Attachment 29

Attachment 29
General Atomics-Electronics Systems Inc. redacted non-proprietary document 04038903QSR, "Qualification Summary Report for Watts Bar Nuclear Plant Unit 2 Replacement
Radiation Monitors," Revision D (Letter Item 10)
25402-01 1-VIA-HARA-00221-001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
REVISIONS
DESCRIPTION
REV
B
C
D
_
_l
INCORPORATED ECN 400000218
A. EVANS 2/1012011
DATE
2-9-11
2-10-11
INCORPORATED ECN 400001040
DICK DOYLE 7/12/2011
2-10-11
7-12-11
7-12-11
P.Berner
A.Evans
E.Cabel
Wilkinson
P.Berner
7-15-11
E. Cabal
2-10-11
7-12-11
APPROVED
Wilkinson
L rsaica for
A.Evans
9frj4'
INCORPORATED ECN 400001428
JOE HEITHAUS 7/15/2011
y/2/n
j
1tk
Change doc
ClaUojn
BECHTEL POWER CORPORATION
I Job Number: 25402
SUPPLIER DOCUMENT REVIEW STATUS
STATUS CODE:
1 Q workmeypreed.
3 E] Reded.Reviseandresubrnt
Mt rtmayprooced. Edilvnal
4 g Reviewnotreqwued. Walcmay
oommenis need only W incorporsted
proeed
if revised fo other puw lfle.
2
Reseaendbnl mit flomay
PO 77469 Release 77448
pr, eed SAW to Incopotlion of
dhairlesindiPats.
Peinbsslan to prceed does not constitute acceptance or approvat of dedgn detads. calculatons.
analysis, test melods. or materias developed or sdeded by theSupplier and does not relieve Ire
Supple•rmnfullwOmpilancewlit
contractual oblllpatiom
Reiewed by IAyAmjdr
CI
Bad
kM Ier10A
M T IePý0
altiI,.fESTE
PD 1 V1,4 I /Slartfl
*#
I
11•-1A
v
V~wOJA/Ai
IC
5
~b
Statuso[f.y'
;
/
fl/IV
GENERAL ATONICS
ELECTRONIC
WAE/
4949 GREENCRAIG LANE
SAN DIEGO, CA 92123-1676
SYSTEMS
A.E. BU-r
12113/10
C
J.oWEN
jKM
irnio0
A90
:E.BBUlT
7
QUALIFICATION SUMMARY REPORT for
1
12_10
WATTS BAR NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 2
REPLACEMENT RADIATION MONITORS
VWGATZA
PRoj I.
WAG"
SIZE
P. SERNER
BCARTER
12/13110
E.CABEL
12117/10
A
1 710
FSCM NO.
58307
DRAWING NO.
04038903-QSR
D
SHEET
I
RELEAS
REV
DRAWING
LEVW. 3
SCALE: NONE
1 of 46
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
CHANGE RECORD
Issue
Date
Rev. A
December 2010
Original Issue
Rev. B
February 2011
Incorporated Customer
Comments
Rev. C
July 2011
Incorporated Customer
Comments
Rev. D
September 2011
Incorporated Customer
Comments
Description of Change
Change doc
Classification
04038903-QSR
Rev D Page 2
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
CONTENTS
1.
PUR PO S E ................................................................................................................
6
2.
EQUIPMENT DESCRIPTION ..............................................................................
8
2.1
GA-ESI PIN 04031101-001 GAS MONITOR (2-RE-90-130 AND 131) ........................................
8
2.2
GA-ESI PIN 04031301-001 PARTICULATE AND GAS MONITOR (2-RE-90-106) ......................
8
2.3
GA-ESI PIN 04031401-001 GAS MONITOR (2-RE-90-1 19) ...........................................................
9
2.4
GA-ESI PIN 04031501-001 PARTICULATE, IODINE, AND GAS MON (2-RE-90-112) ................ 9
2.5
GA-ESI PIN 04032201-001 TWO CHANNEL LIQUID MON (2-RE-90-120 AND 121) ................ 10
2.6
GA-ESI PIN 04033101-001 MAIN STEAM LINE MON (2-RE-90-421, 422, 423, AND 424) .....
2.7
GA-ESI P/N 04034101-001 HIGH RANGE AREA MON (2-RE-90-271, 272, 273, AND 274) .......... 10
2.8
GA-ESI PIN 04034201-001 EXTENDED RANGE AREA MON (2-RE-90-255 AND 256) ........... 11
2.9
GA-ESI PIN 04034401-001 MULTI-CHANNEL AREA MON (2-RE-90-002, 059, 060, AND 061)... 11
3.
QUALIFICATION REQUIREMENTS .................................................................
13
3.1
GENERAL QUALIFICATION REQUIREMENTS ...........................................................
13
3.2
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION REQUIREMENTS .............................................
13
10
3.2.1
GA-ESI P/N 04031101-001 Analog Gas Monitor (2-RE-90-130 AND -131) .............................
14
3.2.2
GA-ESI P/N 04031301-001 Particulateand Gas Monitor (2-RE-90-106).................................
14
3.2.3
GA-ESI P/N 04031401-001 Gas Monitor (2-RE-90-119)..........................................................
14
3.2.4
GA-ESI PIN 04031501-001 Particulate,Iodine, and Gas Monitor (2-RE-90-112)...................
15
3.2.5
GA-ES! P/N 04032201-001 Two ChannelLiquid Monitors (2-RE-90-120 and -121) .............. 15
3.2.6
GA-ES! P/N 04033101-001 Steam Line Monitors (2-RE-90-421, -422, -423, and -424) ......
3.2.7
GA-ESI P/N 04034101-001 High Range Area Monitors (2-RE-90-271, -272, -273, and -274) ... 16
3.2.8
GA-ESI P/N 04034201-001 Extended Range Area Monitors (2-RE-90-255 and -256) .......... 17
3.2.9
GA-ES! P/N 04034401-001 MultichannelArea Monitors (2-RE-90-002, -059, -060, and -061) .. 18
16
3.3
SEISMIC QUALIFICATION REQUIREMENTS .............................................................
3.4
ELECTROMAGNETIC COMPATIBILITY QUALIFICATION REQUIREMENTS ........... 32
3.5
SOFTWARE QUALIFICATION REQUIREMENTS .........................................................
35
4.
GA-ESI'S QUALIFICATION PROGRAMS .........................................................
38
4.1
GA-ESI'S GENERIC QUALIFICATION PROGRAM ......................................................
38
4.2
GA-ESI'S ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION PROGRAM .......................................
38
4.3
GA-ESI'S SEISMIC QUALIFICATION PROGRAM .........................................................
39
20
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 3
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
4.4
GA-ESI'S ELECTROMAGNETIC COMPATIBILITY QUALIFICATION PROGRAM .......... 40
4.5
GA-ESI'S SOFTWARE QUALIFICATION PROGRAM ..................................................
42
5.
QUALIFICATION BASIS ...................................................................................
44
6.
REFERENCE DOCUMENTS .............................................................................
45
TABLES
TABLE 1-1 RADIATION MONITORS QUALIFIED BY THIS DOCUMENT ......................................................................
TABLE
2-1
MAJOR ASSEMBLIES OF THE PARTICULATE AND GAS MONITOR
(GA-ESI P/N 04031301-001) ......
2-2
TABLE 2-3
TABLE 2-4
MAJOR ASSEMBLIES OF THE GAS MONITOR
2-5
TABLE 2-6
MAJOR ASSEMBLIES OF THE STEAM LINE MONITORS
2-7
TABLE 2-8
MAJOR ASSEMBLIES OF THE EXTENDED RANGE AREA MONITORS
TABLE
TABLE
TABLE
MAJOR
MAJOR
6
8
(GA-ESI P/N 04031401-001) ......................................
9
ASSEMBLIES OF THE PARTICULATE, IODINE, AND GAS MONITOR (GA-ESI P/N 04031501-001).9
ASSEMBLIES OF THE Two CHANNEL LIQUID MONITOR (GA-ESI P/N 04032201-001) ......
10
MAJOR ASSEMBLIES OF THE HIGH RANGE AREA
(GA-ESI P/N 04033101-001) ......................
10
MONITOR (GA-ESI P/N 04034101-001) ............. 11
MAJOR ASSEMBLIES OF THE MULTICHANNEL AREA
(GA-ESI PIN 04034201-001) ........ 11
MONITORS (GA-ESI P/N 04034401-001) ........ 12
TABLE
3-1
TURBINE BUILDING ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS ............................................................................
TABLE
3-2
AUXILIARY BUILDING ELEVATIONS
ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS .........................
16
TABLE
3-3
HARSH ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS FOR HIGH RANGE AREA MONITORS ......................................
17
TABLE
3-4
AUXILIARY BUILDING ROOM A14 ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS ......................................................
18
TABLE
3-5
UPPER COMPARTMENT ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS ........................................................................
19
TABLE
3-6
LOWER COMPARTMENT INSTRUMENT ROOM ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS ..................................... 19
TABLE
3-7
RADIATION MONITOR ASSEMBLIES REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA ...............................................
20
TABLE
5-1
Q UALIFICATION BASIS SUPPLEMENTS ..................................................................................................
44
729.0 AND 737.0
15
FIGURES
FIGURE
3-1
NORTH-SOUTH REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA (2-RE-90-002) .................................................
22
FIGURE
3-2
EAST-WEST REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA
(2-RE-90-002) .....................................................
22
FIGURE
3-3
VERTICAL REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA
(2-90-RE-002) ..........................................................
23
3-4
FIGURE 3-5
FIGURE 3-6
VERTICAL REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA
23
24
24
3-8
VERTICAL REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA
(2-RE-90-106, -112, -421, -422, -423, &-424) ........ 25
FIGURE
FIGURE
(2-RE-90-059, -060, -271, &-272) ..........................
NORTH-SOUTH REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA (2-RE-90-059, -060, -271, &-272) ...................
VERTICAL REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA (2-RE-90-061, -273, &-274) ....................................
04038903-QSR
Change doc
lassificationi
Rev D Page 4
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
3-9 NORTH-SOUTH REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA (2-RE-90-106, -112, -421, -422, -423, & -424) ..... 26
FIGURE 3-10 EAST-WEST REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA (2-RE-90-106, -112, -421, -422, -423, & -424)........ 26
FIGURE
3-11 VERTICAL REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA (2-RE-90-130 &-131) ...........................................
FIGURE 3-12 NORTH-SOUTH REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA (2-RE-90-130 &-131) ....................................
FIGURE
27
27
3-13 EAST-WEST REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA (2-RE-90-130 & -131) .........................................
28
FIGURE 3-14 VERTICAL REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA CONTROL ROOM ....................................................... 28
FIGURE
3-15 NORTH-SOUTH REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA CONTROL ROOM ............................................. 29
FIGURE 3-16 EAST-WEST REQUIRED RESPONSE SPECTRA CONTROL ROOM ................................................... 29
FIGURE 3-17 CONTAINMENT SHIELD BUILDING HORIZONTAL ARS CURVES (EL. 735') ....................................
30
FIGURE
FIGURE 3-18 CONTAINMENT SHIELD BUILDING VERTICAL ARS CURVES (EL. 735') .........................................
30
3-19 CONTAINMENT SHIELD BUILDING HORIZONTAL ARS CURVES (EL. 753') ....................................
FIGURE 3-20 CONTAINMENT SHIELD BUILDING VERTICAL ARS CURVES (EL. 753') .........................................
31
31
FIGURE
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 5
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
1.
PURPOSE
The Qualification Summary Report (QSR) is the principal document for environmental, seismic,
electromagnetic compatibility, and software qualification bases for the replacement radiation
monitors for the Tennessee Valley Authority's (TVA) Watts Bar Nuclear Plant Unit 2 purchased
under TVA Purchase Orders 00077448 Rev. 001 and 00077469 Rev. 001.
The replacement
radiation monitors must meet TVA specification 25402-011-MRA-HARA-00001 for non-safety
monitors or TVA specification 25402-01 1-MRA-HARA-00002 for safety related monitors. Table
1-1 identifies the radiation monitors by TVA tag number, monitor service, GA-ESI part number
(P/N), safety class, and seismic category.
Table 1-1 Radiation Monitors Qualified by this Document
TVA Tag
2-RE-90-002
2-RE-90-059
2-RE-90-060
2-RE-90-061
2-RE-90-106
2-RE-90-112
2-RE-90-119
2-RE-90-120
2-RE-90-121
2-RE-90-130
2-RE-90-131
2-RE-90-255
2-RE-90-256
2-RE-90-271
2-RE-90-272
2-RE-90-273
2-RE-90-274
2-RE-90-421
2-RE-90-422
2-RE-90-423
2-RE-90-424
Monitor Service
Personal Lock
Upper Compartment Refueling Floor
Upper Compartment
Lower Compartment Instrument Room
Containment Building Lower Compartment
Containment Building Upper Compartment
Condenser Vacuum Pump Exhaust
Steam Generator Blowdown
Steam Generator Blowdown
Containment Purge Air Exhaust
Containment Purge Air Exhaust
Turbine Building Extended Range Area
Turbine Building Extended Range Area
Upper Inside Containment Post Accident
Lower Inside Containment Post Accident
Upper Inside Containment Post Accident
Lower Inside Containment Post Accident
Main Steam Line
Main Steam Line
Main Steam Line
Main Steam Line
GA-ESI P/N
Class
Seismic1
04034401-001
04034401-001
04034401-001
04034401-001
04031301-001
04031501-001
04031401-001
04032201-001
04032201-001
04031101-001
04031101-001
04034201-001
04034201-001
04034101-001
04034101-001
04034101-001
04034101-001
04033101-001
04033101-001
04033101-001
04033101-001
Non-Safety
Non-Safety
Non-Safety
Non-Safety
Safety
Safety
Non-Safety
Non-Safety
Non-Safety
Safety
Safety
Non-Safety
Non-Safety
Safety
Safety
Safety
Safety
Non-Safety
Non-Safety
Non-Safety
Non-Safety
I(L)
I(L)
I(L)
I(L)
I
I
I(L)
I(L)
I(L)
I
I
I(L)
I(L)
I
I
I
I
I(L)
I(L)
I(L)
I(L)
Notes:
1. Seismic Categories are defined in TVA Design Criteria WB-DC-40-24 Rev.0021.
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 6
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
This report and its 11 supplements are organized to reduce the complication of qualifying three
difference radiation monitor processor types (RM-1000, RM-80, and RP-30AM) with four different
qualifications (environmental, seismic, EMC, and software) in one report. This principle document
discusses the overall organization of the reports, the equipment descriptions, the qualification
requirements, GA-ESI's qualification programs, the supplement describing the qualification basis,
and a list of GA-ESI documents referenced in the principle report. The supplements describe the
qualification basis for each radiation monitor type and qualification. A list of supplements
applicable to each radiation monitor is provided in Section 5.
This report consists of the following sections.
Section 1.
PURPOSE.
This section describes the reason for the report, its organization,
identification of the radiation monitors being qualified, and a description of the contents of each
section.
Section 2. EQUIPMENT DESCRIPTION. This section describes the major equipment items being
qualified organized by GA-ESI part number.
Section 3. REQUIREMENTS.
This section describes the requirements of the technical
specification and the requirements for each qualification type.
Section 4. GA-ESI's QUALIFICATION PROGRAMS. This section delineates the environmental,
seismic, EMC, and software programs used to qualify the radiation monitors for each qualification
type.
Section 5. QUALIFICATION BASIS. This section lists the location of the qualification basis for the
radiation monitors.
Section 6. REFERENCE DOCUMENTS. This section lists the GA-ESI documents and drawings
referenced in the body of the principle report.
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 7
25402-011 -VI A-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
2.
EQUIPMENT DESCRIPTION
The Watts Bar Nuclear Plant Unit 2 replacement radiation monitors applications are listed in
Table 1-1 and include safety related and non-safety related monitors. The monitors are used to
detect, compute and indicate radiation levels in various locations and processes throughout the
nuclear power plant. The monitors are installed in both mild and harsh environments. The
functional and performance specifications for the radiation monitors are described in their
technical manuals. This section does not duplicate that description.
Rather, this section is
organized by GA-ESI monitor or monitor system. A brief description of the monitor or monitor
system, a cross reference to the technical manual, and the major subassemblies of the monitor
or monitor system are listed. The acronyms and abbreviations used in the following subsections
are defined in TVA design criteria WB-DC-40-24 Rev. 0021.
2.1
GA-ESl P/N 04031101-001 Gas Monitor (2-RE-90-130 and 131)
The RP-30AM Analog Gas Radiation Monitor is a skid mounted monitor utilized to monitor the
gas from the containment purge air exhaust. It is Nuclear Safety Related
Business IA
complete description of the equipment, the
Sensitive
principles of operation, performance and functional specifications are found in GA-ESI Technical
Manual 04031101-1TM.
2.2
GA-ESI P/N 04031301-001 Particulate and Gas Monitor (2-RE-90-106)
The RM-80 Particulate and Gas Monitor is a skid mounted monitor utilized to monitor the
sBusiness
Sensitive
atmosphere from the Lower Containment Building Compartment. It is Nuclear Safety Related,
I The major assemblies of
the Particulate and Gas Monitor are provided in Table 2-1.
A complete description of the
equipment, the principles of operation, performance and functional specifications are found in
GA-ESI Technical Manual 04031301-1TM.
Table 2-1 Major Assemblies of the Particulate and Gas Monitor (GA-ESI PIN 04031301-001)
Assembly Description
Particulate and Gas Monitor System
Particulate and Gas Monitor Assembly
Local Indicator Assembly
RM-23A NIM Bin Assembly
GA-ESI PIN
04031301-001
04031303-001
04030270-003
04030841-001
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 8
25402-011 -V1A-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
2.3
GA-ESI PIN 04031401-001 Gas Monitor (2-RE-90-119)
The RM-80 Gas Monitor is used for monitoring radiation in the exhaust of the Condenser
Vacuum Pump. It is Non-Safety Related and Seismic Category I(L). The major assemblies are
provided in Table 2-2. A complete description of the equipment, the principles of operation,
performance and functional specifications are found in GA-ESI Technical Manual 040314011TM.
Table 2-2 Major Assemblies of the Gas Monitor (GA-ESI PIN 04031401-001)
Assembly Description
GA-ESI P/N
Gas Monitor System
Gas Monitor Assembly
RM-23A NIM Bin Assembly
2.4
04031401-001
04031403-001
04030821-001
GA-ESI PIN 04031501-001 Particulate, Iodine, and Gas Mon (2-RE-90-112)
The RM-80 Particulate, Iodine, and Gas Monitor is a skid mounted monitor utilized to monitor
Business
Sensitive
the atmosphere from the Upper Containment Building Compartment.
Related,
It is Nuclear Safety
The major
assemblies of the Particulate, Iodine, and Gas Monitor are provided in Table 2-3. A complete
description of the equipment, the principles of operation,
performance and functional
specifications are found in GA-ESI Technical Manual 04031501-1TM.
Table 2-3 Major Assemblies of the Particulate, Iodine, and Gas Monitor (GA-ESI PIN 04031501-001)
Assembly Description
Particulate, Iodine, and Gas Monitor System
Particulate, Iodine and Gas Monitor Assembly
Local Indicator Assembly
RM-23A NIM Bin Assembly
GA-ESI P/N
04031501-001
04031503-001
04030270-003
04030841-001
Change doc
Classification
04038903-QSR
Rev D Page 9
25402-011 -VI A-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
2.5
GA-ESI P/N 04032201-001 Two Channel Liquid Mon (2-RE-90-120 and 121)
The RM-80 Two Channel Liquid Monitors are used for monitoring radiation in the Steam
Generator Blowdown Line. They are Non-Safety Related and Seismic Category I(L). The major
assemblies are provided in Table 2-4. A complete description of the equipment, the principles
of operation, performance and functional specifications are found in GA-ESI Technical Manual
04032201 -1TM.
Table 2-4 Major Assemblies of the Two Channel Liquid Monitor (GA-ESI PIN 04032201 -001)
Assembly Description
Two Channel Liquid Monitor System
Liquid Monitor Assembly
Liquid Monitor Detector Assembly
NIM Bin Assembly, Control/Display (Safety)
2.6
GA-ESI PIN
04032201-001
04032203-001
04032205-001
04030821-001
GA-ESI P/N 04033101-001 Main Steam Line Mon (2-RE-90-421,422, 423, and 424)
The RM-80 Steam Line Monitors are used for monitoring radiation in the main steam lines.
They are Non-Safety Related and Seismic Category I(L). The major assemblies are provided in
Table 2-5. A complete description of the equipment, the principles of operation, performance
and functional specifications are found in GA-ESI Technical Manual 04033101-1TM.
Table 2-5 Major Assemblies of the Steam Line Monitors (GA-ESI P/N 04033101-001)
Assembly Description
Main Steam Line Monitor
RM-80/CIJB Assembly
Detector Shield Assembly, Main Steam Line
Control/Display Assembly
Power Supply Panel Assembly
2.7
GA-ESI P/N
04033101-001
04033103-001
03602126-002
04034351-002
04033126-001
GA-ESI P/N 04034101-001 High Range Area Mon (2-RE-90-271, 272, 273, and 274)
The RM-1000 High Range Area Monitors are utilized for post accident monitoring in the upper
and lower compartments of the containment building. They are Nuclear Safety Related, QA
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 10
25402-011-VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Business
The major assemblies of the
SensitiveI High Range Area Monitors are provided in Table 2-6. A complete description of the equipment,
the principles of operation, performance and functional specifications are found in GA-ESI
Technical Manual 04034101-1TM.
Table 2-6 Major Assemblies of the High Range Area Monitor (GA-ESI PIN 04034101-001)
Assembly Description
High Range Area Monitor System
RD-23 Gamma Ionization Chamber Assembly
NIM Bin Assembly (Safety)
Line Filter
2.8
GA-ESI PIN
04034101-001
03602062-001
04030801-001
50011202-001
GA-ESI PiN 04034201-001 Extended Range Area Mon (2-RE-90-255 AND 256)
The RM-1000 Extended Range Area Monitors are utilized to monitor radiation in areas in the
Turbine Building.
They are Non-Safety Related and Seismic Category I(L).
The major
assemblies of the Extended Range Area Monitors are provided in Table 2-7.
A complete
description of the equipment, the principles of operation, performance and functional
specifications are found in GA-ESI Technical Manual 04034101-ITM.
Table 2-7 Major Assemblies of the Extended Range Area Monitors (GA-ESI PIN 04034201-001)
Assembly Description
Extended Range Area Monitor System
RD-2A Detector Assembly
RD-1 (10E-1 to 10E4) Area Monitor Detector Assembly
NIM Bin Assembly
Line Filter
2.9
GA-ESI P/N
04034201-001
02810382-016
02810059-001
04030811-001
50011202-001
GA-ESI P/N 04034401-001 Multi-Channel Area Mon (2-RE-90-002, 059, 060, and 061)
The RM-1000 Multi-Channel Area Monitors are utilized for radiation monitoring areas in the
personal airlock, the upper compartment refueling floor, the upper compartment, and the lower
compartment instrument room. They are Non-Safety Related and Seismic Category I(L). The
major assemblies are provided in Table 2-8. A complete description of the equipment, the
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 11
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
principles of operation, performance and functional specifications are found in GA-ESI Technical
Manual 04034101-1TM.
Table 2-8 Major Assemblies of the Multichannel Area Monitors (GA-ESI PIN 04034401 -001)
Assembly Description
Multi-Channel Area Monitor System
RD-1 (10E-1 to 10E4) Area Monitor Detector Assembly
RD-2A Detector Assembly
Local Indicator Assembly
Local Indicator Assembly
RM-1000 and I-F Converter NIM Bin Assembly
Line Filter
GA-ESI PIN
04034401-001
02810059-001
02810382-016
04030270-001
04030270-002
04030831-001
50015790-001
Change doc
Classification
04038903-QSR
Rev D Page 12
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
3.
QUALIFICATION REQUIREMENTS
The Watts Bar Nuclear Power Plant Unit 2 replacement radiation monitors qualification
requirements are delineated in TVA Purchase Order 00077469 Rev. 001 and 00077448 Rev.
001.
Section 3 describes those requirements as they apply to the General Qualification,
Environmental Qualification, Seismic Qualification, Electromagnetic Compatibility Qualification,
and Software Qualification.
3.1
GENERAL QUALIFICATION REQUIREMENTS
TVA Purchase Order 00077469 Rev. 001 requires that TVA 25402-011-MRA-HARA-00001 for
non-safety related radiation monitors and TVA Purchase Order 00077448 requires that TVA
25402-01 1-MRA-HARA-00002 for safety related radiation monitors requirements apply.
3.2
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION REQUIREMENTS
The environmental qualification requirements for the replacement monitors are provided in TVA
25402-011-MRA-HARA-00001
for Non-Safety Related monitors and TVA25402-011-MRA-
HARA-00002 for Safety Related monitors.
qualified are
The environments to which the monitors are
.
WB-DC-40-54 Section 2.1, 2.2, and 2.3 defines
these environments.
Business
Sensitive
Business
Sensitive
The monitors are qualified for
intent in
to
BusinessI GA-ESI Doc. No. E-115-0699
The
and
has a significant effect on these
This plan requires applying specific
Sensitive
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification,
Rev D Page 13
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
accelerated aging techniques to those components that have significant age-related failure
mechanisms. The accelerated age conditioning quantitatively ages the component to its near
end-of-qualified-life condition.
GA-ESI Doc. No. E-115-0699 further requires aging to an
Business ambient equivalent condition of
Sensitive
This is based on an
average
ambient temperature of the environment and an enclosure temperature rise of
IEEE Std 1205-2000, Table D.8 shows that the upper Bounding temperature is
all plant areas except the reactor building.
•
for
Generally the customer requires identification of
these replaceable assemblies
The following subsections describe the environmental qualification requirements for each
monitor organized by GA-ESI part number.
3.2.1
GA-ESI P/N 04031101-001 Analog Gas Monitor (2-RE-90-130 AND -131)
The RP-30AM Analog Gas Monitors are Safety Related requiring qualification as
located in Electrical Equipment Room A19 Elevation 713'. The monitors are qualified for
Business
Sensitive
The environmental conditions are
provided in GA-ESI report 02818905-QSR Figure 3-3, except
(WBNNAL3-029 Rev. 4).
3.2.2
GA-ESI P/N 04031301-001 Particulate and Gas Monitor (2-RE-90-106)
The off-line RM-80 Particulate and Gas Monitor is Safety Related requiring qualification as=.
The monitor detects radiation in air sample drawn from the Containment Lower Compartment
area to satisfy requirements of RG 1.45.
Business
Sensitive
It is located outside containment.
The monitor is
described in GA-ESI report 02818905QSR Figure 3-2. Its associated RM-23 NIM Bin
GAESI report 02818905-QSR Figure 3-9.
3.2.3
GA-ESI PIN 04031401-001 Gas Monitor (2-RE-90-119)
The off-line RM-80 Gas Monitor is Non-Safety Related requiring qualification as M.
The
monitor detects radiation in gas samples drawn from the Condenser Vacuum Pump Exhaust
and is required for primary to secondary tube leak detection.
Business
Building.
Sensitive
It is located in the Turbine
described in
Table 3-1. Its associated RM-23 NIM Bin
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 14
25402-011 -VI A-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
described in GA-ESI
-
Business
area and are qualified to
Sensitive I report 02818905-QSR Figure 3-9.
Table 3-1 Turbine Building Environmental Conditions
ENVIRONMENTAL
NORMAL
ABNORMAL
ACCIDENT
PARAMETER
Temperature (°F)
Avg
Max
Min
Pressure (psia)
Business
Sensitive
Avg
Max
Min
Humidity (% RH)
i
Avg
Max
Min
Radiation (RADS)
Avg
Max
Min
3.2.4
GA-ESI PIN 04031501-001 Particulate, Iodine, and Gas Monitor (2-RE-90-112)
The off-line RM-80 Particulate, Iodine, and Gas Monitor is Safety Related requiring qualification
as M.
The monitor detects radiation in an air sample drawn from the Containment Upper
Compartment area to satisfy requirements of RG 1.45. It is located outside containment. The
Business
Sensitive
conditions described in GA-ESI report
02818905-QSR Figure 3-2. Its associated RM-23 NIM Bin
are located in the
described in GA-ESI report 02818905-QSR Figure 3-9.
3.2.5
GA-ESI P/N 04032201-001 Two Channel Liquid Monitors (2-RE-90-120 and -121)
The off-line RM-80 Two Channel Liquid Monitors are Non-Safety Related requiring qualification
The monitors detect radiation in gas samples drawn from the Steam Generator
as M.
Business Blowdown and are required for primary to secondary tube leak detection. They are located in
Sensitive the Turbine Building. The monitors are
described in Table 3-1. Their associated RM-23 NIM Bin assemblies are located in the Control
Room area and are
described in GA-ESI report
02818905-QSR Figure 3-9.
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 15
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
3.2.6
GA-ESI P/N 04033101-001 Steam Line Monitors (2-RE-90-421, -422, -423, and -424)
The on-line RM-80 Steam Line Monitors are Non-Safety Related requiring qualification
The monitors detect radiation in the steam line from the steam generator and are
required for primary to secondary tube leak detection. They are also RG 1.97 Rev. 2 monitors
for accidents occurring within the Reactor Building and are
The monitors are not required to operate during
Business accidents due to line breaks in the Auxiliary Building. The monitors are located in the Auxiliary
Sensitive Building, elevation 737.0 and the detectors are located in the Auxiliary Building, elevation
729.0. The monitors are
described in
Table 3-2. Their associated RM-23 NIM Bin
the Control Room area and is
are located in
conditions described in GA-ESI
report 02818905-QSR Figure 3-9.
Table 3-2 Auxiliary Building Elevations 729.0 and 737.0 Environmental Conditions
ENVIRONMENTAL
PARAMETER
Temperature (0F)
Avg
Max
we]
N
r
Mi
Business
Sensitive
Pressure (psia)
Avg
Max
Min
Humidity (% RH)
Avg
Max
Mi
Radiation (RADS)
Avg
Max
Mi
3.2.7
GA-ESI PIN 04034101-001 High Range Area Monitors (2-RE-90-271, -272, -273, and
-274)
Business The RM-1000 High Range Area Monitors are Safety Related requiring qualification as ý.
Sensitive
The monitor detects radiation in Containment Upper and
Lower Compartment areas as post
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 16
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
accident monitors. Monitors 2-RE-90-271 and -272 are located in the Upper Compartment and
monitors 2-RE-90-273 and -274 are located in the Lower Compartment.
The monitors are
conditions described in Table 3-3.
Business Their associated RM-1000 NIM Bin assemblies and line filters are located in the Control Room
Sensitive
area and are
described in GA-ESI report
02818905-QSR Figure 3-9.
Table 3-3 Harsh Environmental Conditions for High Range Area Monitors
TVA TAG
GA-ESI PIN
NUMBER
2-RE-90-271
2-RE-90-272
ENVIRONMENTAL
NORMAL
ABNORMAL
ACCIDENT
PARAMETER
04034101-001
Temperature (°F)
Pressure (psia)
Humidity (% RH)
Business
Sensitive
Radiation (RADS)
Operating Time
2-RE-90-273
2-RE-90-274
04034101-001
Chemical Spray
Temperature (fF)
Pressure (psia)
Humidity (% RH)
Radiation (RADS)
Operating Time
Chemical Spray
Notes:
Business
Sensitive
3.2.8
GA-ESI PIN 04034201-001 Extended Range Area Monitors (2-RE-90-255 and -256)
Business The RM-1000 Extended Range Area Monitors are Non-Safety Related requiring qualification as
Sensitive
The monitors are located in the Turbine Building.
04038903-QSR
IChange doc
jClassification
I
Rev D Page 17
25402-011 -V1 A-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Business
Sensitive
1condition
described in Table 3-1. Their associated RM-1000 NIM Bin
assemblies and line filters are located in the
described in GA-ESI report 02818905-QSR Figure 3-9.
3.2.9
GA-ESI P/N 04034401-001 Multichannel Area Monitors (2-RE-90-002, -059, -060,
and -061)
Snensitess
These Non-Safety Related monitors are located in environments that will be
The monitors are to be qualified for
ISensitive
2-RE-90-002 Area Monitor is located in Auxiliary Building Room A14.
The environmental
conditions for that location are given in Table 3-4.
Table 3-4 Auxiliary Building Room A14 Environmental Conditions
ENVIRONMENTAL
NORMAL
ABNORMAL
ACCIDENT
PARAMETER
Temperature (°F)
Business
Sensitive
Avg
Max
Min
Pressure (psia)
Avg
Max
Min
Humidity (% RH)
Avg
Max
Min
Radiation (RADS)
Avg
Max
Min
2-RE-90-059 and -060 Area Monitors are located in the Upper Compartment Area.
The
monitors' environmental conditions are given in Table 3-5.
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 18
25402-011-VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Table 3-5 Upper Compartment Environmental Conditions
ENVIRONMENTAL
NORMAL
ABNORMAL
ACCIDENT
PARAMETER
Temperature (°F)
Avg
Max
Min
Pressure (psia)
Avg
Max
Min
Business
Sensitive
Humidity (% RH)
Avg
Max
Min
Radiation (RADS)
Avg
Max
Min
2-RE-90-061 Area monitor is located in the Lower Compartment Instrument Room.
The
environmental conditions for that location are given in Table 3-6.
Table 3-6 Lower Compartment Instrument Room Environmental Conditions
ENVIRONMENTAL
NORMAL
ABNORMAL
ACCIDENT
PARAMETER
Temperature (°F)
Business ]
Sensitive
Avg
Max
Min
Pressure (psia)
Avg
Max
Min
Humidity (% RH)
Avg
Max
Min
Radiation (RADS)
Avg
Max
Min
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 19
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
3.3
SEISMIC QUALIFICATION REQUIREMENTS
The seismic requirements are specified in the TVA specification referenced in Section 3.1.
Safety Related equipment must survive a DBE, Safe Shutdown Earthquake (SSE) seismic
event, providing reliable measurements before, during, and after the DBE. Both Safety Related
and Non-Safety Related equipment must meet the requirements of TVA document WB-DC-40-
Business 24 Rev. 0021 and CEB-SS-5.10 R3.
Sensitive
TVA requirements to •1•.
New and modified equipment will be analyzed and verified to meet TVA seismic requirements
as described in Section 4.3 of this document. The following are specific requirements of CEBSS-5.10 R3.
1. For seismic testing, the Required Response Spectra (RRS) for the SSE shall be as
shown in Table 3-7.
Table 3-7 Radiation Monitor Assemblies Required Response Spectra
Business
Sensitive
GA-ESl PIN
TVA Tag Number
Description
04031101-001
2-RE-90-130 & -131
Analog Gas Monitor
04031301-001
2-RE-90-106
Particulate and Gas Monitor
04031401-001
2-RE-90-119
04031501-001
2-RE-90-112
Gas Monitor
Particulate, Iodine, and Gas Monitor
04032201-001
2-RE-90-120 & -121
Two Channel Liquid Monitor
04033101-001
2-RE-90-421 to -424
Steam Line Monitor
04034101-001
2-RE-90-271 & -272
2-RE-90-273 & -274
High Range Area Monitor
04034201-001
04034401-001
2-RE-90-255 & -256
2-RE-90-002
Extended Range Area Monitor
Multichannel Area Monitor
2-RE-90-059 & -060
2-RE-90-061
Various
Various
Control Room Equipment
Various
Various
Control Room Panel Equipment
Business
Sensitive
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 20
25402-011-VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
3. Testing using multiple frequencies shall be ate.
Analysis shall be based on
4. The equipment being tested shall be mounted in the same configuration as specified in
the installation manual and shall be orientated in the worse case from both a structural
and functional perspective.
BusinessI
Sensitive
5. Relay chatter greater thar
shall be identified.
6. Qualification may be based on similarity to devices that are qualified to requirements
equal to or greater than these requirements.
7.
=
seismic tests at
followed by
•
is an acceptable
8. All resonance frequencies shall be identified.
9. Biaxial testing shall be in the horizontal and vertical directions.
10. Natural frequency may or may not be determined for analysis.
If it is not, the device
shall be assumed to be non-rigid and the acceleration magnitudes applied to all mass
points in a static stress analysis
Business
Sensitive
11. The results of analysis for "non-pressure retaining members, welds and threaded
fasteners shall satisfy AISC Manual of Steel Construction or equivalent allowable for
tension shear and buckling failure modes.
For threaded fastener materials not explicitly included in the AISC
Manual the following shall be used.
a. Pure Shear:
b. Pure Tension
Business
Sensitive
C.
Where
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 21
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Business
Sensitive
Business
Sensitive
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 22
25402-011-VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Business
Sensitive
IBusiness
Sensitive
04038903-QSR
Change do
Classification
Rev D Page 23
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Business
SensitiveI
Business
Sensitive
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 24
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Business
Sensitive
Business
Sensitive
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 25
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Business
Sensitive
Business
Sensitive
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 26
25402-011-VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Business
SensitiveI
Business
SensitiveI
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 27
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Business
Sensitive
Businessl
Sensitivel
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 28
25402-011 -VI A-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Business
Sensitive
Business
Sensitive
Change doc
Classification
04038903-QSR
Rev D Page 29
25402-011-VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Business
Sensitive
Business
Sensitive
Change doc
Classification
04038903-QSR
Rev D Page 30
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Business
Sensitive
Business
Sensitive
Change doc
Classification
04038903-QSR
Rev D Page 31
25402-011-VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
3.4
ELECTROMAGNETIC COMPATIBILITY QUALIFICATION REQUIREMENTS
The Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC) requirements for both Safety Related and Non-Safety
Related radiation monitors shall be in accordance with TVA specification SS-E18.14.01
Revision 3 unless this requirement is waivered by TVA based on appropriate justifying
documentation.
SS-E18.14.01 Revision 3
Business
ISensitive
All other electronic equipment shall meet the emission requirements of sections 8.6, Radiated
Emissions, and 8.7, ConductedEmissions.
Any or all specific tests may be waivered using operating experience.
The waiver shall be
based on a vendor submitted justification report; the waiver must be in writing and approved by
the TVA Corporate EMI Specialist or his designate. Alternate tests or vendor standard test
reports may be submitted for approval by the TVA Corporate EMI Specialist or his designate.
The following tests are required per SS-E18.14.01 Revision 3:
Change doc
Classification,
04038903-QSR
Rev D Page 32
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Radiated Susceptibility
Verify the device is not susceptible to
radiated electromagnetic signals.
Tests to be conducted in accordance SS-E1 8.14.01
R3 Section 8.1 as the following or MIL-STD-461C
(RS-03, Class 3A), MIL-STD-461D (RS103), IEC 801
Part 3-1991, or PMC33.1-1978.
Business
[Sensitive
The device is acceptable if no malfunction, undesired
response, degradation of performance, or permanent
damage to the device occurs.
Conducted Susceptibility
Tests per SS-E18.14.01 R3 Section 8.2 as follows:
Verify that the device is not susceptible
to conducted electromagnetic signals.
I
Business
Sensitive
The device is acceptable if no malfunction, undesired
response, degradation of performance, or permanent
damage to the device occurs.
Change doc
Classification
04038903-QSR
Rev D Page 33
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Surge Susceptibility
Verify that the device is not susceptible
to surges relatively high energy surges,
unidirectional pulses caused by
lightning, load switching and line faults
on AC power lines.
Tests per SS-El 8.14.01 R3 Section 8.3 as follows.
0
M
Business
Sensitive
*-
-
0
I UV I ), U1 /-ll
I/l-r-r-
%,jO.00 .;[u-
I•
I~.
SWC Class B: Device shall not incur any permanent
damage or require component replacement to
resume operation.
Impulse and Burst of Impulses
Susceptibility
Verify that the device is not susceptible
to low energy impulses from nearby
switching on short power lines.
Tests per SS-E18.14.01 R3 Section 8.4, as follows.
0
0
Business
Sensitive
a
The device is acceptable if no malfunction, undesired
response, degradation of performance, or permanent
damage to the device occurs.
IChange doc
Classification
04038903-QSR
Rev D Page 34
25402-011 -V1A-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Electrostatic Discharge
Susceptibility
Busines-
Tests per SS-E18.14.01 R3 Section 8.5, as follows.
-
Verify that the device is not susceptible
to a sudden transfer of charge resulting
in a spark.
SensitiveI
The device is acceptable if no malfunction, undesired
response, degradation of performance, or permanent
damage to the device occurs.
Radiated Emissions
Verify that the device does not radiate
electromagnetic emissions to the
environment in excess of the limit.
Business
Sensitive
Tests per SS-E18.14.01 R3 Section 8.6, as follows.
The device is acceptable if the electromagnetic
emission do not exceed the values in EPRI TR102323-1994, Figure 7.4
Conducted Emissions
Tests per SS-E18.14.01 R3 Section 8.5, as follows.
Verify that the device does not
generate electromagnetic emissions on
the power leads.
Business
Sensitive
The device is acceptable if the electromagnetic
emission on the power lines do not exceed the
values in EPRI TR-102323-1994, Figure 7.2•
3.5
SOFTWARE QUALIFICATION REQUIREMENTS
The software qualification requirements for both Safety Related and Non-Safety Related
radiation monitors shall be in accordance with TVA specification SS-E18.15.01 Rev. 3 unless
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 35
25402-011-VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
this requirement is waived by TVA based on appropriate justifying documentation or the
acceptance of GA-ESI's testing in meeting this requirement. SS-E18.15.01 Rev. 3
0
Business
Sensitive
Since GA-ESI software program is existing software developed under a 10 CFR 50 Appendix B
quality program,
Business
Sensitive
The evaluation is to determine whether there is sufficient evidence
that the software will reliably perform its intended functions and that the verification and
validation process satisfies the intent of RG1.152-2005. The justification documentation shall
include the following:
Business
Sensitive
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 36
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Business
Sensitive
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 37
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
4.
4.1
GA-ESI's QUALIFICATION PROGRAMS
GA-ESI's GENERIC QUALIFICATION PROGRAM
GA-ESI's qualification program for radiation monitors was initiated in the mid-1970s. The first
qualification programs related to environmental and seismic qualification of analog radiation
monitors.
In the late 1970s, the digital RM-80 and RM-23 were developed and EMI/RFI
qualification was added. Software for the RM-80 and RM-23 was prepared under the control of
a 10 CFR 50 Appendix B quality program. Verification and Validation (V&V) of this software to
RG 1.152-1996 requirements were performed in 1997 after the regulatory guide was first
issued.
Development of the RM-2000, RM-2300, and RM-1000 included qualification of the
monitors to the latest standards at the time of their development.
All qualification is performed
Sensitive
Business
by test, similarity to components that have been tested, or by design for mild environment
conditions.
The following subsections describe each program area (Environmental, Seismic, EMC, and
Software) in more detail and describe the methods used to qualify the TVA replacement
radiation monitors to the requirements in Section 3.
4.2
GA-ESI's ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION PROGRAM
GA-ESI's environmental qualification program is described in Section 4 of GA-ESI document
02818905-QSR. OP-7-3-240 Rev. F and OP-7-3-250 Rev. E are used for this qualification. The
steps taken in this qualification are as follows:
1. An analysis is performed to identify the differences between the monitor being qualified
by this report and the monitor qualified by GA-ESI document 02818905-QSR and its
supplements. As appropriate the assemblies, modules, components, and parts (items)
are listed in a table in the Qualification Basis of this report. Those qualified in GA-ESI
document 02818905-QSR and its supplements are identified in Tables 5-6 through 5-9
(Qualification Summary Tables) of 02818905-QSR.
2. The items that differ from those in GA-ESI document 02818905-QSR and its
supplements will be identified and qualified in the manner described in section 4.2 of
GA-ESI document 02818905-QSR.
04038903-QSR
IChanne doc
I
lClassification ,
Rev D Page 38
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
4.3
GA-ESI's SEISMIC QUALIFICATION PROGRAM
GA-ESI's generic seismic qualification program has been based on the performance of biaxial
or tri-axial multi-frequency tests for complex equipment and calculations for attachment of the
equipment to supporting structures.
Business
Sensitive
Generally, the ZPA for the vertical and horizontal spectra are
above
All testing
was conducted in accordance with IEEE-344 (the latest revision published at the time of the
test). OP-7-3-240 Rev. F and OP-7-3-250 Rev. E are used for this qualification.
The steps
taken in this qualification are as follows:
1. An analysis is performed to identify the differences between the monitor being qualified
by this report and the monitor qualified by previous GA-ESI documents and their
supplements.
As appropriate, items are listed in a table in each of the Qualification
Basis reports. An example is, Table 3-7, Seismic Qualification Summary Table for GAESI P/N 04034101-001 as presented in GA-ESI Doc 04038903-7SP. Those qualified in
GA-ESI documents E-254-0960 and 04508905-QR and their supplements are identified
in these tables.
2. The items that differ from those in previous GA-ESI documents and their supplements will
be identified and qualified. Seismic adequacy will be demonstrated by reference to tests
performed on similar items.
lBusiness
3. The seismic adequacy of individual items
Sensitive
Business
4. Items with parts that have
Sensitive
5. The support structures of items
Business
S
*
and
of this report. These may be internal to assemblies as well as external. For example,
the mounting of a circuit board within a module, if different from the mounting of the tested
item, may be analyzed.
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 39
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
4.4
GA-ESI's ELECTROMAGNETIC COMPATIBILITY QUALIFICATION PROGRAM
GA-ESI's Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC) Program relates closely to the standards that
are available at the time monitor equipment is tested. GA-ESI's focus is on digital monitoring
Business
Sensitive
devices since these are more prone to susceptibility and emissions issues.
perform their safety related functions in nuclear plant electromagnetic environments and that
they do not interfere with other devices. Evidence of analog devices performance is found in
operational history at Sequoyah Units 1 and 2 and Watts Bar Unit 1.
Tests of the RM-80/RM-23 digital radiation monitors were conducted in 1979 and 1980 the
results of which were reported in GA-ESI report E-1 15-0988 in 1981. The tests were conducted
to TVA specification 64-821696, which was the latest nuclear plant EMC specification at the
time.
0
Sensitive
Business
0
S
0
S
With the development of GA-ESI's RM-2000 and RM-2300 in the early 1990's, EMC testing was
expanded to include the latest USA and International standards. MIL-STD-461E and IEC 61000
series were utilized to demonstrate that EMC of the RM-2000 and RM-2300.
Business
Sensitive
0
0
I--
0
04038903-QSR
Change doc
.ClassificationI
Rev D Page 40
25402-011 -VI A-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
Business
Sensitive
RM-1000 modules were developed in the late 1990's and the EMC test program was again
expanded to include the latest standards as well as TVA specification SS E18.14.01 and the
guidance given by EPRI TR-102323, September 1994 issue.
S
I
Business
Sensitive
0
0
0
0
The RM-1000 module was
****Business]
Sensitive
0
U
0
0
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 41
25402-011 -V1 A-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
The qualification basis for EMC will be performed for each monitor type; RP-30AM analog
modules, RM-80/RM-23 digital monitors, and RM-1000 digital monitors. The following steps will
be taken for each qualification.
1. The TVA specification requirements will be compared to the test results of the same type
monitor.
2. Differences will be evaluated and justification provided to demonstrate that the monitor
type will perform satisfactorily.
3. For each monitor the configuration of the monitor will be compared to the test article.
Differences in configuration will be evaluated and justification provided to demonstrate
that the monitor will perform satisfactorily
4.5
GA-ESI's SOFTWARE QUALIFICATION PROGRAM
GA-ESI's software qualification program is in accordance with 10CFR 50 Appendix B since the
program was initiated in the late 1970's. Before the advent of nuclear verification and validation
(V&V) programs, GA-ESI produced a set of design, functional, and performance specifications
for the RM-80 and RM-23 software. These radiation monitors were extensively tested against
these specifications to ensure that they were able to perform their safety function and provide
reliable data and alarm functions. This is evident by a long history of successful operation at
many nuclear power plants throughout the world.
Formal configuration control and error
reporting fully meet the requirements of 10CFR50 Appendix B as well as 10CFR Part 21.
As the industry matured and NRC, EPRI, and IEEE establish new standards for the V&V of
software, GA-ESI kept pace with the new standards by performing a formal V&V to the latest
standards for the RM-80 and RM-23 in the late 1990s.
The standards and regulatory
documents used for this V&V were:
*
NRC Draft Guides DG-1054 through DG-1059 (all issued in 1996)
"
NRC NUREGs -95-02 and -4640
*
IEEE Standards 729, 730.1-1990, 829, 830-1984, 833-1974, 934-1987, 983, 1002,
1012-1986, 1016-1987, 1023-1988, 1028-1988, and 1074-1995.
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 42
25402-011 -V1 A-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
The RM-1000 software has been thoroughly V&V'd to the latest standards at the time. Version
1.2 was approved for use in similar monitors delivered to Browns Ferry Plant, based on TVA
Specification SS-E18.15.01, Rev. 3.
Software Qualification for the TVA Replacement Radiation Monitors is based on the
requirements described in Section 3.5 for software developed under a 10 CFR 50 Appendix B
program. The RM-80/RM-23 software qualification is reported separately from the RM-1000
software. The qualification demonstrates that the software V&V program meets the intent of
RG1.152-2005 by describing the requested information in TVA specification SS-El 8.15.01, Rev.
3 section 5.2.
Change doc
Classification
04038903-QSR
Rev D Page 43
25402-011 -VI A-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
QUALIFICATION BASIS
5.
Due to the complexity of producing one document that qualifies all the monitors environmentally,
seismically, for Electromagnetic Compatibility, and Software V&V as well as shipping schedules;
it is appropriate to prepare the overall requirements and general programs in this document and
supplement to this document for other qualification types. Table 5-1 identifies each monitor and
the associated supplements that qualify that monitor.
Table 5-1 Qualification Basis Supplements
GA-ESl P/N
Processor Type
Qualification Basis
04031101-001
RP-30AM
04038903-01 SP
Note 2
04031301-001
RM-80
04038903-02SP
04038903-11 SP
04031401-001
RM-80
04038903-03SP
04038903-11 SP
04031501-001
RM-80
04038903-04SP
04038903-11 SP
04032201-001
04033101-001
04034101-001
04034201-001
04034401-001
RM-80
RM-80
RM-1000
RM-1000
RM-1000
04038903-05SP
04038903-06SP
04038903-07SP
04038903-08SP
04038903-09SP
04038903-11 SP
04038903-11 SP
04038903-07SP
04038903-08SP
04038903-09SP
EMC
Notes:
1. Individual monitor supplements include Environmental, Seismic, EMC, and Software
qualification basis specific to that monitor.
2. EMC qualification supplements describe the electromagnetic compatibility of the
processor type. Since there is one supplement for the RP-30AM type, its qualification
basis is included in supplement number 1.
3. Software qualification is described in each supplement and refers to a series of report for
that processor type that demonstrates qualification.
Change doc
Classification
04038903-QSR
Rev D Page 44
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
6.
REFERENCE DOCUMENTS
GA-ESI DRAWINGS
04031101
GAS MONITOR ASSEMBLY
04031301
PARTICULATE AND GAS MONITOR SYSTEM
04031401
GAS MONITOR SYSTEM
04031501
PARTICULATE, IODINE, AND GAS MONITOR SYSTEM
04032201
TWO CHANNEL LIQUID MONITOR SYSTEM
04033101
MAIN STEAM LINE SYSTEM
04034101
HIGH RANGE AREA MONITOR SYSTEM
04034201
EXTENDED RANGE AREA MONITOR SYSTEM
04034401
MULTI-CHANNEL AREA MONITOR SYSTEM
GA-ESI DOCUMENTS
02818905-QSR
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION SUMMARY REPORT FOR CLASS 1E
EQUIPMENT FOR WATTS BAR 1 AND 2
04031101-1TM
TECHNICAL MANUAL, ANALOG GAS MONITOR
04031301 -1 TM
TECHNICAL MANUAL, PARTICULATE AND GAS MONITOR
04031401-1 TM
TECHNICAL MANUAL, GAS MONITOR
04031501-1 TM
TECHNICAL MANUAL, PARTICULATE, IODINE, AND GAS MONITOR
04032201 -1 TM
TECHNICAL MANUAL, TWO CHANNEL LIQUID MONITOR
04033101-1 TM
TECHNICAL MANUAL, STEAM LINE MONITOR
04034101 -1TM
TECHNICAL MANUAL, AREA MONITORS
04508905-QR
QUALIFICATION TEST REPORT FOR RM-1000 PROCESSOR MODULE
AND CURRENT-TO-FREQUENCY CONVERTER
04038903-QSR
Change doc
Classification
Rev D Page 45
25402-011 -VIA-HARA-00221 -001
General Atomics HARA
Qualification Summary Report for Replacement Radiation Monitors (Redacted)
E-1 15-0699
CLASS 1 E EQUIPMENT QUALIFICATION AND AGING PLAN
E-254-0960
TEST REPORT CLASS 1E DESIGN QUALIFICATION TESTING OF ANALOG
HIGH RANGE RADIATION MONITOR (RD-23, RP-2C, RP-23, AND RP-20-
01)
E-1 15-0988
ELECTROMAGNETIC
INTERFERENCE TESTS, METHODS, AND TEST
LIMITS
OP-7.3-240
SAFETY-RELATED COMMERCIAL GRADE SPARE PARTS
OP-7.3-250
QUALIFICATION SUMMARY REPORT
Change doc
Classification
04038903-QSR
Rev D Page 46