United Nations, Jan 12, 2010

Zero Waste:
Theory & Practice Around the World
Paul Connett, PhD
Executive Director
American Environmental Health
Studies Project (AEHSP)
www.AmericanHealthStudies.org
[email protected]
United Nations, Jan 12, 2010
OUTLINE






A. A quick word about sustainability
B. Zero Waste the Springboard to
Sustainability
C. The critical step forward
D. From ZW to sustainability
E. ZW around the world
E. Back to the Big Picture
A. A quick word about
sustainability
 We
are living on this
planet as if we had
another one to go to
Sustainability




We would need FOUR planets if every
one consumed as much as the
average American
We would need TWO planets if every
one consumed as much as the
average European
Meanwhile, India, China etc. are
copying our consumption patterns
Something has got to change and the
best place to start is with waste
“The world has enough
for everyone’s need
but not for everyone’s
greed”
Mahatma Gandhi
Our real task is to fight
over-consumption
Please note that
while waste incineration is
aggressively promoted by
many companies and
countries, it is NOT
sustainable
Kg Greenhouse gas/tonne Municipal
Waste
A combination of recycling and
composting is 46 times better
-461
at reducing greenhouse gases
than
X 46
Incineration generating
electricty
-10
Waste Management Options and Climate Change. AEA 2001
B. Zero Waste is the
Springboard
to SUSTAINABILITY
ZERO WASTE
IS A
NEW
DIRECTION
THE
NO BACK
to INCINERATORS
END
OF
WASTE
MANAGEMENT
NO to LANDFILLS
THE
NO BACK
to INCINERATORS
END
OF
WASTE
MANAGEMENT
NO to LANDFILLS
THE
FRONT END
OF
INDUSTRIAL
DESIGN
THE KEY
is to find a way to use
COMMUNITY RESPONSIBILITY
At the back end to drive
INDUSTRIAL RESPONSIBILITY
At the front end
FOUR STEPS FROM ZERO WASTE
TO SUSTAINABILITY
1)
2)
3)
4)
THE FIRST STEP.
THE OTHER PRACTICAL STEPS.
THE KEY STEP TO GET TO ZW.
USING ZW TO GET TO SUSTAINABILITY.
1. Zero Waste starts with
something everyone has


The ten things on the end of our
hands!
These are the “magic machines” which
can make sure that we do not convert
discarded resources into waste
waste
Resources
Source
Separation
2. Zero Waste continues with a
series of simple steps
 which
are
 Practical
 Cost effective and
 Politically acceptable
Source
Separation
Door to Door
Collection
Source
Separation
Door to Door
Collection
Composting
Source
Separation
Recycling
Door to Door
Collection
Composting
Source
Separation
Door to Door
Collection
Recycling
Waste
Reduction
Initiatives
Composting
Source
Separation
Door to Door
Collection
Composting
Recycling
Waste
Reduction
Initiatives
Reuse,
Repair &
Deconstruction
Source
Separation
Door to Door
Collection
Composting
Recycling
Waste
Reduction
Initiatives
Reuse,
Repair &
Deconstruction
Economic
Incentives
3. The critical step forward to
achieve Zero waste
 This
is where
 Community Responsibility
 Must be used to drive
 Industrial Responsibility
Residual
Separation &
Research
Facility
Source
Separation
Door to Door
Collection
Composting
Recycling
Waste
Reduction
Initiatives
Reuse,
Repair &
Deconstruction
Economic
Incentives
Residual
Separation &
Research
Center
Residual
Separation &
Research
Facility
RESIDUAL SEPARATION &
RESEARCH FACILITY





1. Built at entrance to landfill
2. No material can enter landfill without
it being separated and screened
3. Toxics removed and identified
4. Dirty organics biologically stabilized
5. Non-recyclable materials STUDIED
RESIDUAL SCREENING & RESEARCH FACILITY
MORE
RECYCLABLES
MORE TOXICS
DIRTY
ORGANIC
FRACTION
NON-TOXIC, NON-BIODEGRADABLE
FRACTION
RESEARCH
CENTER
INTERIM LANDFILL
BIOLOGICAL
STABILIZATION
RESIDUAL SEPARATION & RESEARCH FACILITY
NON-RECYCABLE MATERIALS
Local
University
Or
Technical College
RESEARCH
CENTER
RESEARCH CENTER



Improve capture rate of reusables,
recyclables and clean compostables
Recommend improved waste avoidance
strategies by local businesses
Develop some local uses for some materials
 Recommend
better industrial designs
to industry on packaging and
products
 Research for CLEAN Production
The Message to Industry:
•
•
•
•
If we can’t reuse it, recycle it or compost
it,
Industry shouldn’t be making it
We need better industrial design for the
21st Century
We cannot become sustainable without it
WITH THE ZERO WASTE
2020 STRATEGY
WE CONVERT 3 TONS OF TRASH
into:
1 ton of compostables
1 ton of recyclables
and
1 ton of EDUCATION for
SUSTAINABILITY!
Source
Separation
Door to Door
Collection
Composting
Recycling
Waste
Reduction
Initiatives
Reuse,
Repair &
Deconstruction
Economic
Incentives
Residual
Separation &
Research
Center
Source
Separation
Door to Door
Collection
Composting
Recycling
Waste
Reduction
Initiatives
Reuse,
Repair &
Deconstruction
Economic
Incentives
Residual
Separation &
Research
Center
Better
Industrial
Design
Source
Separation
Door to Door
Collection
Composting
Recycling
Waste
Reduction
Initiatives
Reuse,
Repair &
Deconstruction
Economic
Incentives
Residual
Separation &
Research
Center
Better
Industrial
Design
Temporary Landfill
Source
Separation
Door to Door
Collection
Composting
Recycling
Waste
Reduction
Initiatives
Reuse,
Repair &
Deconstruction
Economic
Incentives
Residual
Separation &
Research
Center
Better
Industrial
Design
Temporary Landfill
2020
San Francisco








Population = 850,000
Very little space
50% waste diverted by 2000
63% waste diverted by 2004
70% waste diverted by 2008
72% waste diverted by 2009
GOAL:75% waste diverted by 2010
GOAL:100% by 2020 (or very close!)
Separazione
alla
sorgente
Raccolta
Porta a Porta
Compostaggio
70 - 80%
Riutilizzo
Iniziative
Riparazione e
Riduzione
Riciclaggio
Centro per la
COMMUNITY
RESPONSIBILITY
rifiuti
Comunita’
Incentivi
Economici
Residual
Separation &
Research
Facility
INTERIM LANDFILL
Better
Industrial
Design
2020
Separazione
alla
sorgente
Raccolta
Porta a Porta
Compostaggio
70-80%
Riciclaggio
COMUNITY
Incentivi
Economici
INTERIM LANDFILL
Riutilizzo
Iniziative
Riparazione e
Riduzione
Centro per la
RESPONSIBILITY
rifiuti
Comunita’
20-30%
Separazione
migliore
del residuo e
design
Centro di
INDUSTRIAL
industriale
ricerca
RESPONSIBILITY
2020
Industrial Responsibility
1. Design for sustainability
 2. Clean production
 3. Extended Producer Responsibility

Extended Producer
Responsibilty - packaging
• The Ontario (Canada) Beer industry has
been using refillable glass bottles for 50 years
• 98% recovered
• Each bottle reused 18 times
• It saves the company money
• 2000 jobs in collection and cleaning
• No cost to municipality
Extended Producer
Responsibilty - products
XEROX CORPORATION EUROPE

Recovers copying machines from 16 different
countries
Takes them to huge warehouses in the
Netherlands, where the machines are stripped
down for parts and materials
95% of materials recovered for reuse or recycling!

This is saving Xerox $76 millions a year!!


Solid waste is the visible
face of inefficiency!
For more examples of
Industrial Responsibility



Contact Gary Liss at
[email protected]
For more information on EPR
initiatives contact Bill Sheehan at
[email protected]
4. To move from Zero Waste to
Sustainability we must use the
wisest
and brightest minds
in our society
Research Institute for
Zero Waste
and
Sustainability
Research Institute for
Zero Waste
and
Sustainability
1)Research for better industrial design
Research Institute for
Zero Waste
and
Sustainability
1) Research for better industrial design
2) Linking zero waste with other key
developments needed for sustainability
Sustainable
Agriculture
Sustainable
industries
& Jobs
Education
For
Sustainability
Sustainable
Architecture
Zero Waste 2020
Sustainable
Community
development
Sustainable
Economic
development
Sustainable
Energy
Better
Industrial
Design
Sustainable
Agriculture
Sustainable
industries
& Jobs
Education
For
Sustainability
Sustainable
Architecture
Zero Waste 2020
Sustainable
Community
development
Sustainable
Economic
development
Sustainable
Energy
Composting
Better
Industrial
Design
Sustainable
Agriculture
Sustainable
industries
& Jobs
Education
For
Sustainability
Sustainable
Architecture
Zero Waste 2020
Sustainable
Community
development
Sustainable
Economic
development
Sustainable
Energy
Research Center
Composting
Better
Industrial
Design
Sustainable
Agriculture
Sustainable
industries
& Jobs
Education
For
Sustainability
Sustainable
Architecture
Zero Waste 2020
Sustainable
Community
development
Sustainable
Economic
development
Sustainable
Energy
Composting
Better
Industrial
Design
Sustainable
Agriculture
Sustainable
industries
& Jobs
Research Center
Education
For
Sustainability
Deconstruction
Sustainable
Architecture
Zero Waste 2020
Sustainable
Community
development
Sustainable
Economic
development
Sustainable
Energy
Composting
Better
Industrial
Design
Sustainable
Agriculture
Sustainable
industries
& Jobs
Research Center
Education
For
Sustainability
Deconstruction
Sustainable
Architecture
Zero Waste 2020
Sustainable
Community
development
Sustainable
Economic
development
Anaerobic
Digestion
Sustainable
Energy
Composting
Better
Industrial
Design
Sustainable
Agriculture
Sustainable
industries
& Jobs
Research Center
Education
For
Sustainability
Deconstruction
Sustainable
Architecture
Zero Waste 2020
Sustainable
Community
development
Sustainable
Economic
development
Anaerobic
Digestion
Sustainable
Energy
Incineration is
not sustainable
energy!
Composting
Better
Industrial
Design
Sustainable
Agriculture
Sustainable
industries
& Jobs
Research Center
Education
For
Sustainability
Deconstruction
Sustainable
Architecture
Zero Waste 2020
Sustainable
Community
development
Sustainable
Economic
development
Anaerobic
Digestion
Sustainable
Energy
100’s of “green boxes”
Composting
Better
Industrial
Design
Sustainable
Agriculture
Sustainable
industries
& Jobs
Research Center
Education
For
Sustainability
Deconstruction
Sustainable
Architecture
Zero Waste 2020
Sustainable
Community
development
Sustainable
Economic
development
Anaerobic
Digestion
Sustainable
Energy
100’s of “green boxes”
Composting
Better
Industrial
Design
Sustainable
Agriculture
Sustainable
industries
& Jobs
Reuse &
Repair
Centers
Research Center
Education
For
Sustainability
Deconstruction
Sustainable
Architecture
Zero Waste 2020
Sustainable
Community
development
Sustainable
Economic
development
Anaerobic
Digestion
Sustainable
Energy
100’s of “green boxes”
D. Progress towards Zero
Waste around the world
 www.zwia.org
 www.GRRN.org
 www.no-burn.org
(GAIA)
California



As a result of a state law passed in the
early 1990’s hundreds of California
cities exceeded over 50% diversion
from landfills and incinerators by 2000
Some communities said why stop at
50%, why not 60%, 70%…
Why not aim for Zero Waste?
NEW ZEALAND
Over 70%
of communities
have declared
a Zero Waste
strategy
Prince Edward Island,
Canada

Whole island has door to door
collection of recyclables and
compostables
Nova Scotia




50% diversion in 5 years (Halifax ~ 60%)
1000 jobs created collecting and treating
discarded materials
Another 2000 jobs created in the
industries handling the collected material
Nearly all the separated materials are reused in Nova Scotia’s own industries.
Italy


Over 2000 communities in Italy are
achieving over 50% diversion using
“door to door” collection systems
Over 200 communities achieving over
70% diversion
Italy
 Novara
- (a city near Turin,
population = 100,000)
achieved 70% diversion in just
18 months!
Italy
 The
Treviso region - 22
communities averaging 76%
diversion (Priula consortium)
Italy
 Villafranco
d’Asti
(Piedmont) has reached
85% diversion
Some other developments
 Canberra,
 Kovalam,
Australia
India
 The
Philippines and
 The
UK
E. Some practicalities
“The Fantastic 3”
The San Francisco system
I “Fantastici 4”
Capannori, Italia
Capannori
LUNEDI
ORGANICO
MARTEDI
MULTIMATERIALE
MERCOLEDI
CARTA
GIOVEDI
VENERDI
FRAZIONE
RESIDUA
ORGANICO
SABATO
MULTIMATERIALE
1
2
3
1
Composting
Facility
2
3
Composting plant for San Francisco
1
Composting
Facility
2
3
1
Composting
Facility
2
Materials
Recovery
Facility
3
MATERIALS RECOVERY FACIILITY
at Pier 96
Cities
Rural areas
Composting
Plants
Recycling
Plants
1
Composting
Facility
2
Materials
Recovery
Facility
3
Residual
Fraction
We have to minimize the
residual fraction with…
 1)
Waste reduction
initiatives
 2) Reuse, repair and
deconstruction
 3) Economic incentives
Waste
Reduction
Initiatives
Undesirable packaging
 Four
options:
 Ban it
 Tax it
 Put a returnable deposit on it
 Avoid it
Ireland
 Government
put a 15 cent
tax on plastic shopping bags
 reduced use by 92% in one
year!
Italy
 Several
supermarket chains
are providing dispensers which
allow customers to refill
shampoo and detergent
bottles…
 As well as wine, water and
milk
Alcune iniziative italiane per la riduzione
•Un
pizzico di
creatività a monte
può far risparmiare
milioni a valle
Reuse,
Repair
and
Deconstruction
reuse
Reuse, Repair & Deconstruction
Urban Ore, Berkeley, California



“Economically, incineration represents
ONE BIG BLACK BOX
The Zero Waste strategy represents
100’s of LITTLE GREEN BOXES”
(Ted Ward, Zero Waste, Del Norte
County, California)
Deconstruction
Deconstruction
Reuse &
Repair Center
Deconstruction
Reuse &
Repair Center
Furniture,
Flooring, etc
VIDEOS

“On the Road to Zero Waste”

Part 1: Nova Scotia
Part 2: Burlington, Vermont
Part 3: Canberra, Australia
Part 4: San Francisco
Zero Waste: Idealistic Dream or Realistic Goal?
Pieces of Zero: Creativity versus Waste

www.AmericanHealthStudies.org





Economic
Incentives
The “ Pay by bag” system
1
2
3
The “ Pay by bag” system
1
free
2
3
The “ Pay by bag” system
1
2
free
free
3
The “ Pay by bag” system
1
free
2
free
$
The more
you make,
the more
you pay!
The “ Pay by bag” system
1
2
$
No
No
Surcharge!
surcharge surcharge
The “ Pay by bag” system
1
2
$
No
No
Surcharge!
surcharge surcharge
Total cost of program comes out of local taxes
1
Composting
Facility
2
$
Community
Initiatives to
Reduce
waste
Materials
Recovery
Facility
Residuals
?
Reuse & Repair
& Deconstruction
Residual
Separation &
Research
Facility
One stop shopping!
The Resource Recovery Park
The Resource Recovery Park
Materials
Recovery
Facility (MRF)
The Resource Recovery Park
Center for Hard-to-Recycle
Materials (CHARM)
The Resource Recovery Park
Reuse & Repair Center
The Resource Recovery Park
Composting
Facility
The Resource Recovery Park
Composting
Facility
The Resource Recovery Park
C&D
The Resource Recovery Park
Residual Screening
&
Research Center
Eric Lombardi, Eco-Cycle
www.ecocycle.org
F. Back to the Big Picture
Current situation
Consumption of materials
Consumption of fossil fuels
Standard of living
Change 1
Solar Energy
Consumption of materials
Standard of living
Change 2
Solar Energy
Zero Waste
Standard of living
Change 3
Solar Energy
Zero Waste
Quality of Life
We have to separate the
Quality of life from the
material consumption
We have to separate the
Quality of life from the
material consumption
Material consumption
Quality of life
We have to separate the
Quality of life from the
material consumption
Material consumption
Quality of life
To fight over-consumption
We need to swap a life built
around acquiring a series of
objects…
To a life built around a series
of expanding human
relationships
In the 1960’s
“Make Love,
Not War”
In the 2000’s
“Make Love,
Not Waste”
In the 2000’s
“Make Friends,
Not Waste”
Conclusions







We do not need mega-landfills or
incinerators!
There is a better alternative
The ZERO WASTE strategy is
Better for our health (LESS TOXICS)
Better for the economy,
Better for our children, and
Better for the planet (MORE SUSTAINABLE)!