The State of the Central Valley Region Pamela Creedon, Executive Officer
by user
Comments
Transcript
The State of the Central Valley Region Pamela Creedon, Executive Officer
The State of the Central Valley Region Pamela Creedon, Executive Officer December 4, 2014 Item 5 Outline Background Status of Major Programs Achievements Summary Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 2 Central Valley Region Facts Nearly 40% of State’s Land area 18% of State’s population 2/3 of State’s drinking water Nearly 30 million acre-feet of reservoir storage Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 3 Staffing Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 4 Central Valley Region Staff Facts Staff $33.8 million personal services 232.7 authorized positions — 50 managers — 171.7 technical staff — 11 support staff 42 – temp help Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 5 Central Valley Region Staff Facts 300 250 Total Positions by Fiscal Year 274 258 241 240 200 232.7 222.7 150 100 50 0 FY 09/10 Agenda Item 5 FY 10/11 FY 11/12 FY 12/13 FY 13/14 FY 14/15 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 6 Central Valley Region Staff Facts Authorized Positions by Fiscal Year 300 250 200 34 30 56 60 30 54 30 184 37.7 51 58 54 150 100 32.7 168 157 156 139 137 FY 10/11 FY 11/12 FY 12/13 FY 13/14 FY 14/15 50 0 FY 09/10 Sacramento Agenda Item 5 Fresno Redding Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 7 Central Valley Region Staff Facts Potential Retirements in Next 2 Years Redding Fresno Sac Mgmt 1 0 2 Tech Staff 1 0 1 Support 0 0 0 Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 8 Central Valley Region Staff Distribution by Major Programs Planning 11% Surface Water Protection 25% Agenda Item 5 Exec / Mgmt / Support 11% Groundwater Protection 53% Slide 9 Ground Water Protection Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 10 Groundwater Protection Staff Distribution between GW Protection Programs Oil/Gas 3% Other 1% ILRP 14% SLIC / DOD 22% Dairies 10% Ground water 53% UST 12% Title 27 17% Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 WDR 21% Slide 11 Groundwater Quality Protection Strategy • Approved 2010 • June 2011 Workplan • High Priority Actions • CV-SALTS • Long-Term ILRP • Reduce WDR backlog and increase facilities regulated • Updated Workplan 2013 • Medium Priority Action Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 12 Groundwater Quality Protection Strategy Coordination with Integrated Regional Water Management Planning Groups (IRWMs) Expansion of CAFO Program Reduce Site Cleanup Backlog Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 13 WDR Program Over 1,400 Facilities 26 PYs Agenda Item 5 7 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 14 WDR Permitting Program 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Individual Orders Agenda Item 5 Waiver General Order Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 15 WDR Program’s Future • New State-wide Recycling Order • New Small Domestic Systems Order • Renew Small Food Process Waiver • Additional General Orders Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 16 Dairy (CAFO) Program 1,400 dairies 1.7 million cows 12 PYs Reissued Dairy General Order Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 17 Dairy (CAFO) Program Compliance and Enforcement Permitting Poultry Bovine Feedlots Irrigated Agriculture Representative Monitoring Program State Board Review and Fee Audit Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 18 R5 UST Closure Rates Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 19 UST Cleanup Program Open versus Closed UST cases 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 Agenda Item 5 Item #CentralCentral ValleyValley Water Board Meeting 4/5 December 2014 Slide 20 Slide 20 Agenda Water Board Meetingof4/5 August Site Cleanup Program Active Sites: 1240 Sites in Remediation: 525 Sites Closed FY 13/14 and 14/15: 119 Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 21 Site Cleanup Program Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 22 Site Cleanup Program Region 1 Region 2 Region 3 Region 4 Region 5 Region 6 Region 7 Region 8 Region 9 Total Active Cases Statewide By Region Agenda Item 5 Region 1 Region 2 Region 3 Region 4 Region 5 Region 6 Region 7 Region 8 Region 9 Cases Closed and Moved To Remediation Statewide by Region FY 13/14 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 23 Site Cleanup Program Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 24 Site Cleanup Program Program Trends for Next Year: • Increasing Brownfields and Redevelopment Work • Renewal of Underground Tank Fund Legislation Included Funding for Non-tank Cleanups • Evaluation of Petroleum Sites for Closure • Increasing Concerns about Groundwater Quality Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 25 Land Disposal Program Prescriptive Preventative Landfills High strength wastes Dairies Oil fields Mining Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December Slide 26 Land Disposal Program 21 PYs • 9 Fresno • 3 Redding • 9 Sacramento Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 27 Land Disposal Program (Title 27) Total WDRs Issued 18 16 14 17 16 13 17 15 5 –YR Average = 15.6 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 Onsite Wastewater Treatment System (OWTS) Policy Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 29 OWTS Implementation Effective May 2013 Basin Plan Amended March 2014 30 local agencies LAMPs by May 2016 Water Board approval by May 2017 Staff preparing checklist for LAMP development by agencies Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 30 Oil Fields 7 PYs Well Stimulation (SB4) Underground Injection Control (UIC) Sumps Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 31 Surface Water Protection Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 32 Surface Water Protection Staff Distribution between Surface Protection Programs Marijuana 7% Other 3% Timber Harvest 19% NPDES 43% Surface Water 25% 401 Cert 11% Storm Water 17% Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 33 NPDES Permitting Program 16.7 PY 129 Individual Permits 26% of State 52 majors 77 minors Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 34 NPDES Permitting Program NPDES Permits by Office Total 129 20 (15%) R5-Fresno R5-Redding R5-Sacramento Agenda Item 5 68 (53%) 41 (32%) Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 35 NPDES Permitting Program Region 5 Permit Action Items 90 Enforcement Orders Amendments Rescissions Renewals/New Permit Action Items 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 2007 Agenda Item 5 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 2014 Slide 36 NPDES Permitting Program Region 5 Projected Permit Backlog 120 Projected Data *Based on assumed 25 permits adopted per year in Region 5. 100 Permits 80 Adopted Permits Expired Permits Backlogged Permits Historical Data 60 40 20 0 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 Calendar Year Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 37 NPDES Storm Water Program 11.1 PYs Construction Storm Municipal Separate Storm Sewer Systems Industrial Storm Water Water 2,215 enrollees 1,872 enrollees Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 38 NPDES Storm Water Program 129 MS4 permittees 21 Phase I 108 Phase II Redding: 12 Sacramento: 76 Fresno: 41 Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 39 NPDES Storm Water Program Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 40 Water Quality Certification Program 7.8 PYs 250 or more water quality certifications processed per year 46 Redding 185 Sacramento 34 Fresno Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 41 Water Quality Certification Program Certifications Issued 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 2006 Agenda Item 5 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 2014 Slide 42 Irrigated Lands Regulatory Program (ILRP) ILRP addresses discharge to surface water & groundwater 7 million acres 18 PY total 1 Redding, 6 Fresno, 11 Rancho about 2,000 dischargers per staff Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 43 Irrigated Lands Regulatory Program Surface Water Results 7% 93% = 217K Below Trigger Limit E.coli 32% Physical Parameters 22% Toxicity Metals Agenda Item 5 9% 6% Nutrients 2% Pesticides 2% Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 44 Irrigated Lands Regulatory Program Key Trends Participant Trend Line 2006-2014 Acres (millions) 40 5.6 36 55,000 letters sent 5.2 32 Acres 4.8 4.4 28 24 Participants 4.0 20 FY 14-15 FY 13-14 FY 12-13 FY 11-12 FY 10-11 FY 09-10 FY 08-09 FY 07-08 FY 06-07 Agenda Item 5 Participants (thousands) 6.0 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 45 Irrigated Lands Regulatory Program Coming year State Board consideration of Eastern San Joaquin Petitions Compliance/enforcement focused on non-participants Foundational technical reports – e.g., Groundwater Quality Assessment Report Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 46 Forest Activities Program Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 47 Annual Timber Harvesting Projects in Central Valley Region 40 200 Non-federal projects (discretionary) Non-federal projects (non-discretionary) U.S. Forest Service projects (discretionary) 800 Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 48 Forest Activities Program Forest Activities Program Internal Workload Distribution Info onFresno AB 1492 4% Rancho 23% Redding 73% Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 49 Forest Activities Program Inspections Conducted Forest Activities Program 250 200 150 Inspections 100 50 0 2004/05 Agenda Item 5 2011/12 2012/13 2013/14 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 50 Forest Activities Program Looking Ahead AB 1492 requirements Cumulative impacts Wildfire and salvage harvesting Timber Waiver renewal and new permit U.S. Forest Service non-point source permit MOU with U.S. Forest Service for BAER participation Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 51 Planning Staff Distribution between Planning Programs Delta 12% Planning 11% NPS 14% CV Salts 20% TMDLs/ Basin Planning 54% Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 52 Basin Planning and TMDL Programs 19.2 PYs State fee based (17 PYs) Federal grant (2.2 PYs) Activities Integrated Report (303(d) list) Develop and implement TMDLs Develop Basin Plan Amendments Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 53 Basin Planning and TMDLs Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 54 Key Basin Plan Amendments Drinking Water Policy • Narrative objectives for Giardia and Cryptosporidium • Focused assessment • Implementation triggers • One time study Variance & Exception Policy • New Tool • Structured Flexibility • Salinity Component Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 55 TMDL Progress Pre-2014 Listings Addressed Includes Delta 2014 60 47 47 Pending 2015 62 62 Diazinon and Chlorpyrifos 62 Pyrethroids Statewide Hg Reservoirs Only 500+ to go Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 56 TMDL Accomplishments Coordination with EPA Office of Pesticides, Department of Pesticide Regulations (DPR) Urban Pesticide Pollution Prevention Partnership DPR Initiating effort to address Fipronil Improving reviews of new pesticides Cyantraniliprole (“cyan-tran-ili-prole”) Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 57 Nonpoint Source Program Federal 319(h) or “Nonpoint Source” Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Watershed and Integrated Regional Water Management (IRWM) Groups Grazing Regulatory Action Project Funding 06/07 – 5.1 PY 09/10 – 3.95 PY 14/15 – 3.6 PY Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 58 Nonpoint Source Program Clear Lake Nutrient TMDL Forest Service road storm proofing grant BLM sediment reduction project Cyanobacteria Task Force Westside IRWM Group Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 59 Surface Water Ambient Monitoring Program Sampling Events and Analyses Conducted by Fiscal Year 4624 Analyses Site Visits 3759 3341 3045 2615 2489 903 853 1022 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 1371 959 811 2008-09 2009-10 Agenda Item 5 2010-11 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 60 Surface Water Ambient Monitoring Program 2014 Highlights: Sediment Studies Battle Creek Conservancy Final Pathogen Monitoring Report Collaborative Monitoring with DWR Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 61 Surface Water Ambient Monitoring Program Planned for 2015: Microbial Source Tracking Chronic Toxicity Monitoring Mercury in Reservoirs Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 62 Special Planning Initiatives Statewide Reservoir Mercury TMDL CV-SALTS Delta Activities DWR California Water Plan Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 63 Statewide Reservoir Mercury TMDL Source control Water chemistry (decrease methylation) Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 64 Data Compilation and Modeling Conceptual Model GIS Beneficial Use/ AGR Zone Efforts Beneficial Use Tulare Lake Groundwater MUN in Ag Dominated Water bodies Water Quality Objectives Aquatic Life Stock Watering Salt Effects on Irrigated Ag Salt Effects on MUN Lower San Joaquin River Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 65 Implementation SSALTS (Accumulation and Transport) Deep Well Injection Salt Management Zones (Reuse/Containment) Desalinization Real-Time Salinity Management (LSJR River) Regulated Brine Line/Ocean Disposal Alternate Compliance Strategies (Legacy Nitrate) 1) 2) 3) Agenda Item 5 Safe Drinking Water Reduced Loading Restore Groundwater Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 66 Delta Activities 2014 Delta Strategic Work Plan Delta Methyl Mercury Control Program Regional Monitoring Program Stockton DWSC Low Dissolved Oxygen Control Program Nutrient Research Plan Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 67 Delta Methyl Mercury Delta RMP • Stakeholder lead • Initial draft funding allocations approved • Designs for • • • • Pathogen (April 2015) Pesticides/toxicity Nutrients Mercury Proposed Pathogen Monitoring Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 69 San Joaquin River Dissolved Oxygen Control Program Studies Completed Draft Staff Report – Public Review Draft Resolution - February 2015 Improved DO Conditions Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 70 Nutrient Research Plan • Stakeholder & Technical Advisory Group established • Science Work Groups being formed. • White papers and a Nutrient Research Plan available next year Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 71 California Water Plan Update 2013 released 10/30/2014 All three offices provided content: —Five of the twelve regional reports —Resource Management Strategies Drafted and updated the Salt and Salinity Management RMS —Participated in crosscutting teams Statewide Water Analysis Network Groundwater Caucus Water Quality Caucus Agenda Item #5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 72 New/Emerging Programs and Activities Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 73 Water Board/US Forest Service Memorandum of Understanding BAER Team MOU Components: Hazard & overtime pay Specialized training Personal Protective Equipment Annual physical exams Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 74 Marijuana Waste Discharge Program Pilot Program Permitting Enforcement Education & Outreach Coordination w/ Other Agencies Coordinate with F&W 4 PYS Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 75 Marijuana Program Accomplishments Statewide Program Strategy Cannabis Identification and Prioritization System Extensive Coordination Health and Safety Plan 4 new staff hired 7 coordinated inspections under warrants Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 76 Marijuana Program Next Year Staff Training Develop Regulatory Mechanism Extend Public Outreach and Education Identify funds/mechanisms to cleanup cultivation sites with no responsible parties Establish permanent funding for program Update Board and public on program Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 77 Grazing Regulatory Action Project (GRAP) Statewide regulatory strategy to address water quality impacts related to livestock grazing Focused Listening Sessions (stakeholder outreach) Draft Proposal in 2015 Rail Concerns November 25, 2014 Derailment near Big Bar, Feather River Canyon Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 79 Bakken Crude Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 80 Organizational Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 81 Organizational New AEOs in Sacramento New Supervisors in Sacramento Portfolio Management Electronic Content Management Increased Outreach and Access Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 82 Portfolio Management Transparency, Accountability, Efficiency At all Levels 2007 Program Managers Roles & Responsibilities 2008 to 2010 Significant investments in project management training 2011 Project Management Implementation Strategy 2012 Leadership Education Series 2013 Portfolio Management Concept Development 2014 Portfolio Management Rollout & Implementation Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 83 Programs Program Basin Planning CV-SALTS Dairies Enforcement Forest Activities/Timber Irrigated Lands Marijuana Mines Non-Point Source NPDES Oil Fields Site Cleanup Storm Water SWAMP Title 27/Land Disposal TMDL Underground Storage Tanks Water Quality Certifications WDRs Agenda Item 5 Program Manager Executive Sponsor Office Jeanne Chilcott Jeanne Chilcott Doug Patteson Robert LHeureux Angela Wilson Joe Karkoski Clint Snyder Phil Woodward Sue McConnell Nichole Morgan Clay Rodgers Duncan Austin Bryan Smith Susan Fregien Robert Busby Jeanne Chilcott Brian Newman Bryan Smith Lonnie Wass Adam Laputz Adam Laputz Clay Rodgers Andrew Altevogt Clint Snyder Adam Laputz Clint Snyder Clint Snyder Adam Laputz Adam Laputz Clay Rodgers Andrew Altevogt Clint Snyder Adam Laputz Andrew Altevogt Adam Laputz Andrew Altevogt Clint Snyder Clay Rodgers Rancho Cordova Rancho Cordova Fresno Rancho Cordova Redding Rancho Cordova Redding Redding Rancho Cordova Rancho Cordova Fresno Rancho Cordova Redding Rancho Cordova Rancho Cordova Rancho Cordova Rancho Cordova Redding Fresno Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 84 Portfolio Management Next Steps – FY 2015/2016 Align Program Manager and Managing Senior Roles and Responsibilities Improve Programmatic Work Plan Effectiveness Align Programmatic Work Plans w/ Budget and PY Distribution Further Education to foster more efficient and effective work flow Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 85 Electronic Content Management (ECM) Document management tool Implemented Phase I in October Ability to receive, forward, file, and track mail electronically Notable increase in emails Approx. 400-500 emails per month Approx. 2,500 pieces of mail per month Dischargers notified of the ECM process Encouraged to submit documents electronically Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 86 Electronic Content Management (ECM) Anticipate widespread use of ECM from the public next year Goal: decrease pieces of mail by 50% within 6 months Late July 2015 Planned Implementation of Phase 2 Create, route and track documents Allows version control Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 87 Environmental Justice Increased Outreach to DACs Central California Environmental Justice Network, “Roots of Resilience Conference”, 2014 Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 88 Environmental Justice Staff Activity Kern Environmental Enforcement Network Fresno Environmental Reporting Network Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 89 Environmental Justice Efforts – Supplemental Environmental Projects (SEPs) Collaboration with Rose Foundation Resolution Supporting DACs Two Settlements funding the Community Water Center (>$230,000) Other SEPs West Goshen Drinking Water Supply Project ($150,000) Agenda Item 5 West Goshen Water Supply Project Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 90 Special Projects Demonstration Pilot Project for Biological Denitrification of Rural Community Groundwater, Paradise Colony Biological Treatment Pilot Unit Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 91 Coming Year Succession Planning Lean Sigma Six – WDR Program Review of NPDES Program Reinitiate Strategic Plan Development Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 92 Summary Exceptional, highly qualified technical staff Superb support staff Outstanding leadership team Significant achievements Addressing very complex issues/problems Available resources Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 93 Questions? Agenda Item 5 Central Valley Water Board Meeting of 4/5 December 2014 Slide 94