURCHASED FROM AN AUTHORIZED SOURCE: (LCC INV COMBER) 11-25-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-15-2009 150.00 EA CHARGE TOTAL $300.00 OR 15 DAY SUSP : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : VIOLATION DATE : MI 49783 COUNTY: CHIPPEWA INTEREST : 136315 198 E MAIN HARRISON MI VIOLATION DATE : 48625 08/15/2009 CRP 07/18/2009 COUNTY: CLARE LICENSEE(S) : BUDD LAKE BAR & GRILL, LLC CHARGE 1)2) PERMITTED OR ALLOWED ON LIC'D PREMISES, FAITH HARTIG & JACK HARTIG, WHO WERE UNDER 18 YRS OLD, TO WORK OR ENTERTAIN ON A PAID OR VOLUNTARY BASIS: (CLARE CO SHER DEPT/AGED 9 & 11) 12-09-2009 HEARING HELD SAGINAW GAFFNEY/ASEVEDO/CONTRACT NEG SETTLEMENT 12-15-2009 1&2)DISMISSED $50 ADM COSTS NEG SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137733 BOB'S PARTY STORE 4012 N CLARE HARRISON MI 48625 LICENSEE(S) : SMITH, GREGORY S CHARGE NSF CHECK (678.00): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : LLC 10/22/2009 COUNTY: CLARE INTEREST : IND 12-09-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-22-2009 $250 OR 12 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDER THE LICENSEE PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 1 YEAR FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 6 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137012 CHARLIE'S BAR & GRILL 101 N WESTPHALIA WESTPHALIA MI 48894 LICENSEE(S) : DEVINE ENTERPRISES, INC. CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 11-608, WITH AN EXTENSION GRANTED ON 5-12-09, BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 6-30-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 11-30-2009 HEARING HELD LANSING GAFFNEY/HALL/DECLERCQ RULE 15(D) 12-01-2009 $200 OR 10 DAYS SUSP. RULE 15(D) : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137736 CAIDS CORNER GROCERY 6510 E CO RD 612 GRAYLING MI 49738 LICENSEE(S) : TAYLOR'S GROCERY, LLC CHARGE NSF CHECK (258.15): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : 09/28/2009 COUNTY: CLINTON INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : CRP 10/21/2009 COUNTY: CRAWFORD INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 12-11-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-22-2009 100.00/50.00 WAIVED OR 3 DAY SUSP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136914 MAMA MIA'S 1213 LUDINGTON ESCANABA MI 49829 LICENSEE(S) : PUB & GRUB, INC. CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 10-808 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 5-4-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 11-12-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $200 OR 10 DAYS SUSP. : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/23/2009 COUNTY: DELTA INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137011 BLACKSTONE PIZZA CO. 207 E HUGHITT IRON MOUNTAIN MI 49801 LICENSEE(S) : BLACKSTONE PIZZA CO. CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 1-3-08 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 6-27-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 11-25-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 200.00 OR 10 DAY SUSP : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/28/2009 COUNTY: DICKINSON INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137178 JONE'S COUNTRY STORE R 5 2927 W VERMONTVILLE CHARLOTTE MI 48813 LICENSEE(S) : JONES, BRUCE E JONES, JUANITA J CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY #110 W/DOB 6-13-89 (20): (MSP-LANSING POST 11-3903-09(01)/DECOY/CK JUANITA JONES/ID) 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 $800 OR 40 DAY SUSP. SEC.801(2) : COMM. ORDER : Report: LLVC0180 VIOLATION DATE : 09/21/2009 COUNTY: EATON INTEREST : INTEREST : January 08, 2010 07:36 AM GPI GPI Page 7 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137177 FRANK'S PARTY STORE 117 E LANSING POTTERVILLE MI 48876 LICENSEE(S) : F & R PARTY STORE, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY #110 W/DOB 6-13-89 (20): (MSP-LANSING POST 11-3962-09(01)/DECOY/CK T.J. LOVELESS/ID?) 11-24-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $800 OR 40 DAYS SUSP SEC 801(2) : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 127793 LISA'S LONE PINE G- 4061 FENTON BURTON MI 48529 VIOLATION DATE : 09/26/2009 COUNTY: EATON INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : CRP 07/28/2008 COUNTY: GENESEE LICENSEE(S) : COCKING CORP. CHARGE REC'D - REC'D - 1)3)5)7) ALLOWED WAGERING ON A VIDEO POKER MACHINES ON THE LIC'D PREMISES: ON OR ABOUT 7-20-07, ON OR ABOUT 8-8-07, ON OR ABOUT 9-12-07, ON OR ABOUT 11-19-07; 2)4)6)8) ALLOWED ON THE LIC'D PREMISES VIDEO POKER MACHINES USED FOR GAMBLING PURPOSES: ON OR ABOUT 7-20-07, ON OR ABOUT 8-8-07, ON OR ABOUT 9-12-07, ON OR ABOUT 11-19-07: (GIS-4807-MSP GAMING POST) 12-09-2009 HEARING HELD SWARTZ CREEK POBUR/HALL/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-11-2009 7 DAYS SUSP, SUSP SERVED. 1-8)$300 EACH FOR A TOTAL OF $2400 OR 120 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THE LICENSEE TO FORFEIT THE GAMING MACHINES AND MONEY SEIZED IN THE COURSE OF THIS INVESTIGATION AND ORDERS THE MSP TO DESTROY THE SEIZED GAMING MACHINES AND TO DISPOSE OF THE MONEY SEIZED IN THE INVESTIGATION IN A MANNER PRESCRIBED BY LAW, UNLESS THAT DESTRUCTION AND DISPOSAL HAS ALREADY BEEN ADDRESSED BY THE CRIMINAL MATTER ASSOCIATED WITH THESE VIOLATIONS. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THAT NO ADDITIONAL MLCC CHARGES BE FILED AGAINST THE LICENSEE IN THE EVEN THAT THERE ARE ANY CRIMINAL CHARGES AGAINST THE LICENSED CORPORATION, DIRECTORS, SHAREHOLDERS AGENTS OR EMPLOYEES FOR INCIDENTS THAT OCCURRED ON THE DATES ADDRESSED IN THIS ORDER. NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : INTEREST : CRP 09/03/2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136939 CLASSIC LOUNGE G- 4243 S SAGINAW BURTON MI 48529 LICENSEE(S) : RICKEY T'S CLASSICS, INC. CHARGE 1) NSF CHECK (312.64); 2) FAILED AS A CORPORATE LICENSEE TO MAINTAIN A CURRENT CHARTER UNDER THE LAWS OF THIS STATE, AS REQUIRED BY MCL 450.2911 AND/OR MCL 450.2922 AND/OR MCL 450.1911 AND/OR MCL 450.1535 AND/OR RULE 436.1109: AS DISCOVERED ON OR ABOUT 9-25-09 (LCC) 12-09-2009 HEARING HELD SWARTZ CREEK POBUR/HALL/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-11-2009 1)$100, 2)DISMISSED, TOTAL OF $100 OR 5 DAYS SUSP. RULE 15(E) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: GENESEE INTEREST : CRP 07/28/2008 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 127797 PACHYDERM PUB G-1408- 1410 E HEMPHILL BURTON MI 48529 LICENSEE(S) : PACHYDERM, LTD. CHARGE REC'D - 1)2)4)5)7)9) ALLOWED UNLAWFUL GAMBLING DEVICES (VIDEO SLOT OR VIDEO POKER MACHINES) ON LIC'D PREMISES USED FOR GAMBLING PURPOSES: ON OR ABOUT 5-15-07, ON OR ABOUT 5-15-07, ON OR ABOUT 6-1-07, ON OR ABOUT 6-1-07, ON OR ABOUT 7-19-07, ON OR ABOUT 11-1907; 3)6)8)10) ALLOWED WAGERING ON VIDEO POKER MACHINES ON LIC'D PREMISES: ON OR ABOUT 515-07, ON OR ABOUT 6-1-07, ON OR ABOUT 7-19-07, ON OR ABOUT 7-19-07: (GIS-23-07-MSP GAMING POST) 12-09-2009 HEARING HELD SWARTZ CREEK POBUR/HALL/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-11-2009 7 DAYS SUSP, SUSP WAIVED, 1-10)$300 EACH FOR A TOTAL OF $3000 OR 150 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THE LICENSEE TO FORFEIT THE GAMING MACHINES AND MONEY SEIZED IN THE COURSE OF THIS INVESTIGATION AND ORDERS THE MSP TO DESTROY THE SEIZED GAMING MACHINES AND TO DISPOSE OF THE MONEY SEIZED IN THE INVESTIGATION IN A MANNER PRESCRIBED BY LAW, UNLESS THAT DESTRUCTION AND DISPOSAL HAS ALREADY BEEN ADDRESSED BY THE CRIMINAL MATTER ASSOCIATED WITH THESE VIOLATIONS. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THAT NO ADDITIONAL MLCC CHARGES BE FILED AGAINST THE LICENSEE IN THE EVEN THAT THERE ARE ANY CRIMINAL CHARGES AGAINST THE LICENSED CORPORATION, DIRECTORS, SHAREHOLDERS AGENTS OR EMPLOYEES FOR INCIDENTS THAT OCCURRED ON THE DATES ADDRESSED IN THIS ORDER. NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : Report: LLVC0180 VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: GENESEE INTEREST : January 08, 2010 07:36 AM CRP Page 8 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 127798 THE ZOO 4511- 4515 S SAGINAW FLINT MI 48507 LICENSEE(S) : LAURIE FLETCHER, INC. CHARGE REC'D - 1)4)6)8)10)12) ALLOWED ON THE PREMISES VIDEO POKER MACHINES USED FOR GAMBLING PURPOSES: ON OR ABOUT 5-7-07, ON OR AOBUT 6-1-07, ON OR ABOUT 7-19-07, ON OR ABOUT 9-1407, ON OR ABOUT 10-12-07, ON OR ABOUT 11-20-07: 2)3)5)7)9)11)13) ALLOWED WAGERING ON VIDEO POKER MACHINES ON LIC'D PREMISES: ON OR ABOUT 5-7-07/$15/MAYLONE, ON OR ABOUT 5-707/$30/MAYLONE, ON OR ABOUT 6-1-07, ON OR ABOUT 7-19-07, ON OR ABOUT 9-14-07, ON OR ABOUT 10-12-07, ON OR ABOUT 11-20-07: (GIS-24-07-MSP GAMING POST) 12-09-2009 HEARING HELD SWARTZ CREEK POBUR/HALL/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-11-2009 7 DAYS SUSP, SUSP WAIVED 1-13)$300 EACH FOR A TOTAL OF $3900 OR 195 DAYS SUSP TO BE IMPOSED IF THE TOTAL FINE OF $3900 IS NOT PAID WITHIN 90 DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THE INVOICE ASSOCIATED WITH THIS ORDER. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THE LICENSEE TO FORFEIT THE GAMING MACHINES AND MONEY SEIZED IN THE COURSE OF THIS INVESTIGATION AND ORDERS THE MSP TO DESTROY THE SEIZED GAMING MACHINES AND TO DISPOSE OF THE MONEY SEIZED IN THE INVESTIGATION IN A MANNER PRESCRIBED BY LAW, UNLESS THAT DESTRUCTION AND DISPOSAL HAS ALREADY BEEN ADDRESSED BY THE CRIMINAL MATTER ASSOCIATED WITH THESE VIOLATIONS. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THAT NO ADDITIONAL MLCC CHARGES BE FILED AGAINST THE LICENSEE IN THE EVEN THAT THERE ARE ANY CRIMINAL CHARGES AGAINST THE LICENSED CORPORATION, DIRECTORS, SHAREHOLDERS AGENTS OR EMPLOYEES FOR INCIDENTS THAT OCCURRED ON THE DATES ADDRESSED IN THIS ORDER. NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 07/28/2008 COUNTY: GENESEE INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 127799 CHILI WILLY'S 2810 S DORT FLINT MI 48507 LICENSEE(S) : GEORGE-JOY, INC. CHARGE REC'D - 1)3)5)7)11) ALLOWED ON THE PREMISES VIDEO POKER MACHINES USED FOR GAMBLING PURPOSES: ON OR ABOUT 5-7-07, ON OR AOBUT 6-3-07, ON OR ABOUT 7-19-07, ON OR ABOUT 9-1207, ON OR ABOUT 11-17-07: 2)4)6)8)12)13) ALLOWED WAGERING ON VIDEO POKER MACHINES ON LIC'D PREMISES: ON OR ABOUT 5-7-07, ON OR ABOUT ABOUT 6-3-07, ON OR ABOUT 7-19-07, ON OR ABOUT 9-12-07, ON OR ABOUT 11-17-07/$85/MAYLONE, ON OR ABOUT 11-17-07/$45/MAYLONE; 9) ALLOWED LOTTERY AND/OR RAFFLE TICKETS, UNLAWFUL GAMBLING DEVICES, ON LIC'D PREMISES: 10) ALLOWED UNLAWFUL GAMBLING ON LIC'D PREMISES WITH LOTTERY AND/OR RAFFLE TICKETS: (GIS-25-07-MSP GAMING POST) 12-09-2009 HEARING HELD SWARTZ CREEK POBUR/HALL/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-11-2009 7 DAYS SUSP, SUSP WAIVED, 1-13)$150 EACH FOR A TOTAL OF $1950 OR 100 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THE LICENSEE TO FORFEIT THE GAMING MACHINES AND MONEY SEIZED IN THE COURSE OF THIS INVESTIGATION AND ORDERS THE MSP TO DESTROY THE SEIZED GAMING MACHINES AND TO DISPOSE OF THE MONEY SEIZED IN THE INVESTIGATION IN A MANN PRESCRIBED BY LAW, UNLESS THAT DESTRUCTION AND DISPOSAL HAS ALREADY BEEN ADDRESSED BY THE CRIMINAL MATTERS ASSOCIATED WITH THESE VIOLATIONS. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THAT NO ADDITIONAL COMMISSION CHARGES BE FILED AGAINST THE LICENSEE IN THE EVEN THAT THERE ARE ANY CRIMINAL CHARGES AGAINST THE LICENSED CORP, DIRECTORS, SHAREHOLDERS AGENTS OR EMPLOYEES FOR INCIDENTS THAT OCCURRED ON THE DATES ADDRESSED IN THIS ORDER. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THAT THE SUBJECT LICENSE WILL REMAIN IN ESCROW UNTIL IT IS TRANSFERRED TO AN ENTITY APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION. NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : Report: LLVC0180 VIOLATION DATE : 07/28/2008 COUNTY: GENESEE INTEREST : January 08, 2010 07:36 AM CRP Page 9 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 127802 SHERMAN'S LOUNGE 4211 FENTON FLINT MI 48507 LICENSEE(S) : BRUCE & ROBERTS, INC. CHARGE REC'D - 1)3)5)7)9)11) ALLOWED ON THE LIC'D PREMISES VIDEO POKER MACHINES USED FOR GAMBLING PURPOSES: ON OR ABOUT 5-15-07, ON OR AOBUT 7-20-07, ON OR ABOUT 8-18-07, ON OR ABOUT 9-1207, ON OR ABOUT 10-4-07, ON OR ABOUT 11-19-07: 2)4)6)8)10)12) ALLOWED WAGERING ON VIDEO POKER MACHINES ON LIC'D PREMISES: ON OR ABOUT 5-15-07, ON OR ABOUT 7-20-07, ON OR ABOUT 818-07, ON OR ABOUT 9-12-07, ON OR ABOUT 10-4-07, ON OR ABOUT 11-19-07: (GIS-29-07-MSP GAMING POST) 12-09-2009 HEARING HELD SWARTZ CREEK POBUR/HALL/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-11-2009 7 DAYS SUSP, SUSP WAIVED 1-12)$300 EACH FOR A TOTAL OF $3600 OR 180 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THE LICENSEE TO FORFEIT THE GAMING MACHINES AND MONEY SEIZED IN THE COURSE OF THIS INVESTIGATION AND ORDERS THE MSP TO DESTROY THE SEIZED GAMING MACHINES AND TO DISPOSE OF THE MONEY SEIZED IN THE INVESTIGATION IN A MANNER PRESCRIBED BY LAW, UNLESS THAT DESTRUCTION AND DISPOSAL HAS ALREADY BEEN ADDRESSED BY THE CRIMINAL MATTER ASSOCIATED WITH THESE VIOLATIONS. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THAT NO ADDITIONAL MLCC CHARGES BE FILED AGAINST THE LICENSEE IN THE EVEN THAT THERE ARE ANY CRIMINAL CHARGES AGAINST THE LICENSED CORPORATION, DIRECTORS, SHAREHOLDERS AGENTS OR EMPLOYEES FOR INCIDENTS THAT OCCURRED ON THE DATES ADDRESSED IN THIS ORDER. NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: GENESEE INTEREST : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137596 FLUSHING VALLEY GOLF & COUNTRY CLUB, INC. 1124 E MAIN AKA FLUSHING FLUSHING MI 48433 COUNTY: GENESEE LICENSEE(S) : FLUSHING VALLEY GOLF & COUNTRY CLUB, INC. CHARGE 1) SALE TO NON-MEMBER: 2) LICENSE NOT PROPERLY DISPLAYED: (LCC INV LEBOMBARD) : VIOLATION DATE : INTEREST : COMM. ORDER : 12-15-2009 RECEIVED ACKNOWLEDGMENT FROM ATTY. SETH TOMPKINS. ALF 12-16-2009 CHG 1 & 2) $200.00 EACH; TOTAL $400.00 OR 20 DAYS SUSP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 129589 SUEBEE'S PARTY STORE 152 S STATE OTISVILLE MI 48463 LICENSEE(S) : CHARLES KEELEY, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (1448.01): (LCC) : 07/28/2008 - CRP 10/24/2009 CLB COMM POBUR VIOLATION DATE : 10/01/2008 COUNTY: GENESEE INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 12-01-2008 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-03-2009 $150 OR 7 DAYS SUSP. ADDITIONALLY, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THAT THE LICENSEE PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BE CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK, OR MONEY ORDER UNTIL 1-2-09. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137154 HOMETOWN MEAT MARKET 1058 ESTEY BEAVERTON MI 48612 VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: GLADWIN LICENSEE(S) : HOMETOWN MEAT MARKET, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - LAN233 (19): (LCC INV BLANCHARD/DECOY/CK NICOLE FORD/ID) : INTEREST : COMM. ORDER : 12-09-2009 HEARING HELD SAGINAW GAFFNEY/ASEVEDO/DECLERCQ RULE 15(E) 12-15-2009 $300 OR 15 DAY SUSP. RULE 15(E) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137651 THREE RIVERS WAY PARTY STORE STAR ROUTE 4010 THREE RIVERS GLADWIN MI 48624 LICENSEE(S) : THREE RIVERS WAY, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (486.57): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : 09/19/2009 VIOLATION DATE : CRP 09/30/2009 COUNTY: GLADWIN INTEREST : CRP 11-25-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 $150 OR 12 DAY SUSP. Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 10 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137234 WALNUT HILLS COUNTRY CLUB R 1 2874 LAKE LANSING EAST LANSING MI 48823 LICENSEE(S) : WHCC MEMBERS CHARGE REC'D - 1) LEASED, SOLD OR TRF'D POSSESSION OF PORTION OF LIC'D PREMISZES, W/OUT PRIOR WRITTEN APPROVAL OF THE COMMISSION: 2) ALLOWED LLC WHOSE NAME DOES NOT APPEAR ON THE LICENSE, TO DERIVE USE OR BENEFIT FROM THE LICENSE (2874 LAKE LANSING ROAD, LLC): ON OR ABOUT 3-16-09 (LCC INV VILK) 12-08-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-11-2009 1)$300. 2)$300 TOTAL OF $600. $100 WAIVED FOR A TOTAL OF $500 OR 25 DAYS SUSP. AS ADDITIONAL PENALTY FOR THE CHARGES IN THIS COMPLAINT, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES AND PERMITS SUSP AS OF 3-15-10 WITH SAID SUSP BEING WAIVED IF THE PROPER LICENSEE ASSUMES FULL PROPRIETARY CONTROL OF THIS LICENSED BUSINESS, OR IF SAID LICENSE AND PERMITS ARE TRANSFERRED TO A PERSON APPROVED BY THE MLCC. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDERS THAT SAID LICENSE ANDPERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE SUSP IS NOT WAIVED BEFORE 6-15-10. : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137649 SAMMY'S RESTAURANT & LOUNGE 301 E JOLLY LANSING MI 48910 LICENSEE(S) : SAMMY'S INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (168.00): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: INGHAM INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : CLB 10/14/2009 COUNTY: INGHAM INTEREST : COMM. ORDER : 11-17-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 $75 OR 4 DAYS SUSP. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 134913 KROGER STORE #793 4884 MARSH OKEMOS MI 48864 LICENSEE(S) : THE KROGER CO. OF MICHIGAN CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - LAN219 (19): (LCC INV JOINTER/DECOY/CK BERNICE HILL/ID) : 10/01/2009 VIOLATION DATE : CRP 06/03/2009 COUNTY: INGHAM INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 12-07-2009 HEARING HELD LANSING POBUR/GEISSLER/DECLERCQ NEG SETTLEMENT 12-08-2009 3 DAYS SUSP, SUSP WAIVED, $800 OR 40 DAYS SUSP - SEC 801(2) NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137724 2 WATERS GRILLE 1017 & 1021 FOURTH LAKE ODESSA MI 48849 LICENSEE(S) : J.E.Y., INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (249.241): (LLC) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 10/17/2009 COUNTY: IONIA INTEREST : CRP 11-23-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $50 COMBINED WITH 9-137725 FOR $50 TOTAL OF $100. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDERS THAT THE CHECKS, SERVICE CHARGES, AND FINES ARE PAYABLE PRIOR TO RELEASE OF THE SUBJECT CLASS C AND SDM LICENSES FROM ESCROW. THE COMMISSIONER ALSO ORDERS ALL LICENSES AND PERMITS ISSUED BY THE MLCC BE REVOKED IF THE SUBJECT CHECKS, SERVICE CHARGES, AND FINES ARE NOT PAID WITHIN 120 DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 11 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137725 2 WATERS GRILLE 1017 & 1021 FOURTH LAKE ODESSA MI 48849 LICENSEE(S) : J.E.Y., INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (342.87): (LCC) : TO 12-31-2009 VIOLATION DATE : 10/19/2009 COUNTY: IONIA INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 11-23-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $50 COMBINED WITH 9-137724 FOR $50 TOTAL OF $100. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDERS THAT THE CHECKS, SERVICE CHARGES, AND FINES ARE PAYABLE PRIOR TO RELEASE OF THE SUBJECT CLASS C AND SDM LICENSES FROM ESCROW. THE COMMISSIONER ALSO ORDERS ALL LICENSES AND PERMITS ISSUED BY THE MLCC BE REVOKED IF THE SUBJECT CHECKS, SERVICE CHARGES, AND FINES ARE NOT PAID WITHIN 120 DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136916 LICENSEE(S) : VAL'S OPERATIONS, INC. CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 8-1808 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 5-19-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 11-13-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 $200 OR 10 DAYS SUSP. : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 545 W LAKE TAWAS CITY VIOLATION DATE : MI 48763 COUNTY: IOSCO INTEREST : 137824 FRATERNAL ORDER OF EAGLES #4463 AERIE 1440 S ISABELLA MOUNT PLEASANT MI 48858 COUNTY: ISABELLA LICENSEE(S) : FRATERNAL ORDER OF EAGLES #4463 AERIE CHARGE SALE TO NON-MEMBER: (LCC INV SMITH) : VIOLATION DATE : INTEREST : COMM. ORDER : 12-02-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-03-2009 $200 OR 10 DAYS SUSP. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136362 ROBINSON'S PARTY STORE 1233- 1235 S WEST JACKSON MI 49203 LICENSEE(S) : ANSH & SEF, LLC CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY BLOSS (19): (JACKSON PD/DECOY/CK JARNAIL SINGH/NO ID) : VIOLATION DATE : INTEREST : 12-09-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-22-2009 600.00 OR 30 DAY SUSP SEC 801(2) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137855 SPRINGPORT TRADING POST 108 E MAIN SPRINGPORT MI 49284 LICENSEE(S) : THORNTON, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (1365.50): (LCC) : CRP 11/07/2009 CLB 07/13/2009 COUNTY: JACKSON COMM. ORDER : COMM. ORDER : 09/23/2009 VIOLATION DATE : LLC 10/23/2009 COUNTY: JACKSON INTEREST : CRP 12-08-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-18-2009 $150.00 OR 7 DAYS SUSP Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 12 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136099 YARROW GOLF & CONFERENCE CENTER 10499 N FORTY EIGHTH AUGUSTA MI 49012 LICENSEE(S) : HOTEL INVESTMENT SERVICES, INC. YARROW, INC. CHARGE REC'D - 1) SOLD OR TRF'D LICENSE, OR AN INTEREST IN LICENSE W/OUT PRIOR APPROVAL OF MLCC (YARROW GOLF & CONFERENCE LLC): ON OR ABOUT 12-31-08; 2) ALLOWED LLC WHOSE NAME DOES NOT APPEAR ON THE LICENSE, TO DERIVE USE OR BENEFIT FROM LICENSE: ON OR ABOUT 12-31-08; 3) LEASED, SOLD OR TRF'D POSSESSION OF PORTION OF LIC'D PREMISES TO LLC W/OUT PRIOR WRITTEN APPROVAL OF THE COMMISSION: ON OR ABOUT 12-31-08; 4)6) SOLD OR TRF'D IN THE AGGREGATE MORE THAN 10% OF THE STK OF THE LIC'D CORP W/OUT MLCC CONSENT: ON OR ABOUT 2-08 - RONALD J WILSON, AS TRUSTEE UNDER THE REVOCABLE TRUST AGREEMENT OF RONALD J. WILSON; ON OR ABOUT 625-09 - ROXANNE V WILSON, AS TRUSTEE OF THE ROXANNE V WILSON TRUST; 5)7) ALLOWED PERSONS WHOSE NAMES NOT APPEAR ON THE LICENSE TO DERIVE USE OR BENEFIT FROM LICENSE: ON OR ABOUT 2-08 & ON OR ABOUT 5-26-09; 8) FAILED TO REPORT BY 7-1-09, ANY STK TRF IN THE CORPORATION DURING THE PRECEDING LICENSING YEAR: (LCC INV REEDER) 12-14-2009 STIPULATION FOR PROPOSED NEG SETTLEMENT-COMM POBUR-AG HALL 12-21-2009 1-8)$100 EACH FOR A TOTAL OF $800 OR 40 DAYS SUSP. IN ADDITION, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES AND PERMITS ISSUED SUSP AS OF 3-1-10, WITH SAID SUSP BEING WAIVED IF THE CO-LICENSEES RECEIVE APPROVAL FROM THE COMMISSION FOR THE UNREPORTED TRANSERS OF INTEREST AND STOCK ADDRESSED IN THIS MATTER OR IF SAID LICENSES AND PERMITS ARE TRANSFERRED TO AN ENTITY APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDERS THAT SAID LICENSES AND PERMITS RE REVOKED IF THE SUSP IS NTO WAIVED BEFORE 4-30-10. NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 08/04/2009 COUNTY: KALAMAZOO INTEREST : INTEREST : CLC CLC COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137141 VIOLATION DATE : KALAMAZOO AMERICAN LEGION POST NO. 134, INC., THE AMERICAN LEGION, DEPARTMENT 2233 N BURDICK KALAMAZOO MI 49007 COUNTY: KALAMAZOO 09/18/2009 LICENSEE(S) : KALAMAZOO AMERICAN LEGION POST NO. 134, INC., THE AMERICAN LEGION, DEPARTMENT OF MICHIGAN ALLOW FIGHTS ON LIC'D PREMISES: (KALAMAZOO TWP PD) CLB CHARGE : INTEREST : COMM. ORDER : 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD KALAMAZOO MOURNING/HALL/CONTRACT 12-21-2009 $300.00 OR 15 DAYS SUSP. FURTHER, THE AL JUDGE ORDERS A SUSPENSION OF 3 CONSECUTIVE DAYS. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 138068 DINO'S 773 W MICHIGAN KALAMAZOO MI LICENSEE(S) : CUDDLEFISH LLC CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY #1 W/DOB 4-15-89 (20): (KALAMAZOO DPS/DECOY/CK TIMOHTY NORTHRUP/NO ID) 12-16-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-18-2009 $600.00 OR 30 DAYS SUSP SEC 801(2) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 49007 11/12/2009 COUNTY: KALAMAZOO INTEREST : LLC COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137360 J & B DISCOUNT LIQUOR 110 W STOCKBRIDGE SUITE B KALAMAZOO MI 49001 LICENSEE(S) : STOCKBRIDGE ENTERPRISE LLC CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 2-2608 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 8-27-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 12-07-2009 HEARING HELD LANSING POBUR/GEISSLER/DECLERCQ ACK 12-21-2009 $200 OR 10 DAYS SUSP. : COMM. ORDER : Report: LLVC0180 VIOLATION DATE : 10/13/2009 COUNTY: KALAMAZOO INTEREST : January 08, 2010 07:36 AM LLC Page 13 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137640 MUNCHIE MART #2 3626 W MICHIGAN KALAMAZOO MI 49006 LICENSEE(S) : CATULLO, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (3929.84): (LCC) : TO 12-31-2009 VIOLATION DATE : 09/29/2009 COUNTY: KALAMAZOO INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 11-24-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $300 OR 15 DAY SUSP. LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 6 MONTHS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137735 TAPS SPORTS BAR II 48 WEST 8 SW IONIA & 48 W FULTON GRAND RAPIDS MI 49503 LICENSEE(S) : THE TAP HOUSE, L.L.C. CHARGE NSF EFT (764.17) (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : 10/08/2009 COUNTY: KENT INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 12-07-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 $50.00 COMBINED W/9-137734, 9-137851, 9-137852, 9-137853 & 9-137854; TOTAL $300.00 OR 15 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ALSO ORDERS THE LICENSEE PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF ONE (1) YEAR FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137194 RICHARD'S TAKEOUT 1134 SE BURTON GRAND RAPIDS MI VIOLATION DATE : 49507 09/19/2009 COUNTY: KENT CRP LICENSEE(S) : RICHARD'S TAKEOUT, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY SHERMAN W/DOB 2-6-90 (19): (GRAND RAPIDS PD/DECOY/CK BHAGAVATI JOSHI/NO ID) 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $600.00 OR 30 DAYS SUSP SEC 801(2) : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137854 TAPS SPORTS BAR II 48 WEST 8 SW IONIA & 48 W FULTON GRAND RAPIDS MI 49503 LICENSEE(S) : THE TAP HOUSE, L.L.C. CHARGE NSF EFT (2945.45): (LCC) : INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : 10/29/2009 COUNTY: KENT INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 12-07-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 $50.00 COMBINED W/9-137734, 9-137735, 9-137851, 9-137852 & 9-137853; TOTAL $300.00 OR 15 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ALSO ORDERS THE LICENSEE PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF ONE (1) YEAR FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137853 TAPS SPORTS BAR II 48 WEST 8 SW IONIA & 48 W FULTON GRAND RAPIDS MI 49503 LICENSEE(S) : THE TAP HOUSE, L.L.C. CHARGE NSF EFT (997.85): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 10/29/2009 COUNTY: KENT INTEREST : LLC 12-07-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 $50.00 COMBINED W/9-137734, 9-137735, 9-137851, 9-137852 & 9-137854; TOTAL $300.00 OR 15 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ALSO ORDERS THE LICENSEE PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF ONE (1) YEAR FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 14 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137852 TAPS SPORTS BAR II 48 WEST 8 SW IONIA & 48 W FULTON GRAND RAPIDS MI 49503 LICENSEE(S) : THE TAP HOUSE, L.L.C. CHARGE NSF EFT (1378.20): (LCC) : TO 12-31-2009 VIOLATION DATE : 10/28/2009 COUNTY: KENT INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 12-07-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 $50.00 COMBINED W/9-137734, 9-137735, 9-137851, 9-137853 & 9-137854; TOTAL $300.00 OR 15 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ALSO ORDERS THE LICENSEE PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF ONE (1) YEAR FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137851 TAPS SPORTS BAR II 48 WEST 8 SW IONIA & 48 W FULTON GRAND RAPIDS MI 49503 LICENSEE(S) : THE TAP HOUSE, L.L.C. CHARGE NSF EFT (551.83): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : 10/28/2009 COUNTY: KENT INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 12-07-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 $50.00 COMBINED W/9-137734, 9-137735, 9-137852, 9-137853 & 9-137854; TOTAL $300.00 OR 15 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ALSO ORDERS THE LICENSEE PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF ONE (1) YEAR FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137191 BURTON HEIGHTS FOODLAND 16 SW BURTON GRAND RAPIDS MI 49507 LICENSEE(S) : CHO, SUNG SOO CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY KEELEAN W/DOB 2-2-91 (18): (GRAND RAPIDS PD/DECOY/CK SUNG CHOO/ID) ***ENERGY DRINK W/ALCOHOL*** 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 $700 OR 35 DAY SUSP. SEC.801(2) : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137734 TAPS SPORTS BAR II 48 WEST 8 SW IONIA & 48 W FULTON GRAND RAPIDS MI 49503 LICENSEE(S) : THE TAP HOUSE, L.L.C. CHARGE NSF EFT (1648.94): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/19/2009 COUNTY: KENT INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : IND 10/08/2009 COUNTY: KENT INTEREST : LLC 12-07-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 $50.00 COMBINED W/9-137735, 9-137851, 9-137852, 9-137853 & 9-137854; TOTAL $300.00 OR 15 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ALSO ORDERS THE LICENSEE PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF ONE (1) YEAR FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 15 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137817 JOE MARTINI'S 1404 SE TWENTY EIGHTH SUITE B GRAND RAPIDS MI 49508 LICENSEE(S) : JOE MARTINI'S, INC. CHARGE REC'D - 1) SOLD OR TRF'D LICENSE, OR AN INTEREST IN LICENSE W/OUT PRIOR APPROVAL OF THE MLCC (STEVE BENNER AND/OR JAIME PEREZ AND/OR ENEIDA PEREZ AND/OR EL BACHATERO, LLC): AS DISCOVERED 11-9-09; 2) ALLOW PERSON AND/OR LLC WHOSE NAMES DO NOT APPEAR ON THE LICENSE, TO DERIVE USE OR BENEFIT FROM THE LICENSE: AS DISCOVERED 11-9-09; 3) LEASED, SOLD OR TRF'D POSSESSION OF PORTION OF LIC'D PREMISES, W/OUT PRIOR WRITTEN APPROVAL OF THE COMMISSION: AS DISCOVERED 11-9-09; 4) MADE A FALSE OR FRAUDULENT WRITTEN STATEMENT TO THE MLCC SPECIFICALLY: A PARTICIPATION AGREEMENT DATED 2-25-09, WHICH STATEMENT WAS MADE FOR THE PURPOSE OF INDUCING THE COMMISSION TO ACT, OR REFRAIN FROM TAKING ACTION, OR TO ENABLE OR ASSIST A PERSON JAIME PEREZ AND/OR ENEIDA PEREZ AND/OR EL BACHATERO, LLC, IN EVADING THE PROVISIONS OF THE LIQUOR CONTROL CODE: (LCC INV MANN) 12-16-2009 HEARING HELD GRAND RAPIDS POBUR/HALL/DECLERCQ ACK 12-21-2009 CHGS 1 - 4) $300.00 EACH; TOTAL $1200.00 OR 60 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ALSO ORDERS THE LICENSEE TO COMPLY WITH ALL TERMS OF THE APPROVED PARTICIPATION AGREEMENT DATED FEBRUARY 25, 2009, WHICH IS CONTAINED WITHIN THE VIOLATION REPORT. IN ADDITION, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES AND PERMITS ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION TO THIS LICENSEE AT THE ABOVE NAMED ADDRESS BE SUSPENDED AS OF THE DATE OF THIS ORDER WITH SAID SUSPENSION BEING WAIVED IF THE PROPER LICENSEE ASSUMES FULL PROPRIETARY CONTROL OF THIS LICENSED BUSINESS, OR IF THE LICENSEE RECEIVES APPROVAL FROM THE COMMISSION FOR THE UNREPORTED TRANSFER OF INTEREST. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDERS THAT SAID LICENSES AND PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE SUSPENSION IS NOT WAIVED ON OR BEFORE ONE HUNDRED AND TWENTY (120) DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER, UNLESS GOOD CAUSE CAN BE SHOWN TO THE COMMISSION FOR EXTENSION OF SAID DATE. : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 11/13/2009 COUNTY: KENT INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137193 B & E PARTY STORE 757 SE BURTON GRAND RAPIDS MI LICENSEE(S) : WOODMARY INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY SHERMAN W/DOB 2-6-90 (19): (GRAND RAPIDS PD/DECOY/CK IBRAHIM HUSSEIN/ID) 11-30-2009 HEARING HELD GRAND RAPIDS MOURNING/GEISSLER/CONTRACT ACK COST $8.75 12-14-2009 $1000.00 OR 50 DAYS SUSP, PLUS $8.75 WITNESS FEES; TOTAL $1008.75 SEC 801(2) : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136929 JOE V'S 526 NW STOCKING GRAND RAPIDS MI VIOLATION DATE : 49507 VIOLATION DATE : 49504 ANTHONY'S PIZZA, L.L.C. CHARGE NSF CHECK (137.71): (LCC) : COUNTY: KENT INTEREST : LICENSEE(S) : 09/19/2009 CRP 09/03/2009 COUNTY: KENT INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 11-30-2009 HEARING HELD GRAND RAPIDS MOURNING/GEISSLER/CONTRACT RULE 15(D) 12-14-2009 $200.00 OR 10 DAYS SUSP. FURTHER, THE AL JUDGE ORDERS THE LICENSEE PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF SIX (6) MONTHS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. RULE 15(D) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137195 MEXICAN HERITAGE ASSOCIATION, INC. PO BOX 3155 GRAND RAPIDS MI 49503 CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY SMITH W/DOB 2-28-91 (18): (GRAND RAPIDS PD/DECOY/CK ANGEL RODRIGUEZ/ID) 12-16-2009 HEARING HELD GRAND RAPIDS POBUR/HALL/DECLERCQ ACK COST $28.00 12-21-2009 $500.00 SEC 801(2), PLUS $28.00 WITNESS FEES; TOTAL $528.00 WITH NO FUTURE SPECIAL LICENSES TO BE ISSUED UNTIL THE FINE IS PAID. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDERS THAT THE ADMINISTRATIVE COMMISSIONERS BE ADVISED OF THIS VIOLATION IN THE EVENT ANY FUTURE SPECIAL LICENSES ARE REQUESTED BY THE ABOVE SPECIAL LICENSEE. : COMM. ORDER : Report: LLVC0180 VIOLATION DATE : 09/19/2009 COUNTY: KENT January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 16 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137189 SPIKE-N-MIKES 967 E FULTON GRAND RAPIDS LICENSEE(S) : DHOORH LIQUOR & FOOD, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - GR252 (18): (LCC INV A. ANDERSON/DECOY/CK RASMI A-F HAMAD/NO ID) ***ENERGY DRINK W/ALCOHOL*** 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 3 DAYS SUSP, $1000 OR 50 DAYS SUSP - SEC 801(2) : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137190 7-ELEVEN #43 1001 W FULTON GRAND RAPIDS VIOLATION DATE : MI 49503 COUNTY: KENT INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : MI 49504 09/18/2009 CRP 09/19/2009 COUNTY: KENT LICENSEE(S) : GARB-KO, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY JESSEE W/DOB 3-23-90 (19): (GRAND RAPIDS PD/DECOY/CK NICHOLAS LAVELLE/ID) 11-24-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-11-2009 $750.00 OR 37 DAYS SUSP SEC 801(2) : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136936 LOUIS BENTON STEAK HOUSE 77 NW MONROE CENTER GRAND RAPIDS MI 49503 LICENSEE(S) : LOUIS BENTON STEAK HOUSE, LLC CHARGE NSF CHECK (211.85): (LCC) : INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : INTEREST : 11-30-2009 HEARING HELD GRAND RAPIDS MOURNING/GEISSLER/CONTRACT 12-14-2009 $100.00 OR 5 DAYS SUSP RULE 15(D) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137331 WILDERNESS COUNTRY STORE 1585 SEVENTEEN MILE KENT CITY MI 49330 LICENSEE(S) : CROWLEY, PENNY SUE NSF CHECK (502.93): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : 136512 WILDERNESS COUNTRY STORE 1585 SEVENTEEN MILE KENT CITY MI 49330 LICENSEE(S) : CROWLEY, PENNY SUE CHARGE NSF CHECK (625.16): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : LLC RULE 15(D) VIOLATION DATE : 09/24/2009 COUNTY: KENT INTEREST : 11-23-2009 HEARING HELD GRAND RAPIDS POBUR/HALL/DECLERCQ RULE 15(E) 12-08-2009 $50.00 COMBINED W/9-136512; TOTAL $100.00 OR 5 DAYS SUSP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 09/09/2009 COUNTY: KENT COMM. ORDER : CHARGE CRP IND RULE 15(E) VIOLATION DATE : 08/06/2009 COUNTY: KENT INTEREST : 11-23-2009 HEARING HELD GRAND RAPIDS POBUR/HALL/DECLERCQ RULE 15(E) 12-08-2009 $50.00 COMBINED W/9-137331; TOTAL $100.00 OR 5 DAYS SUSP IND RULE 15(E) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137257 JAKE'S FOOD MARKET 758 SW ALGER WYOMING MI 49509 LICENSEE(S) : JACKOBS INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY W/DOB 7-25-91 (18): (WYOMING PD/DECOY/CK ALEX NAWROCKI/ID) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/28/2009 COUNTY: KENT INTEREST : CRP 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-01-2009 $600 OR 30 DAY SUSP. SEC.801(2) Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 17 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137588 LICENSEE(S) : VILLAGE STATION INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY MARDEN W/DOB 8-5-91 (18): (IMLAY CITY PD/DECOY/CK JEANNETTE SLOAN/ID)***LAW ENF AGENCIES (WITHIN LAPEER CO) SWORN LAW ENF AUTHORITY FROM LAPEER CO SD UNDER AGREEMENT W/MI YOUTH ENF GRANT*** 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $700.00 OR 35 DAYS SUSP SEC 801(2) : COMM. ORDER : 4460 FIRST COLUMBIAVILLE VIOLATION DATE : MI 48421 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137493 CASTAWAYS FOOD & SPIRITS R 1 4058 HUNT LAPEER MI 48446 LICENSEE(S) : SALAD ENTERPRISES, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (258.24): (LCC) : 09/30/2009 COUNTY: LAPEER INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : CRP 10/05/2009 COUNTY: LAPEER INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 12-04-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-17-2009 100.00/50.00 WAIVED OR 3 DAY SUSP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137356 CASTAWAYS FOOD & SPIRITS R 1 4058 HUNT LAPEER MI 48446 LICENSEE(S) : SALAD ENTERPRISES, INC. CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 12-1708 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 8-7-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 12-04-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-17-2009 200.00 OR 10 DAY SUSP : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 10/13/2009 COUNTY: LAPEER INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136678 KOLZ'S KORNER 6901 W BEECHER CLAYTON MI 49235 LICENSEE(S) : MILTON PLACE COMPANY CHARGE 1) NSF CHECK (304.94); 2) FAILED AS A CORPORATE LICENSEE TO MAINTAIN A CURRENT CHARTER UNDER THE LAWS OF THIS STATE, AS REQUIRED BY MCL 450.2911 AND/OR MCL 450.2922 AND/OR MCL 450.1911 AND/OR MCL 450.1535 AND/OR RULE 436.1109: AS DISCOVERED ON OR ABOUT 9-18-09: (LCC) 11-12-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 1)$100, 2)$100 TOTAL OF $200 OR 10 DAYS SUSP. AS ADDITIONAL PENALTY IN THIS MATTER, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THAT THE SDDD & SDM LICENSES BE SUSP AS OF 2-15-10 WITH SAID SUSP BEING WAIVED IF THE PROPER LICENSED CORP IS A MEMEBER IN GOOD STANDING IN THE STATE OF MI OR IF THE SDD AND SDM LICENSE ARE TRANSFERRED TO A PERSON APPROVED BY THE MLCC; FURTHER, THAT ALL LICENSES AND PERMITS BE REVOKED IF SAID SUSP IS NOT WAIVED BEFORE 4-15-10. : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 08/26/2009 COUNTY: LENAWEE INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 134254 R & S PETROLEUM 1837 W MICHIGAN CLINTON MI 49236 LICENSEE(S) : R&S PETROLEUM, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - UCB#1 W/DOB 8-4-91 (17): (LENAWEE CO SHER DEPT/DECOY/CK SALAH AYOUD/ID) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 04/17/2009 COUNTY: LENAWEE INTEREST : CRP 11-16-2009 HEARING HELD JACKSON MOURNING/GEISSLER/DECLERCQ ACK 12-08-2009 $700 OR 35 DAYS SUSP & $100 COSTS FOR A TOTAL OF $800 SEC 801(2) Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 18 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 129633 FILLIN' STATION 49434 N GRATIOT CHESTERFIELD MI LICENSEE(S) : J. M. D. VECCHIO, INC. CHARGE REC'D - 1)3)5)7)9) ALLOWED WAGERING ON CASINO-TYPE VIDEO POKER MACHINE ON LC'D PREMISES: ON OR ABOUT 11-30-06, ON OR ABOUT 1-21-07, ON OR ABOUT 4-18-07, ON OR ABOUT 7-10-08, OR OR ABOUT 8-1-08; 2)4)6)8)10) ALLOWED ON THE LIC'D PREMISES A CASINO-TYPE VIDEO POKER MACHINES USED FOR GAMBLING PURPOSES: ON OR ABOUT 11-30-06, ON OR ABOUT 1-21-07, ON OR ABOUT 4-1807, ON OR ABOUT 7-10-08, OR OR ABOUT 8-1-08; 11)12) ALLOWED UNLAWFUL GAMBLING DEVICE ON LIC'D PREMISES CHERRY MASTER VIDEO SLOT DEVICE & "CRAZY BUG" TABLE-TOP VIDEO SLOT DEVICE: ON OR ABOUT 8-7-08; 13) LICENSEE, OR CLERK, SERVANT, AGENT, OR EMPLOYEE OF THE LICENSEE ENGAGED IN AN ILLEGAL OCCUPATION OR ILLEGAL ACT UPON THE LIC'D PREMISES, SPECIFICALLY: KEPT, MAINTAINED OR PERMITTED GAMING ROOM: VARIOUS DATES 2006-2008 (GIS-75-06-MSP GAMING POST & MLCC INV PEISERT) 12-09-2009 HEARING HELD SWARTZ CREEK POBUR/HALL/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-11-2009 7 DAYS SUSP, SUSP WAIVED, 1-13)$300 EACH FOR A TOTAL OF $3900 OR 195 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THE LICENSEE TO FORFEIT THE GAMING MACHINES AND MONEY SEIZED IN THE COURSE OF THIS INVESTIGATION AND ORDERS THE MSP TO DESTROY THE SEIZED GAMING MACHINES AND TO DISPOSE OF THE MONEY SEIZED IN THE INVESTIGATION IN A MANNER PRESCRIBED BY LAW, UNLESS THAT DESTRUCTION AND DISPOSAL HAS ALREADY BEEN ADDRESSED BY THE CRIMINAL MATTER ASSOCIATED WITH THESE VIOLATIONS. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THAT NO ADDITIONAL MLCC CHARGES BE FILED AGAINST THE LICENSEE IN THE EVEN THAT THERE ARE ANY CRIMINAL CHARGES AGAINST THE LICENSED CORPORATION, DIRECTORS, SHAREHOLDERS AGENTS OR EMPLOYEES FOR INCIDENTS THAT OCCURRED ON THE DATES ADDRESSED IN THIS ORDER. NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 48051 136356 PARKWAY PARTY CENTER 37031 GROESBECK CLINTON TOWNSHIP MI LICENSEE(S) : PARKWAY BEVERAGES, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (6,979.25): (LCC) : COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : VIOLATION DATE : 48036 COMM. ORDER : 11-20-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-11-2009 DISMISSED COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136698 VENICE LIQUOR SHOPPE 40000 HAYES CLINTON TOWNSHIP MI LICENSEE(S) : 6R'S, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - ANTHONY EVANGELISTA (19): (CLINTON TWP PD/CK RAFID KAKOS/NO ID) : CRP 08/06/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : 48038 10/22/2008 CRP 08/21/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 12-14-2009 HEARING HELD STERLING HEIGHTS GAFFNEY/ASEVEDO/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT COST $11.50 12-15-2009 $550 OR 27 DAY SUSP. & $11.50 W/FEES TOTAL $561.50 NEG SETTLEMENT SEC.801(2) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137526 EASTPOINTE LIQUOR 24850 GRATIOT EASTPOINTE MI 48021 LICENSEE(S) : DST PARTY STORE, L.L.C. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - MICHAEL QUINN (17): (EASTPOINTE PD/CK ATHIR TALIA/NO ID) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 10/18/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : LLC 12-14-2009 HEARING HELD STERLING HEIGHTS GAFFNEY/ASEVEDO/GIBSON ADVISEMENT COST $22.50 12-15-2009 $1000 OR 50 DAY SUSP. SEC.801(2) Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 19 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136697 PJ'S RIVERHOUSE 24240 N RIVER MOUNT CLEMENS MI LICENSEE(S) : BOAT TOWN LOUNGE, INC. CHARGE REC'D - 1) SOLD, OFFERED OR KEPT FOR SALE, FURNISHED OR POSSESSED ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR, WHICH WAS NOT AUTHORIZED BY THE LICENSE ISSUED TO THE LICENSEE BY THE COMMISSION, ON OR ABOUT 63-09; 2)3) PURCHASED MORE THAN NINE (9) LITERS OF SPIRTIS FROM ASHER'S MARKET, DURING 4-109 TO 4-30-09 AND DURING 5-1-09 TO 5-31-09; 4) NSF CHECK (1192.50/2004 RENL FEES), ON OR AOBUT 5-3-04; 5) FAILED AS A CORPORATE LICENSEE TO MAINTAIN A CURRENT CHARTER UNDER THE LAWS OF THIS STATE, AS REQUIRED BY MCL 450.2911 AND/OR MCL 450.2922 AND/OR MCL 450.1911 AND/OR MCL 450.1535 AND/OR RULE 436.1109: AS DISCOVERED ON OR ABOUT 9-17-09: (LCC INV DAUSEY) 12-15-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/MCDOWELL/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-15-2009 $150 EACH TOTAL $750 NO ALTERNATIVE. FINE MUST BE PAID PRIOR TO RELEASE OF LICENSE FROM ESCROW : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : VIOLATION DATE : 48043 COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : 136685 59069 GRATIOT NEW HAVEN MI VIOLATION DATE : 48048 CRP 08/18/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB LICENSEE(S) : HUCK FAMILY INVESTMENTS, LLC CHARGE NSF CHECK (1,251.13): (LCC) : 05/03/2009 INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $200.00 OR 10 DAYS SUSP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137250 APPLEBEE'S #5817 31653 GRATIOT ROSEVILLE MI 48066 LICENSEE(S) : APPLEBEE'S RESTAURANTS MID-ATLANTIC LLC (A DELAWARE LIMITED LLC INTEREST : LIABILITY COMPANY) SALE TO MINOR - CI#846 W/DOB 6-8-90 (19): (ROSEVILLE PD/DECOY/CK JOSEPH WHALEY/ID) CHARGE : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: MACOMB 12-07-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-17-2009 $700.00 OR 35 DAYS SUSP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136357 PAT O'BRIEN'S TAVERN 22385 TEN MILE SAINT CLAIR SHORES MI LICENSEE(S) : POB, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (1,506.88): (LCC) : SEC 801(2) VIOLATION DATE : 48080 INTEREST : 11-23-2009 HEARING HELD STERLING HEIGHTS MOURNING/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-14-2009 $100 OR 5 DAY SUSP. RULE 15(E) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136681 BARRISTER GARDENS 24225 HARPER SAINT CLAIR SHORES LICENSEE(S) : BARRISTER GARDENS, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (358.92): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : MI 48080 08/05/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB COMM. ORDER : COMM. ORDER : 09/24/2009 CRP 08/26/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : CRP 11-23-2009 HEARING HELD STERLING HEIGHTS MOURNING/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-14-2009 $300 OR 15 DAY SUSP. ALSO LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF CASH FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 6 MONTHS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. RULE 15(E) Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 20 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136198 TIRAMI SU 51195 SCHOENHERR SHELBY TOWNSHIP LICENSEE(S) : TIRAMI SU OF SHELBY INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - CI #349 W/DOB 1-5-91 (18): (SHELBY TWP PD/DECOY/CK AMY SIPSOCK/NO ID) : VIOLATION DATE : MI 48315 07/30/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 11-23-2009 HEARING HELD STERLING HEIGHTS MOURNING/ASEVEDO/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT COST $11.50 12-14-2009 $500 OR 25 DAY SUSP. & $11.50 W/FEES TOTAL $511.50 NEG SETTLEMENT SEC.801(2) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136200 BEEF O'BRADY'S 8194- 8198 TWENTY THREE MILE SHELBY TOWNSHIP MI 48316 LICENSEE(S) : MATEYAK & ASSOCIATES, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - CI #349 W/DOB 1-5-91 (18): (SHELBY TWP PD/DECOY/CK STACI KENNY/NO ID) : VIOLATION DATE : 07/30/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 11-23-2009 HEARING HELD STERLING HEIGHTS MOURNING/RUBIN/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT COST $11.50 12-14-2009 $500 WAIVE $100 $400 OR 20 DAY SUSP. & $11.50 W/FEES NEG SETTLEMENT SEC.801(2) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137020 THE PALAZZO GRANDE 54660 VAN DYKE SHELBY TOWNSHIP MI VIOLATION DATE : 48316 09/28/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB LICENSEE(S) : THE PALAZZO GRANDE, INC. CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 11-2008 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 6-3-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 11-17-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $200.00 OR 10 DAYS SUSP : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137143 BALKAN MARKET 52000 VAN DYKE SHELBY TOWNSHIP INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : MI 48316 CRP 09/11/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB LICENSEE(S) : BALKAN MARKET INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - CI #344 W/DOB 2-5-91 (18): (SHELBY TWP PD/DECOY/CK IGOR ANAKLIEV/ID?) : INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 11-23-2009 HEARING HELD STERLING HEIGHTS MOURNING/RUBIN/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT COST $17.00 12-14-2009 $750 OR 38 DAY SUSP. & $17 W/FEES TOTAL $767 NEG SETTLEMENT SEC.801(2) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137437 STERLING SPORTS PUB 37722 VAN DYKE STERLING HEIGHTS MI LICENSEE(S) : COUPLES, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (762.20): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 48312 09/30/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : CRP 12-14-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-17-2009 $100.00 W/$50.00 WAIVED; TOTAL $50.00 OR 3 DAYS SUSP Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 21 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137028 BD'S MONGOLIAN BARBEQUE 13150 HALL STERLING HEIGHTS MI 48313 LICENSEE(S) : MONGOLIAN OPERATING COMPANY, LLC CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 11-1208 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 7-21-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 11-30-2009 HEARING HELD LANSING GAFFNEY/HALL/DECLERCQ RULE 15(D) 12-01-2009 $100 OR 5 DAYS SUSP. : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137322 VINEYARDS 45747 MOUND UTICA MI 48317 LICENSEE(S) : SHOUNEYIA BROS. CORP. CHARGE NSF CHECK (2051.93): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : 09/30/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : LLC 09/22/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 11-20-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $100.00 WITH $50.00 WAIVED; TOTAL $50.00 OR 3 DAYS SUSP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136194 THE MEXICAN VILLAGE 47350 VAN DYKE UTICA MI 48317 LICENSEE(S) : MEXICAN VILLAGE OF UTICA, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - CI #343 W/DOB 3-3-91 (18): (SHELBY TWP PD/DECOY/CK KERRY TRUSEWICZ/NO ID) : VIOLATION DATE : 07/29/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 11-23-2009 HEARING HELD STERLING HEIGHTS MOURNING/ASEVEDO/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT COST $17.00 12-14-2009 $400 WAIVE $100 $300 OR 15 DAY SUSP. & $17 W/FEES TOTAL $317 NEG SETTLEMENT SEC.801(2) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137433 ABSOLUTE LIQUOR 26953 RYAN WARREN MI 48091 LICENSEE(S) : ABSOLUTE LIQUOR, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (5577.63): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : 09/29/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $200 OR 10 DAY SUSP. LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 3 MONTHS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 133721 BUGSY'S BAR & GRILL 1980 TWELVE MILE WARREN MI 48092 LICENSEE(S) : UNIVERSAL ENTERPRISES, L.L.C. CHARGE 1) SALE TO MINOR - LE94 W/DOB 4-8-89 (19): 2) SALE TO MINOR - LE95 W/DOB 4-25-90 (18): (WARREN PD/DECOYS/CK RACHEL GARCIO/ID) 11-10-2009 HEARING HELD STERLING HEIGHTS POBUR/MCDOWELL/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-12-2009 1)$600 2)DISMISSED TOTAL $600 OR 30 DAY SUSP. SEC.801(2) NEG SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : Report: LLVC0180 VIOLATION DATE : 12/17/2008 COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : January 08, 2010 07:36 AM LLC Page 22 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 08/19/2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136649 RYAN PALACE 4300 E FOURTEEN MILE WARREN MI 48092 LICENSEE(S) : SHAMOUN MANAGEMENT, INC. CHARGE 1) ALLOWED UNLAWFUL GAMBLING WITH CARDS ON LIC'D PREMISES: 2) ALLOWED UNLAWFUL GAMBLING DEVICES, CARDS, ON LIC'D PREMISES: 3)4) ROIL SHAMOUN, LICENSEE, ENGAGED IN AN ILLEGAL OCCUPATION OR ILLEGAL ACT UPON THE LIC'D PREMISES, SPECIFICALLY: MAINTAINING A GAMBLING HOUSE & ALLOWED GAMBLING APPARATUS ON PREMISES: (WARREN PD & MLCC INVS TOMA & O'REILLY) 12-01-2009 STIPULATION FOR PROPOSED NEG SETTMENT - ALJ MOURNING-AAG RUBIN 12-14-2009 $900 OR 45 DAY SUSP. NEG SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 135638 LICENSEE(S) : X-FACTOR GROUP, LLC CHARGE NSF CHECK (629.19): (LCC) : 24200 DEQUINDRE WARREN MI 48091 VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : CRP 07/02/2009 COUNTY: MACOMB INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 11-23-2009 HEARING HELD STERLING HEIGHTS POBUR/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-14-2009 $200 OR 10 DAY SUSP. RULE 15(E) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137238 THE HARD ROCK BAR 212 IRON NEGAUNEE MI 49866 LICENSEE(S) : THE HARD ROCK BAR L.L.C. CHARGE 1) SALE TO INTOX PERSON - KEVIN REIDY: 2) ALLOW INTOX PERSON TO CONSUME: 3) ALLOW INTOX PERSON TO LOITER: 4) ALLOW FIGHTS OR BRAWLS ON LIC'D PREMISES: (NEGAUNEE PD) 12-08-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-18-2009 CHG 1) $500.00 SEC 801(2); CHGS 2, 3 & 4) $100.00 EACH; TOTAL $800.00 OR 40 DAYS SUSP : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/24/2009 COUNTY: MARQUETTE INTEREST : LLC COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137350 LICENSEE(S) : BELGIUMTOWN BAR & RESTAURANT, CORPORATION CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 10-1508 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 8-13-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 12-04-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-17-2009 $300 OR 15 DAYS SUSP. AS ADDITIONAL PENALTY THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES AND PERMITS BE SUSP AS OF 4-1-10, WITH SAID SUSP BEING WAIVED IF DOCUMENTARY PROOF OF SERVER TRAINING IS PROVIDED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE COMMISSION'S 10-15-08 ORDER. FURTHER THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THAT SAID LICENSES AND PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE SUSP IS NOT WAIVED BEFORE 6-1-10. : COMM. ORDER : W4346 BELGIUMTOWN STEPHENSON MI 49887 VIOLATION DATE : 10/13/2009 COUNTY: MENOMINEE INTEREST : CRP 08/18/2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137263 CEDAR RIVER PLAZA N8151 M 35 STEPHENSON MI 49887 LICENSEE(S) : CHIP INVESTMENTS INC. (A WISCONSIN CORPORATION) CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY JENKINS (19): (MENOMINEE CO SHER DEPT/DECOY/CK JACOB PETERSON/NO ID) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: MENOMINEE INTEREST : CRP 12-02-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 600.00 OR 30 DAY SUSP SEC 801(2) Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 23 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137064 NORTHERN MARKET AND PARTY STORE 6700 N SAGINAW MIDLAND MI 48640 LICENSEE(S) : STARK ROAD ENTERPRISES, L.L.C. CHARGE REC'D - 1) JAMES E JOHNSON, LLC MEMBER, WAS FOUND GUILTY OF CRIME INVOLVING EXCESSIVE USE OR ALCOHOL, SPECIFICALLY: OUIL ON 6-16-04: 9-1-04; 2) JAMES E JOHNSON, LLC MEMBER, WAS FOUND GUILTY OF CRIME INVOLVING EXCESSIVE USE OR ALCOHOL, SPECIFICALLY: DWI/OWIL ON 3-1406: 10-26-06 (LCC INV SMITH) 12-22-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-28-2009 3 DAY SUSPENSION WHICH IS WAIVED; CHGS 1 & 2) $300.00 EACH; TOTAL $600.00 OR 30 DAYS SUSP : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/21/2009 COUNTY: MIDLAND INTEREST : LLC COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137358 CLARK'S ONE STOP 3116 N MERIDIAN SANFORD MI 48657 LICENSEE(S) : D & B STORES INC. CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 12-1708 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM ACCEPTABLE TO THE COMMISSION BY ALL EMPLOYEES AND STOCKHOLDERS INVOLVED IN THE SALE OF ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR, AND/OR VERIFICATION OF ELECTRONIC SCANNING EQUIPMENT INSTALLED AT EACH CASH REGISTER WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 7-28-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 12-07-2009 HEARING HELD LANSING POBUR/GEISSLER/DECLERCQ ACK 12-08-2009 $100 OR 5 DAYS SUSP. : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 10/13/2009 COUNTY: MIDLAND INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137030 BEAR CLAW BREWERY AND GRILLE 10559 W WATERGATE CADILLAC MI 49601 LICENSEE(S) : BEAR CLAW BREWERY AND GRILLE, LLC CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 11-2008 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 7-16-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 11-30-2009 HEARING HELD LANSING GAFFNEY/HALL/DECLERCQ RULE 15 (D) 12-01-2009 $150 OR 7 DAYS SUSP. RULE 15(D) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/30/2009 COUNTY: MISSAUKEE INTEREST : LLC COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136443 PORT CITY C.I.O. BUILDING ASSOCIATION 490 W WESTERN MUSKEGON MI 49440 COUNTY: MUSKEGON CHARGE REC'D 8-19-09 - 1)2)3) PERMITTED QUANTITY OF ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR, SOLD FOR CONSUMPTION ON LIC'D PREMISES, TO BE REMOVED FROM THE LIC'D PREMISES, BY VARIOUS UNNAMED PERSONS, ON OR ABOUT 7-17-09, ON OR ABOUT 7-18-09, ON OR ABOUT 7-19-09: (MUSKEGON PD) 11-19-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 CHGS 1 & 2) $200.00 EACH; CHG 3) DISMISSED FOR INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE; TOTAL $400.00 WITH NO FUTURE SPECIAL LICENSES TO BE ISSUED UNTIL THE TOTAL FINE IS PAID. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDERS THAT THE ADMINISTRATIVE COMMISSIONERS BE ADVISED OF THIS VIOLATION IN THE EVENT ANY FUTURE SPECIAL LICENSES ARE REQUESTED BY THE ABOVE NAMED SPECIAL LICENSEE. : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 135376 DREAMER'S 978 PINE MUSKEGON VIOLATION DATE : MI 49442 LICENSEE(S) : OPPORTUNITY, L.L.C. CHARGE NSF CHECK (97.74): : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 08/19/2009 06/04/2009 COUNTY: MUSKEGON INTEREST : LLC (LCC) 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $100.00 OR 5 DAYS SUSP Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 24 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136439 KELLYS PUB 9 N DIVISION FREMONT MI LICENSEE(S) : KJA ENTERPRISES, INC. CHARGE 1) SALE TO INTOX PERSON - MATTHEW LATTIN; 2) ALLOW INTOX PERSON TO CONSUME; 3) ALLOW INTOX PERSON TO LOITER: (FREMONT PD/CK MARLENE DRAKE) 11-23-2009 HEARING HELD GRAND RAPIDS POBUR/HALL/DECLERCQ NEG SETTLEMENT COST $6.00 12-08-2009 CHG 1) $800.00 SEC 801(2); CHGS 2 & 3) $300.00 EACH; $1400.00 OR 70 DAYS SUSP, PLUS $6.00 WITNESS FEES; TOTAL $1406.00 NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 49412 08/21/2009 COUNTY: NEWAYGO INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136647 OAKRIDGE RESTAURANT RR 3 9103 MASON NEWAYGO MI 49337 LICENSEE(S) : OAKS, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY SANDERS (19): (NEWAYGO CO SHER DEPT/DECOY/CK CARMON KOLENBRANDER/NO ID) 11-30-2009 HEARING HELD GRAND RAPIDS MOURNING/GEISSLER/CONTRACT NEG SETTLEMENT 12-14-2009 $500.00 OR 25 DAYS SUSP SEC 801(2) NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136646 CITY LITE INN R 1 1300 EIGHTH WHITE CLOUD MI VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: NEWAYGO INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : 49349 08/26/2009 CRP 08/27/2009 COUNTY: NEWAYGO LICENSEE(S) : LAMP LITE INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY RUNNIONS (18): (NEWAYGO CO SHER DEPT/DECOY/CK CARRIE WILSON/NO ID) : INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 11-30-2009 HEARING HELD GRAND RAPIDS MOURNING/GEISSLER/CONTRACT ACK COST $72.00 12-14-2009 $600.00 OR 30 DAYS SUSP, PLUS $72.00 WITNEES FEES; TOTAL $672.00 SEC 801(2) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 135940 SAV-ON BIRMINGHAM DRUGS 33877 WOODWARD BIRMINGHAM MI 48009 LICENSEE(S) : BILLNAT CORPORATION CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - X172 (19): (LCC INV COSTELLO/DECOY/CK CYNTHIA BRAUN/ID) : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : COMM. ORDER : 12-22-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/MCDOWELL/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-22-2009 $900 OR 45 DAYS SUSP - SEC 801(2) NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137487 DIXIE PARTY STORE 8774 DIXIE CLARKSTON MI 48348 LICENSEE(S) : J, J & G, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (1423.14): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : 07/16/2009 VIOLATION DATE : CRP 09/30/2009 COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : CRP 11-30-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 $200 OR 10 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER, ALSO ORDERS THAT THE LICENSEE PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK, OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 1 YEAR FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 25 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136830 MAIN STREET LIQUOR 243 E FOURTEEN MILE CLAWSON MI 48017 LICENSEE(S) : ANGELO FOOD, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (712.99): (LCC) : TO 12-31-2009 VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : COMM. ORDER : 12-01-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-03-2009 $50 EACH COMB W/9-136829 & 9-137052 TOTAL $150 OR 7 DAY SUSP. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136829 MAIN STREET LIQUOR 243 E FOURTEEN MILE CLAWSON MI 48017 LICENSEE(S) : ANGELO FOOD, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (1,266.79): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : CRP 09/01/2009 COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : COMM. ORDER : 12-01-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-03-2009 $50 EACH COMB W/9-136830 & 9-137052 TOTAL $150 OR 7 DAY SUSP. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137052 MAIN STREET LIQUOR 243 E FOURTEEN MILE CLAWSON MI 48017 LICENSEE(S) : ANGELO FOOD, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (867.23): (LCC) : 09/04/2009 VIOLATION DATE : CRP 09/07/2009 COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 12-01-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-03-2009 $50 EACH COMB W/9-136830 & 9-136829 TOTAL $150 OR 7 DAY SUSP. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137031 COPPER CREEK GOLF COURSE 27925 GOLF POINT FARMINGTON HILLS MI 48331 LICENSEE(S) : C.C. GOLF ASSOCIATES, L.L.C. CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 11-1208 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 7-9-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 $300 OR 15 DAYS SUSP. AS ADDITIONAL PENALTY, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES AND PERMITS ISSUED BY THE MLCC TO THIS LICENSEE BE SUSP AS OF 3-15-10, WITH SAID SUSP BEING WAIVED IF DOCUMENTARY PROFF OF SERVER TRAINING IS PROVIDED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE COMMISSION'S 11-12-2008 ORDER. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDERS THAT SAID LICENSES AND PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE SUSP IS NOT WAIVED BEFORE 5-15-10. : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/30/2009 COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : LLC COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137610 MINIMART 561 E EIGHT MILE FERNDALE MI 48220 LICENSEE(S) : JSC CORPORATION CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY MURRAY W/DOB 8-29-90 (19): (FERNDALE PD/DECOY/CK ALI AK AHMEE/ID) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : 12-08-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-18-2009 $700.00 OR 35 DAYS SUSP Report: LLVC0180 10/23/2009 CRP SEC 801(2) January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 26 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137054 SAM'S LIQUOR 10099 ELEVEN MILE HUNTINGTON WOODS LICENSEE(S) : LBCS, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (5,560.49): (LCC) : TO 12-31-2009 VIOLATION DATE : MI 48070 09/11/2009 COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-15-2009 $100 OR 10 DAY SUSP. FURTHER LICENSES & PERMITS BE SUSPENDED IF THE ABOVE DISHONORED CHECKS, SERVICES CHARGES, TOTAL FINES & CHARGES PREVIOUSLY AND CURRENTLY DUE ARE NOT PAID WITHIN 30 DAYS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER. FURTHER LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 12 MONTHS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136783 SUNOCO 378 S BROADWAY LAKE ORION MI LICENSEE(S) : ORION FOOD STOP, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY SHANE W/DOB 6-29-89 (20): (LAKE ORION PD/DECOY/CK TINA KEITH/ID) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 48362 08/27/2009 COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : 11-23-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-11-2009 $600.00 OR 30 DAYS SUSP CRP SEC 801(2) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137353 FAT IGUANA 27101 DEQUINDRE MADISON HEIGHTS LICENSEE(S) : FAT IGUANA, INC. CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 1-2809 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 8-21-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 12-07-2009 HEARING HELD LANSING POBUR/GEISSLER/DECLERCQ RULE 15(D) 12-08-2009 $200 OR 10 DAYS SUSP. FURTHER THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES AND PERMITS BE SUSP AS OF 4-1-10, WITH SUSP BEING WAIVED IF DOCUMENTARY PROOF FO SERVER TRAINING IS PROVIDED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE COMMISSION'S 12-17-08 ORDER. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDERS THAT SAID LICENSES AND PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE SUSP IS NOT WAIVED BEFORE 7-1-10. RULE 15(D) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : MI 48071 136836 SANTA MARIA BISTRO 350 E FOURTEEN MILE MADISON HEIGHTS MI LICENSEE(S) : KOZBAR, L.L.C. CHARGE NSF CHECK (322.81): (LCC) : COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : VIOLATION DATE : 48071 COMM. ORDER : 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-15-2009 $75 EACH COMB W/9-136835 TOTAL $150 OR 7 DAY SUSP. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136835 SANTA MARIA BISTRO 350 E FOURTEEN MILE MADISON HEIGHTS MI LICENSEE(S) : KOZBAR, L.L.C. CHARGE NSF CHECK (277.18): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : CRP 09/09/2009 COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : 48071 10/13/2009 LLC 09/08/2009 COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : LLC 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-15-2009 $75 EACH COMB W/9-136836 TOTAL $150 OR 7 DAY SUSP. Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 27 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137034 24TH STREET SPORTS TAVERN 13- 15 S WASHINGTON OXFORD MI 48371 LICENSEE(S) : R & V HOLDINGS, INC. CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 12-208 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 7-21-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 11-30-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 200.00 OR 10 DAY SUSP : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136840 ROCKERS SPORTS BAR & GRILLE 1461 N PERRY PONTIAC MI 48340 LICENSEE(S) : ROCKER'S INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (247.23): (LCC) : 09/30/2009 VIOLATION DATE : CRP 09/10/2009 COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-15-2009 $150.00 OR 7 DAYS SUSP. FURTHER, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES & PERMITS BE SUSPENDED IF THE DISHONORED CHECK, SERVICE CHARGE AND TOTAL FINES AND CHARGES PREVIOUSLY AND CURRENTLY DUE, ARE NOT PAID WITHIN THIRTY (30) DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. FURTHER, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THE LICENSEE PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF TWELVE (12) MONTHS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. RULE 15(E) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136693 SERV-RITE 4304 ROCHESTER ROYAL OAK MI LICENSEE(S) : SERV-RITE LIQUOR SHOP, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (1,417.82): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : 48073 08/31/2009 COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 11-16-2009 LIC ACK - COMM 12-02-2009 $250 OR 12 DAY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS ORDER. TOTAL $250 OR COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136262 GLASGOW WINE AND LIQUOR SHOPPE 25822 W NINE MILE SOUTHFIELD MI 48034 LICENSEE(S) : MARALEX, INC. CHARGE 1) NSF CHECK (4387.24): 2) FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY A WRITTEN ORDER OF COMMISSIONER COLLEEN POBUR, DATED 11-12-08, ISSUED RELATIVE TO THE OPERATION OF THE LIC'D ESTABLISHMENT: (LCC) 11-16-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 1)$250 2)$250 COMB W/9-136261. ADD'L LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR 2 YEARS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER. TOTAL $1000 OR 50 DAY SUSP. : COMM. ORDER : Report: LLVC0180 GAFFNEY SUSP. ALSO LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES FROM THE COMMISSION BY CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 18 MONTHS FROM DATE OF THIS 12 VIOLATION DATE : 07/27/2009 COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : January 08, 2010 07:36 AM CRP Page 28 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136261 GLASGOW WINE AND LIQUOR SHOPPE 25822 W NINE MILE SOUTHFIELD MI 48034 LICENSEE(S) : MARALEX, INC. CHARGE 1) NSF CHECK (3731.90): 2) FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY A WRITTEN ORDER OF COMMISSIONER COLLEEN POBUR, DATED 11-12-08, ISSUED RELATIVE TO THE OPERATION OF THE LIC'D ESTABLISHMENT: (LCC) 11-16-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 1)$250 2)$250 COMB W/9-136262. ADD'L LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR 2 YEARS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER. TOTAL $1000 OR 50 DAY SUSP. : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 07/13/2009 COUNTY: OAKLAND INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137752 MCCORMICK & SCHMICK SEAFOOD RESTAURANT 2850 COOLIDGE TROY MI 48084 COUNTY: OAKLAND LICENSEE(S) : MCCORMICK & SCHMICK RESTAURANT CORP. (A DELAWARE CORPORATION) CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY COPLEY W/DOB 9-22-90 (19): (TROY PD/DECOY/CK LAMAR POWELL/NO ID) : COMM. ORDER : 12-11-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-22-2009 600.00 OR 30 DAY SUSP SEC 801(2) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 134719 WALKER'S FINE DINING 227 MAIN HART MI 49420 VIOLATION DATE : INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : 10/28/2009 CRP 05/25/2009 COUNTY: OCEANA LICENSEE(S) : WALKER'S FINE DINING, INC. CHARGE 1) SALE TO INTOX PERSON - CLAYTON VANSLAMBROUCK; 4) SALE TO INTOX PERSON - MARY VANSLAMBROUCK; 2)5) ALLOW INTOX PERSONS TO CONSUME; 3)6) ALLOW INTOX PERSONS TO LOITER: (OCEANA CO SHER DEPT) 11-30-2009 HEARING HELD GRAND RAPIDS MOURNING/GEISSLER/CONTRACT COST $100.00 12-14-2009 CHG 1) $900.00 SEC 801(2); CHGS 2 & 5) $200.00 EACH; CHG 4) $300.00 SEC 1025(3); CHGS 3 & 6) DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE; TOTAL $1600.00 OR 80 DAYS SUSP, PLUS $100.00 WITNESS FEES; GRAND TOTAL $1700.00 : COMM. ORDER : INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136397 SHELBY AMOCO 4252 W SHELBY SHELBY MI 49455 LICENSEE(S) : SIMRAN SHELBY, LLC CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY FRITCHER (17): (OCEANA CO SO/DECOY/CK PEDRO ESTRADA/NO ID) : VIOLATION DATE : 08/08/2009 COUNTY: OCEANA INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 11-23-2009 HEARING HELD GRAND RAPIDS POBUR/HALL/DECLERCQ RULE 15(D) COST $105.00 12-08-2009 $1000.00 OR 50 DAYS SUSP SEC 801(2), PLUS $105.00 WITNESS FEES; TOTAL $1105.00. ALSO, BECAUSE OF THE WARNING ABOUT SALES OF ALCOHOL TO MINORS ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION DURING THE LICENSING PROCESS AND BECAUSE THIS REPRESENTS THE SECOND VIOLATION OF THIS NATURE, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS A SUSPENSION OF THREE (3) CONSECUTIVE DAYS AS ADDED PENALTY. RULE 15(D) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137334 PAUL'S PUB 10757 E M 32 JOHANNESBURG LICENSEE(S) : PAUL'S PUB, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (683.18): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : MI 49751 09/18/2009 COUNTY: OTSEGO INTEREST : CRP 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $250 OR 12 DAY SUSP. LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 1 YEAR FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 29 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137646 COMFORT SUITES LAKESIDE 100 CLEARVIEW HOUGHTON LAKE MI 48629 LICENSEE(S) : HOUGHTON LAKE HOTELS, L.L.C. (AN ILLINOIS LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY) NSF CHECK (1103.25): (LCC) CHARGE : TO 12-31-2009 VIOLATION DATE : 10/08/2009 COUNTY: ROSCOMMON INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 11-19-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $100.00 WITH $50.00 WAIVED; TOTAL $50.00 OR 3 DAYS SUSP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136837 LOS CUATRO AMIGOS 4570 BAY SAGINAW MI 48603 LICENSEE(S) : LOS CUATRO AMIGOS, INC. (A KENTUCKY CORPORATION) CHARGE 1) NSF CHECK (279.12): 8-27-09; 2) FAILED AS A CORPORATE LICENSEE TO MAINTAIN A CURRENT CHARTER UNDER THE LAWS OF THIS STATE, AS REQUIRED BY MCL 450.2911 AND/OR MCL 450.2922 AND/OR MCL 450.1911 AND/OR MCL 450.1535 AND/OR RULE 436.1109: AS DISCOVERED ON OR ABOUT 924-09: (LCC) 12-04-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-18-2009 CHG 1) $100.00 WITH $50.00 WAIVED; CHG 2) $150.00; TOTAL $200.00 OR 7 DAYS SUSP : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137681 HOWARD MARKET 1107 HOWARD SAGINAW MI 48601 LICENSEE(S) : M & K MARKET, LLC CHARGE NSF CHECK (2178.28): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : 08/27/2009 COUNTY: SAGINAW INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : CRP 10/19/2009 COUNTY: SAGINAW INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 12-02-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 $50 EACH COMB W/9-137058 & 9-137683. ALSO LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 6 MONTHS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER. TOTAL $150 OR 7 DAY SUSP. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137683 HOWARD MARKET 1107 HOWARD SAGINAW MI 48601 LICENSEE(S) : M & K MARKET, LLC CHARGE NSF CHECK (859.00): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : 10/15/2009 COUNTY: SAGINAW INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 12-02-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 $50 EACH COMB W/9-137681 & 9-137058. ALSO LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 6 MONTHS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER. TOTAL $150 OR 7 DAY SUSP. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137058 HOWARD MARKET 1107 HOWARD SAGINAW MI 48601 LICENSEE(S) : M & K MARKET, LLC CHARGE NSF CHECK (1,794.18): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/14/2009 COUNTY: SAGINAW INTEREST : LLC 12-02-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 $50 EACH COMB W/9-137681 & 9-137683. ALSO LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 6 MONTHS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER. TOTAL $150 OR 7 DAY SUSP. Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 30 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137499 VERNIER HOTEL 8822 VERNIER FAIR HAVEN MI LICENSEE(S) : VERNIER HOTEL, L.L.C. CHARGE NSF CHECK (308.11): (LCC) : TO 12-31-2009 VIOLATION DATE : 48023 09/28/2009 COUNTY: ST CLAIR INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 12-14-2009 HEARING HELD STERLING HEIGHTS GAFFNEY/ASEVEDO/GIBSON ACK 12-17-2009 $25 NO ALTERNATIVE. FINE MUST BE PAID PRIOR TO RELEASE OF LICENSE FROM ESCROW COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137489 PORT HURON LANES AND ENTERTAINMENT CENTER 1718 HANCOCK PORT HURON MI 48060 COUNTY: ST CLAIR LICENSEE(S) : PHMI CORP. CHARGE NSF CHECK (891.19): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : INTEREST : 09/29/2009 CRP COMM. ORDER : 11-23-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $100.00 WITH $50.00 WAIVED; TOTAL $50.00 OR 3 DAYS SUSP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137355 STONY POINT GOLF COURSE 8102 W US HWY 2 MANISTIQUE MI 49854 LICENSEE(S) : TD CONSTRUCTORS, INC. CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 8-2708 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 8-14-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 12-07-2009 HEARING HELD LANSING POBUR/GEISSLER/DECLERCQ ACK 12-08-2009 $50 OR 2 DAYS SUSP. : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: SCHOOLCRAFT INTEREST : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136862 QUIK STOP 1740 W MAIN OWOSSO MI LICENSEE(S) : RICK'S QUIK STOP, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - LAN229 (19): (LCC INV VILK/DECOY/CK PAUL ROGERS/ID) : VIOLATION DATE : 48867 10/13/2009 CRP 08/29/2009 COUNTY: SHIAWASSEE INTEREST : COMM. ORDER : 12-09-2009 HEARING HELD SWARTZ CREEK POBUR/HALL/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-11-2009 $500 OR 25 DAYS SUSP - SEC 801(2) NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 135690 C & E EXPRESS 3619 MERTZ CARO MI 48723 VIOLATION DATE : CRP 07/10/2009 COUNTY: TUSCOLA LICENSEE(S) : MERTZ ENTERPRISE, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - UNNAMED DECOY W/DOB 5-17-92 (17): (TUSCOLA CO SHER DEPT/DECOY/CK DUAY JADO/NO ID) 12-09-2009 HEARING HELD SAGINAW GAFFNEY/ASEVEDO/CONTRACT NEG SETTLEMENT COST $6.00 12-15-2009 $800 OR 40 DAY SUSP. & $6 W/FEES TOTAL $806 NEG SETTLEMENT SEC.801(2) : COMM. ORDER : Report: LLVC0180 INTEREST : January 08, 2010 07:36 AM CRP Page 31 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137670 DUTCH MILL & SILVER SADDLE SALOON 8763 LAKE SHORE GRAND JUNCTION MI 49056 LICENSEE(S) : SILVER LAKE DUTCH MILL, INC. CHARGE REC'D - 1) ADVERTISED AND/OR SOLD AN UNLIMITED QUANTITY OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES AT A SPECIFIC PRICE: ON OR ABOUT 9-23-09; 2) LICENSE NOT PROPERLY DISPLAYED: ON OR ABOUT 9-2309; 3)-11) MADE CREDIT SALES OF ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR: ON OR ABOUT VARIOUS DATES BTWN 7-1-09 9-09/MARY AND/OR TONY, $1587.44; ON OR ABOUT 8-09 & 9-09/CHUCK AND/OR AMY, $48.80, $26.50, $2.12; ON OR ABOUT 7-17-09 AND/OR 8-28-09/JOEY AND/OR JENNY, $58.41, $31.80; ON OR ABOUT 3-1-09 AND 3-8-09/UNKNOWN PATRONS, $45.58, $29.80; ON OR ABOUT 4-15-09/MARVIN, $63.60; ON OR ABOUT 9-19-09/RITA, $44.40; ON OR ABOUT 7-22-90/KAYLA AND/OR PENNY, $14.84; ON OR ABOUT VARIOUS DATES BTWN 5-09 AND 9-09/ROGER, $454.80; ON OR ABOUT VARIOUS DATES BTWN 3-09 AND 7-09/JAY, $76.32, $39.22, $8.48, $50.35: (LCC DIST SUPR COX & INV SCHMIDT) 12-02-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-17-2009 100.00 CHARGE 1 AND $50.00 EA FOR CHARGE NOS 2 THRU 11 TOTAL $600.00 OR 30 DAY SUSP : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/23/2009 COUNTY: VAN BUREN INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137142 DUTCH MILL & SILVER SADDLE SALOON 8763 LAKE SHORE GRAND JUNCTION MI 49056 LICENSEE(S) : SILVER LAKE DUTCH MILL, INC. CHARGE 1) SALE TO INTOX PERSON - LARRY STOTLER; 2) ALLOW INTOX PERSON TO CONSUME; 3) ALLOW INTOX PERSON TO LOITER: (VAN BUREN CO SHER DEPT) 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD MOURNING/HALL/CONTRACT 12-21-2009 CHG 1) $300.00 SEC 1025(3); CHGS 2 & 3) $300.00 EACH; TOTAL $900.00 OR 45 DAYS SUSP. FURTHER, THE AL JUDGE ORDERS A SUSPENSION OF 3 CONSECUTIVE DAYS. NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 135676 STODDARD POST 93 AMERICAN LEGION 66297 RED ARROW HARTFORD MI 49057 LICENSEE(S) : STODDARD POST 93 AMERICAN LEGION CHARGE NSF CHECK (181.98): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: VAN BUREN INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : INTEREST : 12-15-2009 HEARING HELD KALAMAZOO POBUR/HALL/CONTRACT RULE 15(E) 12-21-2009 DISMISSED RULE 15(E) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 135677 STODDARD POST 93 AMERICAN LEGION 66297 RED ARROW HARTFORD MI 49057 LICENSEE(S) : STODDARD POST 93 AMERICAN LEGION CHARGE NSF CHECK (134.79): (LCC) VIOLATION DATE : INTEREST : 12-15-2009 HEARING HELD KALAMAZOO POBUR/HALL/CONTRACT RULE 15(E) 12-21-2009 DISMISSED RULE 15(E) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 135994 STODDARD POST 93 AMERICAN LEGION 66297 RED ARROW HARTFORD MI 49057 LICENSEE(S) : STODDARD POST 93 AMERICAN LEGION CHARGE NSF CHECK (421.14): (LCC) COMM. ORDER : 06/30/2009 OTC 06/26/2009 COUNTY: VAN BUREN COMM. ORDER : : CRP COUNTY: VAN BUREN COMM. ORDER : : 09/17/2009 VIOLATION DATE : OTC 07/03/2009 COUNTY: VAN BUREN INTEREST : OTC 09-22-2009 HEARING ADJOURNED PER DOCKET SHEET. LSS 12-15-2009 HEARING HELD KALAMAZOO POBUR/HALL/CONTRACT RULE 15(E) 12-21-2009 DISMISSED RULE 15(E) Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 32 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 135379 STODDARD POST 93 AMERICAN LEGION 66297 RED ARROW HARTFORD MI 49057 LICENSEE(S) : STODDARD POST 93 AMERICAN LEGION CHARGE NSF CHECK (213.54): (LCC) : TO 12-31-2009 VIOLATION DATE : 06/12/2009 COUNTY: VAN BUREN INTEREST : OTC COMM. ORDER : 09-22-2009 HEARING ADJOURNED PER 9-22-2009 DOCKET. LSS 12-15-2009 HEARING HELD KALAMAZOO POBUR/HALL/CONTRACT RULE 15(E) 12-21-2009 DISMISSED RULE 15(E) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137140 THE VINEYARD ITALIAN RESTAURANT 259 BROADWAY SOUTH HAVEN MI 49090 LICENSEE(S) : F & R, INC. CHARGE REC'D - 1)3) SOLD OR TRF'D IN THE AGGREGATE MORE THAN 10% OF THE STK OF THE LIC'D CORP W/OUT PRIOR APPROVAL OF MLCC (GIACOMINA RIEDEL & CIFF RIEDEL): ON OR ABOUT 2-10-98; 2)4) ALLOWED PERSONS WHOSE NAME DO NOT APPEAR ON THE LICENSE, TO DERIVE USE OR BENEFIT FROM LICENSE: ON OR AOBUT 2-10-98; 5) FAILED TO REPORT BY 7-1-99, ANY STK TRF IN THE CORP DURING THE PRECEDING LICENSING YR: 6) OBTAINED LICENSE IN ITS NAME FOR THE USE OR BENEFIT OF PERSONS WHOSE NAMES DO NOT APPEAR ON THE LICENSE: ON OR ABOUT LICENSING YR, 1999 THRU LICENSING YR 2009 (LCC INV SCHMIDT) 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD KALAMAZOO MOURNING/HALL/CONTRACT 12-21-2009 CHGS 1 & 3) $300.00 EACH; CHG 5) $200.00; CHGS 2, 4 & 6) DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE; TOTAL $800.00 OR 40 DAYS SUSP. FURTHER, THE AL JUDGE ORDER ALL LICENSES & PERMITS BE SUSPENDED UNLESS THE PROPER LICENSEE ASSUMES FULL PROPRIETARY CONTROL OF THIS LICENSED BUSINESS OR UNLESS ALL LICENSES & PERMITS ARE TRANSFERRED TO A PERSON OR PERSON APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. THE COMMISSION MAY GRANT AN EXTENSION OF TIME BASED ON GOOD CAUSE. FURTHER, THE AL JUDGE ORDERS ALL LICENSES & PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE SUSPENSION IS NOT WAIVED WITHIN 60 DAYS FROM THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE SUSPENSION. THE COMMISSION MAY GRANT AN EXTENSION OF TIME BASED ON GOOD CAUSE. NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/18/2009 COUNTY: VAN BUREN INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137428 THE CHERRY MARTINI 50296 CHERRY HILL CANTON MI 48188 LICENSEE(S) : THE CHERRY MARTINI LLC CHARGE ADVERTISED AND/OR SOLD AN UNLIMITED QUANTITY OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES AT A SPECIFIC PRICE: (LCC INV MEDLER) 11-23-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $200.00 OR 10 DAYS SUSP : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137679 T. C. GATORS 42775 FORD CANTON MI 48187 LICENSEE(S) : HOSPITALITY VENTURES, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (422.01): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 10/31/2008 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : LLC 10/21/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP 12-07-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-18-2009 DISMISSED. Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 33 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 135702 RICHARDSON'S SUPER DRUGS 42433 FORD CANTON MI 48187 LICENSEE(S) : BILLNAT CORPORATION CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY #A635 (20): (CANTON PD/DECOY/CK THOMAS BARNES/NO ID) : VIOLATION DATE : 07/15/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 12-22-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/MCDOWELL/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT COST $11.50 12-22-2009 $500 OR 25 DAYS SUSP & $11.50 COSTS FOR A TOTAL OF $511.50 SEC 801(2) NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137678 T. C. GATORS 42775 FORD CANTON MI 48187 LICENSEE(S) : HOSPITALITY VENTURES, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (523.53): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : 10/16/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 12-07-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-18-2009 DISMISSED. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136789 KROGER STORE #703 45540 MICHIGAN CANTON MI 48188 LICENSEE(S) : THE KROGER CO. OF MICHIGAN CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY #A635 W/DOB 1-9-89 (20): (CANTON PD/DECOY/CK JUDITH MATTHEWS/NO ID) : VIOLATION DATE : 09/10/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 12-22-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/MCDOWELL/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT COST $11.50 12-22-2009 $800 OR 40 DAYS SUSP & $11.50 COSTS SEC 801(2) NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137496 VAN DYKE LIQUOR MARKET 6455 VAN DYKE DETROIT MI 48213 LICENSEE(S) : VAN DYKE LIQUOR MARKET, INC. CHARGE 1) NSF CHECK (1511.41): 10-2-09; 2) FAILED AS A CORPORATE LICENSEE TO MAINTAIN A CURRENT CHARTER UNDER THE LAWS OF THIS STATE, AS REQUIRED BY MCL 450.2911 AND/OR MCL 450.2922 AND/OR MCL 450.1911 AND/OR MCL 450.1922: AS DISCOVERED ON OR ABOUT 10-23-09 (LCC) 12-22-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/MCDOWELL/GIBSON ACK 12-22-2009 1)DISMISSED, 2)$25 : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137317 MAGNOLIA RESTAURANT AND BAR 1440 FRANKLIN SUITE #200 DETROIT MI 48207 LICENSEE(S) : THE KEY CLUB INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (1566.12): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 10/02/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : CRP 09/24/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP 12-22-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/MCDOWELL/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-22-2009 $250 OR 12 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDER THE LICENSEE PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 18 MONTHS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. RULE 15(E) Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 34 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137241 HI 8 MILE MARKET 8065 W EIGHT MILE DETROIT MI 48221 LICENSEE(S) : HI 8 MILE MARKET, INC. CHARGE LICENSE NOT PROPERLY DISPLAYED: (DPD-09-138-12TH PRCT) : TO 12-31-2009 VIOLATION DATE : 07/20/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 11-24-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-11-2009 $200.00 OR 10 DAYS SUSP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136434 VERNOR STREET STATION 6831 W VERNOR DETROIT MI 48209 LICENSEE(S) : CELIAS CANTINA INC. CHARGE 1) ALLOWED FIGHTS OR BRAWLS ON LIC'D PREMISES: 2) ALLOWED ON LIC'D PREMISES THE IMPROPER USE OF KNIFE, FIREARM, OR OTHER WEAPON: (DPD-09-123-VICE ENF) 11-09-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON MOURNING/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(D) 12-08-2009 1)$300 2)$300 TOTAL $600 OR 30 DAY SUSP. RULE 15(D) : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137065 BUTCHERS INN 1489 WINDER DETROIT MI VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : 48207 06/06/2009 CRP 09/18/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE LICENSEE(S) : BUTCHERS INN L.L.C. CHARGE REC'D - 1) LICENSEE FAILED TO MAKE REQUIRED RECORDS AVAILABLE FOR INSPECTION: 2) FAILED TO MAINTAIN ACCURATE RECORDS OF ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR PURCHASES AND SALES, SPECIFICALLY: MOST RECENT MISCELLANEOUS BILL/INVOICES: 3) FAILED TO MAINTAIN RECORDS SUFFICIENT TO DETERMINE OWNERSHIP OF THE LIC'D BUSINESS AND TO WHOM THE PROFITS OR LOSSES OF THE BUSINESS ACCRUED: 4) FAILED TO MAINTAIN APPROPRIATE RECORDS FOR A FOUR-YEAR PERIOD OF TIME: DISCOVERED ON OR OR ABOUT 7-30-09 (LCC INV TOMA) 12-08-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-11-2009 CHGS 1 - 4) $100.00 EACH; TOTAL $400.00 OR 20 DAYS SUSP. ALSO, THE LICENSEE IS ADVISED THAT FAILURE TO MAINTAIN ACCURATE RECORDS WILL RESULT IN ADDITIONAL PENALTIES BY THE MLCC. : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137254 KENNEDY LIQUOR III 13340- 13344 W SEVEN MILE DETROIT MI 48235 INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : LLC 07/22/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE LICENSEE(S) : SEVEN MILE KENNEDY LIQUOR, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY #0001 W/DOB 7-11-89 (20): (DPD-09-143-12TH PRCT/DECOY/CK MUHAMMAD BAJOUA/NO ID) 12-21-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON POBUR/MCDOWELL/GIBSON DISMISSED 12-28-2009 DISMISSED FOR INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137501 HIBBARD PARTY STORE 8935 E JEFFERSON DETROIT MI 48214 LICENSEE(S) : HIBBARD PARTY STORE, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (2924.78): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : CRP 10/06/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP 11-17-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 $300 OR 15 DAYS SUSP. Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 35 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137053 B.M.G. BAR & GRILL 20809 JOY DETROIT MI 48228 LICENSEE(S) : B.M.G., INCORPORATED CHARGE NSF CHECK (478.67): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : 09/17/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : COMM. ORDER : 11-30-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-15-2009 100.00/50.00 WAIVED OR 3 DAY SUSP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137312 DETROIT FISH MARKET 1435 RANDOLPH DETROIT MI 48226 LICENSEE(S) : DETROIT FISH MARKET AT PARADISE VALLEY LLC CHARGE NSF CHECK (2682.73): (LCC) : TO 12-31-2009 VIOLATION DATE : CRP 09/23/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 12-07-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-11-2009 $300 COMBINED WITH 9-137352 $100, $50 WAIVED FOR A TOTAL OF $50 TOTAL OF $350 OR 18 DAYS SUSP. AS ADDITIONAL PENALTY, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES AND PERMITS SUSP AS OF 3-15-10, WITH SAID SUSP BEING WAIVED ID DOCUMENTARY PROOF OF SERVER TRAINING IS PROVIDED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE COMMISSION'S 2-11-09 ORDER. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDERS THAT SAID LICENSES AND PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE SUSP IS NOT WAIVED BEFORE 5-15-10. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137055 LICENSEE(S) : MARRACCI TEMPLE NO. 13 OF DETROIT, MICHIGAN, A SUBORDINATE TEMPLE OF THE IMPERIAL COUNCIL, ANCIENT EQYPTIAN ARABIC ORDER NSF CHECK (368.28): (LCC) CHARGE : 3101 MC DOUGALL DETROIT MI 48207 VIOLATION DATE : 09/11/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : OTC COMM. ORDER : 12-04-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-17-2009 $250 OR 12 DAYS SUSP. ADDITIONALLY, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THAT THE LICENSEE PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BE CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK, OR MONEY ORDER FOR 6 MONTHS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 129628 THE RAINBOW ROOM 6640 E EIGHT MILE DETROIT MI 48234 LICENSEE(S) : RAINBOW NETWORK, INC. CHARGE REC'D - 1)7) ALLOWED BETTING ON THE RANDOM COMBINATION OF SYMBOLS, NUMBERS, FRUITS, ETC., APPEAR ON A VIDEO SCREEN OF A VIDEO SLOT DEVICE ON LIC'D PREMISES: ON OR ABOUT 2-9-08, ON OR ABOUT 7-18-08; 2)4)6)8)10)11)13) ALLOWED AN UNLAWFUL GAMBLING DEVICES ON LIC'D PREMISES VIDEO SLOT DEVICE/VIDEO POKER MACHINES: ON OR ABOUT 2-9-08/VIDEO SLOT DEVICE, ON OR ABOUT 2-9-08/VIDEO POKER MACHINE #1, ON OR ABOUT 2-9-08/VIDEO SLOT MACHINES #2, ON OR ABOUT 718-08/"ELDORADO GRAYHOUND DYNA" VIDEO SLOT DEVICE, ON OR ABOUT 7-18-08/VIDEO POKER MACHINE, ON OR ABOUT 9-10-08/"CRAZY BUGS" VIDEO SLOT DEVICE, ON OR ABOUT 9-10-08/VIDEO POKER MACHINE: 3)5)9)12) ALLOWED WAGERING ON A VIDEO POKER MACHINES: ON OR ABOUT 2-908/#1, ON OR ABOUT 2-9-08/#2, ON OR ABOUT 7-18-08, ON OR ABOUT 9-10-08: 14) ALLOW UNLAWFUL GAMBLING WITH EUCHRE CARD GAMES ON LIC'D PREMISES: VARIOUS DATES; 15) LICENSEE, OR THE CLERK, SERVANT, AGENT, OR EMPLOYEE OF THE LICENSEE ENGAGED IN AN ILLEGAL OCCUPATION OR ILLEGAL ACT UPON THE LIC'D PREMISES, SPECIFICALLY: KEPT, MAINTAINED OR PERMITTED A GAMING ROOM: VARIOUS DATES IN 2008 (GIS-10-08-MSP GAMING POST) 12-09-2009 HEARING HELD SWARTZ CREEK POBUR/HALL/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-11-2009 7 DAYS SUSP, SUSP WAIVED, 1-15)$300 EACH FOR A TOTAL OF $4500 OR 225 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THE LICENSEE TO FORFEIT THE GAMING MACHINES AND MONEY SEIZED IN THE COURSE OF THIS INVESTIGATION AND ORDERS THE MSP TO DESTROY THE SEIZED GAMING MACHINES AND TO DISPOSE OF THE MONEY SEIZED IN THE INVESTIGATION IN A MANNER PRESCRIBED BY LAW, UNLESS THAT DESTRUCTION AND DISPOSAL HAS ALREADY BEEN ADDRESSED BY THE CRIMINAL MATTER ASSOCIATED WITH THESE VIOLATIONS. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THAT NO ADDITIONAL MLCC CHARGES BE FILED AGAINST THE LICENSEE IN THE EVEN THAT THERE ARE ANY CRIMINAL CHARGES AGAINST THE LICENSED CORPORATION, DIRECTORS, SHAREHOLDERS AGENTS OR EMPLOYEES FOR INCIDENTS THAT OCCURRED ON THE DATES ADDRESSED IN THIS ORDER. NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : Report: LLVC0180 VIOLATION DATE : 10/22/2008 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : January 08, 2010 07:36 AM CRP Page 36 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137352 DETROIT FISH MARKET 1435 RANDOLPH DETROIT MI 48226 LICENSEE(S) : DETROIT FISH MARKET AT PARADISE VALLEY LLC CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 2-1109 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 8-18-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 12-07-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-11-2009 $100, $50 WAIVED FOR A TOTAL OF $50 COMBINED WITH 9-137312 FOR $300 TOTAL OF $350 OR 18 DAYS SUSP. AS ADDITIONAL PENALTY, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES AND PERMITS SUSP AS OF 3-15-10, WITH SAID SUSP BEING WAIVED ID DOCUMENTARY PROOF OF SERVER TRAINING IS PROVIDED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE COMMISSION'S 2-11-09 ORDER. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDERS THAT SAID LICENSES AND PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE SUSP IS NOT WAIVED BEFORE 5-15-10. : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136687 HAYES LIQUOR BASKET 11002 HAYES DETROIT MI 48213 LICENSEE(S) : LENORD, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (2,927.32): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : LLC 08/19/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : COMM. ORDER : 12-01-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON 12-02-2009 $100 EACH COMB W/9-136688 TOTAL $200 OR 10 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136688 HAYES LIQUOR BASKET 11002 HAYES DETROIT MI 48213 LICENSEE(S) : LENORD, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (3,313.58): (LCC) : 10/13/2009 CRP NEG SETTLEMENT NEG SETTLEMENT VIOLATION DATE : 09/08/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 12-01-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-02-2009 $100 EACH COMB W/9-136687 TOTAL $200 OR 10 DAY SUSP. NEG SETTLEMENT COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 132795 VSOP LIQUOR 10715- 10727 W EIGHT MILE DETROIT MI 48221 LICENSEE(S) : SILVER LEAF INVESTMENT, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY THIRKILL (20): (DPD-09-56 12TH PRECINCT/DECOY/CK HALIA GORO/NO ID) : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : COMM. ORDER : 12-21-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON POBUR/MCDOWELL/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-28-2009 $500.00 OR 25 DAYS SUSP SEC 801(2) NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136841 WYOMING MINI MARKET 13970 WYOMING DETROIT MI 48238 LICENSEE(S) : MJ&J PROPERTIES, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (3,474.36): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : 02/16/2009 VIOLATION DATE : CRP 09/03/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-15-2009 $100 WAIVE $50 TOTAL $50 OR 3 DAY SUSP. NEG SETTLEMENT Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 37 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137361 STARLITE LIQUOR 10544 FENKELL DETROIT MI 48238 LICENSEE(S) : DOMINIC & CHRISTIAN, INC. CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 6-2508 BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 9-24-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 12-07-2009 HEARING HELD LANSING POBUR/GEISSLER/DECLERCQ RULE 15(D) 12-08-2009 $200 OR 10 DAYS SUSP. AS ADDITIONAL PENALTY, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES AND PERMITS ISSUED BY THE COMMISSION TO THIS LICENSEE BE SUSP AS OF 4-1-10, WITH SAID SUSP BEING WAIVED IF DOCUMENTARY PROOF OF SERVER TRAINING IS PROVIDED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE COMMISSON'S 12-17-08 ORDER. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDERS THAT SAID LICENSES AND PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE SUSP IS NOT WAIVED BEFORE 7-1-10. RULE 15(D) : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137435 BRAD'S TAVERN & GRILL 16915 E WARREN DETROIT MI 48224 LICENSEE(S) : BRAD'S, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (311.73): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : 10/13/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : CRP 09/30/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 12-01-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-17-2009 $250 COMBINED WITH 9-137310 FOR $250, TOTAL OF $500 OR 25 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ALSO ORDERS THAT THE LICENSEE PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BE CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECKK, OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 18 MONTHS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137310 BRAD'S TAVERN & GRILL 16915 E WARREN DETROIT MI 48224 LICENSEE(S) : BRAD'S, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (702.66): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : 09/24/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 12-01-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-17-2009 $250 COMBINED WITH 9-137435 FOR $250, TOTAL OF $500 OR 25 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ALSO ORDERS THAT THE LICENSEE PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BE CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECKK, OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 18 MONTHS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136923 LICENSEE(S) : EL MONTERREY, LLC CHARGE REC'D - FAILED, REFUSED, OR NEGLECTED TO OBEY WRITTEN ORDER OF THE COMMISSION DATED 3-2807, WITH AN EXTENSION OF TIME BEING GRANTED ON 3-6-09, BY FAILING TO PROVIDE PROOF OF SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF AN ALCOHOL TRAINING PROGRAM APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 180 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THE LICENSE: 5-20-09 (MLCC SERVER TRAINING COORDINATOR) 10-30-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $300 OR 15 DAYS SUSP. AS ADDITIONAL PENALTY, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES AND PERMITS BE SUSP AS OF 3-15-10 WITH SAID SUSP BEING WAIVED IF DOCUMENTARY PROOF OF SERVER TRAINING IS PROVIDED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PRIVISIONS OF THE COMMISSION'S 3-28-07 ORDER. THE COMMISSIONER FURTHER ORDERS THAT SAID LICENSES AND PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE SUSP IS NOT WAIVED BEFORE 5-15-10. : COMM. ORDER : 18940- 18950 FORD DETROIT MI 48228 Report: LLVC0180 VIOLATION DATE : 09/23/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : January 08, 2010 07:36 AM LLC Page 38 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137492 SELDOM BLUES TOWER 400 - LEVEL 1 RENAISSANCE CENTER STORE 1404 DETROIT MI 48243 COUNTY: WAYNE VIOLATION DATE : LICENSEE(S) : RIVERFRONT HOLDINGS, INC. (A DELAWARE CORPORATION) SELDOM BLUES, LLC INTEREST : INTEREST : CHARGE NSF EFT (1479.39): (LCC) : 10/08/2009 CLC CLLC COMM. ORDER : 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON ACK 12-15-2009 $75 EACH ACK CHARGE COMBINED W/9-137684 & 9-136843 & 9-137059. FURTHER ALL LICENSES & PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE DISHONORED CHECKS, SERVICE CHARGES, TOTAL FINES & CHARGES PREVIOUSLY DUE ARE NOT PAID BY MARCH 1, 2010. FURTHER LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 12 MONTHS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER. TOTAL $150 OR 7 DAY SUSP. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137684 SELDOM BLUES TOWER 400 - LEVEL 1 RENAISSANCE CENTER STORE 1404 DETROIT MI 48243 COUNTY: WAYNE VIOLATION DATE : LICENSEE(S) : RIVERFRONT HOLDINGS, INC. (A DELAWARE CORPORATION) SELDOM BLUES, LLC INTEREST : INTEREST : CHARGE NSF EFT (1237.93): (LCC) : 10/14/2009 CLC CLLC COMM. ORDER : 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON ACK 12-15-2009 $75 EACH ACK CHARGE COMBINED W/9-137492 & 9-136843 & 9-137059. FURTHER ALL LICENSES & PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE DISHONORED CHECKS, SERVICE CHARGES, TOTAL FINES & CHARGES PREVIOUSLY DUE ARE NOT PAID BY MARCH 1, 2010. FURTHER LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 12 MONTHS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER. TOTAL $150 OR 7 DAY SUSP. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136843 SELDOM BLUES TOWER 400 - LEVEL 1 RENAISSANCE CENTER STORE 1404 DETROIT MI 48243 COUNTY: WAYNE VIOLATION DATE : LICENSEE(S) : RIVERFRONT HOLDINGS, INC. (A DELAWARE CORPORATION) SELDOM BLUES, LLC INTEREST : INTEREST : CHARGE NSF EFT (3,353.29): (LCC) : 09/10/2009 CLC CLLC COMM. ORDER : 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON DISMISSED. 12-15-2009 DISMISSED. COMBINED W/9-137684 & 9-137492 & 9-137059. FURTHER ALL LICENSES & PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE DISHONORED CHECKS, SERVICE CHARGES, TOTAL FINES & CHARGES PREVIOUSLY DUE ARE NOT PAID BY MARCH 1, 2010. FURTHER LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 12 MONTHS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER. TOTAL $150 OR 7 DAY SUSP. COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137059 SELDOM BLUES TOWER 400 - LEVEL 1 RENAISSANCE CENTER STORE 1404 DETROIT MI 48243 COUNTY: WAYNE VIOLATION DATE : LICENSEE(S) : RIVERFRONT HOLDINGS, INC. (A DELAWARE CORPORATION) SELDOM BLUES, LLC INTEREST : INTEREST : CHARGE NSF EFT (150.12): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : 09/14/2009 CLC CLLC 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON DIMISSED. 12-15-2009 DISMISSED. $75 EACH ACK CHARGE COMBINED W/9-137684 & 9-136843 & 9-137492. FURTHER ALL LICENSES & PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE DISHONORED CHECKS, SERVICE CHARGES, TOTAL FINES & CHARGES PREVIOUSLY DUE ARE NOT PAID BY MARCH 1, 2010. FURTHER LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 12 MONTHS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER. TOTAL $150 OR 7 DAY SUSP. Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 39 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137430 LICENSEE(S) : COOGAN'S BAR, INC. CHARGE 1)2) POSSESSED, SOLD, OFFERED FOR SALE, OR EXPOSED FOR SALE ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR; BOTTLE OF JIM BEAM BOURBON WHISKEY, BOTTLE OF JACK DANIELS WHISKEY, WHICH WAS ADULTERED, OR MISBRANDED, OR REFILLED: 3) POSSESSED ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR ON LIC'D PREMISES, NOT PURCHASED FROM AN AUTHORIZED SOURCE: (LCC INVS TOMA & CATO) 12-02-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-17-2009 250.00 EACH CHARGE TOTAL 500.00 OR 25 DAY SUSP : COMM. ORDER : 5890 W VERNOR DETROIT MI 48209 VIOLATION DATE : 09/30/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 135469 IN-N-OUT 14441 W MC NICHOLS DETROIT MI 48235 LICENSEE(S) : ZGHEIB ENTERPRISE, INC. CHARGE REC'D - 1) FAILED TO MAINTAIN ACCURATE RECORDS OF ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR PURCHASES & SALES, SPECIFICALLY: ALL SALES/PURCHASES: 2) FAILED TO MAINTAIN RECORDS SUFFICIENT TO DETERMINE OWNERSHIP OF THE LICENSED BUSINESS & TO WHOM THE PROFITS OR LOSSES OF THE BUSINESS ACCRUED: 3) FAILED TO MAINTAIN APPROPRIATE RECORDS FOR A FOUR-YEAR PERIOD OF TIME: 4) LEASED, SOLD OR TRF'D POSSESSION OF PORTION OF LIC'D PREMISES, W/OUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN APPROVAL OF THE COMMISSION: DISSOVERED 6-2-09 (LCC INV TOMA) 11-17-2009 HEARING HELD - FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/MCDOWELL/GIBSON ***PER COMM ORDER: HRG ADJOURNED - LICENSE TO BE IMMEDIATELY PLACED IN ESCROW - HRG TO BE RESCH'D ON 12-8-09 FARM DOCKET*** 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-15-2009 $250 EACH FURTHER ALL LICENSES & PERMITS REMAIN IN ESCROW UNTIL ALL DOCUMENTS REQUIRED IN THE COMMISSION'S NOTICE OF DEFICIENCIES ARE SUBMITTED TO THE COMMISSION. FURTHER LICENSES & PERMITS SUSPENDED IF ALL DOCUMENTS REQUIRED ARE NOT FILED IN A MANNER & SUBSTANCE APPROVED BY INV TOMA WITH THE COMMISSION WITHIN 30 DAYS OF THE ISSUANCE OF THIS ORDER. TOTAL $1000 OR 50 DAY SUSP. NEG SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 138088 CARMENS LIQUOR & DELI 14650 GRATIOT DETROIT MI 48205 LICENSEE(S) : NABOU, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (10,806.63): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : INTEREST : 12-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-21-2009 DISMISSED COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137242 WINTHROP & 6 LIQUOR 15619 W MC NICHOLS DETROIT MI 48235 LICENSEE(S) : 6 MILE LIQUOR SHOPPE, INC. CHARGE LICENSE NOT PROPERLY DISPLAYED: (DPD-09-140-12TH PRCT) COMM. ORDER : CRP 11/13/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE COMM. ORDER : : 07/10/2009 VIOLATION DATE : CRP 07/19/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 $200 OR 10 DAY SUSP. Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 40 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137318 LABOTTELIA SHOPPE LIQUOR 2545 BAGLEY DETROIT MI 48216 LICENSEE(S) : LENA HADDAD, INC. CHARGE 1) NSF CHECK (549.24): 9-24-09; 2) FAILED AS A CORPORATE LICENSEE TO MAINTAIN A CURRENT CHARTER UNDER THE LAWS OF THIS STATE, AS REQUIRED BY MCL 450.2911 AND/OR MCL 450.2922 AND/OR MCL 450.1911 AND/OR MCL 450.1922: AS DISCOVERED 10-14-09 (LCC) 12-15-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/MCDOWELL/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-15-2009 CHG 1) $150.00; CHG 2) $75.00; COMBINED WITH 9-137488; TOTAL $450.00 OR 22 DAYS SUSP. FURTHER, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THE LICENSEE PAY FOR LIQUOR BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A A PERIOD OF EIGHTEEN (18) MONTHS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. AS ADDITIONAL PENALTY, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES & PERMITS BE SUSPENDED AS OF FEBRUARY 1, 2010, WITH SAID SUSPENSION BEING WAIVED IF THE LICENSEE BECOMES A MEMBER IN GOOD CORPORATE STANDING IN THE STATE OF MICHIGAN AND THE ABOVE DISHONORED CHECKS, SERVICE CHARGES & TOTAL FINES ARE PAID; FURTHER THAT THE LICENSES & PERMITS BE REVOKED IF SAID SUSPENSION IS NOT WAIVED ON OR BEFORE APRIL 1, 2010. RULE 15(E) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/24/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137488 LABOTTELIA SHOPPE LIQUOR 2545 BAGLEY DETROIT MI 48216 LICENSEE(S) : LENA HADDAD, INC. CHARGE 1) NSF CHECK (703.54): 10-6-09; 2) FAILED AS A CORPORATE LICENSEE TO MAINTAIN A CURRENT CHARTER UNDER THE LAWS OF THIS STATE, AS REQUIRED BY MCL 450.2911 AND/OR MCL 450.2922 AND/OR MCL 450.1911 AND/OR MCL 450.1922: AS DISCOVERED 10-23-09 (LCC) 12-15-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/MCDOWELL/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-15-2009 CHG 1) $150.00; CHG 2) $75.00; COMBINED WITH 9-137318; TOTAL $450.00 OR 22 DAYS SUSP. FURTHER, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THE LICENSEE PAY FOR LIQUOR BY CERTIFIED CHECK, CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A A PERIOD OF EIGHTEEN (18) MONTHS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. AS ADDITIONAL PENALTY, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES & PERMITS BE SUSPENDED AS OF FEBRUARY 1, 2010, WITH SAID SUSPENSION BEING WAIVED IF THE LICENSEE BECOMES A MEMBER IN GOOD CORPORATE STANDING IN THE STATE OF MICHIGAN AND THE ABOVE DISHONORED CHECKS, SERVICE CHARGES & TOTAL FINES ARE PAID; FURTHER THAT THE LICENSES & PERMITS BE REVOKED IF SAID SUSPENSION IS NOT WAIVED ON OR BEFORE APRIL 1, 2010. RULE 15(E) : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137327 DIAMOND JIM'S SALOON 19646- 19650 W WARREN DETROIT MI 48228 LICENSEE(S) : WINGED LION ENTERPRISES, INC. CHARGE NSF EFT (210.96): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : INTEREST : 12-09-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-22-2009 100.00 OR 5 DAY SUSP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137582 RIVER DRIVE MARKET 455 SOUTHFIELD LINCOLN PARK MI 48146 LICENSEE(S) : MATTHEW PARTY STORE, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - JOSEPH ZAERZYCKI (18): (LINCOLN PARK PD/CK BASEL TOY) : CRP 09/18/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE COMM. ORDER : COMM. ORDER : 10/06/2009 VIOLATION DATE : CRP 10/17/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP 11-17-2009 LIC ACK - COMM GAFFNEY 12-02-2009 $600 OR 30 DAYS SUSP - SEC 801(2) Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 41 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137325 ONE UNDER BAR & GRILL 35780 FIVE MILE LIVONIA MI 48154 LICENSEE(S) : TOMINNA, LLC CHARGE NSF CHECK (990.09): (LCC) : TO 12-31-2009 VIOLATION DATE : 09/16/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-15-2009 $50.00 COMBINED W/9-136844 & 9-137326; TOTAL $150.00 OR 7 DAYS SUSP. FURTHER, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES & PERMITS BE SUSPENDED IF THE ABOVE DISHONORED CHECKS, SERVICE CHARGES AND TOTAL FINES AND CHARGES PREVIOUSLY AND CURRENTLY DUE, ARE NOT PAID WITHIN THIRTY (30) DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. RULE 15(E) ***FINE, CHECKS & SERVICES CHARGES PAID ON 12-22-09*** COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137326 ONE UNDER BAR & GRILL 35780 FIVE MILE LIVONIA MI 48154 LICENSEE(S) : TOMINNA, LLC CHARGE NSF CHECK (1014.84): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : 09/16/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-15-2009 $50.00 COMBINED W/9-136844 & 9-137325; TOTAL $150.00 OR 7 DAYS SUSP. FURTHER, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES & PERMITS BE SUSPENDED IF THE ABOVE DISHONORED CHECKS, SERVICE CHARGES AND TOTAL FINES AND CHARGES PREVIOUSLY AND CURRENTLY DUE, ARE NOT PAID WITHIN THIRTY (30) DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. RULE 15(E) ***FINE, CHECKS & SERVICES CHARGES PAID ON 12-22-09*** COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137057 THE BENCH PUB 33653 FIVE MILE LIVONIA MI 48154 LICENSEE(S) : M JANZ, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (212.29): (LCC) : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : COMM. ORDER : 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-15-2009 $50 OR 3 DAY SUSP. RULE 15(E) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136844 ONE UNDER BAR & GRILL 35780 FIVE MILE LIVONIA MI 48154 LICENSEE(S) : TOMINNA, LLC CHARGE NSF CHECK (310.44): (LCC) : 09/10/2009 VIOLATION DATE : CRP 09/04/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : LLC COMM. ORDER : 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-15-2009 $50.00 COMBINED W/9-137325 & 9-137326; TOTAL $150.00 OR 7 DAYS SUSP. FURTHER, THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS ALL LICENSES & PERMITS BE SUSPENDED IF THE ABOVE DISHONORED CHECKS, SERVICE CHARGES AND TOTAL FINES AND CHARGES PREVIOUSLY AND CURRENTLY DUE, ARE NOT PAID WITHIN THIRTY (30) DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. RULE 15(E) ***FINE, CHECKS & SERVICES CHARGES PAID ON 12-22-09*** COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136562 1999 TAVERN 447 FOREST PLYMOUTH MI VIOLATION DATE : 48170 LICENSEE(S) : W.G.A.C.A., L.L.C. CHARGE NSF CHECK (513.86): : COMM. ORDER : 08/13/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : LLC (LCC) 12-01-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-03-2009 $75 EACH COMB W/9-136561. ALSO LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 12 MONTHS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER. FURTHER ALL LICENSES & PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE ABOVE DISHONORED CHECKS, SERVICES CHARGES & TOTAL FINE ARE NOT PAID WITHIN 45 DAYS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER. RULE 15(E) Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 42 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136561 1999 TAVERN 447 FOREST PLYMOUTH MI LICENSEE(S) : W.G.A.C.A., L.L.C. CHARGE NSF CHECK (599.92): : TO 12-31-2009 VIOLATION DATE : 48170 08/14/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : LLC (LCC) COMM. ORDER : 12-01-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-03-2009 $75 EACH COMB W/9-136562. ALSO LIC'E PAY FOR PURCHASES OF LIQUOR FROM THE COMMISSION BY CERTIFIED CHECK CASHIERS CHECK OR MONEY ORDER FOR A PERIOD OF 12 MONTHS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER. FURTHER ALL LICENSES & PERMITS BE REVOKED IF THE ABOVE DISHONORED CHECKS, SERVICES CHARGES & TOTAL FINE ARE NOT PAID WITHIN 45 DAYS FROM DATE OF THIS ORDER. RULE 15(E) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136701 THE LIQUOR STATION 12860 SIBLEY RIVERVIEW MI 48193 LICENSEE(S) : RAAD SALMO, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - NICHOLAS GARCIA (17):(RIVERVIEW PD/CK RAAD SALMO/ID) : VIOLATION DATE : 09/03/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP COMM. ORDER : 12-01-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON ACK COST $55.50 12-02-2009 $700 OR 35 DAY SUSP. & $55.50 W/FEES. TESTIMONY AT THIS HEARING BROUGHT OUT THE FACT THAT THE LICENSEE WHILE HAVING A GOOD RECORD, IS BEGINNING TO GET THE REPUTATION OF BEING AN ESTABLISHMENT WHERE UNDER AGE PERSONS CAN PURCHASE ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR. THE COMMISSIONER, THEREFORE, WARNS THE LIC'E THAT FUTURE VIOLATIONS CONCERNING SALES TO MINORS WILL RESULT IN HARSHER PENALTIES. TOTAL $755.50 SEC.801(2) COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136457 WINE TOWN PARTY STORE 13337 DIX TOLEDO SOUTHGATE MI 48195 LICENSEE(S) : MAGGIE INVESTMENTS, LTD. CHARGE 1) SALE TO MINOR - DECOY 06-ACC-55 W/DOB 3-22-89 (20): 8-11-09; 2) FAILED AS A CORPORATE LICENSEE TO MAINTAIN A CURRENT CHARTER UNDER THE LAWS OF THIS STATE, AS REQUIRED BY MCL 450.2911 AND/OR MCL 450.2922 AND/OR MCL 450.1911 AND/OR MCL 450.1922: AS DISCOVERED ON OR ABOUT 9-1-09 (GROSSE ILE PD & SOUTHGATE PD/DECOY/CK EDWARD GRAHAM/NO ID) 12-08-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-15-2009 1)$400 2)DISMISSED TOTAL $400 OR 20 DAY SUSP. NEG SETTLEMENT SEC.801(2) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 08/11/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136458 A-1 DOWNRIVER PARTY STORE 15628 FORT SOUTHGATE MI 48195 LICENSEE(S) : A-1 DOWNRIVER PARTY STORE INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY 06-ACC-55 W/DOB 3-22-89 (20): (GROSSE ILE PD & SOUTHGATE PD/DECOY/CK SARAH CONRADO/ID) 12-01-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) 12-02-2009 $600 OR 30 DAY SUSP. RULE 15(E) SEC.801(2) : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136788 A-1 DOWNRIVER PARTY STORE 15628 FORT SOUTHGATE MI 48195 LICENSEE(S) : A-1 DOWNRIVER PARTY STORE INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY HEPLER (16): (SOUTHGATE PD/DECOY/CK JOHN GASI/NO ID) : COMM. ORDER : 08/11/2009 VIOLATION DATE : CRP 09/07/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP 12-01-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON RULE 15(E) COST $36.80 12-02-2009 $1000 OR 50 DAY SUSP. & $36.80 W/FEES TOTAL $1036.80 RULE 15(E) Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 43 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 136650 CECIL'S SPORTS BAR & GRILL 22615 GODDARD TAYLOR MI 48180 LICENSEE(S) : FERA ENTERTAINMENT, RESTAURANTS, AND AMUSEMENT SYSTEMS, INC. CHARGE REC'D - 1)3)5) ALLOWED UNLAWFUL GAMBLING WITH CARDS ON LIC'D PREMISES: ON OR ABOUT 3-2508, ON OR ABOUT 1-20-09, ON OR ABOUT 1-26-09; 2)4)6) ALLOWED UNLAWFUL GAMBLING DEVICES, CARDS, ON LIC'D PREMISES: ON OR ABOUT 3-25-08, ON OR ABOUT 1-20-09, ON OR ABOUT 1-26-09; 7) ALLOWED WAGERING ON A VIDEO POKER MACHINE ON LIC'D PREMISES: ON OR ABOUT 3-25-08; 9)11)13) ALLOWED WAGERING ON MACHINES ON LIC'D PREMISES: ON OR ABOUT 1-20-09, ON OR ABOUT 1-26-09, ON OR ABOUT 1-29-09; 8)10)12)14) ALLOWED ON LIC'D PREMKISES MACHINES USED FOR GAMBLING PURPOSES: ON OR ABOUT 3-25-08, ON OR ABOUT 1-20-09, ON OR ABOUT 1-26-09, ON OR ABOUT 1-29-09 (MSP-WEST WAYNE, METRO SOUTH, SPECIAL OPERATIONS-CID-SE-GAMBLING SEC-GIS-1708 - TAYLOR PD & ALLEN PARK PD) 12-09-2009 HEARING HELD SWARTZ CREEK POBUR/HALL/GIBSON NEG SETTLEMENT 12-11-2009 7 DAYS SUSP, SUSP WAIVED, 1-14)$300 EACH FOR A TOTAL OF $4200 OR 210 DAYS SUSP. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THE LICENSEE TO FORFEIT THE GAMING MACHINES AND MONEY SEIZED IN THE COURSE OF THIS INVESTIGATION AND ORDERS THE MSP TO DESTROY THE SEIZED GAMING MACHINES AND TO DISPOSE OF THE MONEY SEIZED IN THE INVESTIGATION IN A MANNER PRESCRIBED BY LAW, UNLESS THAT DESTRUCTION AND DISPOSAL HAS ALREADY BEEN ADDRESSED BY THE CRIMINAL MATTER ASSOCIATED WITH THESE VIOLATIONS. THE COMMISSIONER ORDERS THAT NO ADDITIONAL MLCC CHARGES BE FILED AGAINST THE LICENSEE IN THE EVEN THAT THERE ARE ANY CRIMINAL CHARGES AGAINST THE LICENSED CORPORATION, DIRECTORS, SHAREHOLDERS AGENTS OR EMPLOYEES FOR INCIDENTS THAT OCCURRED ON THE DATES ADDRESSED IN THIS ORDER. NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137652 DRINKS SALOON 9015 S TELEGRAPH TAYLOR MI 48180 LICENSEE(S) : BOWLES, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (186.69): (LCVC) : VIOLATION DATE : 09/10/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : CRP 10/09/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : COMM. ORDER : 12-02-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-17-2009 100.00/50.00 WAIVED TOTAL 50.00 OR 3 DAY SUSP COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137068 FRATERNAL ORDER OF EAGLES 4104 WAYNELAND 35850 EARL WAYNE MI 48184 COUNTY: WAYNE VIOLATION DATE : CRP 09/15/2009 LICENSEE(S) : FRATERNAL ORDER OF EAGLES 4104 WAYNELAND CHARGE REC'D - 1)-6) POSSESSED, SOLD, OFFERED FOR SALE, OR EXPOSED FOR SALE ALCOHOLIC LIQUOR WHICH WAS ADULTERATED, OR MISBRANDED, OR REFILLED: 750 ML BOTTLES OF MALIBU RUM, CAPTAIN MORAN "SPICED RUM", JACK DANIEL'S, SEAGRAM'S "Vo,", HOT DAMN BURST (SCHNAPPS), LAUDER'S SCOTCH, DEWAR'S "WHITE LABEL,", CROWN ROYAL, SOUTHERN COMFORT; 1.75 LTR BOTTLE OF SMIRNOFF VODKA; 1.75 LTR BOTTLE OF ABSOLUT VODKA; 1.75 LTR BOTTLE OF BACARDI "LIGHT" RUM; 1.75 LTR BOTTLE OF JIM BEAM "BOURBON WHISKY"; 7.50 BOTTLE OF ROYAL CANADIAN WHISKEY: DISCOVERED 91-09 (LCC INV TOMA) 12-11-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-22-2009 50.00 OR EACH CHARGE TOTAL 300.00 OR 15 DAY SUSP : COMM. ORDER : COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137500 MARIA'S ITALIAN BAKERY 8675 NEWBURGH WESTLAND MI 48185 LICENSEE(S) : AL JARBO, INC. CHARGE NSF CHECK (1732.33): (LCC) : COMM. ORDER : INTEREST : VIOLATION DATE : CLB 10/07/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : CRP 11-18-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $100.00 OR 5 DAYS SUSP Report: LLVC0180 January 08, 2010 07:36 AM Page 44 of 45 Michigan Department Of Energy, Labor & Economic Growth ORIGINAL DECISION REPORT FROM 12-01-2009 TO 12-31-2009 COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137144 DON Q'S PARTY STORE 289 SIXTH WYANDOTTE MI 48192 LICENSEE(S) : TAVAREZ, CATHERINE TAVAREZ, FRANCISCO CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY 06-ACC-58 W/DOB 5-3-89 (20): (GROSSE ILE PD/DECOY/CK MARIO TAVAREZ/NO ID) 12-01-2009 HEARING HELD FARMINGTON GAFFNEY/RUBIN/GIBSON ACK 12-02-2009 $300 OR 15 DAY SUSP. : COMM. ORDER : VIOLATION DATE : 09/03/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : INTEREST : GPI GPI COMPLAINT NO: D.B.A : ADDRESS : 137251 GIZZMOS 3225 BIDDLE WYANDOTTE MI LICENSEE(S) : GIZZMOS, INC. CHARGE SALE TO MINOR - DECOY 06-ACC-53 W/DOB 3-22-89 (20): (MSP-METRO SOUTH TAYLOR POST 0250003797-09/DECOY/CK ERICK NICHOLSON/ID) 12-01-2009 LIC ACK - COMM POBUR 12-07-2009 $600 OR 30 DAY SUSP. SEC.801(2) : COMM. ORDER : Report: LLVC0180 VIOLATION DATE : 48192 09/03/2009 COUNTY: WAYNE INTEREST : January 08, 2010 07:36 AM CRP Page 45 of 45