Comments
Transcript
Lung growth of pre-adolescent children M. B
Eur Respir J 1990, 3, 91-96 Lung growth of pre-adolescent children M. Smeets, B. Brunekreef, L. Dijkstra, D. Houthuijs Lung growth ofpre-adolescenJ children. M. Smeets, B. Brunekreef, L. Dijkstra, D. Houthuijs. ABSTRACT: Lung growth was studied 1n 420 Dutch children aged 6-11 yrs. J?orced vital capacity (FVC), forced expiratory volume In one second (FEV 1), peak expiratory now (PEF) and maximal mJd-expiratory now (MMEF) were measured four times over a 2.5 yr period with a rolling-seal spirometer. In boys, pulmonary function Increased with approximately the same velocity at all ages studied. ln girls, however, Ute growth velocities of FVC and _F~~ Increased markedly at age 10 yrs, and growth velocities of PEF and iVIMt.:F had increased already at age 9 yrs. The minimum pulmonary f11oction growth velocity could not be determined from the available data in boys. In girls, the minimum pulmonary function growth velocities preceded the minimum height growth velocity at the onset of the pubertal growth spurt. All lung function growth rates were significantly associated with the growth rate of height3 • In girls, the growth rate of FVC was also associated wlth the weight growth rate. There was also some association between the growth rates of PEF and MMEF and age. In boys, there was a negative association between age and tbe growth rates of FVC and FEV1 , after adjustment for the growth rate of beight3• Dept of Environmental Health, University of Wageningen, The Netherlands. Correspondence: Dr B. Brunekreef, Dept of Environmental Health, University ofWageningen, P.O. Box 238. 6700 AE Wageningen, The Netherlands. Keywords: Children; growth; lung function. Received: March 24, 1989; accepted for publication July 28, 1989. This study was supported by a grant from rhe Netherlands Asthma Foundarion. Eur Respir J., 1990, 3, 91-96. Several studies have been published on pulmonary function in childhood, often with a primary interest in establishing reference values. Hence, most of these studies had a cross-sectional character relating the level of respiratory function to variables such as age, height and weight [1-5]. Information about the growth of respiratory function collected by means of longitudinal studies is, however, limited. There have been some studies on growth of pulmonary function in adolescence [6, 7). These have indicated that in the pubertal growth spurt the peak in the growth rate of forced vital capacity (FVC) and forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1) occurs about 0.5-1 yr later than that in the height growth rate. Few data have been published on lung function growth (as opposed to level) of pre-adolescent children. A preliminary report from the Harvard Six Cities Study [8) suggested that there is no time lag in the pre-adolescent minimum growth rate of FEV1 relative to the minimum height growth rate. We have studied the development of pulmonary function in 6-11 yr old children in relation to several environmental factors. Repeated observations were made over a period of 2.5 yrs. thus creating the possibility to assess changes in lung function and height growth in this age group. The present report attempts to provide a description of the growth of pulmonary function in relation to age and the growth rates of height and weight in 6-11 yr old children, with special emphasis on differences between boys and girls. Materials and methods The study sample consisted of 420 children of 6-11 yrs in age. There were 206 boys and 214 girls. The children were from a study on the relationship between indoor air pollution and respiratory health, in which repeated observations were made over a 2.5 yr period. In 1984, the parents of 997 children were invited to let their children participate. The children were 6-9 yrs old, and the parents were contacted through ten schools located in four small, non-industrial communities in the south-east of The Netherlands. Of the 997 contacted. 832 (84%) were granted permission. In 1986, the parents of 702 of these children were again contacted for a followup study. Of the original 832, 88 had left the area, and 42 could not be included because their school refused to participate. Of the 702, 614 were allowed to participate in the follow-up study (88%). Pulmonary fu nction of all of the children was measured in the schools by trained technicians, using Vicatest-5 rolling-seal spirometers coupled with a microcomputer. Forced expiratory manoeuvres were performed whilst sitting, without a nose-clip. Each child was required to perform at least five acceptable forced expirations from a maximum of eight attempts. PVC, FEV1 , 92 M. SMEETS ET AL. peak expiratory flow (PEF), maximal expiratory flow when x% remains to be exhaled (MEF.J and maximal mid-expiratory flow (MMEF) were recorded at each effort. In this report, results for FYC, FEY1 , PEF and MMEF only will be discussed. Selection of the lung function values out of the five measurements occurred according to the recommendations made for adults [9) and adolescents [10]. Lung function values were corrected to body temperature, pressure and saturation (BTPS). Details of the protocol are given elsewhere [11]. Tests were performed in the fall of 1984, in the spring of 1985, in the fall of 1986 and again in the spring of 1987. Acceptable data were obtained for 85-89% of all of the children on each of the four occasions. Of the 6 14 children included in the follow-up study, 420 (68%) had acceptable data on all four occasions. If the capacity to perform an acceptable test were uncorrelated between occasions, only 52% (0.854 ) to 63% (0.89 4) of the children would have been expected to have acceptable data on each occasion. A respiratory symptoms questionnaire [12] was completed by the parents of the children, and the reported prevalence of respiratory symptoms was no different in the 420 children with full pulmonary function data compared to the prevalence in the total group of 614 children. The prevalence of chronic cough was 3.3% in the group of 420 children, and 2.5% in the group of 614 children. The prevalence of chronic wheeze was 4.6 and 4.7%, respectively. The prevalence of attacks of shortness of breath with wheeze was 3.1 and 3.0%, respectively. The analysis was restricted to the 420 children with full data, as for them pulmonary function growth could be calculated most reliably. At the time of the lung function test, standing height and weight were measured in stockinged feet. Age at each examination was computed exactly (in yrs) by dividing the difference between birth date and day of measurement (days) by 365.25. Growth rates of pulmonary function, height3 and weight over the 2.5 yr period were estimated by linear regression analysis for each child. The mean age during the study period was calculated for each child from the ages at examination. There were 72 children with mean age 7-8 yrs (age category 7); 131 children with mean age 8- 9 yrs (age category 8); 151 children with mean age 9- 10 yrs (age category 9); 63 children with mean age 10-11 yrs (age category 10); and 3 children with mean age over 11 yrs. Mean growth rates ofFVC, FEY~' PEF, MMEF, height and weight have been tabulated according to age category and gender. A multiple linear regression analysis was performed to investigate the relationship between growth rates of pulmonary function, and mean age and growth rates of height3 and weight. The analyses were performed separately for boys and girls, as a preliminary analysis had indicated that growth patterns in this age group were widely different between boys and girls. Growth rates of pulmonary function were plotted against the height3 growth rate. There was no apparent nonlinearity (figs 1 and 2). To allow for non-linear relationships with age, three dummy variables were created for age, indicating the difference between age Growth rate of FVC ml·vr1 I 450 • 400 A A I i l t A A 350 • I A A A . 8 ' ' AA I' 200 150 ! 100 ! B A AA AA A AA A8 A A A A 8 A A A AAA A ABA A A BABA AB.A A AA .AABB A A 8 ABBC A A AAA AA AAB A AACA A AA AAA ABCCASA A A A 8 BABCACB AA BAABBA CAC ACAS BA AABCA AA A AB AAA AA A AB AA A AAB A A A AA AC !' ..'' ! A A AA A 300 : 250 A A A I ' ' i .. '' I . A '' ' ! so • l - --+- ..... --................ --- .. -- ....... ----- .. - ... -- ·--- .... --........... - ................ 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 +---..--......... ·-.. 0.6 0.7 Growth rate of helghtl m3·yr' Fig. I. - Scauerplot of growth rates of FVC and height' in 214 Dutch gids. FVC: forced vital capacity; A: 1 obs; B: 2 obs, etc. Growth rate of FVC ml·yr' I A 450 • I A 400 • A ! A i A A A A A 350 : lOO AA l A AA AA A A 8 ! A l 250 ; A A I! AA 150 • i A A A A A A A 8 !' A A AAAAA A A A BAAA AB A AA A CAAA AAAA ABA 8 A A A A AAAACA AA A A A BA A888 AAA A A 8 ABBBAA I A A 8 BAA ABAA A A 8 CAB A 8 A A A ABCACAA A A AB A A A 88 A A A A AA AA A 8 AAA A A AAAA AAA A 200 • A A A A A A 100 : I A so . .I . . -+----....................... +------- '"-·- - ......... ·---- 0.1 5 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 t - ..... .... ·+- ...................... 0.40 0.45 0.50 ----+-0.55 3 Growth rate of height" m ·yr' Fig. 2. - Scatterplot of growth rates of PVC and height' in 206 Dutch boys. For abbreviations see legend to figure l. LUNG GROWTH OF PRE-ADOLESCENT CHILDREN categories 8, 9 and 10 and reference age category 7. The three children with mean age over 11 yrs were excluded from this analysis. Residuals from the calculations were plotted against predicted values 1.0 check for remaining trends in the data. Statistical analyses were performed using the SAS system on a VAX mainframe computer. Results The distributions of the lung function growth rates were generally symmetrical, and medians were closely similar to means in all cases. As examples, the distributions of the growth rates of FVC are shown in figs 3 and 4 for girls and boys separately. Table 1 shows the mean growth rates of pulmonary function, height and weight for girls by age category. Growth rates of FVC, FEV1 and weight were the same at mean ages 7 and 8 yrs, and increased at ages 9 and 10 yrs. The height growth rate was greatest at ages 7 and 10 yrs, and lower in between. Growth rates of PEF and MMEF steadily increased over the whole age range. Growth rates at mean age 11 yrs are shown for completeness only, as there were just two girls in this category. 93 Table 2 shows the mean growth rates of pulmonary function, height and weight for boys by age category. Distributions were again generally symmetrical within age categories. Growth rates of FVC and FEV1 were approximately the same at all ages. The growth rate of the PEF was variable. Growth rates of height and MMEF decreased with increasing age, whereas the growth rate of weight increased with age. Growth rates at mean age 11 yrs are shown for completeness only, as there was just one boy in this category. · Table 3 contains the results of the regression analysis for girls. All pulmonary function growth rates were related to the height3 growth rate. In addition, the growth rate of FVC was associated with the weight growth rate. There was also some association between the growth rates of PEF and MMEF and age. Table 4 shows the results of the regression analyses for boys. Again, the growth rate of height3 was significantly associated with the growth rates of all lung function variables. After adjustment for the height3 growth rate, there remained some negative association between age and the growth rates of FVC and FEV1 . Stem leaf # Stem leaf 44 42 40 38 36 34 32 30 28 26 24 22 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 44 42 40 38 36 34 32 30 28 26 24 22 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 4 3 21 098 2 3 1 9 44672 0014922234469 035660144889 0247045556 0222233678999000234567799 00123455677778990224455557 111223334788999901122222333357777899 1223456666777790133445677777799 136899990134466779 02227904889999 3471233889 4078 45 5 13 12 10 25 26 36 31 18 14 10 4 2 ----+----+----+----+----+----+----+Fig. 3. -Stem-and-Leaf display of the distribution of growth rates of FVC in a population of 214 Dutch girls aged 7- 11 yrs. Growth rate of FVC in ml·yr 1• There were (e.g.) four girls with growth rates between 100 and 120 ml·yr 1; their respective values were 104, 110, 117 and 118 m1·yr·• (10 4078). FVC: Forced vital capacity. 11 8 1 1 1 3 5 6 143 61 2556 713578 047801233566699 000001267723456 01 136677833344677 0001223345600111222333344456778888 001233556788890001234556889 11233466678899122334679 1456689000222355666788899 02445501133337788 055825589 038 2 4 6 15 15 17 34 27 23 25 17 9 3 288 3 ----+----+----+----+----+----+---Fig. 4. - Stem-and-Leaf display of the distribution of growth rates of PVC in a population of 206 Dutch boys aged 7-11 yrs. Growth rate of FVC in ml·yr·•. There were (e .g.) three boys with growth rates between 380 ana 400 ml·yr'; their respective values were 381, 384, and 393 ml·yr 1 (38 143). FVC: forced vital capacity. Table 1. - Mean growth rates of pulmonary function, height and weight in 214 Dutch girls aged 7-11 yrs Growth rate of: Age category 7 1 FVC ml·yr FEV1 ml·yr· 1 PEF ml·s· 1·yr MMEF ml·s·1·yr height cm·yr·1 weight kg·yr· 1 n 210 161 419 125 6.10 3.19 36 8 (44) (39) (179) (112) (0.56) (1.03) 209 167 459 147 5.70 3.05 67 10 9 (48) (41) (203) (97) (0.69) (0.88) 227 185 524 164 5.78 3.48 76 (72) (61) (218) (106) (1.00) (1.18) 252 214 581 230 6.12 3.97 33 11 (62) (58) (216) (238) (1.14) (1.26) 291 286 683 381 7.46 5.09 2 Values are mean and standard deviation in parentheses. FVC: forced vital capacity; FEV1 : forced expiratory volume in one second; PEF: peak expiratory flow; MMEF: maximal mid-expiratory flow. · · · M. SMEETS ET AL. 94 Table 2. - Mean growth rates of pulmonary function, height and weight in 206 Dutch boys aged 7-11 yrs Growth rate of Age category 7 FVC ml·yr· 1 FEV1 ml·yr- 1 PEP ml·s· 1·yr MMEP ml·s·'·yr height cm·yr-1 weight kg-yr- 1 246 190 390 149 5.93 2.64 n 8 (43) (43) (201) (103) (0.55) (0.60) (63) (51) (175) (108) (0.56) (1.01) 249 187 492 134 5.60 2.93 36 10 9 229 175 432 124 5.36 2.98 64 (59) (43) (212) (97) (0.61) (0.83) 238 179 468 119 5.32 3.48 11 (81) (73) (204) (108) (0.81) (1.56) 30 75 214 218 265 259 4.43 2.73 1 Values are mean and standard deviation in parentheses. For abbreviations see legend to table 1. Table 3.- Association between lung function growth rates and mean age and growth rates of height and weight in 212 Dutch girls aged 7-10 yrs Lung function variable FVC PEV1 PEP MMEP Regression coefficients (SE) of: Intercept Age 8 yrs 11 -4 172 -19 (14) (13) (72)* (38) 4 9 45 25 (8) (8) (42)* (22) Age 9 yrs -2 8 81 25 (8) (8) (41)* (22) Age 10 yrs -4 15 106 72 (10) (9) (50)* (26)** Growth rates of weight height3 7 1 7 2 (3)* (3) (16) (8) 569 521 718 440 (50)*** (46)*** (251)** (132)** R2 0.573 0.545 0.128 0.157 Coefficients in ml·yr·1, or ml·s· 1-yr- 1 (ages 8, 9 and 10, compared to age 7); ml·yr- 1 per m'·yr·1 or ml·s· 1·yr·1 per m'·yr- 1 (height'); ml·yr· 1 per kg·yr 1 or ml·s· 1·yr·1 per kg·yr- 1 (weight);*: p<0.05; **: p<0.01; ***: p<O.OOl. For abbreviations see legend to table 1. Table 4. -Association between lung function rates and mean age and growth rates of height and weight in 205 Dutch boys aged 7-10 yrs Lung function variable PVC FEV1 PEP MMEF Regression coefficients (sE) of: Intercept 53 43 123 30 (22)* (19)* (82) (44) Age 8 yrs Age 9 yrs Age 10 yrs Growth rates of weight height' -2 -7 92 -17 -28 -23 25 -31 -30 -27 40 -41 6 (4) 2 (4) 22 (16) -1 (8) (11) (9)* (40)* (21) (10)** (9)* (39) (21) (13)* (11)* (49) (26) 598 475 699 408 (77)*** (66)*** (290)* (153)** R2 0.335 0.278 0.099 0.052 Coefficients in ml·yr1 or ml·s· 1·yr· 1, (ages 8, 9 and 10, compared to age 7); ml·yr 1 per m 3 ·yr· 1 or ml·s· 1-yr 1 per m'·yr·1 (height3 ); ml-yr- 1 per kg·yr- 1 or ml·s·1-yr per kg-yr 1 (weight);*: p<0.05; **: p<O.Ol; ***: p<O.OOl. For abbreviations see legend to table 1. The residuals of the models were plotted against the predicted values to check for remaining patterns in the data. There was no indication in these plots for remaining patterns that would call for additional analyses. Discussion The growth rate of height decreased in boys over the entire age range studied. In girls, there was a decrease 95 LUNG GROWTH OF PRE-ADOLESCENT CHILDREN from mean age 7 yrs to mean age 8 yrs. followed by an increase at mean age 10 yrs, indicating that some of the girls had started their pubertal growth spurt. This was also apparent from the standard deviation of the height growth rate, which was twice as high in those 10 yrs old than in those 7 yrs old. The growth rate of weight increased with age in the boys over the entire age range studied, whereas in the girls, the weight growth rates were comparable in those 7 and 8 yrs old. There was a clear increase from ages 8 to 9 yrs, and again from ages 9 to 10 yrs. VENROOD-USSELMUIDEN [13) measured height and weight growth rates in Dutch children over a one year period in 1970-1972. Height growth rates in boys were 5.4, 5.0, 4.6 and 4.8 cm·yr1 for boys in the age intervals 8-9, 9-10, 10-11 and 11-12 yrs, respectively. For girls, they were 5.3, 5.3, 5.5 and 6.3 cm·yr1, respectively. In our study, the time interval over which the growth rates were calculated was about 2.5 yrs. The mean age 7, 8, 9 and 10 categories therefore included children who were up to about 9, 10, 11 and 12 yrs of age at the end of the study. Although this makes a direct comparison with the earlier data impossible, it seems that the growth rates found in 1970-1972 were slightly lower than the growth rates found in this study. The mean weight growth rates found by VENROOU-USSELMUIDEN (13) were 3.1, 2.9, 2.9 and 3.5 kg·yr 1 for boys in the age intervals 8-9, 9-10, 10-11 and 11-12 yrs. respectively. For girls, they were 3.1 , 3.2, 3.7 and 5.0 kg·yr1, respectively. These growth rates for weight were, therefore, very comparable to those estimated in this study. In boys, the growth rates of FVC and FEV1 were somewhat higher in those 7 and 8 yrs old than in those with mean ages 9 and 10 yrs. In girls, the pattern was reversed. Also, the growth rates of FVC and FEV1 at age lO yrs were clearly higher than at mean age 9 yrs. In the boys, there was no clear variation of the growth rate of PEF with age. The growth rate of MMEF declined slightly with age. In the girls, on the contrary, there was a steady increase of the growth rates of both PEF and MMEF with mean age over the entire age range studied. For girls, there was no indication in the data that the minimum growth rates for FVC, FEV,, PEF and MMEF lagged behind the minimum growth rates for height and weight. Apparently, the time lag noted for FVC and FEV1 growth rates at the end of the growth spurt [6, 7] is not present at the beginning. For boys, who enter their growth spurt at a higher age than girls, the data at hand do not permit a proper analysis of the timing of the minimum growth rates of the different study variables. After taking the growth rate of height3 into account, there was not much residual effect of age and weight on the lung function growth rates. In girls, there remained some positive effect of age on the growth rates of PEF and MMEF, whereas in boys there was a negative association between age and the gro wth rates of FVC and FEV1, after adjustment for the growth rate of height3• Apparently, the growth rates of FVC and FEV 1 are overestimated by the growth rate of heig htl at ages 9 and 10 yrs in boys, but not in girls. A possible explanation for these patterns is offered by TANNER [14], who noted that there is a steady increase in the growth rates of both chest depth and chest width in girls, but not in boys, from age 7 yrs. These increases are not accompanied by increases in the growth rates of standing height or sitting height over the age range studied here. The growth patterns of lung function in children in the age categories studied by us can be more adequately predicted from the growth rate of height3 in girls than in boys. Acktlowledgemerrls: The authors would like to thanlc Prof. Ph.H. Quanjcr (Physiology Dept, University of Leiden, Leiden) for his helpful comments on an earlier version of the manuscript. References 1. Michaelson ED, Watson H, Silva G, Zapata A, SerafmiMichaelson SM, Sackner MA. - Pulmonazy function in normal children. Bull Eur Physioparhol Respir, 1978, 14, 525-550. 2. Schoenberg JB, Beck GJ, Bouhuys A. -Growth and decay of pulmonazy function in healthy blacks and whites. Respir Physiol, 1978, 33, 367- 393. 3. Dockery DW, Berkey CS, Ware JH, Speizer FE, Ferris BG Jr. -Distribution of forced vital capacity and forced expiratory volume in one second in children 6 to 11 years of age. Am Rev Respir Dis, 1983, 128, 405-412. 4. Burrows B, Cline MG, Knudson RJ, Taussig LM, Lebowitz MD. -A descriptive analysis of the growth and decline of the PVC and FEV1• Chest, 1983, 83, 717- 724. 5. Knudson RI, Lebowitz MD, Holberg CJ, Burrows B.Changes in the normal expiratory flow-volume curve with growth and ageing. Am Rev Respir Dis, 1983, 127, 725-734. 6. Lawther PJ, Brooks AGF, Waller RE.- Respiratory function measurements in a cohort of medical students: a ten year follow-up. Thorax, 1978, 33, 773- 788. 7. Schrader PC, Quanjer PhH, Borsboom G, Wise ME. Evaluating lung function and anthropometric growth data in a longitudinal study on adolescents. Hum Bioi, 1984,56, 365-381. 8. Dockery DW, Speizer FE, Ware JH, Ferris BG Jr. Growth of pulmonazy function between 6 and 18 years of age. Am Rev Respir Dis, 1987, 135 (Suppl.). 9. Quanjer PhH (ed). - Standardized lung function testing. Bull Eur Physiopalhol Respir, 1983, 19 (Suppl.), 1-95. 10. Schrader PC, Quanjer PhH, Borsboom G, Wise ME. Selection of variables from maximum expiratory flow volume curves. Bull Eur Physiopathol Respir, 1983, 19, 43-49. 11 . Houthuijs D, Remijn B, Brunekreef B, Koning R de. Estimation of maximum expiratory flow volume variables in children. Pediarr Pulmonol, 1989, 6, 127- 132. 12. Florey C du V, Leeder SR. - Methods for cohort studies of chronic airflow limitation. WHO Regional Publications, European Series no. 12, 1982. 13. Venrooij-Ijsselmuiden ME van. - Groeigegevens over 1970-1972 van een groep kinderen uit Utrecht en omgeving: lengte en gewicht. (Growth data over 1970-1972 for a group of children studied in Utrecht: height and weight). Ned T Geneesk, 1977, 121, 261- 271. 14. Tanner JM. -In: Growth at adolescence. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford and Edinburgh. 2nd edition, 1962. Croissance pulmoMire d' enfanls pre-adolescenls. M. Smeets, B. Brunekreef, L. Dijkstra, D. Houthuijs. RESUME: La croissance pulmonaire a ete etudiee chez 420 enfants hollandais, ages de 6 a 11 ans. La capacite vitale forcee, 96 M. SMEETS ET AL. le VEMS, le debit expiratoire de pointe et le debit expiratoire maximum moyen on:t ete mesures a 4 reprises au cmrrs d'une periodc de 2 ans et derni, au moyen d'un spirometre "rolling seal". Chez les garyons !'augmentation fonctionnelle pulmonaire a approximativement la meme vitesse a tous les ages etudies. Chez les filles toutefois, la vitesse de croissance de la capacite vitale forcee et du VEMS augmentent de fayon marquee a l'age de 10 ans alors que la vitesse de croissance du debit expiratoire de pointe et du debit expiratoire moyen augmentent deja a l'age de 9 ans. La vitesse minimum de la croissance de la fonction pulmonaire n. a pu elre determinee apartir des donnees disponibles chez les garyons. Chez les filles, les vitesses de croissance fonctionnelles pulmonaires minimales prece.dent la vitesse de croissance minimale de la taille, au debut de la poussee de croissance pubertaire. Tous les indices de croissance de la fonction pulmonaire sont en relation significative avec le taux de croissance de la taille. Chez lcs filles, le taux de croissance de la capacite vitale forcee est egalement associe au taux de croissance du poids. n y avait egalement quelques associations entre les taux de croissance du debit expi.ratoire maximum ou du debit expiratoi.re maximum moyen et l'age. Chcz les gar~ons, on a note une association negative ~nlre l'age et les taux de croissance de la capacite vitale forcee et du VEMS, apres ajustement pour le taux de croissance de la taille. Eur Respir J., 1990, 3 , 91-96.